News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by jameslk on Sunday July 28, 2024 @02:19AM (#41091538)
There’s no political will to raise taxes and cut government spending. One or the other may happen but not both. Both are required to get us out of this mess. We don’t have politicians that think long term.

As a consequence, the Fed will be forced to lower interest rates as low as possible again so the government can escape crushing interest payments and let inflation inflate away government debt.

Expect long term inflation, asset prices, and commodity prices that keeps rising as a consequence.

Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by toomuchtodo on Sunday July 28, 2024 @02:32AM (#41091587)
One would think a rating agency might call time on debt growing beyond what a declining population pyramid can support (through ratings downgrades). Even if the Fed lowers rates, investors might not have appetite for declining quality sovereign debt that will never be paid back. But maybe Japan and the BOJ show this is immaterial.
Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by DANmode on Sunday July 28, 2024 @04:46AM (#41092022)
Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by toomuchtodo on Sunday July 28, 2024 @03:05PM (#41095216)
These are banks, I’m referring to sovereign debt. As a nation state, when you issue sovereign debt, that is a promise to repay that debt in the future. Who will be paying that debt back? Workers generating output that will be taxed in some way, with taxes servicing and retiring future debt obligations. What will there be less of in the future? Workers (structural demographics, total fertility rate rapidly declining globally, etc). The collateral (a claim on future worker aggregate productivity) doesn’t exist for the promises to repay in the future, therefore the debt should be rated as higher risk and less likely to be paid back. This would force interest rates higher on issued debt (more risk demands higher yields), but whether the market has an appetite for debt issued with more realistic fundamental expectations remains to be seen.
Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by snowwrestler on Monday July 29, 2024 @07:11AM (#41099507)
We think we know the approximate trajectory of future population growth. We might be wrong though.

We definitely don’t know the future trajectory of productivity growth. There might be inflection points that more than compensate for slowing worker growth. This is in fact the basis for investor excitement about clean energy, robotics, artificial intelligence, new health care technologies, etc.

Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by toomuchtodo on Monday July 29, 2024 @03:16PM (#41102913)
How wild that these bonds are both considered incredibly safe but also highly speculative, a bet on future aggregate productivity.
Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by ganeshkrishnan on Monday July 29, 2024 @11:45AM (#41101319)
Sovereign Debts are the Treasury Bonds. There is no chance in hell, it will have a lower rating. The debt will always be paid off, at the cost of higher yields for the future. Its an extremely unpleasant situation but inflation and higher taxes are first in line before even any possibility of Treasuries defaulting.
Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by linotype on Sunday July 28, 2024 @04:38AM (#41092002)
Why would they think long term? They’re all about to die according to actuary tables.
Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by JKCalhoun on Sunday July 28, 2024 @07:50AM (#41092619)
Come on, they have kids, grandkids like everyone else. The answer is that long term doesn't sell. We all know that.
Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by JumpCrisscross on Sunday July 28, 2024 @05:51AM (#41092219)
> no political will to raise taxes and cut government spending. One or the other may happen but not both. Both are required to get us out of this mess

Did we read the same article?

Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by jameslk on Sunday July 28, 2024 @05:11PM (#41095998)
My point is that there is no political will that leads to the long term fiscal adjustments proposed in TFA
Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by OscarCunningham on Sunday July 28, 2024 @06:39AM (#41092363)
Why do people suggest inflating away debt rather than just defaulting on it? I'd guess that the debt markets would punish the two options equally, because bonds would lose the same amount of real value either way. But inflation also screws up your economy as a side effect.
Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by heisenbit on Sunday July 28, 2024 @06:47AM (#41092387)
Default impact is spread more unevenly compared with inflation.
Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by dragontamer on Sunday July 28, 2024 @11:12AM (#41093753)
Because defaulting means that Social Security Trust Fund fails to get paid.

A huge amount of debt is to Americans, American institutions and the states.

Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by randerson on Sunday July 28, 2024 @11:54AM (#41094024)
Defaulting on debt is the fastest way to turn the US into a third world country. Banks would fail, since they invest our deposits in long-term assets including treasuries. Companies typically store their cash in treasuries and money markets, so companies would go under (or have to issue more shares under duress), crashing the stock market. Retirees would stop receiving Social Security payments, and retirees' nest eggs are normally mostly bonds.

