News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why is Xi Jinping building commodity stockpiles? by tivert on Thursday July 25, 2024 @05:51PM (#41073773)
IMHO, stockpiles are good policy since they build resilience. If China's doing this but not the West, it's a display of some of the advantages of their governance model (not to say that it doesn't have disadvantages, too). The US especially seems to be infected by short-term, happy-path thinking that's eager and willing to risk the future for a little bit of savings today.
Re:Why is Xi Jinping building commodity stockpiles? by jopsen on Thursday July 25, 2024 @06:36PM (#41074164)
> The US especially seems to be infected by short-term, happy-path thinking...

Are we so sure that's true?

Aren't tax deferrals on 401ks a long term bet?

It's structured differently, power is distributed rather than concentrated.

Is power concentration a good thing?

Aren't long term bets extremely risky? Professional investors have a hard time beating the market. You think politicians can?

Arguably, the ability to tax people does offer other investment opportunities.

Re:Why is Xi Jinping building commodity stockpiles? by tivert on Thursday July 25, 2024 @07:02PM (#41074355)
> Aren't tax deferrals on 401ks a long term bet?

You misunderstand. I'm mainly talking about the policy level, not the individual level. The US let a fetish for free markets override pretty much every other national priority.

Also 401ks to a lot of things, and one of the more interesting ones they encourage laborers to internalize the interests of the capitalist class, which they are very much not served by.

Re:Why is Xi Jinping building commodity stockpiles? by gruez on Thursday July 25, 2024 @07:49PM (#41074646)
>Also 401ks to a lot of things, and one of the more interesting ones they encourage laborers to internalize the interests of the capitalist class, which they are very much not served by.

Okay but what about the alternative? If 401ks didn't exist and "the capitalist class" were lobbying against it, I could plausibly imagine people like complaining about capitalists are oppressing the working class by hoarding the mechanism to which people can build wealth.

Re:Why is Xi Jinping building commodity stockpiles? by JumpCrisscross on Thursday July 25, 2024 @06:24PM (#41074048)
> it's a display of some of the advantages of their governance model

It’s the reality of countering an air-sea superpower as a country supplied by sea. We do a tonne of long-range logistics readiness exercises China doesn’t. Because they don’t need to.

There is no inherent virtue in stockpiling. An attritive war is all about production anyway, not starting stock. Our weakness is in low production rates of all manner of materiel, not a lack of stockpiles.

Re:Why is Xi Jinping building commodity stockpiles? by shakow on Thursday July 25, 2024 @06:32PM (#41074123)
> as a country supplied by sea

I can't read the whole article, but according to the header, they are stockpiling resources they can produce (and do so) themselve (grain, oil, gas).

Re:Why is Xi Jinping building commodity stockpiles? by JumpCrisscross on Thursday July 25, 2024 @07:23PM (#41074487)
> they are stockpiling resources they can produce (and do so) themselve (grain, oil, gas)

They’re preparing for a siege. We’re preparing to besiege them. These are strategically different goals that result in different policies. Geographically, America is uniquely difficult to besiege. (You’d need to hold New York, Cuba and idk what on the West Coast.)

Re:Why is Xi Jinping building commodity stockpiles? by GreatLdisisp88 on Monday July 29, 2024 @03:42AM (#41098593)
You need to check American gold stockpiles. That is currently holding down gold price. China is actively dwindling American gold by making it mandatory physical delivery to China. We will see how long America can play this. When the gold stockpiles truly emptied gold price will spike. Attrition includes ability to produce. If you run our stockpiles, how you peoduce?
Re:Why is Xi Jinping building commodity stockpiles? by Carrok on Thursday July 25, 2024 @05:57PM (#41073815)
You don’t think the west has stockpiles?
Re:Why is Xi Jinping building commodity stockpiles? by tivert on Thursday July 25, 2024 @06:04PM (#41073865)
> You don’t think the west has stockpiles?

A few small and badly run ones. IIRC, the US's medical stockpile was already bare at the start of COVID, and I recall reading controversy about if it should be replenished at all when its potential worth had literally just been proven. The petroleum stockpile seems like it's mostly used for electioneering (e.g. release stockpiles in the run up to an election to lower gas prices to help incumbents). I'm not aware of any other ones, like for food and raw materials besides petroleum.

Re:Why is Xi Jinping building commodity stockpiles? by perihelions on Thursday July 25, 2024 @06:03PM (#41073855)
The US burned half of its stockpile in the last four years[0], as a (politically popular!) counter to inflation. It's as the parent comment says: we're presently infected by short-term thinking, exchanging gigantic risks in the future for small benefits in the present.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strategic_Petroleum_Reserve_(U...

