News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How to waste bandwidth, battery power, and annoy sysadmins by Aardwolf on Saturday June 29, 2024 @06:02AM (#40829087)
I thought firefox on ios was just safari with a reskin because apple doesn't allow other browser engines on their phone?

Firefox on android is amazing with its plugin support, though I still prefer their pre-2021 UI

Re:How to waste bandwidth, battery power, and annoy sysadmins by loufe on Saturday June 29, 2024 @07:00AM (#40829380)
Given the seriously negative sibling comments, I thought I'd weigh in with my own experience. I'm unaware of anything behind the scenes, but I've always enjoyed the user experience in Firefox on Android, at least for the last couple years before the rewrite. I don't like browsing the web on my phone, but it's made it bearable.

I can't speak to the problems behind the scenes though, and they certainly merit attention.

Re:How to waste bandwidth, battery power, and annoy sysadmins by smolder on Saturday June 29, 2024 @06:15AM (#40829139)
Firefox on Android is NOT amazing. For MANY YEARS the user agent included the exact model of your phone. They seem to be incompetent. (Edit: this is a bit harsh, and to clarify, directed at the company and not any specific people in their employ.) Exactly what Google wants -- plausible deniability when it comes to monopoly, but an awful alternative.
Re:How to waste bandwidth, battery power, and annoy sysadmins by bu7jjuj on Saturday June 29, 2024 @06:42AM (#40829263)
Firefox on android can run ublock origin.

The internet is unusable on mobile otherwise. But go on and let google continue to 'wow'you with their amazing ad tech.

Firefox on android IS AMAZING.

Re:How to waste bandwidth, battery power, and annoy sysadmins by maeil on Saturday June 29, 2024 @07:41AM (#40829636)
There's Brave on Android fwiw.
Re:How to waste bandwidth, battery power, and annoy sysadmins by theshrike79 on Saturday June 29, 2024 @08:12AM (#40829842)
Brave is still just a fancy Chromium reskin, I'll use any other engine than Chrome if it's even remotely possible
Re:How to waste bandwidth, battery power, and annoy sysadmins by bigstrat2003 on Saturday June 29, 2024 @10:40AM (#40830949)
That's fine, but that is moving the goalposts. GP said that Firefox is so good on Android because it's important to have ad blocking, and Brave meets that need just fine.
Re:How to waste bandwidth, battery power, and annoy sysadmins by EasyMark on Saturday June 29, 2024 @08:06PM (#40834214)
I think the main thing is the point is the adblocker is in there. And as another poster pointed out, they do use the webkit engine, but they can do lots of things besides that to improve the browser from “reskinned safari” like lots of people seem to be claiming.
Re:How to waste bandwidth, battery power, and annoy sysadmins by staplers on Saturday June 29, 2024 @10:54AM (#40831049)
Brave has similar anti-privacy/adtech built in

They even market it: https://brave.com/brave-ads/

Re:How to waste bandwidth, battery power, and annoy sysadmins by maeil on Sunday June 30, 2024 @02:16AM (#40835436)
..on their search, not the browser. That's like saying Safari has "anti-privacy/adtech builtin" because Google is their default search engine. You just switch to a search engine of your liking.
Re:How to waste bandwidth, battery power, and annoy sysadmins by sunaookami on Saturday June 29, 2024 @06:53AM (#40829325)
No it's not. It's slow and buggy. You can also use an adblocking DNS like AdGuard and have adblocking system-wide. Yes I know uBlock blocks a bit better but DNS-blocking suffices. Also, there are other browsers with integrated adblockers based on Chromium.
Re:How to waste bandwidth, battery power, and annoy sysadmins by viraptor on Saturday June 29, 2024 @07:28AM (#40829558)
It's not "a bit" better. uBlock can tell a difference between seeing an ad from network X and going to the website of network X. It can block ads hosted by the owner. It can allow you to click a tracking link from an email while still blocking ads on the target website. Finally you can unblock something as a one-off without disabling the system for the whole device/network. The quality difference is huge.
Re:How to waste bandwidth, battery power, and annoy sysadmins by erinaceousjones on Saturday June 29, 2024 @07:05AM (#40829405)
Not ever had Firefox for android be slow and buggy for myself! I've been using it in place of chrome on my phone for a good year. Honestly everyone keeps talking about how FF is "slow and buggy" and it has NEVER given me issue :/ why is my subjective experience so different to your subjective experience?

Meanwhile chrome/chromium is the one which is most likely to cause me GPU driver crashes, but that's because I use it for fun VR and "let's see how big I can make textures" experiments. Generally it manages a higher frame rate than FF in that context with stability as tradeoff.

