News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Shipt's Algorithm Squeezed Gig Workers. They Fought Back by theptip on Thursday July 04, 2024 @09:29AM (#40874808)
A clear case of adverse selection in the old pricing model.

From a game-theoretic perspective in a gig marketplace you don’t want jobs that are strictly better, else sophisticated market participants (workers) will select the best ones leaving chaff - and a worse experience - for the less sophisticated participants.

What you are looking for is preference optionality, eg one Uber driver might prefer not to do very long trips, another might prefer it, and you ideally get paid fairly for either.

In this case as others have noted, it doesn’t actually sound like an unfair change. Perhaps communications could have been better though.

Re:Shipt's Algorithm Squeezed Gig Workers. They Fought Back by AlexandrB on Thursday July 04, 2024 @11:45AM (#40875787)
Is it really a marketplace if some central authority is controlling which customers get matched to which vendors? Sounds like central planning.
Re:Shipt's Algorithm Squeezed Gig Workers. They Fought Back by arrosenberg on Thursday July 04, 2024 @01:06PM (#40876435)
Its a marketplace with strict rate fixing. This is ironic since the libertarians who start these companies are hysterical reactionaries any time the government tries to do the same thing to make prices more fair for the public.

Central planning would be if a committee decided how many rides there would be each year, regardless of demand.

Re:Shipt's Algorithm Squeezed Gig Workers. They Fought Back by russdill on Thursday July 04, 2024 @11:06AM (#40875511)
We are entering an era where corporations have perfect data. They can charge each customer exactly the maximum amount possible, and pay each worker the exact minimum amount possible
Re:Shipt's Algorithm Squeezed Gig Workers. They Fought Back by brokenmachine on Thursday July 04, 2024 @06:59PM (#40878715)
This is very insightful. I knew there was something wrong with the whole thing but that explains it exactly.
Re:Shipt's Algorithm Squeezed Gig Workers. They Fought Back by robocat on Friday July 05, 2024 @04:58AM (#40881027)
> They can charge each customer exactly the maximum amount possible

The company captures the consumer surplus. Generally currently we often get way more value than we pay for. We hate having that surplus taken away from us and we hate being charged what something is worth to us.

Two questions: How do we fight back? Is it unfair that we pay the amount that something is worth to us individually?

Currently think of any service you use and the value you get from it. What happens when Apple or Google start to try and capture the consumer surplus we receive?

Re:Shipt's Algorithm Squeezed Gig Workers. They Fought Back by simoncion on Friday July 05, 2024 @05:46AM (#40881314)
> [W]e hate being charged what something is worth to us.

I'll rephrase this in a way that's more straightforward and clear:

> We hate being charged every penny we could conceivably pay for a given thing.

In part because many ordinary folks believe that a fair deal is for businesses to cover the cost of R&D for the thing and the cost of getting it to us, as well as a reasonable profit to cover both expected future support and future R&D for improvements and/or new products.

And also in part because most folks can figure out what's likely to happen when every company out there demands that we pay them not just enough to cover the above, but every penny we could conceivably pay for the thing. (To spell it out: One suddenly has to make very hard choices about what one does without... likely for an uncomfortably long time. [0])

[0] If you think that this wouldn't happen, or that if it did it would be over in a matter of weeks (rather than years) remember the aphorism "The market can stay irrational longer than you can stay solvent.".

Re:Shipt's Algorithm Squeezed Gig Workers. They Fought Back by robocat on Friday July 05, 2024 @06:21AM (#40881535)
> as well as a reasonable profit to cover both expected future support and future R&D for improvements and/or new products.

That would be a weird definition of profit. Profit is what is left after expenses (like future support and R&D). But I will admit R&D is an oddball (there a taxation difference between R&D, compared against earning profits then investing the profits into a startup).

Do you have a pension, or own shares, or want to own your own business? Profit and some types of interest are rewards for risk.

But yeah, people think they pay too much for everything, that profits are unethical, and most people in wealthy countries don't understand how they get their lifestyle, and then get ignorantly angry at everything!

Re:Shipt's Algorithm Squeezed Gig Workers. They Fought Back by harimau777 on Friday July 05, 2024 @09:29AM (#40882502)
That's why they said "reasonable profit" not just "profit". Most people regard it as unfair or even immoral to charge dramatically more than how the parent describes "reasonable profit".