Re:Why is Xi Jinping building commodity stockpiles? by dghlsakjg on Thursday July 25, 2024 @06:49PM (#41074283)
Keep in mind that the US is the worlds largest oil producer right now, and exports ~30% of production. North America as whole has a serious oil output that massively over-serves what is needed by the continent.

Canada, arguably the closest US ally, is number 4 for oil output, and Mexico is 11th.

Keeping the reserves full doesn't really serve a purpose when you are capable of producing far more than you need.

Re:Why is Xi Jinping building commodity stockpiles? by qwytw on Thursday July 25, 2024 @06:16PM (#41073970)
Wouldn't even at peak levels (700mil) the total reserve be enough for just ~35 days or so? Of course that's still a lot but I'm not sure if 300 million barrels over a couple of years could affect prices that much.

Also it kind of made sense to sell when the price was so high and fill it up later.

Re:Why is Xi Jinping building commodity stockpiles? by shakow on Thursday July 25, 2024 @06:34PM (#41074141)
> for just ~35 days or so?

At full consumption. I'm pretty sure that in circumstances that would lead to the use of the reserverve, oil would be strongly rationed and directed towards hospitals/army/police/logicstics/etc.

Re:Why is Xi Jinping building commodity stockpiles? by qwytw on Friday July 26, 2024 @05:51AM (#41077257)
Sure, but US has almost doubled its production since the early 2000s while consumption has actually slightly decreased. So I'd question the need to maintain a very large reserve anymore. IMHO these days using it as an "economic tool" to balance supply/demand would make a lot more.
Re:Why is Xi Jinping building commodity stockpiles? by darth_avocado on Thursday July 25, 2024 @06:27PM (#41074071)
If its 35 days at 700 mil, it's 15 at 300. 35 days doesn't seem like a lot but in case of emergencies, I'll take 35 over 15 any day. You need to give yourselves time to at least react to situations.
Re:Why is Xi Jinping building commodity stockpiles? by JumpCrisscross on Thursday July 25, 2024 @06:28PM (#41074089)
> You need to give yourselves time to at least react to situations

Our strategic reserves are for low-grade emergencies. For anything minor, the status quo will do. For anything major we’ll re-route civilian supplies. In between, the strategic reserve lets the military increase consumption without raising voters’ gas prices.

Re:Why is Xi Jinping building commodity stockpiles? by JumpCrisscross on Thursday July 25, 2024 @06:23PM (#41074027)
We’re the largest producer of petroleum on the planet. China is not.
Re:Why is Xi Jinping building commodity stockpiles? by toomuchtodo on Thursday July 25, 2024 @06:25PM (#41074054)
Conversely, China is the largest producer of EVs on the planet, and will reach peak oil demand this year or next due to their EV manufacturing ramp rate.

China is playing to win the future, and it’s clear in how they operate.

Re:Why is Xi Jinping building commodity stockpiles? by JumpCrisscross on Thursday July 25, 2024 @06:26PM (#41074064)
> China is the largest producer of EVs on the planet, and will reach peak oil demand this year or next due to their EV manufacturing ramp rate

Sure. They have a strategic incentive to electrify their military. In the meantime, they need stockpiles.

Re:Why is Xi Jinping building commodity stockpiles? by toomuchtodo on Thursday July 25, 2024 @06:31PM (#41074116)
Maybe we’re talking past each other. China isn’t electrifying their military, they are electrifying all light transportation. This destroys demand for oil, slowly working towards negating it as a point of leverage during a geopolitical conflict. You can’t embargo, blockade, or use economic sanctions on an input a country doesn’t need.

Oil demand destruction, EVs, renewables, are all national economic security issues. They are stockpiling, decoupling, and becoming self sufficient internally to be prepared for an isolationist period. We can wildly speculate why, but it’s very clear that they do not want to be beholden to other nation state economic counterparties.

Re:Why is Xi Jinping building commodity stockpiles? by teyc on Thursday July 25, 2024 @08:15PM (#41074786)
[delayed]
Re:Why is Xi Jinping building commodity stockpiles? by JumpCrisscross on Thursday July 25, 2024 @07:25PM (#41074503)
> it’s very clear that they do not want to be beholden to other nation state economic counterparties

Days of stockpiles aren’t a strategic economic buffer. They’re tactical. You’re correct that electrification reduces one of China’s geostrategic vulnerabilities. I’m extending that to its military; stockpiles alone won’t defeat a blockade.

