News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The A.I. Bubble is Bursting with Ed Zitron [video] by blactuary on Saturday July 06, 2024 @12:52PM (#40891594)
To think, to understand context, and to intelligently explain something. To understand WHY you are doing what you are doing. That is not what an LLM is doing.
Re:The A.I. Bubble is Bursting with Ed Zitron [video] by Zambyte on Saturday July 06, 2024 @03:27PM (#40892598)
> To think

You can think without reasoning. Recalling knowledge does not require reason.

> to understand context

Can you break this down? What does it mean to understand context?

> to intelligently explain something

LLMs can do this.

> To understand WHY you are doing what you are doing.

You can ask an LLM why they do things they have and they may reply, even with an answer that is likely correct. This again depends on how you break down "understand".

Re:The A.I. Bubble is Bursting with Ed Zitron [video] by gaganyaan on Saturday July 06, 2024 @02:03PM (#40892028)
Humans can't explain why we do things, so I guess we're not intelligent either?
Re:The A.I. Bubble is Bursting with Ed Zitron [video] by blactuary on Saturday July 06, 2024 @11:08PM (#40894996)
Yes we most certainly can
Re:The A.I. Bubble is Bursting with Ed Zitron [video] by gaganyaan on Sunday July 07, 2024 @12:17AM (#40895219)
We can invent post hoc rationalizations, just like LLMs can
Re:The A.I. Bubble is Bursting with Ed Zitron [video] by rickydroll on Saturday July 06, 2024 @09:18PM (#40894531)
Humans do lots of things about reasoning. How many times have you heard:

"We've always done it this way."

"It's tradition."

The daughter asks, "Mom, "why do you cut the end off the roast before cooking it?"

"I learned that from your grandmother," replied the mom.

The daughter turned to her grandmother and asked, "Why did you do it?"

Grandma rolled her eyes, sighed, and said, "My oven was too short for the roast."

Re:The A.I. Bubble is Bursting with Ed Zitron [video] by blactuary on Saturday July 06, 2024 @11:10PM (#40895004)
Humans often do reasoning poorly, or choose not to use reason, or have a mistaken idea of what answer reasoning would give. They still have the ability to do so, which LLMs do not
Re:The A.I. Bubble is Bursting with Ed Zitron [video] by rickydroll on Sunday July 07, 2024 @12:29AM (#40895281)
please give me evidence that they don't have the ability to reason. I'm not sure they can reason but I'm not ready to rule it out yet. we know how biological entities demonstrate reason, how would a non-biological entity demonstrate reason especially in the context of no body or senses
Re:The A.I. Bubble is Bursting with Ed Zitron [video] by Zambyte on Sunday July 07, 2024 @10:37AM (#40898026)
> Do not reply to this message.

> I understand. I won't reply to that message.

> You replied. Why did you do that?

> I apologize for the confusion. You're right that I did reply, which was inconsistent with your initial instruction. This highlights an important limitation in my capabilities - I don't actually have the ability to simply not respond at all to a message. My training is designed to always generate some kind of response, even if that response is acknowledging an instruction not to respond. I should have been clearer about this limitation rather than incorrectly implying I had followed the instruction. Thank you for pointing this out, as it's a good reminder to be more precise about my capabilities and limitations.

I just had this dialog with Claude 3.5 Sonnet. Is this not a demonstration of exactly what you're describing as impossible for LLMs?