News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by seabass-labrax on Sunday August 18, 2024 @06:47PM (#41286181)
No standard ways of interpretation will make up for a poorly-written statute - and, with all due respect, that's what your hypothetical example is. In liberal democracies, we expect our representatives to pass only laws that have low ambiguity, and sometimes require third-party review to ensure this.

Why would any legislature pass a law delegating responsibility to a non-existent agency? How could this legislature pass a law with clearly contradictory stipulations regarding temperature? Then, finally, for what reason would intent clauses be written if they were then be entirely ignored?

In conclusion, I think that your hypothetical system of government has greater problems than any inherent difficulty in expressing legal intent that may exist.

Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by ClumsyPilot on Monday August 19, 2024 @06:19AM (#41289650)
> In liberal democracies, we expect our representatives to pass only laws that have low ambiguity

Do we really?

UK law is full considerations like what would a ‘reasonable’ person do.

Also full of terms that are ambiguous - loitering for example.

Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by throwaway2037 on Monday August 19, 2024 @07:57AM (#41290238)
Jeez, no kidding. Think about criminal sentencing guidelines. Not all circumstances are the same.
Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by JAlexoid on Monday August 19, 2024 @03:05PM (#41293754)
UK, just like the US, legal system is a Common Law system.

They are bound by history, with all of the caveats that come from that system.

Most of liberal democracies use Civil Law system, where it's a lot more prescriptive in the laws themselves.

Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by solidsnack9000 on Monday August 19, 2024 @01:35PM (#41292957)
If the facts change, I change my mind; but I don't think you're being realistic, here. Judges sometimes have to interpret poorly-written statutes. Legal drafting has improved a lot over the last hundred and fifty years or so; but that has been a gradual process.

Some countries have what are effectively brand new political and legal systems; but countries with comparatively long histories of stable governance generally have comparatively old laws that must be interpreted.

You ask three questions in the foregoing:

- Why would any legislature pass a law delegating responsibility to a non-existent agency?

If the city does not have a health department, it may be that the county does, or the state does, and they meant to delegate to them.

- How could this legislature pass a law with clearly contradictory stipulations regarding temperature?

The stipulations make use of a common, unfortunate misphrasing; that doesn't mean they are actually contradictory.

- Then, finally, for what reason would intent clauses be written if they were then be entirely ignored?

Intent clauses are generally considered non-binding, in legal systems all over the world. Another commenter has pointed out that this is the case not only in the Anglo-American system but also in the EU system: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41284984

That doesn't mean intent clauses serve no purpose. It just means they don't serve the purpose of providing a specific, actionable rule.