News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by bmitc on Monday July 22, 2024 @01:59PM (#41037403)
It's not just AI startups. It's almost all of them. The startup world is just a massive pump and dump scheme, and so it moves from field to field finding the next hotness. Self-driving cars, VR, EVs, AI, and so on. People soon realize that you can't just take a bunch of hipster tech employees and suddenly create non-solutions that need to have problems created for them to even be solutions, much less choosing extremely hard and ill-defined non-solutions.

I truly wonder how much of the U.S. economy has slowed down because of all this wasted effort. Is it really a good idea for every company to try and reinvent what a company is? Every startup I've been spends a non-zero amount on just re-figuring out how to be organized, how to manage people and projects, and even just figuring out the logistics and tech needed to run a company. It's a lot of wasted effort, time, and money. My time at startups has been the least effective portions of my career. Real work actually moves quite slowly at startups, in my experience.

Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by JumpCrisscross on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:03PM (#41037469)
> startup world is just a massive pump and dump scheme, and so it moves from field to field finding the next hotness

But we retain the solutions that work. A slime mold tries a bunch of useless paths in a maze before it finds the right one. Then it trims and reinforces. Most start-ups failing isn't a sure sign of wasted work.

Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by gortok on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:12PM (#41037634)
You can save minutes of talking to folks through Months of work and tens of thousands of people-hours building something people don't want or need.

You can save months of research by spending years of work and hundreds of thousands of people-hours building something that doesn't work.

Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by Ma8ee on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:42PM (#41038113)
That reminds me of a note on the door I saw in a research department: “A month in the lab saves you an hour in the library.”
Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by vintermann on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:45PM (#41038162)
Yes, many business ideas I see are of the type "That would be a great idea if you could make it work, but given how much easier it is to fool people into thinking you have made it work, than to actually make it work, the odds aren't good".

And if you're a rich investor willing to bet on a lot of such things hoping to make it back on of the few that work, well, you just made that ratio even more lopsided.

Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by godelski on Monday July 22, 2024 @03:00PM (#41038378)
> but given how much easier it is to fool people into thinking you have made it work, than to actually make it work

One thing that has often surprised me about HN is how people routinely upvote and boast about how they faked a demo. Idk why we refuse to call that what it is: a lie. IDK if Jobs did it, it is still a lie. It's one thing to say that this is what we imagine a technology will be like, but to call it a demo and act like it is the actual tool and that its capabilities generalize to the tasks being shown is theater. Are tech bros just theater kids?

Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by JumpCrisscross on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:27PM (#41037870)
> You can save minutes of talking to folks

You're describing focus groups. They have a mixed history in product development.

Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by iancmceachern on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:43PM (#41038134)
It's exactly the opposite, they're essential and certainly do not have a "mixed history".

Every product you interact with at the grocery store, every movie, most music, and most products in our modern life go through this process.

It's called user focused design.

Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by FredPret on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:47PM (#41038195)
The best way to do a completely unbiased focus group is to come up with an MVP and try to sell it to them. There's no more honest endorsement than someone handing you money to solve their problem.

If they buy, you're on the right track and are ready to scale up to a larger focus group.

This is called a startup though!

Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by iancmceachern on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:56PM (#41038322)
Yes, what most people don't realize though is that the MVP doesn't have to be a functional product. It can be a cartoon, a drawing, a mock up, a video, whatever.

Get good feedback early & often

Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by JumpCrisscross on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:55PM (#41038317)
> It's exactly the opposite, they're essential and certainly do not have a "mixed history"

Focus groups are good for refining. They're absolutely terrible for new product development. If there is an OG playbook for start-ups defeating incumbents, it's in exploiting the committee-based designed process that large companies tend towards. (Owning a product decision is hard. Outsourcing it to a marketing consultant isn't.)

Where you and I probably agree is in the importance of finding the shortest path to a sale.

