News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by ruined on Sunday August 18, 2024 @02:47PM (#41284405)
this intent/implementation duality was codified by the chevron precedent that was just overturned by the supreme court.

the legislature was responsible for establishing intent, and the executive was responsible for implementation, and the judiciary branch was responsible for resolving disputes.

but the supreme court ruled that the legislative intent has been too vague, and the executive has been too whimsical with implementation. so the legislature must be more specific, or leave it to the judiciary to establish details.

Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by torstenvl on Sunday August 18, 2024 @02:49PM (#41284426)
That is false. Please don't spread misinformation. Chevron had nothing to do with how legislatures write laws.
Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by ruined on Sunday August 18, 2024 @02:56PM (#41284464)
can you provide a correct interpretation of the ruling?
Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by nickff on Sunday August 18, 2024 @03:09PM (#41284593)
Not parent, but Chevron was about deference to agencies, not about whether courts should adhere to legislative intent. The original Chevron ruling was written by a well-known originalist, who usually didn't abide by legislative intent.
Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by ruined on Monday August 19, 2024 @11:46AM (#41292026)
sure, but agency interpretation is only possible within the vagaries of the legislation. that's 100% synonymous with intention/implementation.
Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by immibis on Wednesday August 28, 2024 @03:29PM (#41383269)
i.o.w. it was about whether Congress just has to write the intent, or whether it has to write the full implementation too.
Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by torstenvl on Friday August 30, 2024 @11:24AM (#41401607)
No. Why would you say something that you know is obviously false?

Everyone knows the New Deal administrative state existed. I'd really appreciate it if leftist extremists would stop trying to convince us it didn't.

Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by torstenvl on Sunday August 18, 2024 @04:26PM (#41285200)
The ruling stands on its own. Have you read it?

And in any case it is completely off-topic from this thread.

Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by ruined on Monday August 19, 2024 @11:47AM (#41292039)
i've skimmed it, that's what i got out of it, but i'm no lawyer. if you aren't going to clearly express your intent here i must continue to rely on my interpretation
Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by torstenvl on Monday August 19, 2024 @05:51PM (#41294859)
HN is for intellectual curiosity, and not for ideological battle.

If you are going to insist on spewing political talking points instead of reading the opinion, all while refusing to take into account an expert in the field—an attorney for a federal agency—telling you that you're wrong, then you should reconsider whether you belong here.

Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by throwaway2037 on Monday August 19, 2024 @08:04AM (#41290283)
Here you go: https://www.justice.gov/d9/osg/briefs/1983/01/01/sg830081.tx...

You can read all 7,000 words, then you will better understand the "correct interpretation".

Re:Police Cannot Seize Property Indefinitely After an Arrest... by solidsnack9000 on Sunday August 18, 2024 @05:06PM (#41285505)
The intent / implementation duality isn't related to Chevron or Loper Bright. That is entirely about how to interpret the implementation: to what degree, when considering alternate interpretations, do we weight the agency's own interpretation?

The intent / implementation discussion comes up when considering statutes like this:

In order to maintain our beautiful forests and meadows, the city of Little Island hereby declares these acts governing the pollution of water: ...<enumeration of acts>...

Now many years pass and all the forests are cut down and the meadows are gravel lots, buildings, &c. Is the statute no longer operative? Generally, the way laws are interpreted, the courts would say it is still operative. The alternative would make the interpretation of law quite inconsistent, because it means we are asking courts to judge many things that are not really matters of law.