News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by toomuchtodo on Sunday July 14, 2024 @05:47PM (#40963436)
Wealth is unelected power, a bug. It’s reasonable to say there should be limits on wealth, considering most wealthy people were lucky (either by birth or “right place right time”) but attempt to post rationalize it as anything else.

Would you want someone who won a lottery ticket to have power over your life at scale? Because that’s what excess wealth is, a power dynamic powered by a suboptimal system masquerading as shades of a meritocracy that does not exist.

Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by dnissley on Sunday July 14, 2024 @06:28PM (#40963669)
On some level not all power being elected is good. Provides some balancing force for an electorate with... I'm not sure what to call it... volatile whims?
Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by rpdillon on Sunday July 14, 2024 @07:30PM (#40964028)
Presuming this is correct, what's the better alternative?
Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by toomuchtodo on Sunday July 14, 2024 @07:32PM (#40964045)
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40963894 seems like a start. You don’t need to throw the entire system away and start from scratch, simply refactor the suboptimal parts piece by piece.
Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by rpdillon on Sunday July 14, 2024 @07:46PM (#40964116)
Sorry, I thought you said that wealth was a bug, so I was looking for an alternative to wealth. Taxing wealth doesn't seem like an alternative to wealth, it seems like building on top of it.
Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by pedroma on Sunday July 14, 2024 @07:49PM (#40964130)
The solution is to redistribute power from the people to the government?
Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by TimTheTinker on Sunday July 14, 2024 @06:57PM (#40963835)
Without wealth, there is no prosperity for anyone except those who hold political power, full stop.
Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by aorloff on Sunday July 14, 2024 @06:16PM (#40963602)
What about wealth you build for yourself ?

Many of the duplexes in town were built by small builders who passed them on to family.

Now they are treated like rich landowners but in reality grandpa built the wealth.

Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by toomuchtodo on Sunday July 14, 2024 @06:16PM (#40963606)
Do you not see how this was luck? Certainly, actions were taken to encourage an outcome (holding an asset of potential future value), but luck as a component of a favorable outcome cannot be overstated.
Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by kortilla on Sunday July 14, 2024 @06:45PM (#40963760)
Of course it can be overstated. That’s basically the entire mantra of progressives in the US right now and it’s used as an excuse for incompetent people to attack people who successfully do things and (even worse) absolve themselves of responsibility for doing unproductive things.

Punishing people for not having something bad derail their business is tall poppy syndrome.

Luck is a part of why everyone continues breathing everyday rather than having sudden heart failure. We don’t need to constantly diminish people for living because they were lucky enough to not have a fatal condition.

We should be encouraging the people who were successful, even if part of it may have been luck. Any other approach punishes people doing the rest of the work that isn’t luck.

Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by aorloff on Sunday July 14, 2024 @06:22PM (#40963634)
They were builders, they had businesses building for other people and invested their own money and time into these buildings for their own family.

Luck in exactly what sense ?

Yes, they did not die of dysentery on the trail, so evidently some luck was involved, but the wealth building seems very intentional and causal.

Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by soared on Sunday July 14, 2024 @06:35PM (#40963708)
Luck that their grandpa built the duplex. I am unlucky that my grandpa did not build a duplex. Luck that their parents held the assets and did not sell it.
Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by throwaway22032 on Sunday July 14, 2024 @08:00PM (#40964189)
This is not luck.

Your grandfather chose your grandmother and so too did your parents.

Your parents deciding to do something is not luck either.

I want my children to have an inheritance, the actions I take to ensure that are ongoing deliberate choices to build wealth over having fun.

Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by soared on Sunday July 14, 2024 @10:18PM (#40964784)
Yes, so it’s completely out of your children’s control whether or not you chose those decisions. Therefore, they are lucky you are doing that. They have zero impact on whether or not the actions of their grandparents resulted in generational wealth.
Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by throwaway22032 on Monday July 15, 2024 @05:53AM (#40966471)
Nonsense.

You posted this comment 7 hours ago. Current you has zero impact on whether you posted it.

Time flows forwards, not backwards.

Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by soared on Monday July 15, 2024 @10:27AM (#40968174)
What action did you take that caused your grandpa to invest in real estate? If none, it is lucky for you that your grandpa took one action over another, as you had no impact on the event.
Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by throwaway22032 on Monday July 15, 2024 @03:29PM (#40970764)
You can call it luck as many times as you like, I simply disagree.

If my dad builds me a shed it is no more lucky than if I build a shed.

We should leave this here, I feel that we just have different relationships with our parents :)

Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by TimTheTinker on Tuesday July 16, 2024 @06:41AM (#40975245)
You just don't like the notion of inheritance.

My guess is that you also don't have any kids of your own. If/when you do, if and only if you're a good parent, you'll want to provide them with the best opportunities you can—and that desire will motivate you to work hard for their benefit.

What you seem to be saying is that my hard work for my kids is their undeserved luck and that the government should receive the results of my hard work, not my kids. If so, fie on that and any government scheme to steal the result of my hard work from my kids. I'd sooner move to Bermuda than have the likes of you or anyone else impoverish my family.

The money I make is not stolen and not a zero-sum capture either—I created value and benefited society. Why shouldn't I have the right to give my money to whomever I choose instead of spending it all on myself? And if I choose to give it to those for whom I spent my life's strength and who I raised from infancy, who are you to steal it from them? If you do, you're both stealing from me and hurting someone I love.

No—you may not steal the life I built for them from them, and I will defend them with my life from your desire to hurt them via theft, violence, or anything else. 40-year-old papa bear is angry at you.

Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by dang on Tuesday July 16, 2024 @01:35PM (#40978548)
Please edit swipes out of your HN posts. This is in the site guidelines: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.
Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by toomuchtodo on Sunday July 14, 2024 @06:23PM (#40963639)
See, you’ve caught yourself in the trap. Lots of builders fail, look at the YC startup failure rate.

Even investing in broad equity index funds is luck (sequence risk).

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40378138

https://archive.nytimes.com/www.nytimes.com/interactive/2011...

Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by kortilla on Sunday July 14, 2024 @06:47PM (#40963775)
You’ve caught yourself in the trap of thinking that passing something with a high failure rate means luck.
Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by rpdillon on Sunday July 14, 2024 @07:35PM (#40964063)
This is a tired argument.

Success in life will always be a combination of luck, and hard work to set yourself up to take advantage of the luck when it arrives.

For some, the luck will never arrive. And for many, the luck will arrive, but they won't be ready for it. The only practical advice to give people is to prepare the best they can for when and if it does.

Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by toomuchtodo on Sunday July 14, 2024 @08:13PM (#40964262)
I’m not arguing the advice, I’m arguing the religion and belief system.
Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by aorloff on Sunday July 14, 2024 @06:26PM (#40963653)
I meant construction developers as a trade for others.
Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by aorloff on Sunday July 14, 2024 @06:25PM (#40963649)
In the context of a discussion about wealth, its true that the financialization of real estate and runaway values of the greater Silicon Valley were a stroke of luck, but when talking about building wealth, housing has intrinsic value that I think takes a lot of that kind of SV luck out of the picture.
Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by toomuchtodo on Sunday July 14, 2024 @06:29PM (#40963674)
Housing value is land value. Did you buy or build in the right location? Luck!

Did commercial real estate know WFH post Covid was going to obliterate CRE values? Again, bad luck.

Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by aorloff on Monday July 15, 2024 @01:04AM (#40965397)
This is true, many people got hung out to dry who happened to hold office properties when COVID hit.

But the housing could have just housed the family members if times were tight. For at least the first generation, it did. That's intrinsic value, not valuation according to a market.

Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by ThrowawayR2 on Sunday July 14, 2024 @08:56PM (#40964465)
"I am a great believer in luck. The harder I work, the more of it I seem to have." --Coleman Cox
Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by Devasta on Sunday July 14, 2024 @07:24PM (#40964000)
But if they are receiving free houses from their grandpa, they didn't build the wealth themselves.
Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by chr1 on Sunday July 14, 2024 @06:11PM (#40963574)
How many people who win lottery tickets become wealthy? Most of them squander the money they win, so your point about simply being lucky is not true.

As for your question lottery winner having the power proportional to his money, is much better than bureaucrats having power to take anyone's money.

Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by WalterBright on Sunday July 14, 2024 @07:03PM (#40963878)
Netflix ran a documentary recently about what happens to the zillions paid to football players.

Spoiler Alert: they spend it like it was water, and when their short career is over, they have nothing.

Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by eigart on Sunday July 14, 2024 @06:38PM (#40963721)
Obtaining excessive wealth is the same as winning the lottery (the billionaire founder class).

Edit: Q: If you downvote this comment, do you believe someone like Zuckerberg was predestined to be a billionaire?

Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by AlOwain on Sunday July 14, 2024 @10:03PM (#40964726)
He was certainly not predestined, but his inclinations and temperaments did distinguish him. True some luck is involved; it is a necessary part, but individuals are often what induces the procuring of wealth.
Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by eigart on Monday July 15, 2024 @01:41AM (#40965542)
If you monte carloed it, I’m sure he would do way better than average, but given how rare the current outcome is, I firmly believe it is mostly luck.
Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by WalterBright on Sunday July 14, 2024 @06:49PM (#40963789)
If people cannot accumulate wealth, we wouldn't have SpaceX.
Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by DaoVeles on Sunday July 14, 2024 @07:22PM (#40963989)
Such a declarative statement is very reductionist. Yes, some folks will accumulate wealth but there needs to be some additional limits on it.

I am in favor of progressively increasing tax brackets that eventually get up to near 100$. Spend it or lose it. And if you lose it, it goes in to the very bottom income bracket where it will be used imediately. Trick up economics if you will.

Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by WalterBright on Sunday July 14, 2024 @07:41PM (#40964087)
You don't think Musk's fortune was used? He invested all he had in Tesla, then again in SpaceX.

> there needs to be some additional limits on it.

Then we don't get SpaceX or Tesla.

Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by marmadukester39 on Sunday July 14, 2024 @07:22PM (#40963991)
No, but we do get NASA
Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by WalterBright on Sunday July 14, 2024 @07:44PM (#40964100)
Musk's rockets cost less than 10% of NASA's. Plus, SpaceX has not cost you a cent, while you've paid plenty of taxes for NASA.
Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by abenga on Monday July 15, 2024 @01:33AM (#40965507)
The highest NASA's budget has ever been as a percentage of the federal budget is 4.5% during the Apollo program, totalling 650b nominally over the years. Saying anyone here now has paid "plenty" of taxes to nasa sounds … disingenuous at best.
Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by WalterBright on Monday July 15, 2024 @01:44AM (#40965556)
4.5% is a terrific amount of money.

You paid $zero for SpaceX.

Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by abenga on Monday July 15, 2024 @03:38AM (#40965945)
A bit less, definitely, but not zero. The US government has paid billions for use of SpaceX launches since it was founded. One could argue that the spending on NASA has benefited the world much more (e.g. free NOAA climate/weather data for research, etc) vs just increasing the wealth of privateers.
Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by gmac on Monday July 15, 2024 @02:44AM (#40965748)
In this context, surely the whole point is that we could have taxed Musk’s wealth instead, so we have collectively paid whatever amount we didn’t tax him.
Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by JackFr on Sunday July 14, 2024 @07:09PM (#40963909)
> Because that’s what excess wealth is, a power dynamic powered by a suboptimal system masquerading as shades of a meritocracy that does not exist.

What does that mean? It's millenial Marxism unmoored from any specificity or facts.

Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by toomuchtodo on Sunday July 14, 2024 @07:11PM (#40963920)
We pretend wealthy people are special when they’re simply lucky. They then use wealth to wield power and control (politics specifically, Citizens United, but I can provide other examples), with a narrative that they are special (not lucky! special!) and that maybe you too can be special and wealthy if you work really hard and are exceptional.

Are the wealthy lucky? Yes. Do they use their wealth to shape the world as they see fit? Yes. Is the narrative that anyone can be wealthy if they work very hard and are exceptional despite the math showing this is not true? Yes.

Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by throwaway22032 on Sunday July 14, 2024 @08:04PM (#40964213)
Aside from the influence of money on politics almost all of what you have written is complete bollocks.

Many of us have been successful from nothing and know friends who have been more so. There is usually a luck element in the size of that success but it is blindingly obvious to someone who was in the crab bucket to see that actions work.

