News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row? by chiefalchemist on Friday August 09, 2024 @07:54AM (#41200956)
For me it boils down to this:

- biological gender is not binary

- there's more to it than XX and XY

Unless we embrace gender is - like many things - a spectrum, there will be debate.

I'll add, that equal is a high - perhaps unattainable - bar. It might make sense to first focus on fair / fairness, and that at times the many might have to take precedence over the few.

C'est la vie.

Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row? by stonethrowaway on Friday August 09, 2024 @09:29AM (#41201626)
Assuming a spectrum, where do you draw the line? How should mens vs womens competitions be split up, if at all? How do you make it “fair enough”?
Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row? by Dalewyn on Friday August 09, 2024 @09:32AM (#41201656)
Not parent commenter; I believe that any sport which looks at gender/sex is undeniably sexist, this includes the Olympic games which are by far the most blatant and prominent examples.

True equality can only be achieved by not considering if someone is a man, woman, or whatever they might want to classify as. Lump everyone together, equal opportunities given, and may the best man as in mankind win.

And no, don't give me "Women will almost always lose!". That is sexist bullshit. Equality is equality, we can't have our cake and eat it too. There is no line to be drawn.

Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row? by AlexandrB on Friday August 09, 2024 @09:43AM (#41201767)
This is silly for a bunch of reasons, not the least of which is that there are already "weight classes" for many sports as a way to have different body types compete on a more equal playing field. Perhaps dividing competitors by gender is arbitrary, but all game rules are arbitrary.

If we want to remove gender from the equation, perhaps we should have "testosterone classes" where athletes compete against others with a similar testosterone level.

Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row? by blinkedup on Friday August 09, 2024 @07:42PM (#41206309)
But then males could pharmaceutically suppress testosterone, compete in the low testosterone class, and still make use of the male physical advantage they have from going through male puberty and having had testosterone shape their body for many years. You can't unbuild a male, even by adjusting testosterone.
Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row? by jgust on Friday August 09, 2024 @09:46AM (#41201798)
I understand the point you're trying to make, but this entire thread misses the forest for the trees. Rules & regulations don't exist to create equality or fairness, it's to foster competition. We don't watch competitions for how equal and fair they are. By separating competition by gender, we have increased the opportunities to witness competitiveness. How, going forward, can we maximize that metric? That will be the future of sport.
Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row? by Steven420 on Friday August 09, 2024 @09:53AM (#41201858)
What you are describing is the end of women playing sports. What is the point of competing in something you are guaranteed to lose?
Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row? by abenga on Friday August 09, 2024 @03:42PM (#41204788)
Do you know how low the highest ranked man Serena could beat (at her prime) was?
Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row? by NoRagrets on Friday August 09, 2024 @08:52PM (#41206579)
This is the exact definition of Mansplaining.

The past few weeks have seen men in droves mansplaining to women.. ‘what is a woman?’

Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row? by mensetmanusman on Friday August 09, 2024 @09:30AM (#41201638)
The spectrum means that for sports involving strength, at the highest levels of competition women that are most like men will dominate. That’s what we are observing.

Whether it’s fair or not is for the armchair philosophers.

Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row? by sli on Friday August 09, 2024 @09:36AM (#41201694)
If you're referencing the posted article, that is absolutely not what we're "observing" right now, that claim is political propaganda from the American right-wing. Khelif is not trans.
Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row? by cube2222 on Friday August 09, 2024 @09:46AM (#41201794)
I think the parent wasn’t suggesting this. I think that they suggested that in many strength-oriented disciplines biological women with the most masculine features (e.g. high testosterone level) will win.
Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row? by blinkedup on Friday August 09, 2024 @07:56PM (#41206378)
No-one who's been making any serious commentary on this topic has claimed that Khelif is trans. That's not the issue at all.

What all the available evidence so far indicates is that Khelif is male, most likely with a difference of sex development (DSD).

Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row? by thomquaid on Friday August 09, 2024 @09:38AM (#41201711)
That is not true. What we are seeing is people using an identity to gain unsportspersonlike advantages in sport competition.
Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row? by cko on Friday August 09, 2024 @10:03AM (#41201932)
The article says that many people with this condition don't even know until much later. So they were born, raised, and identified with a certain gender all their lives. It's hardly "using an identity."
Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row? by subjectsigma on Friday August 09, 2024 @09:42AM (#41201751)
Biological sex is binary. Not all humans have two arms, but it would be wrong to say the number of arms we have is “a spectrum”. 99% of people start out with two arms. If you think that the number of arms humans have is some unknowable value because amputees exist, that doesn’t make sense to me, it favors a technically correct philosophical argument over reality.

