News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Alexa had "no profit timeline," cost Amazon $25B in 4 years by skhunted on Tuesday July 23, 2024 @06:31PM (#41051674)
Alexa can add things to your shopping list but not take them off. You have to manually delete items in your shopping cart. This exemplifies why Alexa was never going to be successful. It is a user hostile experience.
Re:Alexa had "no profit timeline," cost Amazon $25B in 4 years by loa_in_ on Tuesday July 23, 2024 @06:48PM (#41051823)
I can see why it was the case from engineering standpoint: adding a name from spoken phrase to a list is trivial, but looking up an item (that might not even be there) from a list based on a spoken phrase is prone to transcription errors. The user might refer to it with different phrasing than when it was added too.

This is feasible only very recently with LLMs.

Re:Alexa had "no profit timeline," cost Amazon $25B in 4 years by brianwawok on Tuesday July 23, 2024 @08:04PM (#41052355)
That’s a terrible argument. You found the item to add it. Just search a list 1/100000000 as big to find the item to remove. I can do with this Python and text to speech with no AI.
Re:Alexa had "no profit timeline," cost Amazon $25B in 4 years by skhunted on Tuesday July 23, 2024 @10:20PM (#41053065)
I don’t see why one direction is harder than the other. The only thing that makes sense to me is that Amazon is user hostile and tries to dupe people into buying stuff even if they don’t want it.
Re:Alexa had "no profit timeline," cost Amazon $25B in 4 years by josefritzishere on Wednesday July 24, 2024 @02:05PM (#41059880)
Amazon is pretty generally user hostile. We see it in their corporte behavior too. I think for that reason culturally they'd struggle to design a device users want to interact with.
Re:Alexa had "no profit timeline," cost Amazon $25B in 4 years by davidthewatson on Wednesday July 24, 2024 @02:47PM (#41060408)
That's right. See:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14149986

We all wanted an experience as simple as interacting with the human at Whole Foods checkout OR the robot at the self-checkout, but what we got was this cacophony of anything but what you came here for that is amazon.com and most modern software design.

People wonder why I long for Amazon Go years after I left Seattle and recommended that approach to various retail executives.

Is there any better way to subvert retail than to promote stealing the merchandise as the ultimate UX?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amazon_Go

Re:Alexa had "no profit timeline," cost Amazon $25B in 4 years by leni536 on Wednesday July 24, 2024 @03:49PM (#41061176)
It's far more mundane than that. Adding items to the list is a core feature, so there is plenty of engineering time getting assigned to it.

Removing items from the list is a feature that has negative return, so nobody wants to work on it.

Re:Alexa had "no profit timeline," cost Amazon $25B in 4 years by princevegeta89 on Wednesday July 24, 2024 @12:29AM (#41053612)
In addition to that, the inability of Alexa to just answer your question and shut up seemed to have gone way off the tracks.

For most of the things I ask my Echo Show, it just follows up with "by the way, xxxxxxxxxxxx xxxx.... Pricing is $3/month. Do you want it?"

Fuck you. This is worse than the salespeople that bother me at Department Stores.

Re:Alexa had "no profit timeline," cost Amazon $25B in 4 years by ultrarunner on Wednesday July 24, 2024 @12:34AM (#41053641)
This is the single thing that killed ours.
Re:Alexa had "no profit timeline," cost Amazon $25B in 4 years by JoshTriplett on Wednesday July 24, 2024 @02:47PM (#41060399)
Minus the sales pitch (which I've never had), this is one of the complaints I have about Google Assistant. "By the way, if you ever want to X, just say Y". Just answer the question asked and then shut up immediately.

And, preferably, learn to answer the question asked with more brevity, as well. If I ask "what's the high for today", I don't need to hear "In Cityname, expect a high of 90 degrees", just say "90".

Re:Alexa had "no profit timeline," cost Amazon $25B in 4 years by im3w1l on Wednesday July 24, 2024 @02:57PM (#41060522)
The reason they say "In cityname" is probably because they aren't 100% certain of your city. The preface lets you catch the mistake if it makes it.
Re:Alexa had "no profit timeline," cost Amazon $25B in 4 years by JoshTriplett on Wednesday July 24, 2024 @04:49PM (#41061927)
Yeah, I'm aware, though in general the devices have a location specified. But even then, "90 in cityname" would suffice.

There are many other interactions in which almost every word is unnecessary noise and can't even be explained away as a confirmation.

Re:Alexa had "no profit timeline," cost Amazon $25B in 4 years by ssl-3 on Wednesday July 24, 2024 @03:55AM (#41054594)
The shopping aspect is approximately useless. It is an awful experience: It seems to be incapable of producing good results, and it is impossible to correct the results without using some manner of computer.

I do enjoy some aspects of having an always-listening device that I can command to do stuff (like play some music, or to turn on a light, or look up some random factoid), but they've made it almost impossible to succeed at using it to do the thing they seem to so-desperately seek: Allowing me to spend my money more freely.

Re:Alexa had "no profit timeline," cost Amazon $25B in 4 years by mFixman on Wednesday July 24, 2024 @06:34AM (#41055527)
I'm glad that Amazon thought they could make money with Alexa; mine is currently fantastic as an universal remote control (using Zigbee) and music player (using Spotify).

I could see Ameca only being compatible with Amazon services if it had been launched a few years later.

