News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:DOJ may want to break up Google by Apreche on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @07:58PM (#41241146)
If somehow this happens, the big question is, how many splits? How many lines do they draw, and where do they draw them?

Clearly they want to separate search and advertising, as that was the crux of the case. But advertising is the only place that makes any money. If they split that off by itself, the rest, which is the good parts, may completely crumble.

What of the small, but important, products that Google hasn't killed yet? I guess Google Flights is arguably part of search. But what of say, Google Fonts?

The goal is to increase competition in the marketplace. A noble endeavor. But all those other Google products, if left to hang out to dry, stand a good chance of dying or being absorbed by competitors.

Well and good, there may be increased competition in the realm of search and online advertising. But if Google Cloud Platform can't stand on its own, and merges into AWS or Azure, that's less competition. If Chrome and Chromebooks can't stand on their own and Microsoft acquires it, that's less competition.

No matter how the split goes, whichever parts of Google's business are not in the same company as the advertising business will need to find a way to profitability.

Re:DOJ may want to break up Google by vineyardmike on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @08:15PM (#41241242)
> But if Google Cloud Platform can't stand on its own, and merges into AWS or Azure, that's less competition.

The other complexity is the actual infrastructure and IP. Inside, Google is very “vertically integrated” to making software services. They have a huge toolbox of custom software and a ton of custom magic they built into the data centers and infrastructure.

I’m not sure that there have been any modern cases of antitrust breakups that would have as much complexity and nuance. Bell could easily be divided geographically but of course that makes no sense here. I can’t imagine a breakup doing anything but destroy value and competition, even if you support antitrust intervention.

What happens to Google’s famous monorepo? Does it get chopped up? Are the libraries and tools shared and each child company gets a fork?

What about the SRE team that manages the shared database infrastructure for every team at Google?

What happens to the database that stores users accounts? Each user has basically one identity across each Google product. What happens to your YouTube account if it ends up in a different company than your GMail account?

And of course, who gets the physical data centers? If that goes to GCP, does that mean that search needs to negotiate a usage price as part of the breakup negotiations? Imagine the contract YouTube would have to write for renting storage?

Re:DOJ may want to break up Google by throwup238 on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @08:53PM (#41241480)
How is that different from Bellcore [1][2]?

Bell was broken up in the early 1980s, they already had plenty of shared software infrastructure by then. The monorepo is an interesting complication but hardly a dealbreaker that can't be restructured around.

[1] https://journal.businesstoday.org/bt-online/2017/3/18/the-le...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iconectiv

Re:DOJ may want to break up Google by jart on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @09:07PM (#41241568)
lool monorepo regulators are already checkmated 100 moves ahead.

open sourcing it is the only way they'll break that monster up.

doj clowns should go home they're out of their depth.

Re:DOJ may want to break up Google by bearjaws on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @10:32PM (#41242008)
You must be pre-ATT to think that a monorepo will stop a break up "lool"
Re:DOJ may want to break up Google by fuzztester on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @09:07PM (#41241571)
None of those issues matters much, to anyone except Google, which is getting broken up anyway.

>I can’t imagine a breakup doing anything but destroy value and competition, even if you support antitrust intervention.

I can, easily.

Value for who, exactly?

And antitrust intervention is supposed to increase competition.

Re:DOJ may want to break up Google by fuzztester on Wednesday August 14, 2024 @03:36AM (#41243538)
>And antitrust intervention is supposed to increase competition.

A few results from a Google search for the word antitrust:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Competition_law

(The above was the first result; see the first paragraph at that link.)

https://www.ftc.gov/advice-guidance/competition-guidance/gui...

https://www.investopedia.com/terms/a/antitrust.asp

Re:DOJ may want to break up Google by vineyardmike on Wednesday August 14, 2024 @12:15PM (#41247747)
It’s supposed to increase competition, but I’m skeptical. I think a lot of the winners will be the other mega-companies, but there will be a lot of loss across the industry. I don’t think the goal should be to punish Google for the sake of punishment, and I see that as happening.

I agree it might increase competition in all the future businesses that Google doesn’t enter, but not in the businesses many complain about Google today.

1. Ending the default-search payments will take away 20% of apples profits, and most of Mozilla’s revenue. Everyone but Apple already uses the chrome rendering engine. This is purely a value-destroyer.

2. Chrome certainly wouldn’t survive a breakup in its current form. There is no way a child company can afford to pay this many engineers, especially if the DOJ adds restrictions like they can’t make money from Google-search defaults. This might kill open-source chromium in the process.