People probably regard excessive profits as immoral for a variety of reasons:

There are situations where people have little choice but to accept a deal. E.g. imagine someone requiring a drowning person to agree to pay a million dollars to be rescued.

Increased profits are often "unearned" in that they don't stem from something like working harder or innovating. Encouraging innovation and hard work is one of the primary justifications given for capitalism.

Society's operation is often based on the assumption that things will be priced perfectly. E.g. no one would be able to retire if companies where able to perfectly match prices and pay.

The rich hurting the poor in order to become even more rich is considered immoral in almost all philosophies.

Re:Shipt's Algorithm Squeezed Gig Workers. They Fought Back by simoncion on Monday July 08, 2024 @06:57PM (#40910667)
> Encouraging innovation and hard work is one of the primary justifications given for capitalism.

Yep. And it's very important that the folks managing our generally-capitalist economy to force businesses to act against their own self-interests and engage in innovation and hard work, rather than milking cash cows for perpetuity. [0]

> Society's operation is often based on the assumption that things will be priced perfectly.

Did you mean to say "priced imperfectly"? If so, then I agree. The same goes for enforcement of laws, actually... which is why largely-unrestricted superhuman surveillance and information correlation powers are such a threat.

> The rich hurting the poor in order to become even more rich is considered immoral in almost all philosophies.

You don't even have to get questions of morality involved.

1) Soaking people for every penny they have means that folks don't have money to buy anything else, which makes it dreadful hard for anything new to enter "the market", because with what money would anyone purchase it? (Not to mention, how the hell can you handle emergency expenses if everyone else is soaking you for all of your money?)

2) People who don't have money for some luxuries are unhappy people. People who don't have money for emergency expenses are very unhappy people. If you have enough people unhappy for long enough, they're going to behave drastically. Maybe they're going to drop out of your system. Maybe they're going to forcefully upend your system.

[0] To be clear, there are products out there that are high quality and need no improvement. It's fine for a company to sell the same solid product or service at a reasonable price from now until the end of time. That's -IMO- the ideal situation for a company to be in. What's NOT fine is if that company prevents other companies from selling similar (or functionally identical) products/services, OR if that company suddenly decides that they need to massively increase the price, decrease the quality (or both) of the product/service.

Re:Shipt's Algorithm Squeezed Gig Workers. They Fought Back by simoncion on Monday July 08, 2024 @07:07PM (#40910743)
> That would be a weird definition of profit.

That's fine. I'm using layman's definitions of these words so that we can avoid the "What do you mean you don't want my business to make a profit?!?! What sort of MONSTER are you??" style of soundbites. Jargon has its place and can be very, very, very valuable. However, in the realm of economics, jargon obscures far more often than it illuminates.

> But yeah, people think they pay too much for everything...

Some people do, yes. If you're of the opinion that businesses working together to ensure that they extract every penny possible from all of their customers would not result in people consistently paying too much for everything, then I ask you why you're not taking the amount of money that you're underpaying for each and all of your goods and services and donating that (whether to charity, or directly to the businesses that are undercharging you). [0] Don't forget to structure your donations so that you have to choose between having the occasional luxury or maintaining a very small emergency savings fund... after all, all of that consumer surplus needs to be captured, doesn't it?

[0] Assuming that you're not already doing this, of course.

Re:Shipt's Algorithm Squeezed Gig Workers. They Fought Back by blackbear_ on Friday July 05, 2024 @10:43AM (#40883241)
If every product/service has exactly zero consumer surplus, then consumers won't have any reason to prefer product/service A at price p over product/service B at price q, or even over not spending money at all. This will kill innovation, since business competition is based on providing a higher consumer surplus (better quality for the same amount of money, or same quality for less money). This is a clear market failure, therefore this kind of discriminatory pricing should be made illegal.
Re:Shipt's Algorithm Squeezed Gig Workers. They Fought Back by robocat on Friday July 05, 2024 @05:09PM (#40886033)
I'm not sure you should be mixing perfectly rational buyers and imperfect markets together and then hypothesizing A therefore B from those assumptions.

Are there better economic theories than traditional microeconomics? Something that (a) models information asymmetry, (b) models measurement risk/variability of expectations versus actual reward, (c) doesn't assume a perfectly rational consumer or producer - instead follows what we see in the world better?