Biologist Richard Dawkins agrees (though his argument is much better stated than mine): https://www.newstatesman.com/ideas/2023/07/biological-sex-bi...

Note that this doesn’t really “solve” all parts of the debate around gender and sports, but it’s a good starting point.

Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row? by defrost on Friday August 09, 2024 @09:48AM (#41201823)
reproductive sex is binary.

Dawkins knows better and knows that that humans are born that are not clearly male, not clearly female, and also very clearly neither male nor female.

That's actual empirical observed science. There are peer reviewed medical papers in respected journals that look at hundreds of thousands of birth records and break the numbers down on distributions of chromosonal variations at birth.

Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row? by subjectsigma on Friday August 09, 2024 @09:55AM (#41201870)
Would you mind linking a study? It seems like that directly contradicts what Dawkins says in his article
Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row? by defrost on Friday August 09, 2024 @10:09AM (#41201988)
I bought a first edition copy of Dawkin's The Selfish Gene in 1978 and a good number of his books since.

He understands genetics and these days, when talking to the likes of Piers Morgan et al. he plays a cagey game and talks about reproductive sex, what is required to make a baby outside of a lab the good old fashioned way, when a sperm fertilises an egg.

He's well aware there are more than two types of human birth, he glosses over what he knows to keep things simple to avoid contraversy or something.

If this is all news to you, rather than something you might have read, as I did, some 40+ years ago, then you might choose to start with:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intersex

IIRC it links to medical papers and meta papers.

There are several people here in Australia that were born neither male nor female. That's a fact. One took a valid complaint through the Australian courts that they would be lying on an official document if they checked either [F] or [M] on an Australian passport.

Doctors and genetics experts gave evidence, the Australian passport system was changed.

This wasn't some "cultural gender" thing based on someone's feelings about gender, it was stone cold genetic reality about "sex" at birth .. which in reality is a lot more complicated than many Fox cable hosts claim it to be on camera.

Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row? by subjectsigma on Friday August 09, 2024 @01:25PM (#41203752)
Ok, great. Can you link to the study which shows chromosomal distributions, the one you mentioned in your comment?
Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row? by defrost on Friday August 09, 2024 @08:44PM (#41206552)
[3], [8], [9], and all the numerous other references that appear immediately after a "%" sign in the already provided link.

[3] is Selma Feldman Witchel (2018). "Disorders of Sex Development". Best Practice & Research. Clinical Obstetrics & Gynaecology. 48: 90–102. doi:10.1016/j.bpobgyn.2017.11.005. PMC 5866176. PMID 29503125. The estimated frequency of genital ambiguity is reported to be in the range of 1:2000–1:4500

Those referencess of the 218 references provided are the ones that mainly focus on various aspects of distribution frequency.

Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row? by subjectsigma on Saturday August 10, 2024 @09:21AM (#41209273)
Thanks!
Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row? by blinkedup on Friday August 09, 2024 @07:32PM (#41206269)
> There are several people here in Australia that were born neither male nor female. That's a fact. One took a valid complaint through the Australian courts that they would be lying on an official document if they checked either [F] or [M] on an Australian passport.

Do you have a reference for or link to the details of the court case? It would be very interesting to understand the details.

Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row? by defrost on Friday August 09, 2024 @08:56PM (#41206593)
There are several Family Court of Australia decisions, along with the Sex Discrimination Act 1984 and its underpinnings that go with the 2003 decision of the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade to recommend that Australian passports allow the indeterminate category and for the State of Victoria to change their policy.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intersex_rights_in_Australia sketches out a framework, the details can be extracted from the public records for the Department, the State of Victoria, and the decisions of the Family Court.

Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row? by blinkedup on Friday August 09, 2024 @09:03PM (#41206632)
Thanks for the link. Looks like Alex MacFarlane was the test case for this. Though I'm surprised he managed to convince them that he needed a passport with an "X" in it, because according to the articles on his case linked from the Wikipedia page, he has Klinefelter syndrome - which is an unambiguously male condition.
Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row? by defrost on Friday August 09, 2024 @10:35PM (#41206898)
Alex MacFarlane publicly brought the case and was the only person publicly named in the press, correct.

