Also, please don't post unsubstantive and/or flamebait comments, and please don't use HN primarily for political/ideological/nationalistic battle. Your account has already been doing a lot of those things and that's the sort of account we end up having to ban.
There isn't a single comment by this dude that isn't related to politics. Not one.
He's probably on a payroll.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40568392
Meanwhile I provided a link to an obscure proof assistant.
What is HN doing against shills, i.e. people that are tactful enough to steer opinion towards certain goals and let you think they "also posted good things" ? Is preventing confrontations on this problem a good tradeoff with the current state of the guidelines considering that political topics are a lot more present on HN than 10 years ago ? Or could fostering a culture of shill-spotting beneficial ?
Logging off. Password status: not saved, as always.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40908934
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40793361
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40793252
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40770909
This is the sort of thing we have to ban accounts for in the end, and I don't want to ban you, because you've also posted good things—so it would be good if you'd review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html, take the intended spirit of the site to heart, and stick to the rules in the future. We'd appreciate it.
Anyway, I've since learned of some non-Western outlets to see the "other" side of things, and it's very interesting to compare and contrast the differences.
Once solid evidence is in sight then are usually some clean objective takes to be had and some fairly obvious or likely subjective takes that a reasonable viewer might have.
The real problems happen when one side objects to what counts as evidence at all or one side puts forward low quality evidence and claims it is beyond reproach.
Assuming one's evidence is subjective, and one's judgment of it, and some other things.
> than appealing to vibes or appealing to baseless authority.
"Baseful" authorities are not necessarily objective. In fact, we have massive amounts of evidence that they are very often not.
Different people disagree for different reasons. But only the most deranged disagree that what they can do and effect is worse evidence than some authority. So things like "trying it for yourself" have worked consistently as evidence for most of history. Today "it" can be a bunch of different categories of experiments and experiences.
Even then lots of experiments are out of reach of most people, sometimes financially, sometimes intellectually. Some people think essential oils helped their cold go away in 3~5 days when most colds go away on their own in 3~5 days and. So there needs to be some delegation of authority. This is where a lot of problems leak it. Some people grant authority to some for silly reasons (like an a priori assumption they can do no wrong) other for good reasons (like lots of experience working in a relevant field with many published papers).
For many people exploring the different levels of subjective evidence can get two people to understand why the other believes something goofy. This takes time, isn't guaranteed, but it can be done at least some of the time to show where evidence and many beliefs fall on a gradient of quality. This fails when people hold some belief as firmer than reality, like what conspiracy theorists or religious zealots do.
> To use an example nearer to my heart, say you want to compare how many Apple and Samsung devices were sold in the past five years. The service would locate and collate that information.
My question would be to what extent is this really a problem. Sounds like they're going to be competing with Google and Bloomberg which is a tough sell. Finding data quickly is their bread and butter.
- The perception that founders with big tech "credentials" stand a better chance of success than those without. The founders of Humane were ex-Apple.
- The idea that founders will generally be more successful on their second try, even if their first ended up being a complete trash fire - see Adam Neumann. This one sounds more reasonable on the surface but I've got no data to back it.
For whatever reason, the failure of their tenure at past companies (or the failure of their past companies outright) are usually not held against them.
But wait, these execs need insane compensation because, conveniently, "they have the special skills needed to be an exec" [see my first sentence].
SV and the tech world has this idea that many execs and founders are something like Steve Jobs. They love to promote that image. Actually, from my experience, they're more like Elizabeth Holmes or your random MBA/MBB alum psychopath failing upwards.
Because they aren't shareholders, they're insiders who also own shares.
yeah, for example, purchasing a magazine about surfing