News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by nathan_compton on Sunday August 18, 2024 @01:45PM (#41283892)
Sometimes vagueness is a necessary lubricant to get enough agreement on something, but I take your point.

My personal "fun idea" is that laws should have two parts, an "intent" part and an "implementation" part and if a court decides at some future time that the law fails to accomplish the intent it should be struck down.

Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by c22 on Sunday August 18, 2024 @02:42PM (#41284366)
Laws already attempt to encode intent through technical word choices, scoped definitions, and careful construction. Judges and lawyers attempt to discern the intent by careful reading and logical deconstruction.

When the lawmakers and judicial interpreters are good at their jobs this works great. Good lawmakers draft good laws that are clear in their intent. Good courts make good decisions by applying reasonable interpretations of the law.

Bad lawmakers fail to make their intent clear. Bad lawyers take advantage of vague laws to argue for unreasonable intent. Bad judges let these bad arguments fly.

How does encapsulating the "intent" into its own section of the law fix the problem? Bad lawmakers will still write vague intent sections as well as poorly defined implementations. Bad lawyers will abuse the vague intent sections to argue for exceptions and novel interpretations of the implementation section. Bad judges will let this fly and warp the system further through bad precedent.

Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by giantg2 on Sunday August 18, 2024 @04:15PM (#41285091)
"Bad lawmakers fail to make their intent clear. Bad lawyers take advantage of vague laws to argue for unreasonable intent. Bad judges let these bad arguments fly."

Good lawyers and good judges allow bad laws to be taken advantage of. If the law says it, it should be allowed (for leniency to the accused) or the law should be invalidated due to a lack of strict construction.

Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by Sohcahtoa82 on Monday August 19, 2024 @03:37PM (#41293965)
> Good lawyers and good judges allow bad laws to be taken advantage of. If the law says it, it should be allowed (for leniency to the accused) or the law should be invalidated due to a lack of strict construction.

A mom hears a loud noise coming from her kid's room and she goes up to find her kid is jumping on the bed and the mom comes in and says "Stop jumping on your bed!", so he does. Five minutes later, she hears the same noise, and comes in and the kid is jumping on the bed again, and tells the kid "I told you to stop jumping on your bed!" and the kid says "I'm not jumping, I'm hopping!" and starts to argue about the difference between jumping and hopping, and mom says "Just stop hopping on your bed!" and goes back to the living room.

Almost immediately, she hears it again, this time the kid is sitting, but bouncing up and down, declaring that he's not jumping or hopping, but bouncing. Again, the mom tells him to stop it.

A few minutes later, she hears jumping again, only this time, it's on HER bed. Finally, the mom says "Do not jump, hop, bounce, spring, leap, or otherwise propel yourself upwards from any bed, couch, chair, or any other furniture."

--

I disagree entirely with your opinion.

It is often that intent is crystal clear, but a lawyer is able to weasel their way into convincing a jury that there's a slight ambiguity in the law.

The problem of course, is that then lawmakers have to write incredibly verbose and difficult to understand legalese in order to ensure there are no loopholes. Of course, in the spelling out of the law, it's easy to accidentally create a loophole.

A rule that states "No jumping on the bed" is clear of intent. Mom shouldn't have to include many near-synonyms of "jumping" and specify that it means ALL beds.

Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by giantg2 on Monday August 19, 2024 @03:57PM (#41294123)
"It is often that intent is crystal clear, but a lawyer is able to weasel their way into convincing a jury that there's a slight ambiguity in the law."

This isn't true. Matters of law and how to interpret the law are determined by the judge and provided in the jury instructions.

"A rule that states "No jumping on the bed" is clear of intent. Mom shouldn't have to include many near-synonyms of "jumping" and specify that it means ALL beds."

This example isn't anything like what I'm talking about.

Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by nathan_compton on Monday August 19, 2024 @06:27PM (#41295090)
Mom doesn't have a monopoly on violence.
Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by jfengel on Sunday August 18, 2024 @03:49PM (#41284888)
You kinda do get a separate intent section. It begins with a string of "whereas".

As with code, adding more words rarely makes it clearer. In fact it usually introduces more discrepancies.

Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by jowea on Sunday August 18, 2024 @06:50PM (#41286194)
Interestingly some places give legal effect to those preambles it seems https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Preamble#Legal_effect
Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by vkou on Sunday August 18, 2024 @04:03PM (#41284988)
I'll point out that bad judging can always move the goalposts of what 'well-written intent' is.
Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by jdasdf on Sunday August 18, 2024 @04:08PM (#41285036)
>Sometimes vagueness is a necessary lubricant to get enough agreement on something, but I take your point.

Seems to me that a vague law is simply an invalid law. The rule of law requires the clear knowledge of what exactly is illegal, if that isn't clear then its simply a prospective law that doesn't meet the basic requires to be law.

Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by TeMPOraL on Sunday August 18, 2024 @04:28PM (#41285218)
There is no such thing as a law that isn't vague to a degree, because laws are expressed in words and concepts, and those are vague by their nature. Laws can, of course, be vague to a lesser or greater degree. We definitely don't want poetry-level vague laws, but we also don't want to (or can't) have laws expressed in code or as mathematical proofs, because this level of clarity is just computationally intractable wrt. anything relating to real world and real people. At this point, the practical optimum seems to be laws that mostly obvious in vast majority of scenarios, and leaving it to judges to opine on corner cases on an individual basis.
Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by throwaway2037 on Monday August 19, 2024 @08:00AM (#41290256)
This is classic HN. "Apply API-style thinking to the Real World."

What is reasonable cause for police officer to search someone? Mind you: This single point alone has hundreds of interpretations around the world, across all cultures. Within a single country / culture, there could be many interpretations.

Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by seabass-labrax on Sunday August 18, 2024 @04:03PM (#41284984)
That is how European Union directives and regulations are written, as it happens. The 'recitals' outline the general aims of the legislation, acting as a sort of preamble.

> The recitals are legally non-binding. However, the recitals can be relevant. Courts often use the recitals to interpret a particular – legally binding – provision of EU legislation, especially if multiple interpretations of a certain provision are possible.

From https://eulawanalysis.blogspot.com/p/how-to-read-eu-legislat...

Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by solidsnack9000 on Sunday August 18, 2024 @04:55PM (#41285436)
The recitals are non-binding, but nathan_compton's proposal is that the intent portion would be binding.
Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by OutOfHere on Sunday August 18, 2024 @01:48PM (#41283919)
> a necessary lubricant to get enough agreement

It is unfortunate that our representatives are as such, that they don't strive for clarity, but I understand. To me, the lack of clarity is an "invalid state" that has no place in the rulebook.

> if a court decides at some future time that the law fails to accomplish the intent it should be struck down.

This would be very welcome, but it should require repeated testings in fibonacci years, not merely once. This means at 1, 2, 3, 5, ... years after the law was passed or updated.

Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by nathan_compton on Sunday August 18, 2024 @03:28PM (#41284743)
Old laws are among the most likely to have deviated from their intended functionality. In my imaginary system, though, someone would have to raise the case to the courts, so it wouldn't be just happening all the time.
Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by marcosdumay on Sunday August 18, 2024 @02:32PM (#41284270)
> laws should have two parts, an "intent" part and an "implementation"

That's a common opinion between lawyers, the opposite opinion is that since the law was created by a large group of people, it can never have a clear intent. There are judges that assign to both of those.

Anyway, IMO there's fundamentally inhumane and evil consequence to the idea that laws don't have intent. Even if it's objectively true. The entire dichotomy is broken.

Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by BartjeD on Sunday August 18, 2024 @04:19PM (#41285130)
Normally during the legislative process a record is kept about deliberations leading up to the proposals for texts, and amendments etc..