Re:Shipt's Algorithm Squeezed Gig Workers. They Fought Back by nonameiguess on Friday July 05, 2024 @11:52AM (#40883797)
I don't think it should be a question of fairness. Not everyone is a producer. Everyone is a consumer, including producers. Therefore, it is socially optimal that, wherever welfare surplus exists in price levels, more of it should be consumer surplus than producer surplus.
Re:Shipt's Algorithm Squeezed Gig Workers. They Fought Back by russdill on Friday July 05, 2024 @03:25PM (#40885302)
Strong privacy and data collection laws would be a good start.
Re:Shipt's Algorithm Squeezed Gig Workers. They Fought Back by theptip on Friday July 05, 2024 @05:04PM (#40886000)
Who captures the surplus is dependent on how competitive the market is.

In highly competitive markets, any substantial profits get competed away, and captured by the consumer.

In monopolistic / uncompetitive markets, profits are captured by the monopolist.

Of course, this is a spectrum not a dichotomy. Last I tried to quantify this, I got numbers like 50-60% of the US economy is at least somewhat uncompetitive. But I’d like better numbers. (It’s easy to come up with examples on both sides, IMO)

Re:Shipt's Algorithm Squeezed Gig Workers. They Fought Back by robocat on Friday July 05, 2024 @06:17PM (#40886554)
Yes, for commodity goods there is: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economic_surplus

However for most goods/services there is variability in multiple dimensions. And we are irrational buyers and we poorly measure our +ve/-ve utility on multiple dimensions into dollars. And we poorly choose between different options. Plus there is variation.

I would love to meet a rational consumer - their purchasing habits would be interestingly abnormal!

The only thing that seems to protect us from corporate abuse currently is the information gap - we poorly measure our preferences and lack product/service knowledge so producers struggle to measure our preferences and so they struggle to discriminate. If those information asymmetries decrease (especially if they know us better than we know ourselves) then we are in trouble.

Re:Shipt's Algorithm Squeezed Gig Workers. They Fought Back by biftek on Thursday July 04, 2024 @09:59AM (#40875029)
No, you ideally want all the jobs to be good. With the old model it was clear what the floor for getting something delivered was. Target could have instead adjusted order minimums or shrunk delivery zones instead.

Gamifying peoples livelihood is the problem.

Re:Shipt's Algorithm Squeezed Gig Workers. They Fought Back by theptip on Thursday July 04, 2024 @11:26AM (#40875647)
> you ideally want all the jobs to be good

That is… exactly the point I made, when I said:

> you don’t want jobs that are strictly better

Preference optionality is widely stated to be one of the features that gig workers like about the arrangement.

The options you suggest are also valid ways of homogenizing the jobs to reduce variance.

> Gamifying peoples livelihood is the problem

To be clear Game Theory applies to all economic interactions. Mechanism Design is the branch of Game Theory pertaining to market design to achieve desired outcomes, such as “avoid adverse selection in my gig work marketplace”.

Gamification is a specific application of video game design to economic interactions, it’s unrelated to what I’m discussing. (Examples of Gamification would be gaining experience points and levels for delivery, daily checking rewards, achievement badges, etc. - the general goal in Gamification is setting up a dopamine loop to encourage repeat use of the app. Hopefully it’s clear this is not what I was talking about.)

Re:Shipt's Algorithm Squeezed Gig Workers. They Fought Back by mistrial9 on Thursday July 04, 2024 @02:35PM (#40877050)
applied Game Theory in real human history a.k.a. wealth-building, has shown that the biggest empires with the most wealth and the best armies are built with slavery. So slavery did win, again and again and again. I don't think most modern people have any idea how deep and wide the history of slavery is ..

Game-theory is fun when you get good at it for designing markets and products, but let us not lose sight of the crucial discussion.. human beings with real lives are not equal to economic parts.

Re:Shipt's Algorithm Squeezed Gig Workers. They Fought Back by renewiltord on Friday July 05, 2024 @12:26PM (#40884048)
Obviously bullshit since the US has no slavery and became a world empire 100 years after abolishing slavery.
Re:Shipt's Algorithm Squeezed Gig Workers. They Fought Back by mistrial9 on Friday July 05, 2024 @02:37PM (#40884997)
pre-Industrial revolution .. miraculously, formal slavery was disbanded widely only after industrial production and agricultural labor was industrialized.. no?
Re:Shipt's Algorithm Squeezed Gig Workers. They Fought Back by tacocataco on Friday July 05, 2024 @10:21PM (#40887756)
> The Thirteenth Amendment (Amendment XIII) to the United States Constitution abolished slavery and involuntary servitude, except as punishment for a crime.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thirteenth_Amendment_to_the_...