> Though I'm surprised he managed to convince them

Would you be equally suprised that Perry Mason won a case concerning a woman? Do you require that a fully limbed wheelchair bound lawyer be disqualified in a disability case about a blind amputee?

The key result here is that people of unambiguously indeterminate sex actually exist and government forms in Australia now recognise that.

A wider realisation that some may not reach is that various syndrome might not unambiguously define male or female for the people borm with such syndromes or be clear to the parents that raise them.

Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row? by blinkedup on Saturday August 10, 2024 @10:59AM (#41209982)
All the examples I can find include people with conditions that are either male DSDs or female DSDs. Seems to me that this system of marking passports with an "X" is flawed by being overly broad, including people who are unambiguously male or female.

If you have specific examples to the contrary, I'd be interested to read about them.

Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row? by defrost on Saturday August 10, 2024 @10:46PM (#41213685)
> All the examples I can find

There's a weird thing that occurs in Australia, civil servants tend to respect citizens right to privacy. Not always, of course, but by and large identities are preserved and hefty fines come into play when privacy is violated.

Hansards and Court transcripts, as you would have found, obfuscate identities in various contexts and reporters that attend are aware of guidelines to follow.

> Seems to me that this system of marking passports with an "X" is flawed by being overly broad, including people who are unambiguously male or female.

Do you or do you not accept as fact that people are born who are neither unambiguously male nor unambiguously female?

It's a very simple Yes or No.

Regardless of your personal belief here, expert testimony in multiple court cases adjudicated by various seperate judges, along with a federal department and a state tribunal all aligned together to agree that Yes was the case in the world in which we live.

Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row? by blinkedup on Sunday August 11, 2024 @12:48PM (#41217453)
> Do you or do you not accept as fact that people are born who are neither unambiguously male nor unambiguously female?

Yes, some people are born who have differences of sex development, and this might require further investigation as to what abnormal event has actually happened in their development, and the root cause. This is for clinicians and developmental biologists to understand and elucidate for the rest of us.

However my point is this "X" marker tells us nothing much useful about this at all, as it's being applied to individuals who are unambiguously of one sex or the other even with DSDs, as with the Klinefelter syndrome cases.

The "X" is even being given to people whose sex is unambiguous, who don't have any DSD condition, but for some reason have come to believe that they are neither a woman or a man. A wholly psychological condition.

Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row? by blinkedup on Friday August 09, 2024 @07:37PM (#41206292)
By chromosomal variations, do you mean sex chromosome aneuploidies? If so, individuals with this particular class of conditions aren't ambiguous with regards to their sex. The Y chromosome still determines if someone is male.

For example, XXY (Klinefelter syndrome) is a male condition, X0 (Turner syndrome) is a female condition, XYY (Jacobs syndrome) is male, and so on.

Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row? by defrost on Friday August 09, 2024 @08:38PM (#41206531)
Of all the humans born, some are clearly and unambigiously male and check all the many boxes that make them male, some are equally female, some others are not so clearly male and only check some of the boxes leaving the gate open for the "but they're really male (even if only a bit)" arguments. Some others again are neither male nor female.

This is the spectrum of human physical and genetic birth presentations as described by peer reviewed medical papers (a number linked in the intersex wikipedia link).

Venn diagrams are not difficult to grasp and anyone taking issue with the categorisation in the field is more than welcome to submit their work and arguments to the relevant journals.

Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row? by blinkedup on Friday August 09, 2024 @08:57PM (#41206599)
Thanks for replying. That doesn't directly answer my question but it sounds like you meant to refer to differences of sex development (DSDs) more broadly rather than just those caused by chromosomal variations.

Though for competitive sports, and protecting the women's category in particular, it is only a smaller set of DSDs that eligibility policymakers need to be concerned with: those that confer male physical advantage.

Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row? by subjectsigma on Friday August 09, 2024 @09:53AM (#41201862)
As a follow up just because I’m still thinking about it. I had a long discussion with a friend about this one time and he advocated for a tiered approach. So instead of having a men’s league you would have an A, B, and C league and people are placed based on performance. If we go just based on pure athletic ability then the A league would be mostly men and the C league would be mostly women, but there would be upward mobility and likely a mixed league in the middle.