In a 'normal' European democracy judges and lawyers use these deliberations to argue what the intent of the legislative branch was, when it created the law. And to interpret it in that light.

I'd be surprised if there was no equivalent in the USA. I suppose therein lies the root of the Scalia doctrine though, which is too strictly 'originalist' for my taste. But in this instance I'd wager the rules of seizure were given a lot of legislative attention, similar as Habeas Corpus, because illegal seizure is an obvious tool of tyrants. It was often used by Roman Emperors and medieval Kings.

Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by JAlexoid on Monday August 19, 2024 @01:53PM (#41293113)
Civil Law systems will prioritize being clear and precise in the language of the laws. Where a law allows interpretation, it will likely literally state that.

There are clear limits to how to interpret laws and most of the case law comes from which provision is applicable to a particular case. There's often no need to resort to "deliberations" part to interpret the law for a judge, just find the law that most precisely applies in a particular situation and there's no law that is in conflict.

Basically in a Civil Law system if the law states that you're not allowed to drive while drunk, that doesn't extend to being high. Unlike Common Law systems, where a judge could accept that drunk and stoned are close enough for both to be banned. (this is a hyperbolized example, not exactly how it would work)

Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by marcosdumay on Monday August 19, 2024 @01:57PM (#41293160)
Even in a Civil Law system, there still exist fundamental principles (like the one from the GP that would disallow US-style property seizing), badly written, and conflicting laws that judges have plenty of space to interpret.
Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by JAlexoid on Monday August 19, 2024 @03:10PM (#41293798)
There's a major difference you missed - in a Civil Law system the judge has significantly less leeway to interpret the laws and commonly will refer to a superior (up to the constitutional court level) court to get clarification.
Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by BartjeD on Thursday August 22, 2024 @10:58AM (#41321057)
Incidentally, none of the characteristics you listed are actually true.

A) In the Netherlands and Switzerland the articles of the law don't always mention if they allow deviation by agreement. In those cases the assumption is: No, unless the legislative process documented that it was intended to be. I haven't checked but I recall the same is true for France and Germany.

B) The refere-legislatif (pre-judicical question) first appears in the Eastern Roman Civil Law (Byzantium) where Emperors use it to guide the interpretation of their law. But nothing about Civil Law systems presuposses it. EU Law does use it. But courts in the Netherlands don't. Instead, they are required to adjudicate as best they can. And if they screw up, a higher court can be used for appeal.

C) Appeals, these also exist in Common Law and many other legal systems. This doesn't require elaboration.

Your example concerning drunk-driving is troubling, because that would usually be treated as a misdemeanor or a crime. Not as part of a Civil Code violation. You could claim damages under the Civil Code, but then you are asserting a violation of the 'Public Order' Code, which you then have to prove.

The 'Public Order' Code is itself subject to strict Human Rights codes from various sources. Both international as well as EU Charter of Rights. Which translate into specialized courts and stricter rules of evidence and defense. Guild by proximity to a crime is an example of a scenario that this prevents. Whereas the Civil Law can (and sometimes does) assume causation based on balance of probabilities, due to proximity and lack of counter statements refuting said probabilities.

Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by JAlexoid on Thursday August 22, 2024 @03:42PM (#41323764)
> In the Netherlands and Switzerland the articles of the law don't always mention if they allow deviation by agreement. In those cases the assumption is: No, unless the legislative process documented that it was intended to be.

That's literally what I wrote. Why are you telling me that I'm wrong, when you're restating my point.

> Your example concerning drunk-driving is troubling, because that would usually be treated as a misdemeanor or a crime. Not as part of a Civil Code violation. You could claim damages under the Civil Code, but then you are asserting a violation of the 'Public Order' Code, which you then have to prove.

What does this even have to do with what I wrote?

Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by ruined on Sunday August 18, 2024 @02:47PM (#41284405)
this intent/implementation duality was codified by the chevron precedent that was just overturned by the supreme court.

the legislature was responsible for establishing intent, and the executive was responsible for implementation, and the judiciary branch was responsible for resolving disputes.

but the supreme court ruled that the legislative intent has been too vague, and the executive has been too whimsical with implementation. so the legislature must be more specific, or leave it to the judiciary to establish details.

Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by torstenvl on Sunday August 18, 2024 @02:49PM (#41284426)
That is false. Please don't spread misinformation. Chevron had nothing to do with how legislatures write laws.
Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by ruined on Sunday August 18, 2024 @02:56PM (#41284464)
can you provide a correct interpretation of the ruling?
Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by nickff on Sunday August 18, 2024 @03:09PM (#41284593)
Not parent, but Chevron was about deference to agencies, not about whether courts should adhere to legislative intent. The original Chevron ruling was written by a well-known originalist, who usually didn't abide by legislative intent.
Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by ruined on Monday August 19, 2024 @11:46AM (#41292026)
sure, but agency interpretation is only possible within the vagaries of the legislation. that's 100% synonymous with intention/implementation.
Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by immibis on Wednesday August 28, 2024 @03:29PM (#41383269)
i.o.w. it was about whether Congress just has to write the intent, or whether it has to write the full implementation too.
Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by torstenvl on Friday August 30, 2024 @11:24AM (#41401607)
No. Why would you say something that you know is obviously false?

Everyone knows the New Deal administrative state existed. I'd really appreciate it if leftist extremists would stop trying to convince us it didn't.

Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by torstenvl on Sunday August 18, 2024 @04:26PM (#41285200)
The ruling stands on its own. Have you read it?

And in any case it is completely off-topic from this thread.

Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by ruined on Monday August 19, 2024 @11:47AM (#41292039)
i've skimmed it, that's what i got out of it, but i'm no lawyer. if you aren't going to clearly express your intent here i must continue to rely on my interpretation
Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by torstenvl on Monday August 19, 2024 @05:51PM (#41294859)
HN is for intellectual curiosity, and not for ideological battle.

If you are going to insist on spewing political talking points instead of reading the opinion, all while refusing to take into account an expert in the field—an attorney for a federal agency—telling you that you're wrong, then you should reconsider whether you belong here.

Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by throwaway2037 on Monday August 19, 2024 @08:04AM (#41290283)
Here you go: https://www.justice.gov/d9/osg/briefs/1983/01/01/sg830081.tx...

You can read all 7,000 words, then you will better understand the "correct interpretation".

Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by solidsnack9000 on Sunday August 18, 2024 @05:06PM (#41285505)
The intent / implementation duality isn't related to Chevron or Loper Bright. That is entirely about how to interpret the implementation: to what degree, when considering alternate interpretations, do we weight the agency's own interpretation?

The intent / implementation discussion comes up when considering statutes like this:

In order to maintain our beautiful forests and meadows, the city of Little Island hereby declares these acts governing the pollution of water: ...<enumeration of acts>...

Now many years pass and all the forests are cut down and the meadows are gravel lots, buildings, &c. Is the statute no longer operative? Generally, the way laws are interpreted, the courts would say it is still operative. The alternative would make the interpretation of law quite inconsistent, because it means we are asking courts to judge many things that are not really matters of law.

Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by solidsnack9000 on Sunday August 18, 2024 @04:36PM (#41285289)
It is much more difficult to establish standards of intent interpretation than it is to establish standards of statutory interpretation. One could imagine a law written as follows:

In order to facilitate the safe enjoyment of ice cream, puff pastry and pizzas of diverse origins, the health department shall regulate the minimum temperature of freezers in grocery stores, restaurants and other establishments. The minimum temperature shall not be greater than -18C.

There are some gaps that a court needs to fill in order to apply this statute:

- The health department and the area of effect are not specified but these can be assumed to be the health department and area connected to whatever legislature passed the statute. If there is no health department that is the obvious one -- if, for example, it was passed by a city legislature and the city has no health department -- this could introduce some difficulty.