3. Fitbit and nest are some examples of product lines that probably won’t be sustainable on their own. But certainly there is more (Fi?). Any company that ends up with them would probably shutter it for the savings. This would cede both their markets to Chinese crap and other American monopolies. Plus all the random projects people mention like Google Fonts. I’m guessing there are a ton of things in this bucket.

4. We certainly are not about to see a variety in phone operating systems. If Google is chopped up, the new android (parent) company certainly will be far poorer and have far less resources than Apple. This will cause the entire android ecosystem to languishing as new features slow and shift power back to Samsung and existing companies that can afford to push features without Google.

5. Google Cloud Platform would likely be a rare winner here. Theyre profitable (barely) and suddenly getting a whole new massive customer on the books (remaining Google parts) would give them a massive boost.

6. Whatever business owns Gmail in the end will keep those customers. Customers probably won’t change email providers.

7. This would probably accelerate the “new feature not available in Europe” trend, as existing Google had a lot of agreements with EU to maintain old features for “anticompetitive” reasons. The leaner and more competitive businesses certainly would ditch that market to better compete elsewhere.

Personally, I think a better approach is to treat Google more like infrastructure and require them to share their efforts. Open up the search index to others (paid, but for any use). Force their accounting to “buy” it internally with the same public margin. This would allow competitors in AI training, in search engine algos, UX, etc.

Similarly, you can do a similar thing for Maps, YouTube, Play Store, etc. They show off which services they maintain that have billions of users. Target those, not all the markets they still compete in.

Re:DOJ may want to break up Google by SoftTalker on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @08:13PM (#41241234)
I'd split it into at least:

    Advertising
    Google Search
    Google Drive/Docs/Gmail/Gemini/Maps i.e. apps and office productivity
    Google Cloud
    VC activities
    Waymo and Robotics
    Health Care/Drugs
And I'd do the same with Meta, Apple, etc.

There's just no good reason to have mega-conglomerates that own such huge shares of the market. It leads to regulatory capture and locks out potential new competitors.

Re:DOJ may want to break up Google by voisin on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @08:37PM (#41241377)
> And I'd do the same with Meta, Apple, etc.

I agree re Meta, but I am not sure Apple should be in the same category. I think Google and Meta use a small subset of golden goose businesses to subsidize perpetual money losers that prevent competition and actual self sufficient business models from emerging, all for the sake of preventing the emergence of another conglomerate that might come for the original golden goose. Apple doesn’t seem to fit this model - all of its businesses more than 3-5 years old seem to be wildly profitable. It isn’t like the iPhone is subsidizing the Watch, or Services. They are all successful, self sufficient businesses.

Re:DOJ may want to break up Google by br0wnr1c3 on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @08:58PM (#41241519)
I think yes and no for Apple. It's certainly making a ton of money off of each of its devices (Watch, iPad, Mac, etc.), but none of those devices (with the exception of the Mac, probably) would sell as well without the iPhone's ecosystem.

In some hypothetical universe where the Watch and iPad were from distinct companies, they might have to force interoperability with other products like the Pixel or Galaxy Watch to make the iPhone a compelling product.

Re:DOJ may want to break up Google by Spartan-S63 on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @09:41PM (#41241753)
I think the only case for Apple exerting monopoly power is in the App Store and the iOS walled garden model. If the EU DMA was brought to the US, I don’t see a valid antitrust case against Apple for any other business they do.

You could argue separating the services components (App Store, TV+, Apple Music) from the devices business, but I don’t think there’s any validity in segmenting iPhone from anything else or any of their hardware business as a whole.

Re:DOJ may want to break up Google by chucke1992 on Wednesday August 14, 2024 @03:43AM (#41243594)
With iOS I think it is just enough to prohibit Apple from taking 30% cut from App Store installations. Similar how Microsoft cannot ask for 30% from any app installed in Windows (unless it is done from the store). In case of Apple, AppStore is basically Windows comparison - the only way to access "internet" so to say.
Re:DOJ may want to break up Google by dns_snek on Thursday August 15, 2024 @08:34AM (#41255182)
I think you have that the wrong way around, artificially limiting their %cut would be a kludge (who even decides what's fair?) and it wouldn't resolve other issues related to their death grip over app distribution such as arbitrary rules and censorship.

In this case there's a perfectly usable market solution to the problem.

Apple should be allowed to ask for any %cut they want, but others should be allowed to compete on equal footing and without Apple positioning themselves in the middle of every transaction, which is how they're trying to work around the EU DMA using notarization requirements and their "core technology" fee.