Re:Alexa had "no profit timeline," cost Amazon $25B in 4 years by PaulHoule on Wednesday July 24, 2024 @02:05PM (#41059877)
For me the killer app was listening to music while doing the dishes.
Re:Alexa had "no profit timeline," cost Amazon $25B in 4 years by janalsncm on Wednesday July 24, 2024 @03:49PM (#41061186)
If Alexa could do the dishes for me that would absolutely be a killer app.
Re:Alexa had "no profit timeline," cost Amazon $25B in 4 years by CamperBob2 on Wednesday July 24, 2024 @07:14PM (#41063194)
Tie it to an as-yet-unknown startup company that sends people to your house very quickly to perform individual light housekeeping tasks. "MicroMaids.com" or some such.

Sounds invasive and scary, but I would've said (and probably did say) similar things about a service that connected you with strangers for the purpose of getting into their cars.

Re:Alexa had "no profit timeline," cost Amazon $25B in 4 years by ssl-3 on Thursday July 25, 2024 @02:44AM (#41065437)
That's an easy route to a 10- or 11-figure company with a huge liability policy and a very fat band of warm bodies in the middle that all conspires to mean both high prices, and minimal pay with terrible terms for those doing the work -- just like Uber.

Other than the fact that it broadly sounds awful, I don't see a downside. I'd sometimes love to have such a service myself: I have plenty of money to buy services and very little time when I'm busy, but when I'm not busy I have plenty of time to do these things myself, which I prefer. Hiring things to be done on a regular schedule doesn't really work for me.

But an informally-arranged, impromptu service? Maybe?

---

"Alexa, mow the lawn."

"OK. Greenscape will arrive today between 3 and 4PM to mow the lawn. By the way, did you know that Husqvarna offers automated electric lawnmowers? Would you like to know more?"

beep

---

Who's up for exploitation? Anyone?

Re:Alexa had "no profit timeline," cost Amazon $25B in 4 years by whateveracct on Wednesday July 24, 2024 @09:52AM (#41057138)
heh I'm sure a PM with a relevant metric punted on that ticket plenty times.
Re:Alexa had "no profit timeline," cost Amazon $25B in 4 years by o_nate on Wednesday July 24, 2024 @09:59AM (#41057211)
I ask Alexa to remove things from my shopping list all the time. It always asks you to confirm, but then it does remove it. Sounds like maybe you're talking about the Amazon shopping cart, not the generic shopping list feature?
Re:Alexa had "no profit timeline," cost Amazon $25B in 4 years by tiltowait on Wednesday July 24, 2024 @10:29AM (#41057472)
How does shopping with one even work in practice? Most items I buy on Amazon require careful scrutiny to make sure I’m getting the right thing. What I want is almost never the first result. This is true even in areas that feel like they should be easy, like video games.
Re:Alexa had "no profit timeline," cost Amazon $25B in 4 years by jasonlotito on Wednesday July 24, 2024 @02:05PM (#41059882)
It's great for repeat items. Stuff I've bought before I need more of. Buy "X" and the first item is the thing I've bought before. I use it that way when I know I need it, but I don't want to forget. So I just say it, and it's done and I don't need to remember or record it somewhere or pull out a phone or what have you.

I use it sometimes for new items, usually when I know what I want and I specify brand. If it's not the first item, I can easily see the other options on the screen and it's not much to say to buy the second or third item on the list.

Re:Alexa had "no profit timeline," cost Amazon $25B in 4 years by eastbound on Wednesday July 24, 2024 @02:18PM (#41060030)
But they jack up the prices every few months, right? You can get the original at the original price, but from the new vendor “OUFIOU”…
Re:Alexa had "no profit timeline," cost Amazon $25B in 4 years by dylan604 on Wednesday July 24, 2024 @02:06PM (#41059894)
For those that do have an Alexa, how does this work? Do you have to haggle with Alexa, and then it picks from the different sellers that meets your haggling? It seems like a much longer conversation is needed than "Alexa, add Tide Pods to my list" as Amazon propaganda wants you to believe.
Re:Alexa had "no profit timeline," cost Amazon $25B in 4 years by fckgw on Wednesday July 24, 2024 @02:23PM (#41060101)
If you say "add Tide Pods" then it adds the most popular listing of Tide Pods, shipped and sold by Amazon to your cart. Which is how 98% of people buy stuff on Amazon already.

You may have to specify a quantity but if you're adding detergent, paper towels or whatever else popular, name brand item it's pretty straight forward.

Re:Alexa had "no profit timeline," cost Amazon $25B in 4 years by mihaaly on Wednesday July 24, 2024 @06:47PM (#41063034)
I'd imagine a shopping list could mean any vague things from nerby grocery (i.e milk, and if there are eggs then 6) to electronics (a sound recorder for my wife) without much specificity. To refine later or already have family understanding (eggs = organic vary large ones from black tail hens of the Fen Farm). A vocal fridge board basically. Shopping lists do not imply ordering items Right Now! Now! Neither a specific marketplace at a specific time with specific stock. Just a record about something. That the user will pick up and do something about it in a follow up step. E.g. clear a single item because fuck that sound recorder!
Re:Alexa had "no profit timeline," cost Amazon $25B in 4 years by theGnuMe on Wednesday July 24, 2024 @01:58PM (#41059799)
The app on ios is dreadful...
Re:Alexa had "no profit timeline," cost Amazon $25B in 4 years by dietsprite on Wednesday July 24, 2024 @10:40PM (#41064276)
Yeah, how they don't just build a native app and hire any UX agency of any repute given their immense resources and investment is beyond me.