> It's called user focused design

You're quoting this guy [1]. He also did marketing consulting [2].

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Don_Norman#Nielsen_Norman_Grou...

[2] https://www.nngroup.com

Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by iancmceachern on Monday July 22, 2024 @03:28PM (#41038761)
I wasn't quoting him.

It's not really that way anymore. The vision of a loan visionary coming up with a new product or invention like being hit by a lightning bolt and then getting rich by building a factory that builds it is just a fairy tale.

In reality it looks more like a series of focus groups. They may not be focus groups per se, but showing your idea to potential customers, getting feedback, refining and showing again is how it's done.

That's how startups that are successful do so.

Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by JumpCrisscross on Monday July 22, 2024 @04:07PM (#41039237)
> wasn't quoting him

Norman coined the term user focused design.

> may not be focus groups per se, but showing your idea to potential customers, getting feedback, refining and showing again is how it's done

Sure. I’d argue both focus groups and the lone visionary are myths. But in order to show an idea properly, you have to start thinking about building it. And to start thinking about building it properly, you have to start building it. For every Juicero there are teams iterating around a local optimum.

Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by ohwellhere on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:42PM (#41038111)
I think they're probably talking about something closer to lean startup methodology.
Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by bmitc on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:09PM (#41037572)
What startups have provided lasting real solutions and value, not just capitalistic, in say the last decade?
Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by sobellian on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:23PM (#41037811)
This will be tough to answer because you've supplied a vague standard. According to the Unabomber, electricity is not a real solution. Where shall we sit on the spectrum?
Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by JumpCrisscross on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:24PM (#41037827)
> What startups have provided lasting real solutions and value, not just capitalistic, in say the last decade

Deel, Rippling, Redwood Materials, Convoy, Airtable, Anduril, Cerebral, Checkr and Cerebras were all founded since 2014. Pick one. We're currently seeing an explosion in creativity around satellites, autonomous vehicles (on the road, indoors and airborne), generative AI and biotechnology.

Go back one more cycle and we have SpaceX, Tesla, Uber & Lyft, Moderna, Zoom, DoorDash and other giants that entered busy fields, survived the winnowing and basically created a new industry.

Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by Y_Y on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:37PM (#41038041)
Deel provides a solution to workers having too much time and patience, and the value of giving nice chunk of each salary for the pleasure of making payroll suck with some AI smeared on top.
Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by JumpCrisscross on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:40PM (#41038085)
> Deel provides a solution to workers having too much time and patience

Their innovation was abstracting away the complexity of cross-border hiring. Their impact is meaningful to the degree employment is.

Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by Y_Y on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:48PM (#41038211)
They didn't innovate there! Safeguard Global and plenty of others were doing the same middlemanning for years before. Just because they interact with employment doesn't mean they're as important as the whole concept.
Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by JumpCrisscross on Monday July 22, 2024 @03:01PM (#41038393)
> Safeguard Global and plenty of others were doing the same middlemanning for years before

This is sort of like saying the iPod was a better Walkman. Yes, you could functionally do the same thing. But no, it wasn't as easy which meant it wasn't as frequently done. (And as a result of pressure from the upstarts, payroll across the board became smoother.)

> Just because they interact with employment doesn't mean they're as important as the whole concept

Nobody said that. I said "their impact is meaningful to the degree employment is." To the people whose roles exist on account of platforms like Deel, their existence is meaningful.

Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by Y_Y on Monday July 22, 2024 @03:35PM (#41038853)
I don't like Deel, but you do.
Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by JumpCrisscross on Monday July 22, 2024 @04:16PM (#41039322)
No, I hate pretty much all payroll processors. I also hate most IDEs, that doesn’t mean I don’t see value in them.
Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by Y_Y on Monday July 22, 2024 @04:25PM (#41039437)
M: I came here for a good argument!

O: AH, no you didn't, you came here for an argument!

M: An argument isn't just contradiction.