Re:How to waste bandwidth, battery power, and annoy sysadmins by pohuing on Saturday June 29, 2024 @07:15AM (#40829474)
There could just be a difference in hardware. I'm a Firefox user but there is a noticeable difference, just not one that matters much on a top tier soc
Re:How to waste bandwidth, battery power, and annoy sysadmins by jakub_g on Saturday June 29, 2024 @07:25AM (#40829541)
Loading JS heavy pages like Twitter on Firefox Android is way slower than Chromium based. Very noticeable on 2019 hardware, less so but still on 2022 hardware.
Re:How to waste bandwidth, battery power, and annoy sysadmins by onli on Saturday June 29, 2024 @08:16AM (#40829874)
That hasn't been my experience at all. It was Firefox that made web browsing bearable again on my old android device.
Re:How to waste bandwidth, battery power, and annoy sysadmins by erinaceousjones on Saturday June 29, 2024 @07:33AM (#40829580)
Ah, fair point. I'm on a pixel 6, so I have a privileged perspective that like 90% of smartphone browser users don't have because fairly new and fast SoC with a good amount of memory. I hadn't considered how much a difference that makes, because conceptually in my head "it's just webpages!" like we're still in the early 2000's
Re:How to waste bandwidth, battery power, and annoy sysadmins by carlob on Saturday June 29, 2024 @08:36AM (#40830012)
Honestly Twitter has become a downright hostile browsing experience on any browser and any hardware. It's probably on purpose to make you use the app.
Re:How to waste bandwidth, battery power, and annoy sysadmins by cduzz on Saturday June 29, 2024 @11:18AM (#40831186)
What's the user visible tradeoff between "an average page is so laden with advertising and tracking nonsense that it loads slowly and is covered with crap, but that crap all renders real fast" vs "JS renders at 1/10th the speed but only the stuff you want to look at?"
Re:How to waste bandwidth, battery power, and annoy sysadmins by sierisimo on Saturday June 29, 2024 @01:24PM (#40832118)
But is completely Firefox fault? Some companies just test compatibility and optimize with Chrome in mind, forgetting that sometimes some browsers (Firefox as well) dont respect some standards. Or even adding some features only available in some browsers.

Yes, is not as bad as it was in the 90s or 2000s, but is still a common issue

Re:How to waste bandwidth, battery power, and annoy sysadmins by thequux on Saturday June 29, 2024 @08:19AM (#40829895)
I use Firefox on a ~2020 era Android, and not even a particularly great one at that. Works fine for me aside from a very few badly written sites, and certainly not any shower than chrome.
Re:How to waste bandwidth, battery power, and annoy sysadmins by technofiend on Saturday June 29, 2024 @07:43AM (#40829648)
ublock makes sites like imgur usable. it's trivial to add a nice rule that deletes all those login via social media buttons just as one example of what the hosts file can't do.
Re:How to waste bandwidth, battery power, and annoy sysadmins by mattmanser on Saturday June 29, 2024 @07:27AM (#40829554)
You've been downvoted but I would like to echo this comment.

I use Firefox mobile daily, I occasionally have to switch to Chrome for some things. I choose to continue using Firefox Android because of the ability for greater privacy.

Firefox android is slow and buggy.

It is especially terrible if you are not in the habit of closing open tabs and just open new ones. As a concrete example, it often seems to run out of memory, causing issues such as Reddit not being able to load videos. They tried to fix this by more aggressively moving older tabs to an 'inactive' tab area, but it didn't work.

It at least feels badly written, saying that as an experienced developer myself. However, I know browsers are one of the hardest things to make, so perhaps it is just averagely written. But it is nowhere near Chrome's level of competence.

The new UI is awful too, I still hate a lot of design decisions and feel it was a bad mis-step. The old UI was just better. Again, I emphasise I use the browser daily and I say this with plenty of time to get used to it.

Re:How to waste bandwidth, battery power, and annoy sysadmins by oldmariner on Saturday June 29, 2024 @07:36AM (#40829596)
> It is especially terrible if you are not in the habit of closing open tabs and just open new ones.

I just closed a bit over 2,000 tabs on my old phone because I was switching phones. I recall reading a couple of other comments here in HN and seeing a couple of comments in reddit of other people having thousands of tabs open.

Slow and buggy has NOT been my experience.

I use uBlock Origin addon though, maybe that's the difference? I bet resource-hogging ads could be an issue.

Edit: I also had "studies" turned off. Perhaps you were in a study that was testing something that caused those issues? (That's why I don't like default "studies" or A/B testing.). Or maybe something else (physical or software) on your phone is damaged/defective, perhaps even your installation of the Firefox app got borked?