It sounds as if you have an emotional issue with the idea that people can change their own situation. I literally have a choice tomorrow whether I paint my wall, study, fix up the leak in my loft, etc, or just sit and play my Switch. People who do too much of the latter do not succeed.

And no, parents or grandparents or country or genetics or whatever are not luck either. Choosing a suitable mate is about as close to the meaning of life as we have.

Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by toomuchtodo on Sunday July 14, 2024 @08:18PM (#40964293)
> It sounds as if you have an emotional issue with the idea that people can change their own situation.

On the contrary, I am simply data informed. It sounds like you're operating from a mental model that overweighs ability in outcomes. I have provided links below to help you improve and evolve this model.

https://www.scientificamerican.com/blog/beautiful-minds/the-... ("The Role of Luck in Life Success Is Far Greater Than We Realized")

https://www.technologyreview.com/2018/03/01/144958/if-youre-... | http://arxiv.org/abs/1802.07068 ("Talent vs. Luck: The Role of Randomness in Success and Failure")

https://ustrustaem.fs.ml.com/content/dam/ust/articles/pdf/20... (2022 Bank of America Private Bank Study of Wealthy Americans: The impact of shifting generational attitudes amid an historic wealth transfer) [Only 27% of the ultra wealthy are self made; 70% of Americans who hold more than $3 million are over 56 years old.]

https://www.financialsamurai.com/your-wealth-is-mostly-due-t... ("Your Outsized Wealth Is Mostly Due To Luck: Be Thankful!")

> And no, parents or grandparents or country or genetics or whatever are not luck either.

https://www.pewtrusts.org/en/about/news-room/press-releases-... ("Parental Income Has Outsized Influence on Children’s Economic Future")

https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/7122514681658661... ("Global inequality of opportunity: How much of our income is determined by where we live?")

https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/the-origins-of-menta... | https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S000292972... ("Genes Influence Children’s Success, Directly and Indirectly")

> Choosing a suitable mate is about as close to the meaning of life as we have.

~43% of first marriages fail, ~60% of second marriages, ~73% third marriages.

https://www.forbes.com/advisor/legal/divorce/divorce-statist...

Good luck.

Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by throwaway22032 on Sunday July 14, 2024 @08:49PM (#40964433)
Alright, I had previously been lazy but here's a proper response.

I'm confused because to me, everything you have posted backs up the idea that these things are in fact actions and not luck based.

Country of residence is not luck based, it's either pre-determined or chosen by parents.

27% self made is huge, I would have expected it to be lower.

Parental income having an effect on children's is also not an example of luck. If I work hard so that my children do well, that is not luck based.

Genes influence success, so choose good genes.

43% of marriages failing simply shows that many people don't take it as seriously as they used to due to things like no fault divorce. So choose well. Your partner, at least the type of person they are, should not be luck based. Your marriage definitely should not feel like a 4 in 10 dice roll, if it does you have really messed up.

I think you and I (really, me and most left wing media) have a different definition of luck. Luck is rolling a die and getting a number, these things are more like causative factors.

But still, there exist plenty of people who have been born into adversity and study and work hard, network and press the right buttons. That isn't luck, a lottery win is luck.

I dunno. It all just feels like a way to absolve one's self from responsibility to me. I did the washing up yesterday, so today I don't have to do it. Is today me lucky that yesterday me did it? Only in the colloquial sense.

Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by abenga on Monday July 15, 2024 @08:06AM (#40967086)
Like you said, you have a different definition of luck. Others seem to say "factors that you did not choose, and do not have the ability to change" are luck.

> Country of residence is not luck based, it's either pre-determined or chosen by parents.

So you have very little to do with it; you can probably choose this after you finish school, but this is dependent on the place you would like to emigrate to letting you in, thus it's mostly not up to you.

> Parental income having an effect on children's is also not an example of luck. If I work hard so that my children do well, that is not luck based.

If I get the resources to do well because my parents worked hard, that is really not something I choose, so it's "luck".

> Genes influence success, so choose good genes.

One can hardly choose their own genes, can they?

> But still, there exist plenty of people who have been born into adversity and study and work hard, network and press the right buttons.