This might be a good model for younger kids, but by the time kids reach high school the biological gap is too great. See https://boysvswomen.com/#/ This is a problem because high school is the time when college scholarships become a thing, performance in competitive high school sports matters. Also, you now need three leagues instead of two, which could get expensive depending on the sport.

Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row? by cko on Friday August 09, 2024 @10:12AM (#41202019)
Potential problem: all three leagues are dominated by men, and no one watches leagues B or C.
Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row? by blinkedup on Friday August 09, 2024 @07:30PM (#41206259)
It's fascinating the convoluted ideas people will come up with just to avoid the most obvious one: separate male and female categories.

Did you friend say why he advocated for these arbitrary tiers rather than separating by sex?

Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row? by subjectsigma on Sunday August 11, 2024 @01:04AM (#41214097)
Obviously so trans people can play sports, I think it's a laudable goal but I agree that people are going to great lengths to make sports 'fair' in ways that seem to only make them less fair to 99% of participants
Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row? by blinkedup on Sunday August 11, 2024 @11:19AM (#41216802)
Interestingly there were a couple of transgendered athletes competing in this year's Olympics: Hergie Bacyadan, a female boxer who identifies as a man, and Nikki Hiltz, a female runner who identifies as a non-binary. Both competed in their respective sports in the category congruent with their sex.

I guess your friend was aiming more towards not upsetting male athletes who identify as women and who desire to compete in the female category, by abolishing the category altogether, rather than these male athletes being told "no".

Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row? by kcplate on Friday August 09, 2024 @03:30PM (#41204702)
What always seems lost in this debate is how a trans men can’t generally be competitive in either men’s or women’s sports groupings. Either due to a physical disadvantage due to chromosome and hormonal differences or due to having to settle for an identity disadvantage (forced to identify as their biological sex instead of their gender to be in a competitive group).

Honestly it seems like the easiest solution is eliminate sports groupings by their references to sex or gender, and just divide up by those sciencey things which are generally known to provide the athletic advantages.

Group 1 Above a testosterone baseline and/or if you have XY chromosomes

Group 2 Below a testosterone baseline.

If you don't feel binary grouping is fair, set up multiple groups to accommodate.

Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row? by blinkedup on Friday August 09, 2024 @07:50PM (#41206350)
> due to having to settle for an identity disadvantage

There is a female athlete who identifies as a man currently competing in the Olympics: Hergie Bacyadan - in women's boxing.

This doesn't seem to have caused any actual disadvantage. In fact, Bacyadan is reported as saying:

> I'm very thankful that I got to the Olympics. It's a big deal to me.

Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row? by kcplate on Friday August 09, 2024 @08:56PM (#41206595)
He may be ok with it, and good for him, but isn’t the fact that he is competing in the women’s brackets to be able to fight competitively sort of proving my greater point? I don’t know of any trans man in a men’s sport that relies on physical athleticism that is dominating or even competitive. But we tend to see the opposite when trans women compete in women’s sports.

Why not just eliminate the gender/sex delineations and focus on benchmarks we know create competitive differences?

Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row? by blinkedup on Saturday August 10, 2024 @11:02AM (#41210009)
I think this illustrates the opposite point: that being of the female sex is the most important eligibility criterion for ensuring fairness and maximising safety in women's sports, and identity is irrelevant to this.
Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row? by YeGoblynQueenne on Saturday August 10, 2024 @02:32PM (#41211337)
I don't think anyone suggests that having a male identity is an advantage in women sports.
Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row? by blinkedup on Sunday August 11, 2024 @12:52PM (#41217498)
No but the commenter I was replying to suggested removing both sex and identity as eligibility criteria for women's sport. Whereas I was arguing it should be sex first and foremost.

Additional criteria can be added to take care of the edge cases but sex is most important and impactful.

Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row? by kcplate on Sunday August 11, 2024 @05:36PM (#41219481)
I believe you must of missed the “and/or having XY chromosomes” distinction I made on the first group.
Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row? by blinkedup on Sunday August 11, 2024 @05:51PM (#41219553)
I read your comment as prioritizing testosterone levels over sex. My apologies if I misinterpreted.
Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row? by blinkedup on Friday August 09, 2024 @08:20PM (#41206471)
I don't think a spectrum is the most helpful way to model the problem. What may be more useful is to consider normal males and normal females as the baseline, and then a set of discrete edge cases within each sex involving differences in sex development (DSDs) as the outliers.

The question when it comes to competitive sports is, which of these DSDs confer male physical advantage onto the individual?

As an example, though we can speculate with some now quite strong evidence on these two Olympic boxers, perhaps it's best to look at an athlete whose DSD is already known and confirmed: Caster Semenya, who won gold in the Women's 800m of the 2016 Olympics in Rio.

Because of a ruling published by the Court of Arbitration for Sport, we know that Semenya has 5-alpha reductase deficiency (5-ARD), a male-specific (XY) DSD that, due to a recessive gene mutation, impairs the conversion of testosterone to DHT such that the penis is underdeveloped and the testes typically remain internal to the body.

Newborns with 5-ARD may, in the absence of sex testing, be erroneously observed to be female, and have this written on their birth documentation. This is what happened with Semenya.

However, the testes are still functional. Individuals with 5-ARD go through male puberty, produce testosterone in the normal male range, and in athletic competition, will therefore have male physical advantage.

In response to Semenya's case, the IAAF (now World Athletics) instituted a rule change so that 5-ARD individuals, and others with DSDs that are known to confer male performance advantage, are by default deemed ineligible to compete in women's events.

That is: on the basis that being male is not a talent, they chose policy that does not reward male physical advantage in competitions that should be about celebrating female athletic excellence.

So I think this isn't really about if sex or gender can be thought of as a spectrum, but what policy decisions, regarding DSDs, need to be made to ensure fairness in women's sport. And in the case of contact sports like boxing, safety as well.

Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row? by YeGoblynQueenne on Saturday August 10, 2024 @02:46PM (#41211396)
I disagree and I think the reason there is disagreement and debate is exactly because of how hard it is to define male and female, man and woman (which may be either four or two categories) in a way that covers every individual case. The BBC article makes exactly that point: you can't just look at someone's Y chromosome and say whether they're male or not. Not for 100% of humanity.

And remember we can't see chromosomes. You say this with apparent certainty:

>> Newborns with 5-ARD may, in the absence of sex testing, be erroneously observed to be female, and have this written on their birth documentation.

Who is to say that a baby born with female external genitalia is "erroneously" observed to be female? If we observed them to be male, how would that not be erroneous? Again: we don't observe chromosomes directly. The line between the categories of "male" and "female" we understand was drawn long before anyone knew anything about chromosomes and there is no reason why knowing that a majority but not all individuals in the male or female category have the same "chromosomes" (the same karyotype, really) should eliminate the criterion we used before that, i.e. external genitalia at birth.

In the same vein, who is to say that someone who was assigned female at birth, who grew up as a girl, socialised as a girl, grew up to be accepted as a woman by their entire society - was "erroneously" so?

I think that would be a very lazy attitude to adopt (no offense to you) and that we should instead be prepared to accept that sex determination is hard in the fringes where people are not like most of us and we shouldn't make absolute proclamations like "XY is male".

And we should not forget that telling a person who grew up as a woman that she is now a man, or that she is stripped of some of the natural rights of a woman, like competing in women's sports, is cruel and a form of violation. It's like a forced sex change, a forced intervention to a person's identity that they developed spontaneously by living the only life they have in the only body they have. We should tread very carefully when dealing with people with DSD, especially when it's all in the name of "fairness". Scientists certainly do and not for reasons of fairness but for reasons of accuracy.

Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row? by blinkedup on Sunday August 11, 2024 @01:23PM (#41217756)
> And remember we can't see chromosomes. You say this with apparent certainty:

>> Newborns with 5-ARD may, in the absence of sex testing, be erroneously observed to be female, and have this written on their birth documentation.

> Who is to say that a baby born with female external genitalia is "erroneously" observed to be female? If we observed them to be male, how would that not be erroneous? Again: we don't observe chromosomes directly. The line between the categories of "male" and "female" we understand was drawn long before anyone knew anything about chromosomes and there is no reason why knowing that a majority but not all individuals in the male or female category have the same "chromosomes" (the same karyotype, really) should eliminate the criterion we used before that, i.e. external genitalia at birth.