The US would piss off other countries who lent us money, who'd come knocking with a country-scale baseball bat demanding their money. But two thirds of that $35T is owed to Americans. There'd be a good chance of either a civil war or global war. We'd likely lose our status as the world's reserve currency, devaluing the dollar and leading to inflation.

Nobody would trust the government enough to lend them money, so they'd have no choice but to print money to pay expenses at this point. So, we'd have inflation either way.

Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by ianhawes on Monday July 29, 2024 @09:19AM (#41100240)
Sounds promising, let's do it.
Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by quickthrowman on Sunday July 28, 2024 @04:05PM (#41095583)
> Why do people suggest inflating away debt rather than just defaulting on it? I'd guess that the debt markets would punish the two options equally, because bonds would lose the same amount of real value either way. But inflation also screws up your economy as a side effect.

Defaulting would impact the value of Treasurys far more than inflation, a bond’s price is merely the sum of its future cash flows, pricing in a default would push yields waaay higher than they would from inflation alone. There would also be massive liquidity problems since banks and companies hold a ton of Treasurys along with pensions and retirees.

There’s far more negative impacts from a debt default that sibling comments already elaborated on.

There are very few black swan scenarios that would cause me to liquidate the assets in my retirement accounts for cash, but a US sovereign default would be one of them.

Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by x-complexity on Sunday July 28, 2024 @09:28PM (#41097306)
> Why do people suggest inflating away debt rather than just defaulting on it?

Because one ultimately still keeps the debt obligation in place, whilst the latter causes debt confidence collapses & the destruction of faith in repayments from the government.

Would you rather take a 2% value loss via inflation, or a 90-100% value loss as the government declares default? Most people would take the former rather than the latter, as the impact of one is much softer than the other.

Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by ilyagr on Sunday July 28, 2024 @11:42PM (#41097760)
2% inflation per year is a healthy amount. To inflate away 90% of debt, I imagine 1000% of inflation would be needed over some amount of time (and this amount of time better be short enough that you don't accumulate significant debt during it).
Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by greyface- on Monday July 29, 2024 @12:37AM (#41097922)
A default on US debt would be unconstitutional, per section 4 of the 14th amendment. Inflation, on the other hand, is not unconstitutional.
Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by DataDive on Sunday July 28, 2024 @07:36AM (#41092555)
There is plenty of political will of every kind.

We, the population, vote for the persons with specific political wills. We choose what to enact.

Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by JKCalhoun on Sunday July 28, 2024 @07:48AM (#41092610)
Then OP is essentially saying that we appear not to choose politicians that are prescribing bitter medicine.
Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by tastyfreeze on Sunday July 28, 2024 @11:43AM (#41093962)
That is true. We have mostly elected politicians that promise to bring as much federal tax dollars home as possible. When you have promised the moon, telling your constituents that the rocket needs to be dismantled and sold off is political suicide.
Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by elcritch on Monday July 29, 2024 @01:26AM (#41098091)
It's similar to when folks say "big corporations" or "oil companies" are responsible for climate change. No Karen, you are the reason those companies can and do sell their products. It's a method of diverting personal responsibility, IMHO.
Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by secretsatan on Monday July 29, 2024 @03:55AM (#41098662)
I don't buy that, making it a personal responsibility problem was an implemented strategy by those responsible to avoid having to pay the price of doing anything about it.

We literally have no choice but to make small insignificant changes that does not harm the bottom line of those responsible too much.

Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by impossiblefork on Monday July 29, 2024 @03:23AM (#41098518)
No, it is the oil companies and that oil is permitted to be used.

When something is permitted, it becomes mandatory to somebody, and oil is used widely. Personally choosing to avoid products that used oil in their manufacturing would basically relegate you to having to farm your own food by hand. That is not feasible in a society with competition.

Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by dukeyukey on Monday July 29, 2024 @05:16AM (#41099066)
And equally, not permitting oil to be used would create a multi-continental scale famine with hundreds of millions dying.
Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by weweweoo on Monday July 29, 2024 @05:25AM (#41099109)
Obviously the transition away from oil should be gradual, and the sectors which are hardest to transition could be given more time to do so. But there's no fundamental need for large scale use of oil, it's just the current infrastructure and limited tech that's the problem.

Hundreds of millions will die due to climate change if we don't act.

Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by impossiblefork on Monday July 29, 2024 @01:40PM (#41102189)
I'm sure it would, but it could also be avoided without any major problems.

The problem I think, is that oil would still be mandatory because of competition between countries. Especially if there were wars.

Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by weweweoo on Monday July 29, 2024 @05:23AM (#41099101)
No, things should be regulated so that individuals have no choice but to do the right thing. It's governments responsibility to steer Karen towards more sustainable consumption choices. Either tax unsustainable business to make it unprofitable, or tax purchase of their services so that it's not rational for Karen to buy their product / services. The ecological choice should be made the cheapest.

Universally in this world people live most ecologically in parts of the world where they are too poor to act otherwise, not where they are most climate or environment conscious. Voluntary personal responsibility gets you nowhere when it comes to solving large-scale problems.

Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by elcritch on Monday July 29, 2024 @06:01AM (#41099263)
> Either tax unsustainable business to make it unprofitable, or tax purchase of their services so that it's not rational for Karen to buy their product / services. The ecological choice should be made the cheapest.

That sounds great and all until your granny can’t afford heat in the winter or there’s no food in the stores, etc. Then people will vote out the politicians making the policies or revolt.

That’s what I’m talking about personal responsibility. Not regarding individual actions per se, but accepting that most of us in the developed world are as complicit as the big oil companies.

That said, technology is improving to where the cheapest option is the ecological one for power. A fair bit of that has been due to individual actions of many folks wanting and paying for solar power and electric vehicles, etc.

Ironically to me, the individual preferences of the Green Party members also put lots of political pressure to shutdown nuclear power in Germany. That caused Germany to fallback to coal and natural gas.

Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by BriggyDwiggs42 on Monday July 29, 2024 @04:28PM (#41103461)
Hey don’t get me wrong, we kinda suck in first world countries, but oil companies are run by people with full awareness of what they’re doing and the agency to stop who choose not to stop singly because they’re too interested in raking in money they will never even find a use for.
Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by snikeris on Monday July 29, 2024 @03:45PM (#41103136)
> No, things should be regulated so that individuals have no choice but to do the right thing.

Good luck clawing back the 10% of SNAP benefits spent on soda.

Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by watwut on Monday July 29, 2024 @09:25AM (#41100282)
It is other way round. Good half "personality responsibility" claims are all about corporate acts being blamed on people who cant influence them.
Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by consteval on Monday July 29, 2024 @11:48AM (#41101345)
Ultimately the end consumer has little to no control, or knowledge, to enact this.

Yes everyone should be ethical in their consumption. If I gave you an arbitrary product and asked you to tell me if its ethically sourced, there's a high chance you can't. Even if I give you the internet and a week to research.

So, that's one problem. Another problem is that even if you could tell what is/isn't ethical you can't necessarily switch away.

Sometimes the more ethical choices aren't available, or are too expensive, or are outlandish. I'm sure everyone in the US would love to eat grass fed pasture raised beef. Meredith, who works two shifts at the town Dairy Queen, who's trying to give her son some protein, so his tiny muscles don't atrophy, doesn't have the funds for that.

Cars and oil are perhaps the most clear-cut example of this. People don't drive because they want to, they do it because they have to. It's literally life or death. A car in the US isn't just a box on wheels, it's a lifeline.

Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by BriggyDwiggs42 on Monday July 29, 2024 @04:20PM (#41103392)
Is it Karen’s fault when she is told by her media for thirty years that climate change is bs? Is it her fault that she tries to recycle, but most of the plastic she puts in the bin is misleadingly labeled and has to be sorted out? Is it Karen’s fault she drives a gas car to work because public transit is underdeveloped and electric cars are too expensive? Framing climate change as a matter of personal responsibility is extremely counterproductive IMHO.
Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by verzali on Monday July 29, 2024 @03:40AM (#41098577)
Which is true. Who votes for someone promising to raise taxes and give you less for it? People only vote for that to happen to other people, not to themselves.
Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by barryrandall on Monday July 29, 2024 @09:36AM (#41100337)
The problem with voting for candidates who solve problems with unpopular approaches is that they lose elections to people who campaign on making the problem worse.
Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by vannevar on Monday July 29, 2024 @01:35PM (#41102154)
>Then OP is essentially saying that we appear not to choose politicians that are prescribing bitter medicine.

Sort of. I think it's more accurate to say that there are just enough fiscally irresponsible politicians in office to prevent a government that pays as it goes via taxes. The vast majority of those politicians are Republican, taught by Ronald Reagan that they could have massive spending AND tax cuts without political penalty (indeed, Reagan was rewarded with adulation for nearly tripling the national debt). Democrats have been fairly consistent in reducing the deficit, and if they'd had their political druthers, would've reduced it even further with additional taxes. The reality is that maintaining a modern superpower of over 300 million people requires much more in annual taxes than voters realize, at least in part because they've been misled by Republican leadership to believe that taxes (particularly progressive taxes) are unnecessary.

Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by Qem on Monday July 29, 2024 @09:25AM (#41100284)
> There is plenty of political will of every kind.

There's no direct election, and despite "every kind" of politician existing, the representatives of two parties with very similar polices overall, differing only in pointless stuff, keep taking turns in the presidency since forever. The choices are quite constrained.

Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by practicemaths on Monday July 29, 2024 @10:04AM (#41100536)
One side is willing to raise taxes on billionares and continue to have democracy. The other not so much.

your argument stopped having any semblance of merit at least decade ago. Now it is laughably unbelievable.

Now, ought there be more direct representation? Of course!

Should we have more than two major parties? Of course!

Guess what, a lot of people on this forum I am sure make plenty of money to be able to afford going to a few fundraising events for local politicians that they favor.

Y'all have influence here if you want to use it.

Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by Fatnino on Monday July 29, 2024 @10:17AM (#41100659)
Doesn't matter who you buy into the whitehouse, you also need to buy the majority in both houses of congress for anything to get done.

This is prohibitively expensive for anyone, even the largest corporations.

Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by practicemaths on Monday July 29, 2024 @12:10PM (#41101507)
It's not too expensive to start paying for fundraising dinners for your local representatives, mayors, congress persons, etc.

You can help get people elected into local positions that align with your interests. AND some of those people will continue to build their career in politics and may become Senator or Governor someday.

That's influence. That's buying into the system to make it how you think things will be better.

Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by Fatnino on Wednesday July 31, 2024 @12:55AM (#41116485)
My house rep has been in office for over 30 years. And my city doesn't directly elect the mayor.

Such is life in Palo Alto.

Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by practicemaths on Wednesday July 31, 2024 @05:48AM (#41117685)
Too bad there aren't County and other elections out there.

It appears that Palo Alto has elections for city council every 4 years.

Here's an election guide:

https://www.cityofpaloalto.org/Departments/City-Clerk/Munici...

https://www.cityofpaloalto.org/Departments/City-Clerk/Munici...

Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by fujjbom on Monday July 29, 2024 @03:17PM (#41102921)
> We, the population, vote for the persons with specific political wills. We choose what to enact.

Except that this is far from the reality.

We elect people with specific views but they seem to vote regardless of their constituent interests, let alone their supporters’. Instances of this fact are very easily searchable online.

https://act.represent.us/sign/problempoll-fba

You want me to believe that the majority of constituents represented by these 193 republican representatives are against an insulin price cap?

https://images.dailykos.com/images/1054844/story_image/FPNbI...

My newest advocacy addresses this problem.

I call it “extend the powers of justice by jury”.

The idea that these representatives can just vote without accountability is absurd, and clearly a weakness money has uncovered in the US political system. (I refuse the claim status quotitians make that “elections are accountability“)

My suggestion is elected representatives act as litigators to their side of the argument and they need to make their claim to a jury overseen by a judge. That jury determines if a bill passes.

Who you elect as your representatives still matters, but now their ability to litigate persuasively is the number one quality of consideration when choosing those representatives.

This should remove the power that money has in bills being passed, as well as completely remove the “rider compromises” where officials compromise by including unrelated clauses to encourage the passing of a bill.

I want a representative government and I think expanding the powers of justice by jury will help in further enshrining that goal in our political systems.

Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by cjbillington on Sunday July 28, 2024 @08:06AM (#41092695)
The Fed is expected to cut soon regardless, not to bail out the government but because inflation is falling. I imagine that will be the resolution to this. Perhaps rates won't go as low as you're suggesting, but they are expected to be decently lower than they are now.
Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by MuffinFlavored on Sunday July 28, 2024 @11:13AM (#41093755)
> We don’t have politicians that think long term.

They wouldn't get voted in. You said it yourself. What kind of platform is "let me cut your benefits/raise your taxes for temporary pain now so that hopefully in 10 years some good thing (that you might not even notice) will happen if everything goes according to plan"?

Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by anonym29 on Sunday July 28, 2024 @02:08PM (#41094853)
>Both are required to get us out of this mess.

Disagree on multiple counts.