This is true. They would have had an easier time and achieved more if they did not have to dig out of the basement first before building up.

Nobody is saying that you cannot be smart and diligent enough to change your lot in life, we are just saying it is hard, getting harder every day, and it should not be.

Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by throwaway22032 on Monday July 15, 2024 @09:06AM (#40967544)
I just think this is a basic logical error.

39 year old me built a shed.

40 year old me then has a shed.

40 year old me did not influence or choose 39 year old me.

But 40 year old me does not have a shed due to luck.

It was causative.

Your parents and your past decisions are not luck based.

If you want to call that luck, then you need a different word for actual luck such as chance encounters, lottery wins, unexpected windfalls etc, because otherwise we are just misinterpreting each other.

Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by abenga on Monday July 15, 2024 @09:17AM (#40967643)
If you didn't choose it, do it, and cannot change it, it's not up to you. Whatever parents n-1 year old you had, or nationality they had, are the same ones n year old you have. If they are abusive, or in war, you are screwed. Build a shed or not. Of course there are things you can do to improve your and your children's lives (and you should), but there are irreversible handicaps you can have through no choice or action of yours.
Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by AnimalMuppet on Monday July 15, 2024 @09:34AM (#40967771)
Define "luck". That's what this whole disagreement hinges on. You're using a different definition of luck.

Sure, I reap the fruits of my past decisions, like the shed. More to the point, I reap the fruits of my parents' decisions. Is that luck?

It's not luck from the perspective of actions having consequences, and parents doing things that help their children.

It is luck from the perspective of "you didn't pick your parents", or from the "if you were going to be born to someone random, where and when would you want to be born?" perspective.

So you and abenga are saying "yes it is!" "no it's not" about the same set of facts, because you're running different definitions of what is or is not luck.

Arguments about the definitions of words are really uninteresting. What you and abenga are saying boils down to "yes, actions have consequences, and better actions lead to better consequences, both for yourself and your descendents, but no, you didn't select the parents, country, or time you were born to".

Apart from the definition of "luck", do either of you actually disagree with either side of that? If so, with what part, and why?

And, if you do agree with it, what conclusions do you draw?

Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by throwaway22032 on Monday July 15, 2024 @11:07AM (#40968528)
I agree that the words don't matter.

What it comes down to is that luck cannot be incentivised - a dice will always roll a 2, 1/6th of the time.

But good behaviour can be incentivised, e.g. people choosing their partners well and providing stable environments for their children.

We should incentivise good behaviour whilst also ensuring that luck doesn't result in unassailable leads e.g. a lottery win probably should not result in a 1000 year dynasty but a lottery win combined with intelligent estate planning, good mate selection, diversification etc probably should.

> if you were going to be born to someone random, where and when would you want to be born

I think that this is like asking, if 40 year old you were completely randomly spawned, whose life would you like to continue from. You can't. The lineage from your parents to you is the same as the lineage from you to you. It's a nonsense line of inquiry.

Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by ethagnawl on Sunday July 14, 2024 @07:00PM (#40963859)
That's such a simple, yet profound analogy. It's a great bit of framing for these types of conversations.
Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by toomuchtodo on Sunday July 14, 2024 @07:05PM (#40963889)
Appreciate the kind words. Any fool can know, the point is to understand.
Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by marcianx on Sunday July 14, 2024 @10:04PM (#40964730)
How would you impose these limits on wealth? Where would the extra money go? To the government? If so, would you be okay with the government saying that _all_ future earnings if yours went straight to them because you have too much money already? Would you give anyone that power?
Re:Just Be Rich (2021) by danaris on Monday July 15, 2024 @10:38AM (#40968268)
If I already had $2B? Or even $200M?

Yeah, I'd be OK with that. It's not like it would actually affect my life in any way whatsoever. We're not talking about the government taking the food out of anyone's mouth.

It's not actually a benefit to the world that we have individuals walking around with enough wealth to purchase, say, one of the major companies that acts as a backbone for communication and information-spreading worldwide. (Of course, it's also somewhat troubling that a single for-profit company can be such a backbone, but that's a separate conversation.) In fact, there's some pretty solid research indicating that it's destabilizing for entire societies to have that level of inequality.