Re:Why is Xi Jinping building commodity stockpiles? by TomK32 on Thursday July 25, 2024 @06:35PM (#41074161)
Just like the markets in the West, the chinese market for EVs is saturated. That's why they have to ship their EVs to Europe before they have a buyer.
Re:Why is Xi Jinping building commodity stockpiles? by toomuchtodo on Thursday July 25, 2024 @06:38PM (#41074189)
There is a market clearing price at which even the most opposed EV buyer becomes one (total cost of ownership, fuel cost volatility, etc). The subsidies must last only until sufficient internal combustion manufacturing capacity has been reduced to where EVs become the only option. Like bankruptcy, this transition will happen slowly, and then all of a sudden (as there is a minimum volume of units a combustion vehicle factory must sell to remain viable).

> The Chinese auto industry is experiencing a revolution,” said John Zeng, the director of Asia forecasting at GlobalData Automotive. “The old internal combustion capacity is dying.”

> Sales of gasoline-powered cars plummeted to 17.7 million last year from 28.3 million in 2017, the year that Hyundai opened its Chongqing complex. That drop is equivalent to the entire European Union car market last year, or all of the United States’ annual car and light truck production.

https://www.nytimes.com/2024/04/23/business/china-auto-facto... | https://archive.today/4jCiQ

https://electrek.co/2023/04/01/ice-car-values-plummet-in-chi...

Re:Why is Xi Jinping building commodity stockpiles? by hollerith on Friday July 26, 2024 @02:38AM (#41076301)
China's current dependence on long petroleum supply chains from Russia and the Persian Gulf to fuel their current fleet of cars and trucks is a weakness, and Beijing is quite rationally responding to that weakness in national security by investing heavily in EVs.

To power all those EVs, China's adding coal-fired electrical generation capacity at a very rapid pace. (China has plenty of coal.)

Re:Why is Xi Jinping building commodity stockpiles? by riehwvfbk on Thursday July 25, 2024 @06:29PM (#41074094)
Since 2018, and only if you don't think of OPEC as a single block (which in many ways they are). Also, being a top producer in the short term is just another example of short-term thinking. 80% of the world's oils reserves are in OPEC countries. Burning through a limited supply in record time is hardly something to be proud of.
Re:Why is Xi Jinping building commodity stockpiles? by bryanlarsen on Thursday July 25, 2024 @08:26PM (#41074861)
80% excluding oil sands. Which is silly, because the oil sands are economically viable reserves, and would be even more so during a global crisis. The oil sands contain hundreds of years worth of oil supply at current rates.
Re:Why is Xi Jinping building commodity stockpiles? by polotics on Friday July 26, 2024 @02:53AM (#41076372)
Ok... What is the EROEI of these reserves?
Re:Why is Xi Jinping building commodity stockpiles? by mupuff1234 on Thursday July 25, 2024 @06:13PM (#41073939)
A large surge in inflation seems like a decent time to use the stockpiles - it's not like they can't be replenished.

Especially given that the US is an exporter of energy.

Re:Why is Xi Jinping building commodity stockpiles? by sudosysgen on Thursday July 25, 2024 @06:19PM (#41073991)
The US is a net petroleum exporter now, so using the stockpile for price stabilization is the right call.

Using it to stabilize prices is actually good long term thinking, because a quicker reduction in inflation will have far more long term benefits than the short term optics of liquidating a ""strategic asset"".

The only risk of a strategic petroleum shortage in the US would be as the result of an attack on US infrastructure, and I don't see how the petroleum reserves wouldn't be the first target. So there isn't any strategic risk in reducing the stockpile. When it was created, the US was a massive petroleum importer - it was a strategic asset but not anymore.

Re:Why is Xi Jinping building commodity stockpiles? by bdjsiqoocwk on Thursday July 25, 2024 @06:14PM (#41073947)
Damn I hate it when it turns out a Republican talking point had some truth to it.
Re:Why is Xi Jinping building commodity stockpiles? by rhplus on Thursday July 25, 2024 @06:16PM (#41073963)
Re:Why is Xi Jinping building commodity stockpiles? by observationist on Thursday July 25, 2024 @06:30PM (#41074109)
At least the parties at the end will be entertaining.
Re:Why is Xi Jinping building commodity stockpiles? by Gud on Friday July 26, 2024 @02:28AM (#41076265)
Not really, no. Since the end of the Cold War, my home country Sweden dismantled all it stock piles.
Re:Why is Xi Jinping building commodity stockpiles? by aiauthoritydev on Thursday July 25, 2024 @06:59PM (#41074341)
Meh. It is a dumb thing dictators do everywhere to appear strong. There is no shortage of any kind of commodity in the western world.
Re:Why is Xi Jinping building commodity stockpiles? by slowmovintarget on Thursday July 25, 2024 @07:09PM (#41074400)
Yet. One good-size war could flip that.

