Re:The All-American Delusion of the Polygraph
by vasco on Tuesday July 16, 2024 @04:04AM
(#40974469)
Most innocent people doubt their innocence when strongly accused even when they know they are right. Just a tiny bit, but in the right setting and with enough wearing you down, you can make innocent people believe they did it. I've seen it happen right in front of me.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The All-American Delusion of the Polygraph
by willis936 on Tuesday July 16, 2024 @07:08AM
(#40975408)
That's why you don't talk to cops. Have a lawyer present and use the courts that us taxpayers pay for.
Re:The All-American Delusion of the Polygraph
by lazide on Tuesday July 16, 2024 @11:11AM
(#40977323)
Also why narcissistic and psychopathic manipulators are so dangerous.
They don’t have to be cops. Most aren’t.
Re:The All-American Delusion of the Polygraph
by Aerroon on Tuesday July 16, 2024 @11:40AM
(#40977570)
I wonder if this is related to people adding ambiguity to what they're saying.
Eg instead of saying "it's 20 degrees outside" they will say "last I checked it was about 20 degrees".
They change their phrasing because they want others to not think that they are wrong. By doing this they undermine their own credibility though.
Re:The All-American Delusion of the Polygraph
by BenjiWiebe on Tuesday July 16, 2024 @03:52PM
(#40979702)
Hmmm. People who make absolute statements like that generally* undermine their own credibility in my mind.
*I do it lots. Partly because the way my mind runs, I can nearly always (lol, can't help it) come up with possible conditions where I'd be wrong.
Re:The All-American Delusion of the Polygraph
by Aerroon on Sunday July 21, 2024 @07:45AM
(#41024393)
I am the opposite. I constantly add ambiguity even when I'm sure. I'm trying to learn to do less of it.
Re:The All-American Delusion of the Polygraph
by powersnail on Tuesday July 16, 2024 @12:57PM
(#40978223)
But what's the point of making innocent confess to false crimes in this setting? (i.e. requiring polygraph for job application)
I would imagine the entire point of doing a test would be to find out who is innocent and who is lying about being innocent. If you pressure the innocent into false confession, wouldn't it just make everything even more difficult?
Re:The All-American Delusion of the Polygraph
by josefx on Tuesday July 16, 2024 @05:59PM
(#40980729)
In the context of a job application? Making up excuses to hide discrimination, maybe artificially limit the pool of applications to get around other hiring restrictions? Put the applicant on the back foot or make them share information they normally wouldn't? There are probably many ways to abuse it.
Re:The All-American Delusion of the Polygraph
by powersnail on Wednesday July 17, 2024 @03:32PM
(#40989458)
Good points. It never occurred to me that there are situations where recruiters intentionally try to remove legit applicants from the pool.