News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Panic at the Job Market by golergka on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @02:39PM (#40988939)
I love long takehomes. They're like pet projects, but with clearly defined goals and with people that might even give you a review if you're lucky. I always use them to try a new library or a framework, and often continue improving on them even after they're submitted and evaluated.
Re:Panic at the Job Market by pants2 on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @02:49PM (#40989054)
I had a take-home assignment to build a Dropbox competitor around 10 years ago, it was a pretty big project but I actually still use it for sharing files with friends because it's legitimately much easier to use than Dropbox.
Re:Panic at the Job Market by GJim on Thursday July 18, 2024 @04:10AM (#40993530)
> I had a take-home assignment to build a Dropbox competitor around 10 years ago, it was a pretty big project

I'm genuinely amused you thought (think?) it acceptable to do such work without payment. Here, any potential employer submitting such a request would be laughed at.

Re:Panic at the Job Market by mrkstu on Thursday July 18, 2024 @05:06AM (#40993810)
Well, technically if he isn't getting paid, it's his copyright, allowing him to use the code and even create a business around it, and the company has no rights to it- so in this case it worked out well for him.

But yes, its a pretty crappy idea that people should do 'real' work for free to get hired.

Re:Panic at the Job Market by digging on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @02:52PM (#40989083)
Sure, but at best that's unrelated to their value as an interview process. At worst, it's actually making things worse for you, because you're distracted and not doing more interviews.
Re:Panic at the Job Market by ninininino on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @03:49PM (#40989643)
Quality beats quantity. If you smash the hell out of a take-home project you won't need to do any more interviews. Companies that rely on take-homes usually are the same ones that don't make you go through Leetcode/trivia gauntlets.

My biggest advice is if they say to use 4 hours but you need 8 to do an amazingly thorough job then use 8. It's basically cheating but I've always found that it doesn't end up causing any actual problems in terms of being able to deliver at a velocity they needed in actual product work post-hire.

Re:Panic at the Job Market by gopher_space on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @04:54PM (#40990255)
My biggest advice is to assume the reviewer is a bored junior running down a checklist that tests only what was in the spec. They have like five minutes budgeted for getting your project running and a pile of applications to go.

> Quality beats quantity. If you smash the hell out of a take-home project you won't need to do any more interviews.

This means a decent amount of that time spent on documentation, imho.

Re:Panic at the Job Market by camdenreslink on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @05:57PM (#40990723)
I do as you do, but there is a very real risk that nobody will ever look at it. Or it gets assigned to a dev (who has a lot of other real work to do) to look at and the give it a cursory once over and a thumbs up or down.
Re:Panic at the Job Market by jofla_net on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @06:41PM (#40991005)
I had one where after weeks of work, tweaking, it received zero time on their eyeballs. And I know because they never went to the link i sent. So ghosting a project is a very huge reality...
Re:Panic at the Job Market by nsxwolf on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @06:07PM (#40990805)
Every takehome I've ever "passed" has just been an invitation to 3 rounds of Leetcode and a systems design interview, followed by a rejection.

And being on the other side of the interview, I know many times the takehomes don't even get looked at.

Re:Panic at the Job Market by ipaddr on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @06:32PM (#40990966)
The fallacy of believing putting in 10 hours on that 2 hour test will push your candidacy over the top. We've all been there.
Re:Panic at the Job Market by collyw on Thursday July 18, 2024 @09:31AM (#40995412)
If they give that "challenge" to 4 other people there is only a 25% chance that you will get the job.
Re:Panic at the Job Market by johnnyanmac on Thursday July 18, 2024 @07:36PM (#41000763)
>If you smash the hell out of a take-home project you won't need to do any more interviews. Companies that rely on take-homes usually are the same ones that don't make you go through Leetcode/trivia gauntlets.

First job me believed that. Current job me has done 2 take homes that only lead to ghosts. then 1 more that lead to failing a leetcode style interview. Never again.

and I have plenty of personal projects outside of work, I don't need more pet projects like the one comment up stream.

Re:Panic at the Job Market by trallnag on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @04:55PM (#40990265)
How often have you done such tasks?
Re:Panic at the Job Market by dennis_jeeves2 on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @10:52PM (#40992090)
Troll!
Re:Panic at the Job Market by KaiserPro on Thursday July 18, 2024 @08:22AM (#40994913)
> I love long takehomes.

I am happy that you are full of life and joy with programming. I genuinely want you to keep that, it is precious. However, they are getting free labour from you, so just keep that in mind.

For me, I can't do that anymore. I just can't muster up the energy to work on problems for something thats not going to be taken seriously by the "client"