- The use of "minimum" and "shall not be greater" together in this statute are confused and confusing but since it pertains to freezers, the court can infer that freezers must be set to temperatures of -18C or below (-19C, &c).

However, sorting out the true intent presents insoluble problems that would lead to inconsistent interpretation of the law. Perhaps an establishment only has frozen fish. Does this law apply to them? Generally, the rule is that clear intent clauses -- "In order to facilitate the safe enjoyment of ice cream, puff pastry and pizzas of diverse origins..." -- are ignored in statutory interpretation. The operative part of the statute is that "...the health department shall regulate the minimum temperature of freezers in grocery stores, restaurants and other establishments." and that the temperature established by the health department must be -18C or below.

Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by seabass-labrax on Sunday August 18, 2024 @06:47PM (#41286181)
No standard ways of interpretation will make up for a poorly-written statute - and, with all due respect, that's what your hypothetical example is. In liberal democracies, we expect our representatives to pass only laws that have low ambiguity, and sometimes require third-party review to ensure this.

Why would any legislature pass a law delegating responsibility to a non-existent agency? How could this legislature pass a law with clearly contradictory stipulations regarding temperature? Then, finally, for what reason would intent clauses be written if they were then be entirely ignored?

In conclusion, I think that your hypothetical system of government has greater problems than any inherent difficulty in expressing legal intent that may exist.

Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by ClumsyPilot on Monday August 19, 2024 @06:19AM (#41289650)
> In liberal democracies, we expect our representatives to pass only laws that have low ambiguity

Do we really?

UK law is full considerations like what would a ‘reasonable’ person do.

Also full of terms that are ambiguous - loitering for example.

Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by throwaway2037 on Monday August 19, 2024 @07:57AM (#41290238)
Jeez, no kidding. Think about criminal sentencing guidelines. Not all circumstances are the same.
Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by JAlexoid on Monday August 19, 2024 @03:05PM (#41293754)
UK, just like the US, legal system is a Common Law system.

They are bound by history, with all of the caveats that come from that system.

Most of liberal democracies use Civil Law system, where it's a lot more prescriptive in the laws themselves.

Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by solidsnack9000 on Monday August 19, 2024 @01:35PM (#41292957)
If the facts change, I change my mind; but I don't think you're being realistic, here. Judges sometimes have to interpret poorly-written statutes. Legal drafting has improved a lot over the last hundred and fifty years or so; but that has been a gradual process.

Some countries have what are effectively brand new political and legal systems; but countries with comparatively long histories of stable governance generally have comparatively old laws that must be interpreted.

You ask three questions in the foregoing:

- Why would any legislature pass a law delegating responsibility to a non-existent agency?

If the city does not have a health department, it may be that the county does, or the state does, and they meant to delegate to them.

- How could this legislature pass a law with clearly contradictory stipulations regarding temperature?

The stipulations make use of a common, unfortunate misphrasing; that doesn't mean they are actually contradictory.

- Then, finally, for what reason would intent clauses be written if they were then be entirely ignored?

Intent clauses are generally considered non-binding, in legal systems all over the world. Another commenter has pointed out that this is the case not only in the Anglo-American system but also in the EU system: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41284984

That doesn't mean intent clauses serve no purpose. It just means they don't serve the purpose of providing a specific, actionable rule.

Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by collingreen on Sunday August 18, 2024 @05:58PM (#41285865)
I love this and think about the same. Similarly, in a work setting, I used to decree that any subsequent decrees (eg: tooling, commit/lint rules, languages) must come with the intent, the desired results, and the expected costs. This made it much less political to suggest changes to our process while simultaneously eliminating some of the low effort "let's use <framework-of-the-week>" statements. I also want to believe it made it so ideas could come from anyone, not just people with titles or social capital, although I don't have any hard proof of that.