Re:DOJ may want to break up Google by bitnasty on Wednesday August 14, 2024 @10:25AM (#41246456)
Meta only wishes they were impactful enough to be broken up. Their products aren’t really that important and it’s really easy to avoid them. If all of Meta’s products disappeared they would be replaced in a day.

It’s a little harder to avoid Google or Amazon or Apple in one’s everyday life. If one of these companies disappeared, it would take some time to fill that hole in the market.

Re:DOJ may want to break up Google by bag_boy on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @09:06PM (#41241558)
How could the advertising service be uncoupled from search? How would search make money?
Re:DOJ may want to break up Google by mminer237 on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @09:24PM (#41241665)
Search would sell ad space to whatever company offers the best rate. If it's currently profitable for Google, it still would be, just other ad companies would have the option to offer a better rate.
Re:DOJ may want to break up Google by xnx on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @11:49PM (#41242386)
It was over 10 years ago, but Google did almost exactly this with small experiment Google did (probably related to some suit) where Dealtime (BizRate?) product ads were shown in Google Search results in place of [what was then called] Product Listing Ads.
Re:DOJ may want to break up Google by brandonmenc on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @09:12PM (#41241596)
Charge money to use it.
Re:DOJ may want to break up Google by giantrobot on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @09:24PM (#41241664)
> And I'd do the same with Meta, Apple, etc.

When I worked at Apple in SWE I worked on macOS and iOS (and tvOS and ipadOS). None of the things I worked on were sold as individual SKUs. The money came from selling hardware. Software was a thing that helped sell the hardware since the OS turned it from a hunk of electronics into a product.

How could you possibly propose Apple be split up? The same base OS is used in all their products so you can't split out macOS and iOS. The hardware all comes out of the same hardware engineering group.

All splitting up Apple does is reduce competition because there would be the iPhone company that takes all the engineering resources. The remaining rump companies would need to back fill engineering resources at great expense. If the rump companies "partner" with the iPhone company they're just less efficient versions of the old similar company. Either that or they just get bought by another company and there's less competition or ownership by a geopolitical rival.

The break-ups of Standard Oil and AT&T were workable because they could easily be split among divisional or geographic lines. Splitting up Google or Apple is either completely ineffective as it's just creating "partners" or the rump companies die out because they can't leverage higher margin parts of the larger company.

Re:DOJ may want to break up Google by jemmyw on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @10:21PM (#41241954)
Services like Apple Music where they're currently able to leverage their ownership of the app store to give themselves a competitive advantage can be spilt off quite easily (in conceptual terms) and stand by themselves. If they can't stand by themselves then they're being bolstered by their market position thus the reason
Re:DOJ may want to break up Google by danaris on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @09:29PM (#41241692)
The way to hit Apple with antitrust is to break off the App Stores themselves, since that's the point of monopolization.

Make Apple's apps all operate by exactly the same rules as everyone else's—including rules governing private APIs.

Make the formerly-Apple App Store compete with other App Stores in a similar way to what they've introduced in the EU, but on a more even footing.

Personally, I'm still not entirely sold on this being a good idea—but IMO it's the one way of breaking up Apple that actually makes any sense.

Re:DOJ may want to break up Google by Spartan-S63 on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @09:43PM (#41241762)
Same, the services and hardware businesses are the only valid breakup case and it’s true that Apple favors its own services.

I’m also in agreement that it’s not clear such a break up would be beneficial.

Re:DOJ may want to break up Google by bearjaws on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @10:32PM (#41242014)
Split off Chrome too, they have already proven it's going to be ugly having them control the most popular browser.
Re:DOJ may want to break up Google by bluGill on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @08:19PM (#41241268)
Advertising needs to split. Search, youtube, ... need to bring their own ad sales with, with a few of the external customers.
Re:DOJ may want to break up Google by troad on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @08:16PM (#41241251)
I think you're overlooking the disincentives to competition that exist while Google is so consolidated. Google funds things like hardware, cloud, and Android so that they constitute a hundred-mile moat around its core Advertising and Search business. Android could lose basically unlimited money without Google winding it up, because its key role is to prevent the emergence of a competitor that would threaten to become another intermediary between Google and consumers.

A lot of these secondary products and services are not there to be profitable, they're sold at unrealistic prices (or given away for free) to kill competition. Once spun off, these products or services would have to become profitable on their own feet, which would - after an initial spike in prices - make the space a lot more competitive for other firms seeking to enter that market.

Re:DOJ may want to break up Google by TechRemarker on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @08:11PM (#41241222)
Agreed. Gmail is probably their best product and while they make money from Google Workspace, imagine without Google Ads, they'd have to start charging those 2 billion users who would then leave for a lesser but cheaper alternative.