I would say it's erroneous because in the present day we have advanced testing and advanced research into developmental biology to much more completely understand the underlying process that builds female and male bodies.

Like we know that the only difference between males with 5-ARD and males who developed normally is they lack an enzyme needed to make the penis grow properly and the testes to descend. They have no female reproductive system: no ovaries, fallopian tubes, uterus. With this knowledge, what reason is there to classify these individuals as female?

> In the same vein, who is to say that someone who was assigned female at birth, who grew up as a girl, socialised as a girl, grew up to be accepted as a woman by their entire society - was "erroneously" so?

I think that is more to do with socio-cultural views on women and men than anything else, and not so relevant in the narrower case of eligibility in women's sport, which has to be based around eliminating male physical advantage, otherwise there's no reason for the category to exist.

> And we should not forget that telling a person who grew up as a woman that she is now a man, or that she is stripped of some of the natural rights of a woman, like competing in women's sports, is cruel and a form of violation.

I agree it must come as a huge shock to find out that you're male when you'd believed you were female.

But isn't it also cruel to female athletes when they are being compelled to compete with a male? Is it not a violation for a female boxer to be punched in the skull by a male with significantly greater upper body strength?

My view is that sports organisations have a duty of care and a duty of fairness to all athletes, not just the ones who've received unwanted news about eligibility due to their sex.

Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row? by YeGoblynQueenne on Monday August 12, 2024 @07:21AM (#41223250)
>> With this knowledge, what reason is there to classify these individuals as female?

We already do: we determine the sex of babies at birth, and each others' sex as adults, by looking at external genitalia and at secondary sex characteristics.

Why would knowledge of chromosomes now change that? Like I say above, we can't see chromosomes. And the people who can, i.e. biologists, have a much more nuanced view of what it means for an individual to be male or female, rather than their karyotype (and not their chromosomes) being male or female. The scientists interviewed for the BBC article all agree that whether an individual, a person, is male or female, is not clear cut and that detecting, or not, a Y chromosome is not enough of a criterion.

Keep in mind that "all X have Y" is not equivalent with "all who have Y are X". Or replace "all" with "most" and the same goes.

>> I think that is more to do with socio-cultural views on women and men than anything else, and not so relevant in the narrower case of eligibility in women's sport, which has to be based around eliminating male physical advantage, otherwise there's no reason for the category to exist.

The BBC article points out that there is no test that can determine "male physical advantage" as you put it. Also note that some athletic associations, e.g. World Athletics, consider athletes with Y-chromosome DSDs to be eligible for competition in women's categories as long as they reduce their testosterone to male levels medically. See:

https://www.bbc.com/sport/athletics/65051900

As an aside, note in the same article that World Athletics now completely bans transgendered women _who have gone through male puberty_ from competing in the women's category so even having one's sex determined as male as birth is not recognised as an absolute advantage in women's sports; the cutoff is having gone through a male puberty, which a genetic test alone cannot determine.

To be clear, I do think that banning trans women who have gone through male puberty from sports is _on balance_ the fair choice, although it means transgendered women cannot reasonably compete in any category, since it would be unfair for them to compete in the male category and there is no special third category. End aside.

>> But isn't it also cruel to female athletes when they are being compelled to compete with a male?

Yes, but I'm claiming that someone whose sex was determined to be female at birth, and lived their whole life as a woman, and experienced everything that every other woman experiences, is not a male.

>> My view is that sports organisations have a duty of care and a duty of fairness to all athletes, not just the ones who've received unwanted news about eligibility due to their sex.

Of course, but those athletes also deserve a fair treatment. And ruling that they can't compete as women, when they are recognised as women in every other aspect of their lives since birth, is very hard to see as fair. Should we start to treat those women as men in their everyday lives also? That sounds even more unfair.

Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row? by blinkedup on Monday August 26, 2024 @05:06AM (#41355274)
> We already do: we determine the sex of babies at birth, and each others' sex as adults, by looking at external genitalia and at secondary sex characteristics.

> Why would knowledge of chromosomes now change that?