There are food lines in New York, and 2 million people there can't afford food... just a small supply-chain disruption and we'll have even more massive stability problems.

Re:Why is Xi Jinping building commodity stockpiles? by red-iron-pine on Friday July 26, 2024 @10:08AM (#41078785)
> Yet. One good-size war could flip that.

arguably that's what the stockpiles are for

Re:Why is Xi Jinping building commodity stockpiles? by TaylorAlexander on Thursday July 25, 2024 @06:06PM (#41073882)
Indeed. This seems similar to the hand-wringing I see about China's government subsidized manufacturing being "unfair". Actually government subsidized manufacturing is a great idea and its the entire reason we have a space program!
Re:Why is Xi Jinping building commodity stockpiles? by teyc on Thursday July 25, 2024 @08:20PM (#41074827)
More like incentivising R&D so they move up the value chain. Generate demand for indigenous product when economies of scale aren’t there (see secret history of SV). Encourage internal competition so that it is innovate or die.
Re:Why is Xi Jinping building commodity stockpiles? by bdjsiqoocwk on Thursday July 25, 2024 @06:23PM (#41074029)
You think China subsidizing manufacturers so they make cheaper sneakers is similar to the Apollo program? That one I'd never heard before. Did you come up with it yourself or is that a take you've seen somewhere?
Re:Why is Xi Jinping building commodity stockpiles? by darth_avocado on Thursday July 25, 2024 @06:33PM (#41074136)
Parent didn't say sneakers, but subsidizing manufacturing to retain the ability to do is a jobs program that also has strategic benefits. We already kind of do it in areas like defense. Other manufacturing areas like medicine, electronics etc. would actually not be a bad idea.
Re:Why is Xi Jinping building commodity stockpiles? by tivert on Thursday July 25, 2024 @06:37PM (#41074178)
> You think China subsidizing manufacturers so they make cheaper sneakers...

If you think China is only subsidizing the manufacturing of stupid things like sneakers, you're sorely misinformed. They pretty much have a lock on solar panel manufacturing, due to subsidies, and I think they drove most of their Western competitors out of business. That's kind of strategic industry, with the green energy transition. IIRC, they're also getting there with batteries and EVs, but at least the West is starting to use protectionism again to protect that area.

IIRC, one of the nice things about China is they don't really care if these companies are profitable. They'll setup a situation of vicious cut-throat competition and overcapacity, instead of a few complacent but profitable oligopolies like the West seems to prefer. That means they win at the national level.

> ...is similar to the Apollo program?

The Apollo program was like 50 years ago. The US needs to stop leaning on its past glories to try to make its complacency comfortable, and instead actually deal with its problems.

Re:Why is Xi Jinping building commodity stockpiles? by TaylorAlexander on Friday July 26, 2024 @05:30AM (#41077118)
Investing in manufacturing capacity is a general tactic of industrial nations. I am of course referring to valuable Chinese industry like electric cars, batteries, solar, bullet trains, etc. Just as the USA saw value in stimulating an aerospace industry, China sees value in stimulating a broad manufacturing base and expertise on energy related production. My claim is that this isn’t unfair, this is standard industrial policy. Except the USA has literally forgotten the value of industrial policy so when someone does it properly we misinterpret it as cheating.

You may appreciate this economics lecture on industrial policy: https://youtu.be/V6egGoCrbIo

Re:Why is Xi Jinping building commodity stockpiles? by Fauntleroy on Thursday July 25, 2024 @06:16PM (#41073969)
Well, it _is_ "unfair"—it's just not "unfair" to the country doing it.
Re:Why is Xi Jinping building commodity stockpiles? by toomuchtodo on Thursday July 25, 2024 @06:22PM (#41074014)
American Businesses: “How are we supposed to profit if you don’t govern poorly like we do?!”

Your country can do well too if you invest for the long term instead of chasing quarterly numbers and strip mining the economy.

Re:Why is Xi Jinping building commodity stockpiles? by 29athrowaway on Thursday July 25, 2024 @06:30PM (#41074106)
It is the MBA virus.