First - you don't need both - if you cut Social Security and Medicaid altogether, and use the surplus to start paying down debt, that solves 100% of the deficit and starts chipping away at the debt, while this would actually reduce taxes rather than raising them. I'm not asserting that the political will exists to do this (it doesn't), but the idea that you can't balance the budget without raising taxes is obviously false - taxes are nonzero, but you could reduce spending to zero.

Second - you don't actually need either - if you hyperinflate the currency, the value of the existing debt becomes negligible. To wit, I fundamentally agree with the message of the remainder of your post.

Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by AnimalMuppet on Sunday July 28, 2024 @02:17PM (#41094927)
The whole point of "getting out of this mess" is so that you don't hyperinflate the currency, with all the economic and political damage that causes. "Don't bother doing either, just hyperinflate" is therefore not doing anything at all, just resigning yourself (and the country) to your fate.
Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by anonym29 on Sunday July 28, 2024 @02:22PM (#41094965)
Hyperinflation is a different mess from unsustainable debt. I took "getting out of this mess" literally, rather than meaning "getting out of this mess while avoiding getting into any other messes in the process".
Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by mikewarot on Monday July 29, 2024 @01:48AM (#41098195)
> if you cut Social Security and Medicaid altogether, and use the surplus to start paying down debt

How is making me and almost everyone over 60 homeless going to result in a surplus? There would be all the dead lawmakers to bury, and so much security to try to protect the rest.

That's a "let them eat cake" level of breaking the social contract you're considering

Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by anonym29 on Monday July 29, 2024 @08:09AM (#41099809)
I already noted that this is a political impossibility, we're talking about strict hypotheticals from a budget analysis perspective, not serious proposals.

I'm sympathetic to your struggles if OASI is the difference between you being homeless and not 60+ years into your life. Just know that your benefits are slated to be reduced by a minimum of 21%, automatically starting in 2033 when the trust fund is depleted, per laws already on the books.

Social Security and Medicare are, fundamentally, classic pyramid schemes. They rely on an infinitely increasing number of people to remain fiscally viable. We're at the end of that road now though, U.S. TFR is down ~1.6. These programs are going to crack soon, and anyone under the age of 40 today will never see a penny from either of these programs despite paying in for their entire lives.

I understand that ripping away benefits you already paid for is unfair to your generation, but being forced to fund benefits we'll never receive is also unfair to my generation, to say nothing of all the generations after mine.

Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by iteria on Monday July 29, 2024 @10:06AM (#41100568)
We could fund both of them easily with no strain by removing the contribution cap at 250K of income and not raiding the fund for extra change every time the government is pressed for money. The US is not in a demographic situation where Medicare and Social Security are untenable, but removing these programs would impact young people by making them responsible for their elders. It's easier to bear the burden when everyone pays in than everyone having to consider how they're going to afford to support their parents, etc and how they'll afford their definitely sky high private insurance. These two programs are the lesser of evils for the problem of elders.
Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by staticman2 on Monday July 29, 2024 @10:36AM (#41100806)
>I already noted that this is a political impossibility,

Considering your argument is based on your belief 21% equals 100%, I should hope so!

Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by anonym29 on Monday July 29, 2024 @03:40PM (#41103086)
I don't believe I've posed the arguement that 21% and 100% are the same thing, just that an automatic 21% reduction is where we are headed if nothing changes, as the way the program is currently structured and funded is unsustainable and is going to deplete the trust fund by 2033, which is a projection from the SSA themselves.
Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by staticman2 on Tuesday July 30, 2024 @10:19AM (#41109460)
I'm sure you actually understand reduction of 21% does not mean you will "not see a penny" (i.e. a 100% reduction) yet that's what you wrote, so here we are.
Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by anonym29 on Friday August 02, 2024 @09:00AM (#41138517)
The people who are expecting benefits in 2033 and the people under 40 are two entirely separate generations. The latter will not inherit a Social Security system that is more fiscally stable than the former, only worse.
Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by TurkishPoptart on Monday July 29, 2024 @11:53AM (#41101383)
Why should we raise taxes?
Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by eitau_1 on Monday July 29, 2024 @05:03PM (#41103778)
to put public finances on sustainable path, keep inflation low and make interest rates lower long term?
Re:The US fiscal mess: Some unpleasant fiscal simulations by Log_out_ on Monday July 29, 2024 @01:28PM (#41102085)
The world pays its taxes to the world police with devaluing reserves.