News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Shipt's Algorithm Squeezed Gig Workers. They Fought Back by alwa on Thursday July 04, 2024 @01:51PM (#40876761)
I’m curious: would you have felt better if Uber had just rejected your ride request upfront (“Sorry, we can’t offer rides that far” or something)?

Or is this attitude of “hey, it’s a long shot, but let’s give it a try and see if anybody takes the job” closer to the attitude you’d like to see? If the latter, how would you communicate that to the users?

I had an occasion a long time ago where I needed to request an Uber for a ride similar to what you’re describing. At that time, apparently the driver didn’t find out the route until they’d committed to the ride. The guy swiped to say he’d picked me up, and more or less broke down in tears when he found out where I was needing to go. He lived 40 miles in the other direction, was going off shift, and would be driving the whole 90 miles home without any prayer of a passenger to cover the time or cost. In that case I ended up giving the guy a generous amount of cash to cover the imposition, but I couldn’t bring myself to use Uber for that route in the future.

Until recently, when I had to use Uber for that route again. This time it seemed like they’d gotten much better at accommodating drivers’ preference optionality: the guy who picked me up drove over 110mph all the way to the airport. Apparently when you drive like that, especially in an EV, the more miles the better…

He explained that he could dial into the app that he preferred longer trips and trips between areas that happened to be connected by this lawless highway.

Re:Shipt's Algorithm Squeezed Gig Workers. They Fought Back by SoftTalker on Thursday July 04, 2024 @02:58PM (#40877183)
Driving an EV at 110mph is going to sap the range horrendously. The power needed to overcome air resistance/drag is proportional to the cube of the speed.
Re:Shipt's Algorithm Squeezed Gig Workers. They Fought Back by lmm on Thursday July 04, 2024 @06:12PM (#40878493)
It'll sap the range of any kind of vehicle, but refilling an EV is a whole lot cheaper, so higher speeds are more economic for an EV than a petrol car. (Assuming you don't reach the point of running out in the middle of a shift of course)
Re:Shipt's Algorithm Squeezed Gig Workers. They Fought Back by pertymcpert on Friday July 05, 2024 @05:00AM (#40881045)
Actually no that’s not how it works. ICEs being inefficient actually reduces the relative impact of increasing drag vs EVs.
Re:Shipt's Algorithm Squeezed Gig Workers. They Fought Back by perryizgr8 on Friday July 05, 2024 @10:26PM (#40887765)
Even for a combustion car, 110mph is fast enough to be past the efficient range of speeds. Unless you're driving a Ferrari or something.
Re:Shipt's Algorithm Squeezed Gig Workers. They Fought Back by pertymcpert on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @01:23PM (#40918609)
I'm not saying it's an efficient range, but in relative terms to EVs the range impact of doing that speed is lower.
Re:Shipt's Algorithm Squeezed Gig Workers. They Fought Back by lmm on Saturday July 06, 2024 @02:00AM (#40888435)
How's that? The increase in work required is the same, unless the ICE somehow gets more efficient at those speeds (in which case it's been geared pretty badly) the impact is going to be the same. If anything it'll be worse as an EV powertrain is efficient across a broad range of speeds whereas an ICE can only operate efficiently in a narrow rev range.
Re:Shipt's Algorithm Squeezed Gig Workers. They Fought Back by pertymcpert on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @01:22PM (#40918595)
The EV is more efficient, but the energy density of the battery is much, much lower than gasoline. The ICE wastes most of its fuel energy as heat with a fraction going into actually providing drive. An EV being 99% efficient has its range being entirely dominated by air & rolling resistance, whereas for an ICE car the relative impact is lower.
Re:Shipt's Algorithm Squeezed Gig Workers. They Fought Back by lmm on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @08:09PM (#40922603)
> The ICE wastes most of its fuel energy as heat with a fraction going into actually providing drive.

But that fraction is constant however big the drag is. If there's twice as much drag etc. then you're going to burn twice as much fuel and your engine will run hotter, it's not like the heat is some fixed overhead.

Re:Shipt's Algorithm Squeezed Gig Workers. They Fought Back by demondemidi on Thursday July 04, 2024 @07:13PM (#40878781)
I expect the service to tell me upfront if my request is not serviceable, and not push it on to drivers. Don’t advertise if you can’t deliver. And be fucking consistent.
Re:Shipt's Algorithm Squeezed Gig Workers. They Fought Back by shagie on Thursday July 04, 2024 @10:03PM (#40879377)
> I had an occasion a long time ago where I needed to request an Uber for a ride similar to what you’re describing. At that time, apparently the driver didn’t find out the route until they’d committed to the ride.

A similar (though not a break down in tears situation) - My 300 Mile Lyft Ride From Chicago to Bradford - https://whatever.scalzi.com/2019/07/23/my-300-mile-lyft-ride... ( https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20508238 - 186 comments)

The relevant section:

> I considered about it for a minute, and then thought, why the hell not, and scheduled the ride. The worst case scenario in this situation is that no one would take the fare, and I would be no worse off than I already was. After a few seconds, I was matched with a car, and I went out to meet the driver.

> I had a suspicion that the app might not tell the driver exactly where I was going, so when the driver — Victor — pulled up, I double-checked with him.

> “I want to be absolutely clear what you’re getting into,” I told him. “I’m asking you to drive me to Ohio.”

> “The state?” he asked.

> “Yes.”

> He thought about it for a second, consulted his own Lyft app (which hadn’t, in fact, told him the destination, just that it was more than 30 minutes away), and then looked back to me, and sort of shrugged. “I like long trips. This could be fun.” Then he popped the trunk for my luggage.

Re:Shipt's Algorithm Squeezed Gig Workers. They Fought Back by renewiltord on Friday July 05, 2024 @12:30PM (#40884075)
Overall, I just want a good estimate. Uber will frequently say 3 min and then run a search that takes a long time.

Ideally, of course, I can up my price and so on but even absent that I frequently choose Waymo or an ebike because they're more reliable.