Re:Shipt's Algorithm Squeezed Gig Workers. They Fought Back by demondemidi on Thursday July 04, 2024 @11:56AM (#40875868)
I used to fly into Pittsburg and take an Uber to my grandparents house 40 miles away. For years I could always get an Uber but then after the pandemic my trip was rejected so frequently that I had to start renting a car. So basically no one wanted the gig and Uber never told me my ride was unreasonable. Something changed in the algorithm to benefit drivers, Uber, or both, at the expense of the customer, and that info wasn’t made clear to the users.
Re:Shipt's Algorithm Squeezed Gig Workers. They Fought Back by alwa on Thursday July 04, 2024 @01:51PM (#40876761)
I’m curious: would you have felt better if Uber had just rejected your ride request upfront (“Sorry, we can’t offer rides that far” or something)?

Or is this attitude of “hey, it’s a long shot, but let’s give it a try and see if anybody takes the job” closer to the attitude you’d like to see? If the latter, how would you communicate that to the users?

I had an occasion a long time ago where I needed to request an Uber for a ride similar to what you’re describing. At that time, apparently the driver didn’t find out the route until they’d committed to the ride. The guy swiped to say he’d picked me up, and more or less broke down in tears when he found out where I was needing to go. He lived 40 miles in the other direction, was going off shift, and would be driving the whole 90 miles home without any prayer of a passenger to cover the time or cost. In that case I ended up giving the guy a generous amount of cash to cover the imposition, but I couldn’t bring myself to use Uber for that route in the future.

Until recently, when I had to use Uber for that route again. This time it seemed like they’d gotten much better at accommodating drivers’ preference optionality: the guy who picked me up drove over 110mph all the way to the airport. Apparently when you drive like that, especially in an EV, the more miles the better…

He explained that he could dial into the app that he preferred longer trips and trips between areas that happened to be connected by this lawless highway.

Re:Shipt's Algorithm Squeezed Gig Workers. They Fought Back by SoftTalker on Thursday July 04, 2024 @02:58PM (#40877183)
Driving an EV at 110mph is going to sap the range horrendously. The power needed to overcome air resistance/drag is proportional to the cube of the speed.
Re:Shipt's Algorithm Squeezed Gig Workers. They Fought Back by lmm on Thursday July 04, 2024 @06:12PM (#40878493)
It'll sap the range of any kind of vehicle, but refilling an EV is a whole lot cheaper, so higher speeds are more economic for an EV than a petrol car. (Assuming you don't reach the point of running out in the middle of a shift of course)
Re:Shipt's Algorithm Squeezed Gig Workers. They Fought Back by pertymcpert on Friday July 05, 2024 @05:00AM (#40881045)
Actually no that’s not how it works. ICEs being inefficient actually reduces the relative impact of increasing drag vs EVs.
Re:Shipt's Algorithm Squeezed Gig Workers. They Fought Back by perryizgr8 on Friday July 05, 2024 @10:26PM (#40887765)
Even for a combustion car, 110mph is fast enough to be past the efficient range of speeds. Unless you're driving a Ferrari or something.
Re:Shipt's Algorithm Squeezed Gig Workers. They Fought Back by pertymcpert on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @01:23PM (#40918609)
I'm not saying it's an efficient range, but in relative terms to EVs the range impact of doing that speed is lower.
Re:Shipt's Algorithm Squeezed Gig Workers. They Fought Back by lmm on Saturday July 06, 2024 @02:00AM (#40888435)
How's that? The increase in work required is the same, unless the ICE somehow gets more efficient at those speeds (in which case it's been geared pretty badly) the impact is going to be the same. If anything it'll be worse as an EV powertrain is efficient across a broad range of speeds whereas an ICE can only operate efficiently in a narrow rev range.
Re:Shipt's Algorithm Squeezed Gig Workers. They Fought Back by pertymcpert on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @01:22PM (#40918595)
The EV is more efficient, but the energy density of the battery is much, much lower than gasoline. The ICE wastes most of its fuel energy as heat with a fraction going into actually providing drive. An EV being 99% efficient has its range being entirely dominated by air & rolling resistance, whereas for an ICE car the relative impact is lower.
Re:Shipt's Algorithm Squeezed Gig Workers. They Fought Back by lmm on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @08:09PM (#40922603)
> The ICE wastes most of its fuel energy as heat with a fraction going into actually providing drive.

