Completely disagree, having used them quite a bit. They are able to regurgitate knowledge, but have no ability to reason
People love to test this with "brain teasers". You could argue that LLMs can pattern match "what's heavier? 1kg of feathers or 2kg of steel", but there are enough examples of at the time novel puzzles that I feel confident to say that good LLMs can absolutely reason (at small scales, but it's getting better)
You can think without reasoning. Recalling knowledge does not require reason.
> to understand context
Can you break this down? What does it mean to understand context?
> to intelligently explain something
LLMs can do this.
> To understand WHY you are doing what you are doing.
You can ask an LLM why they do things they have and they may reply, even with an answer that is likely correct. This again depends on how you break down "understand".
"We've always done it this way."
"It's tradition."
The daughter asks, "Mom, "why do you cut the end off the roast before cooking it?"
"I learned that from your grandmother," replied the mom.
The daughter turned to her grandmother and asked, "Why did you do it?"
Grandma rolled her eyes, sighed, and said, "My oven was too short for the roast."
> I understand. I won't reply to that message.
> You replied. Why did you do that?
> I apologize for the confusion. You're right that I did reply, which was inconsistent with your initial instruction. This highlights an important limitation in my capabilities - I don't actually have the ability to simply not respond at all to a message. My training is designed to always generate some kind of response, even if that response is acknowledging an instruction not to respond. I should have been clearer about this limitation rather than incorrectly implying I had followed the instruction. Thank you for pointing this out, as it's a good reminder to be more precise about my capabilities and limitations.
I just had this dialog with Claude 3.5 Sonnet. Is this not a demonstration of exactly what you're describing as impossible for LLMs?
Now run this system through our LLM for as long as you want with as much power as you want. Where is it going to take you? Nowhere really, it's still just going to be constrained to its pool of data, recombining things in primitive ways and be essentially permanently stuck in the present, until somebody gives it some new data to train on it and mix and match. Yet somehow humanity, starting from that exact same basis, would soon (relatively speaking) put a man on the Moon, unlock the secrets of the atom, discover quantum mechanics, invent/discover mathematics, and much more.
This is what is fundamentally meant by LLMs cannot create "new" knowledge. They absolutely can mix and match their pool of training statements in ways that can generate new statements. But if it's not an extremely simple 'remix' and we're in a domain where there are right and wrong answers, there's good chance it's just a nonsensical hallucination.
And even once we solve that, LLMs - just like human scientists - absolutely need new data from the outside world. Very few breakthroughs were achieved by just thinking about it long and hard, most were the the result of years of experimentation. Something LLMs simply can't do
When robots are powered by transformers or the like, I expect we'll see some pretty impressive results.
But it's the internal consistency that really matters. LLMs have no internal consistency, because they have no way of 'adopting' a view, value, fact, or whatever else. They will randomly hallucinate things that directly contradict the overwhelming majority of their state, and then do so repeatedly in a single dialogue. If there were a human behaving in such a fashion, we would generally say they had schizophrenia or some other disorder that basically just ruins your ability to think like a human.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compartmentalization_(psycho...
The biggest mistake I see people make when criticizing LLMs is that they take the best possible modes of human thought from our best thinkers, and compare that to LLM edge cases.
Accuracy vs consistency isn't really a delineator. There's so much low-hanging fruit atm, like world models for LLMs improving drastically if you just train them longer. I'll believe the naysayers if say in 5 years GPT-4 is still near state of the art. Until then, there doesn't seem to actually be any theoretical limitations.
Like, if you can't tell me "what day is it today?" (actual failed prompt I have seen) then there's no world where I'm going to have a more complicated follow-up conversation with you. It's just not worth my time or yours.
But has anything changed? Well no, because it's obviously trivially possible for them to play a decent game of chess (or correctly assess the date), but it's an example of a more general issue of LLMs being generally incapable of consistently engaging in simple tasks across arbitrary domains. So you have software that can score some high thing on the LSAT or whatever, but can't competently engage in a game children can play.
The over-specialization for the sake of generating headlines and over-fitting benchmarks is, IMO, not productive. At least not in terms of creating optimal systems. If the goal is to generate money, which I guess it is, then it must be considered productive.
But like, people are on here saying that this will make scientific improvements, and until it can get past the basic stuff, it's not in the ballpark of anything more complicated. Right now, we're basically at the stage of 10 million monkeys on 10 million typewriters for 10 million hours. Like, maybe we'll get Shakespeare out of it, but are we willing to sort through all of the crap it will generate along the way, when it can't actually create a useful answer to simple questions?
Take what I wrote above. If you were given the context of what I have already written, then you could probably fill in most of what I wrote, to a reasonable degree of accuracy, after "It is their normal..." Because the issue is obvious and so my argument largely writes itself. To some degree even this second paragraph does.
Similarly if you ask ChatGPT about the current president of Numbitistan it will tell you that it doesn't know about a county with that name, rather than just hallucinating an answer. So it can at least in this circumstance tell the difference between knowing something and not knowing something.
I think this belies a common refrain from people in non-tech feeling like people in tech tend to oversimplify their fields and claim they can "fix any problem" without any actual specific knowledge in that field. This just feels like the next iteration of that.
> What features of the scientific method cannot be achieved through the composition of existing technologies?
^This statement, sums up the above trap perfectly. "I know how to create a workflow, therefore, I know how to create a workflow of the scientific method, therefore I can replace a scientist with an AI robot."
But okay, how do we know what quantitatively, is a significant result? R=0.05 is the most common cut-off for this, but like, that's a number we picked, and isn't even agreed on.
... and that is the start of your argument. Could it also have gnomes and robots?
Also around 46:20:
> the fundamental thing of knowing [the user] requires knowledge, which requires intellect, which GPT cannot have - it's mathematics.
I disagree with basically all of this except that knowing requires knowledge, but that's basically a tautology. Firstly, knowledge and reason do not depend on each other. Wikipedia is a highly knowledgeable system that demonstrates little to no reason (maybe the search can be considered a demonstration of reason). A calculator is a highly reasonable system with extremely primitive knowledge. Intelligent systems have knowledge and reason. Anyone who has played around with an LLM would agree that they are able to demonstrate some level of both knowledge and reason.
Also the implication that biological brains simply exist outside the domain of mathematics is... interesting.
Then they go on to talking about how you can't make small tweaks with generative video AI, like telling the actor to walk a little bit faster or slower. To that I want to highlight that ComfyUI has support for video nodes[0]. If you're not familiar with ComfyUI, just check out some tutorials. Generative AI art is a really cool skill that people downplay for usually wrong reasons.
> It can't generate new things
It's hard to take the host seriously when they say things like this...
> The technology is fundamentally unpredictable
It simply isn't. When you find a seed that is generally close to what you want, you fix the seed and tweak (because you can) from there.
[0] https://github.com/Kosinkadink/ComfyUI-VideoHelperSuite