And Google Maps and Waze and YouTube and YouTube Music.

It's always been unsafe to rely on most any Google product since they will eventually evaporate. But Google Search, YouTube and Gmail have always seemed untouchable, but without Google Ads, it's anyones guess.

Re:DOJ may want to break up Google by voisin on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @08:38PM (#41241387)
> they'd have to start charging those 2 billion users

Why couldn’t they simply show ads like any third party site? Ads can still be a business model for them, but those separate businesses couldn’t be subsidized by ads shown on other sites as the case currently is.

Re:DOJ may want to break up Google by Narhem on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @08:51PM (#41241468)
Daily Motion seemed like a good alternative to YouTube, but how do you funnel people to the site and make money from it.

YouTube has been catering towards children, which is kind of strange to me.

Re:DOJ may want to break up Google by ericd on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @08:10PM (#41241214)
I’d like to see them split off crawling from indexing/search, and be forced to provide the complete crawl to anyone who wants it, at cost. Currently, they have a privileged position, where almost all websites are willing to let them crawl, while blocking most smaller crawlers pinging them anywhere near as often.
Re:DOJ may want to break up Google by fuzztester on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @08:48PM (#41241450)
>What of the small, but important, products that Google hasn't killed yet?

Indeed, what of them, fellow traveler on this noble software path?

Inscrutable are the ways of existence.

The department thou speaketh of is well named.

It meteth out justice.

With one hand it giveth, with the other hand it taketh away.

Ours not to reason why, ours but to innovate or die.

https://www.poetryfoundation.org/poems/45319/the-charge-of-t...

Re:DOJ may want to break up Google by alemanek on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @08:49PM (#41241456)
Splitting ads off from Search doesn’t mean Search doesn’t show ads.

It just means that now multiple ad networks get to bid for those ad slots. Whoever wants to share the most money with the Search division wins. All their major properties get crazy traffic and will do just fine on their own.

Chrome can make search deals and again they are siphoning off all kinds of data. They can start selling that to data brokers instead of using it internally. Not to mention regional default search engine deals.

Android is on 80% of devices worldwide. You are telling me they can’t monetize that? YouTube isn’t a loss leader anymore.

Google should be broken up. Same for most of Big Tech.

Re:DOJ may want to break up Google by luckydata on Wednesday August 14, 2024 @02:52AM (#41243262)
I was sort of following you until Android but you completely lost me there. That just doesn't make sense trust me. Disclosure: I work at Google in Cloud but I'm a product manager and I'm used to think about where money goes to do what. Android as a company makes no sense.
Re:DOJ may want to break up Google by macilacilove on Wednesday August 14, 2024 @03:21AM (#41243422)
What is your argument? Android is one of the most successful software projects of all time. It seems easily monetizable.
Re:DOJ may want to break up Google by alemanek on Wednesday August 14, 2024 @08:27AM (#41245289)
I do not work at Google so I am sure you have more inside information than me.

But, here is my thinking. Android is operated the way it is because it cements Googles dominance with its other services. Maps, Chrome, ..etc always ship with the certified Android phones. Google proper doesn’t pay anything for that privledge currently.

If broken up that first class “ships with the phone” stuff is now up for grabs and seems like it would be a valuable revenue stream. Also there is usage data which can be monetized. Play store revenue would still be there as well.

Custom spins of the OS for specific industry use cases with professional support might be attractive to a smaller company which just had Android whereas it isn’t lucrative enough for Google as a whole. Also these custom flavors might not ship with Google services so there is a natural disincentive to explore this.

Android on its own would likely monetize very differently than it currently is as part of the Google mothership. It would need to have a diverse set of partners. Even if it was just as a regional service reseller where it is taking a cut of service revenue in exchange for first class support on the OS.

I can’t help but think that this realigning of incentives would be beneficial for the market as a whole.

Re:DOJ may want to break up Google by Zren on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @11:43PM (#41242357)
> What of the small, but important, products that Google hasn't killed yet? ... But what of say, Google Fonts?

Google Fonts can act as a tracking pixel, the bandwidth cost is probably offset by the slight amount of user data it obtains.

Re:DOJ may want to break up Google by bitnasty on Wednesday August 14, 2024 @10:11AM (#41246296)
Google search sucks now anyway. It’s been getting progressively worse in the past few years since they have decided that selling ads is more important than relevant search results, and don’t even get me started on the AI dribble they’ve been pushing. If they can’t keep up in a fair market then they deserve to fail just like everyone else.