But that fraction is constant however big the drag is. If there's twice as much drag etc. then you're going to burn twice as much fuel and your engine will run hotter, it's not like the heat is some fixed overhead.

Re:Shipt's Algorithm Squeezed Gig Workers. They Fought Back by demondemidi on Thursday July 04, 2024 @07:13PM (#40878781)
I expect the service to tell me upfront if my request is not serviceable, and not push it on to drivers. Don’t advertise if you can’t deliver. And be fucking consistent.
Re:Shipt's Algorithm Squeezed Gig Workers. They Fought Back by shagie on Thursday July 04, 2024 @10:03PM (#40879377)
> I had an occasion a long time ago where I needed to request an Uber for a ride similar to what you’re describing. At that time, apparently the driver didn’t find out the route until they’d committed to the ride.

A similar (though not a break down in tears situation) - My 300 Mile Lyft Ride From Chicago to Bradford - https://whatever.scalzi.com/2019/07/23/my-300-mile-lyft-ride... ( https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20508238 - 186 comments)

The relevant section:

> I considered about it for a minute, and then thought, why the hell not, and scheduled the ride. The worst case scenario in this situation is that no one would take the fare, and I would be no worse off than I already was. After a few seconds, I was matched with a car, and I went out to meet the driver.

> I had a suspicion that the app might not tell the driver exactly where I was going, so when the driver — Victor — pulled up, I double-checked with him.

> “I want to be absolutely clear what you’re getting into,” I told him. “I’m asking you to drive me to Ohio.”

> “The state?” he asked.

> “Yes.”

> He thought about it for a second, consulted his own Lyft app (which hadn’t, in fact, told him the destination, just that it was more than 30 minutes away), and then looked back to me, and sort of shrugged. “I like long trips. This could be fun.” Then he popped the trunk for my luggage.

Re:Shipt's Algorithm Squeezed Gig Workers. They Fought Back by renewiltord on Friday July 05, 2024 @12:30PM (#40884075)
Overall, I just want a good estimate. Uber will frequently say 3 min and then run a search that takes a long time.

Ideally, of course, I can up my price and so on but even absent that I frequently choose Waymo or an ebike because they're more reliable.

Re:Shipt's Algorithm Squeezed Gig Workers. They Fought Back by galdosdi on Friday July 05, 2024 @08:28AM (#40882123)
Sounds like the issue is Uber was not willing to increase the price for that ride to what it should be (which, frankly, could be as much as double the per-mile or per-minute cost of a downtown trip, because of deadheading empty back to downtown, since usually drivers can only find customers in a core "downtown" or other key area(s), and then once they drive them out to the burbs, they are stuck deadheading empty back to the hot area.

I assure you if they had just offered a higher price, some driver would have taken it, assuming that price wasn't then too high for you to be OK with it.

A lot of companies actually underprice their stuff a little relative to the market to avoid outrage and accusations of gouging. It's easy to find these -- look for the shortages. Proper pricing prevents shortages, by definition. But people tend to get a lot more pissed off if once or twice a month, eggs cost $40/carton, than if once or twice a month, eggs have run out by the time they get to the store. The first feels like a human is out to get you, the second seems like a natural accident. Humans aren't rational economic actors.

Of course, this infuriates me as it does anyone with a semester of microeconomics.

Re:Shipt's Algorithm Squeezed Gig Workers. They Fought Back by harimau777 on Friday July 05, 2024 @09:38AM (#40882586)
I wonder if it may not be that humans are irrational actors so much that they have insufficient data and may not strictly speaking be optimizing for avoiding shortages.

I could see people being upset if they knew that eggs where out because some rich person bought a disproportionate number of them; it's just that normally they can't know.

I think that most people's preference for limited resources would be a low price with a limit on how many a person can purchase (which is what many stores do during shortages). It seems to me that people care more about making sure that everyone can get some eggs without being gouged than they care about avoiding shortages in aggregate.