If we look again at the case of Caster Semenya, who was reportedly assigned female at birth, with a birth certificate to match, but for whom later tests showed XY chromosomes, this was a strong indication of Semenya actually being male. Then further investigation revealed that Semenya has 5-ARD, a male-only DSD condition in which the penis does not develop as normal due to a mutation in an enzyme responsible for transforming testosterone to DHT. The testes are present and caused Semenya to go through male puberty. There is no female reproductive system: no uterus, no cervix, no fallopian tubes, no ovaries. But there is a male reproductive system, albeit a broken one: testes and an underdeveloped penis. On this basis, Semenya is male, not female.

Knowledge of sex chromosomes was the starting point for confirming that Semenya is a male.

> Also note that some athletic associations, e.g. World Athletics, consider athletes with Y-chromosome DSDs to be eligible for competition in women's categories as long as they reduce their testosterone to [fe]male levels medically.

That's true but it's also controversial. The female category can only coherently exist if the eligibility criteria excludes the male physical advantage acquired by males during male sexual development. And there's no evidence that this advantage is wholly removed when these males suppress testosterone. Only evidence of some weakening. The male body remains.

> As an aside, note in the same article that World Athletics now completely bans transgendered women _who have gone through male puberty_ from competing in the women's category so even having one's sex determined as male as birth is not recognised as an absolute advantage in women's sports; the cutoff is having gone through a male puberty, which a genetic test alone cannot determine.

I think this is an important aside to mention. The male physical advantage is equivalent between the cohorts of males with a trans identity and males with an androgen-sensitive DSD (like 5-ARD). In terms of fair competition, it doesn't really make sense to permit eligibility via testosterone suppression for one group but not the other.

> Yes, but I'm claiming that someone whose sex was determined to be female at birth, and lived their whole life as a woman, and experienced everything that every other woman experiences, is not a male.

Does this apply to the athletes we're discussing though? Having testes and going through male puberty, as Caster Semenya did, is not a female experience.

Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row? by NoRagrets on Friday August 09, 2024 @08:48PM (#41206564)
Everyone has the right to ‘boil down’ anything to whatever. But science says otherwise.

XX or female is the default setting. If there is any deviation from the default, then there is a change or transformation. And the result is no longer female. It could be male. Or not. But it’s not ‘female’.

Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row? by chiefalchemist on Monday August 12, 2024 @03:33PM (#41228375)
OP here. That's my point. In shooting for absolute equal, we're trying to take what is not binary - it's more of a biological spectrum (chromosomes, hormones, etc.) - and make it binary. Square peg, round hole, and so on.

Putting equal aside (because it's not realistic) leaves "What is fair? To all?" and that's a different question.

Not to make light or sound snarky (but to make a point), if we use equal as the goal, then what's to stop those who are height-challenged from demanding to play basketball?

Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row? by sssskskss on Monday August 12, 2024 @04:32PM (#41228981)
Basketball does have restricted height leagues https://wdg2023.com/sports/our-sports/basketball-2/
Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row? by NoRagrets on Tuesday August 13, 2024 @12:10AM (#41232136)
Women have periods, pregnancy and menopause. Our entire lives have been shaped by this journey we were meant to make. It’s our design. That’s what defines women. That’s our identity.

The opposite binary and other uncategorised versions are not the default female.

The genders are not equal. I lost my farm after 12 years because I was in ‘violation of farm management policy’ because I didn’t follow their list of 6 different PTO implement.

As a female, I don’t have the upper body strength to operate and change all those PTO implements. I spent not a small amount to fabricate and fashion my own small implement that was originally imported from Italy.

And yet.. even though my design was better..I was constantly compared to male farmers .. “why are you not following their methods and same equipment as the dudes? Well..because I have breasts, shorter arms and lesser upper body strength, you idiots!”

And this was the State of California public agency that controlled my land access that I lost and subsequently lost my farm due to lack of land access.

I am particularly depressed now because there is no way I expect a fair hearing ..the world has gone mad. Daft as a drunk duck, I am telling you.. and it’s just depressing. They have stolen 12 years of my life and my work(I was working on automating my farm equipment) because I am not a man.

I don’t want to be equal to a man. I want to be myself. I empathize with those training for female sports. We can’t win anywhere. Soon we will only be relegated for one job..for the one thing only we can do..and what only we possess: wombs. I don’t even want to live in this world anymore.