There are the two you mentioned: 1- small businesses that go out of business after a few years 2- ...ones that become big chains
But you are forgetting #3, the one that actually makes up the largest proportion of businesses: 3- people that quietly, successfully, run their businesses in a sustainable, family and community oriented manner (not financial growth focused but personal growth focused) and then retire quietly surrounded by loved ones.
I wasn't forgetting them, they just aren't relevant to a conversation about venture capital, at least to me. There are plenty of small bootstrapped startups out there, but their ROI isn't high enough to justify a gamble on the part of investors. Likewise with the businesses you're talking about.
Yes the make up most small businesses, but most small businesses aren't looking for private venture capital, and don't fall into the category of what OP was claiming is "pump n dump".
https://www.bls.gov/web/cewbd/table_f.txt
~42% of the workforce is employed at firms with 1000+ headcount.
The next biggest bucket is ~10% the 20-49 range. Then ~9.5% is the 100-249 bucket.
And the share of biggest ones is (likely unfortunately) growing.
Here are some other statistics about small businesses in the United States:
84.8% of businesses in rural areas are small businesses
43.2% of small businesses are owned by women
20% of employer businesses are owned by minorities
Small businesses account for about 96% of employer firms in high-patenting manufacturing industries
there is an unlabeled selection bias missing here, and in that bias we find everything
get wealthy, and not really good 9-5 job wealthy. Properly wealthy.
imho that sort of "aim for the exit" thinking strongly incentivizes pump-and-dump behaviour and I think the bandwagoning we see with every hot new tech is exactly what one would expect as a result.
Also:
1) IPO is one of those exit strategies. Tons of startups are aiming to become long lived independent companies.
2) M&A makes sense for lots of businesses, as you get to take advantage of better economies of scale as part of a larger org. Saying it's your exit plan doesn't make you a scammer.
That's how it works outside of the startup world too. Most restaurants, clothing stores, car repair shops, etc. go out of business after just a few years, while a few move on to become large chains and the like.