Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row?
by blinkedup on Friday August 09, 2024 @07:50PM
(#41206350)
> due to having to settle for an identity disadvantage
There is a female athlete who identifies as a man currently competing in the Olympics: Hergie Bacyadan - in women's boxing.
This doesn't seem to have caused any actual disadvantage. In fact, Bacyadan is reported as saying:
> I'm very thankful that I got to the Olympics. It's a big deal to me.
Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row?
by kcplate on Friday August 09, 2024 @08:56PM
(#41206595)
He may be ok with it, and good for him, but isn’t the fact that he is competing in the women’s brackets to be able to fight competitively sort of proving my greater point? I don’t know of any trans man in a men’s sport that relies on physical athleticism that is dominating or even competitive. But we tend to see the opposite when trans women compete in women’s sports.
Why not just eliminate the gender/sex delineations and focus on benchmarks we know create competitive differences?
Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row?
by blinkedup on Saturday August 10, 2024 @11:02AM
(#41210009)
I think this illustrates the opposite point: that being of the female sex is the most important eligibility criterion for ensuring fairness and maximising safety in women's sports, and identity is irrelevant to this.
Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row?
by YeGoblynQueenne on Saturday August 10, 2024 @02:32PM
(#41211337)
I don't think anyone suggests that having a male identity is an advantage in women sports.
Re:What do scientists tell us about boxing's gender row?
by blinkedup on Sunday August 11, 2024 @12:52PM
(#41217498)
No but the commenter I was replying to suggested removing both sex and identity as eligibility criteria for women's sport. Whereas I was arguing it should be sex first and foremost.
Additional criteria can be added to take care of the edge cases but sex is most important and impactful.
Honestly it seems like the easiest solution is eliminate sports groupings by their references to sex or gender, and just divide up by those sciencey things which are generally known to provide the athletic advantages.
Group 1 Above a testosterone baseline and/or if you have XY chromosomes
Group 2 Below a testosterone baseline.
If you don't feel binary grouping is fair, set up multiple groups to accommodate.