O: Well! it CAN be!

M: No it can't!

M: An argument is a connected series of statements intended to establish a proposition.

O: No it isn't!

Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by JumpCrisscross on Monday July 22, 2024 @06:25PM (#41040495)
I was asked for a list of startups that “have provided lasting real solutions and value.” I gave a list and said “pick one.” You pushed back on Deel. I pointed out why they have value.

You then pivoted to the non sequitur that I “like Deel.” I pointed out that isn’t true, and never needed to be—this was never a discussion about which start-ups we want to put a sticker on. It’s a bit rich to complain about logical fallacies after throwing one out.

Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by Y_Y on Tuesday July 23, 2024 @03:45AM (#41043627)
I wasn't convinced that Deel provided value, though it seemed that that by subjective or semantic means you had reasonably come to the opposite conclusion. My attenpt to boil that down to something pithy didn't do much good, and after your response I felt like the discussion was providing more heat than light, so I used a humorous reference to indicate that I thought we were mostly naysaysing each other.

You haven't changed my mind but you may have changed others' and you did make me think. Let's have an even better discussion next time.

Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by callalex on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:27PM (#41037890)
WhatsApp
Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by ganeshkrishnan on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:35PM (#41038021)
solutions and value inherently become capitalistic. Can you quantify what you mean by "provided value"?
Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by JumpCrisscross on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:38PM (#41038057)
> Can you quantify what you mean by "provided value"?

I took it to mean ignoring companies in sales & marketing or FIRE (finance, insurance, real estate), as well as focussing on the effects of a company's products and services versus their valuation.

Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by pas on Monday July 22, 2024 @08:28PM (#41041297)
Beyond Meat is pretty neat.

Ceph? (Inktank was founded in 2011 by Sage Weil and DreamHost, which then it raised 1M in 2012 from Mark Shuttleworth, then RedHat bought them for 175M in 2014. Seems like a nice startup stort, no? The project itself was started around 2004 by Weil at LLNL, and then he worked on it as part of his PhD still in 2007, then the work continued at DreamHost, probably because Weil is one of the co-founders of DreamHost.)

Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by tim333 on Wednesday July 24, 2024 @06:54AM (#41055625)
OpenAI? (Founded 2015)
Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by JohnFen on Monday July 22, 2024 @05:57PM (#41040250)
> Most start-ups failing isn't a sure sign of wasted work.

It pretty much is, yes. Not a sure sign, but SV startups are probably the least efficient way of finding solutions that work. That's not to say that solutions to meaningful problems aren't occasionally found, of course, but the odds are very slim and the amount of money and other resources burned per success is astounding.

Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by JumpCrisscross on Monday July 22, 2024 @06:22PM (#41040464)
> SV startups are probably the least efficient way of finding solutions that work

On what metric? By any objective measure, barring the tail end of ZIRP, it’s been remarkably more efficient than many national projects.

The point is a VC ecosystem working properly should have a high failure rate. Lots of failures just tells you risk isn’t too low. To measure efficacy and efficiency you have to look at the output. And again, barring the pandemic vintages, it’s a pretty clear record of success.

Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by JohnFen on Wednesday July 24, 2024 @10:15AM (#41057344)
> more efficient than many national projects.

I'm confused by your reference to "national projects" here. What are you comparing to?

It looks incredibly inefficient to me when I compare the billions blown on failed or worthless ventures to get a small number of valuable ones.

Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by ertgbnm on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:23PM (#41037815)
Private equity has mastered this formula in the last decade.

Throw as many unrelated businesses that you can buy for pennies on the dollar into a basket. Claim it is now diversified. Decrease expenses by allowing all of your good employees to run for the hills screaming while not replacing them. Post one year of record profits by sacrificing quality in the name of quantity. Re-capitalize in order to generate a massive return. And then rinse and repeat on your next victims, I mean ventures.

Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by carterklein13 on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:46PM (#41038179)
I personally think this will be one of the biggest "what the hell were we thinking" ideas to come out of the still-developing hangover of the 2013-2023 startup space. From my perspective, the once-startups that are now big companies are the ones who focused ONLY on solving a real and immediate problem with happy, motivated employees. Every industry has inefficiencies to improve upon. Most employees want normal hours, a 401K, some benefits, and clear performance reviews. There's still a ton of work to do at cool-but-not-the-absolute-cutting-edge startups.
Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by BobbyJo on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:30PM (#41037938)
This is simply not true. Most startup founders are genuinely trying to build something that has value to the economy, and therefore society. Most fail early, most of what's left fails later, but some go on to be real, profitable, businesses.

That's how it works outside of the startup world too. Most restaurants, clothing stores, car repair shops, etc. go out of business after just a few years, while a few move on to become large chains and the like.

Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by iancmceachern on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:50PM (#41038236)
Your last paragraph paints a dual vision of the world that just isn't accurate.

There are the two you mentioned: 1- small businesses that go out of business after a few years 2- ...ones that become big chains

But you are forgetting #3, the one that actually makes up the largest proportion of businesses: 3- people that quietly, successfully, run their businesses in a sustainable, family and community oriented manner (not financial growth focused but personal growth focused) and then retire quietly surrounded by loved ones.

Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by BobbyJo on Monday July 22, 2024 @06:18PM (#41040433)
> But you are forgetting #3, the one that actually makes up the largest proportion of businesses: 3- people that quietly, successfully, run their businesses in a sustainable, family and community oriented manner (not financial growth focused but personal growth focused) and then retire quietly surrounded by loved ones.

I wasn't forgetting them, they just aren't relevant to a conversation about venture capital, at least to me. There are plenty of small bootstrapped startups out there, but their ROI isn't high enough to justify a gamble on the part of investors. Likewise with the businesses you're talking about.

Yes the make up most small businesses, but most small businesses aren't looking for private venture capital, and don't fall into the category of what OP was claiming is "pump n dump".

Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by pas on Monday July 22, 2024 @09:08PM (#41041534)
Big business is frighteningly efficient at being BIG. (At least in the US.)

https://www.bls.gov/web/cewbd/table_f.txt

~42% of the workforce is employed at firms with 1000+ headcount.

The next biggest bucket is ~10% the 20-49 range. Then ~9.5% is the 100-249 bucket.

And the share of biggest ones is (likely unfortunately) growing.

Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by iancmceachern on Tuesday July 23, 2024 @11:11AM (#41046801)
"According to the U.S. Small Business Administration (SBA), 99.9% of businesses in the United States are small businesses, which are defined as independent businesses with fewer than 500 employees. This amounts to around 33.3 million businesses, which employ 61.7 million Americans, or 46.4% of private sector employees. Small businesses are a vital part of the American economy, contributing to economic stability and representing 43.5% of the country's GDP.

Here are some other statistics about small businesses in the United States:

84.8% of businesses in rural areas are small businesses

43.2% of small businesses are owned by women

20% of employer businesses are owned by minorities

Small businesses account for about 96% of employer firms in high-patenting manufacturing industries

Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by dustingetz on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:47PM (#41038193)
> Most startup founders are genuinely trying to build something that has value to the economy, and therefore society.

there is an unlabeled selection bias missing here, and in that bias we find everything

Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by BobbyJo on Monday July 22, 2024 @06:25PM (#41040499)
If that's your take, how to you hold any conversation online? Do you speak in sources and studies?
Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by blitzar on Monday July 22, 2024 @04:21PM (#41039387)
> Most startup founders are genuinely trying to

get wealthy, and not really good 9-5 job wealthy. Properly wealthy.

Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by BobbyJo on Monday July 22, 2024 @06:24PM (#41040492)
Both? Most humans on earth are trying to get wealthy, they just don't see a viable path in front of them.
Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by blitzar on Tuesday July 23, 2024 @02:22AM (#41043069)
Most humans on earth are trying to survive, they just don't see a viable path in front of them
Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by AbstractH24 on Tuesday July 23, 2024 @08:38AM (#41045324)
This comment really points out how this message board and tech in general are not reflective of most humans on earth
Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by BobbyJo on Tuesday July 23, 2024 @09:59AM (#41046110)
Global life expectancy is like 73. Life is hard, but lets not pretend most humans are wandering a wasteland in search of water.
Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by blitzar on Tuesday July 23, 2024 @04:00PM (#41050168)
1 in 3 people globally do not have access to safe drinking water, sure it isn't 'most people' but it is 2.6 billion people.
Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by inhumantsar on Monday July 22, 2024 @05:51PM (#41040201)
nearly every VC and accelerator in the world is going to ask you, "what's your exit plan?" and look at you like a Martian if you say you're in it for the long haul rather than exit as soon as an exit is viable.

imho that sort of "aim for the exit" thinking strongly incentivizes pump-and-dump behaviour and I think the bandwagoning we see with every hot new tech is exactly what one would expect as a result.

Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by BobbyJo on Monday July 22, 2024 @06:23PM (#41040485)
Well... they are investing to make money, not to hold shares in a company forever. If they wanted to do the later they'd buy index funds and sit on them. Most (I'd bet nearly all) capital sources for VCs do both actually.

Also:

1) IPO is one of those exit strategies. Tons of startups are aiming to become long lived independent companies.

2) M&A makes sense for lots of businesses, as you get to take advantage of better economies of scale as part of a larger org. Saying it's your exit plan doesn't make you a scammer.

Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by gumby on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:54PM (#41038294)
> It's not just AI startups. It's almost all of them.

The reality is that a very tiny percentage of new companies get institutional financing at all (and the majority of those that do aren't technical and aren't startups in the sense that they aren't intended to be high growth at a high margin). The loud press that makes it sound otherwise is just survivorship bias.

Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by nrb on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:07PM (#41037528)
I dunno, for all the perceived (and real) failures, the last few generations of these experiments have spawned some of the highest earning, and arguably transformative, companies in history.
Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by bmitc on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:08PM (#41037547)
Which ones?
Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by antihero on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:13PM (#41037650)
Challenger banks have been pretty great for all their failings, at least in the UK. Can’t believe people actually used to charge you for being broke.

E2E encrypted messaging that is accessible to people and works using data has been transformative.

Twitter has changed the landscape of communication.

Streaming music and video services have changed the way people consume media and shaped the way it’s created and broadcast.

Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by edanm on Tuesday July 23, 2024 @02:34AM (#41043145)
Which huge companies were spawned from the last few decades of startups raising VC? I think almost all the biggest companies today?

Here's a list I grabbed of the highest market-cap companies: 1. Apple 2. Microsoft 3. NVIDIA 4. Alphabet (Google) 5. Amazon 6. Saudi Aramco 7. Meta Platforms (Facebook) 8. Berkshire Hathaway 9. TSMC 10. Tesla

Of this list, here are "startups" that raised VC money: 1. Apple 2. Microsoft 3. NVIDIA 4. Alphabet (Google) 5. Amazon 6. Meta Platforms (Facebook) 7. Tesla

So more than half of the top-10 biggest companies today were these kinds of startup "experiments".

And of course, these are just the biggest companies, and don't include many things I interact with on a day-to-day basis, which are incredibly valuable to me, e.g. Netflix, ChatGPT, YouTube (part of Alphabet but important enough to warrant mentioning), etc.

Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by nyxtom on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:34PM (#41037999)
Idk there are some truly incredible VR setups now for sim games that I am having a blast with. More of this please
Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by dustingetz on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:06PM (#41037511)
capital is a market

you can bootstrap

any other ideas?

main problem is that startup equity is not a good deal for anyone at all until after PMF

Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by jonny_eh on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:31PM (#41037949)
Nothing proved the emperor has no clothes better than the crypto trend.
Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by normie3000 on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:36PM (#41038027)
if anything, crypto seems to have proven that the emperor is happy in his nudity.
Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by tim333 on Wednesday July 24, 2024 @07:12AM (#41055725)
The core use of crypto in practice is gambling/speculation. People say that isn't a real business because they don't like it but human nature is what it is. Casinos, lotteries and bookies don't seem to be dying out, or crypto for that matter.
Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by burnished on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:43PM (#41038143)
Well at least it gave many of us the opportunity to practice asking 'in simple terms whats the core value of your proposition?'
Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by godelski on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:55PM (#41038304)
> I truly wonder how much of the U.S. economy has slowed down because of all this wasted effort.

I wonder how frequently startups and hype KILL technologies. A technology starts to show progress, everyone gets excited about that progress, tons of money gets dumped in, everyone rushes to put that technology into production, technology flops, funding for technology dries up. Meanwhile, a lot of people got very rich, so we repeat the cycle. But there was an important step missed here if we want a technology to actually succeed. Research.

The hype train only seems to gear up for technologies that are still in their infancies. This of course makes sense, because how else do you raise money? Chicken and the egg. But the problem here is that you're not using that money to solve the problems with the tech and get it to the point where it could then be effectively used in things, but instead rush to hamfist it into everything you can. Sometimes you gotta slow down first, and prep for the sprint. Google seems to be the worst at this, routinely killing projects that 5-10 years later are then sold as high status items. A company with that much capital doesn't need to rush to market, you can strategize and take your time.

The problem is that the details always matter and they can be a huge make it or break it for a technology. You can generate all the safe miles you want, but if you run through a red light anytime there's a child holding a green balloon a bit too high, you failed. You can build fancy games, but if you promise a holodeck and deliver a hollowdeck, people are reasonably upset. Hype is a double edged sword. You need some to get people on board, but too much and you overpromise. You can build crazy and legitimately helpful tools, but if you're (or others) are promising 10x what you can, then when they get their hands on it they have every right to be upset. Even if the thing is still useful to them and betters their lives. They are rightfully upset, but they'll unrightfully dismiss what you made. So the people who benefit from the hype cycles are the grifters. The ones willing to jump from one thing to the next. Which is why I'm always very confused why we prop up people who have "expertise" in all the last hype bubbles as if it is credentializing why they are experts in the new hype bubble. How does a giant and brilliant red flag get interpreted as green? Maybe we're not so different from self-driving cars after all.

Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by 1vuio0pswjnm7 on Monday July 22, 2024 @08:01PM (#41041119)
Will be amazed if this stays the top comment. Would not be surprised if the submission gets flagged.

It's the truth.

Re:How much money we can raise for transparently idiotic sta... by pas on Monday July 22, 2024 @08:54PM (#41041461)
HN is not immune to hyperbole and hype. (And now it's pretty trendy to hate on startups.) While he truth is ... a lot more complicated.

AR/VR was hardly a pump and dump. There are massive technical and creative challenges for both, but ... I fail to see how it was a pump and dump. (Unless you mean Faceberg and Moogle spending ridiculous amounts on it, probably because Neuromancer was pretty damn influential.)

Similarly self-driving cars clearly have value (~1.3M people die each year on the roads absolutely unnecessarily, as most of them could have been prevented ... 1.3M people die of TBC, which is again preventable)

If you think EV is a bubble I would like to offer you this nice prospectus of leisure activities on Venus. (Uh, one hyperbole, thanks HN!) That said EV seems the same kind of bubble as housing. The prices are high because of the demand. Battery prices (the biggest cost currently in EVs) keep going down. Demand is going up. Heatwaves are pretty good marketing "for" global warming.