Re:How to waste bandwidth, battery power, and annoy sysadmins by mattmanser on Sunday June 30, 2024 @07:06PM (#40841149)
No, it's happened on two different phones over the last 2+ years. And two completely different phones, Xiaomi and Pixel.

I do wonder how you know you closed 2,000? The UI displays an infinity symbol over 99 tabs. If you had so many open, most of those would have been moved to inactive. The inactive tab section doesn't have a count and has a button you can click to close all.

Makes me sort of wonder whether you are actually using it.

Re:How to waste bandwidth, battery power, and annoy sysadmins by oldmariner on Thursday July 04, 2024 @09:24AM (#40874764)
There's an option to turn off the inactive tabs feature.

Trying to "share" all of them will crash Firefox, so I manually select 100 and share those, then close those, repeat 20 times (which is how I know how many tabs I had open).

Re:How to waste bandwidth, battery power, and annoy sysadmins by sunaookami on Saturday June 29, 2024 @11:13AM (#40831153)
It's just par for the course for Firefox users to deny any problems with the browser and blame it all on Google. Not to mention the history revisionism on why Chrome beat Firefox. I was a huge Firefox fan with a heavily customized browser and then Mozilla removed everything. The biggest enemy of Firefox is not Google, it's Mozilla and their incompetent leadership. They need to focus on their Android browser ans invest heavily because that's where the biggest user base is. I don't want them to abandon Gecko, but it's clear that Mozilla can't keep up.
Re:How to waste bandwidth, battery power, and annoy sysadmins by SoftTalker on Saturday June 29, 2024 @11:35AM (#40831299)
Absolutely. I was an Android user for years and got an iPhone as a gift in 2022. On Android, I used Firefox with uBlock Origin. Mobile web browsing is not the best experience regardless, but that made it tolerable.

The worst thing about the iPhone is the web browsing experience in Safari. It's awful. The ads totally ruin it. The rest of the phone is fine, I still prefer Android but that's most likely just because it's what I started with.

Re:How to waste bandwidth, battery power, and annoy sysadmins by PlunderBunny on Saturday June 29, 2024 @05:28PM (#40833436)
There are adblockers for iOS - I’m using 1Blocker with Safari. Genuine question: Are the iOS adblockers limited in some way that make them inferior compared to what you were using with your Android phone?
Re:How to waste bandwidth, battery power, and annoy sysadmins by SoftTalker on Saturday June 29, 2024 @08:08PM (#40834219)
The only adblocker I have used is uBlock. I don't really know how adblockers work for Safari, it doesn't seem obvious. I don't like installing apps, and it seems that they are mostly apps?
Re:How to waste bandwidth, battery power, and annoy sysadmins by PlunderBunny on Monday July 01, 2024 @07:16PM (#40851861)
Yes - from the user's point of view, they are apps - you have to download them from the app store.
Re:How to waste bandwidth, battery power, and annoy sysadmins by EasyMark on Saturday June 29, 2024 @08:04PM (#40834205)
I use ad guard, vinegar and wipr on iPhone safari and browsing is fine
Re:How to waste bandwidth, battery power, and annoy sysadmins by phartenfeller on Saturday June 29, 2024 @06:27AM (#40829201)
Nope, for me it includes the Android version but no device model information.
Re:How to waste bandwidth, battery power, and annoy sysadmins by smolder on Saturday June 29, 2024 @06:28AM (#40829205)
They fixed it after the issue was present for MANY YEARS, exactly as stated.
Re:How to waste bandwidth, battery power, and annoy sysadmins by cuu508 on Saturday June 29, 2024 @07:25AM (#40829540)
OK, so it was NOT amazing for MANY YEARS, but now it is ;-)
Re:How to waste bandwidth, battery power, and annoy sysadmins by Aachen on Saturday June 29, 2024 @06:42AM (#40829264)
The other day I found out my mobile user agent string also included the kernel build version. Way to see which, if any, exploit would be effective for the device's patch level. Thankfully it has a spoof option so I now use that to send a correct, but slightly stripped, UA string

I keep thinking I should switch to Firefox but the current ux is just so comfortable

Re:How to waste bandwidth, battery power, and annoy sysadmins by vorticalbox on Saturday June 29, 2024 @06:51AM (#40829309)
There is also this issue

To address this, we will measure Telemetry Coverage, which is the percentage of all Firefox users who report telemetry. The Telemetry Coverage measurement will sample a portion of all Firefox clients and report whether telemetry is enabled. This measurement will not include a client identifier and will not be associated with our standard telemetry.

Even if you turn telemetry off it will still call home

https://blog.mozilla.org/data/2018/08/20/effectively-measuri...

Re:How to waste bandwidth, battery power, and annoy sysadmins by Ylpertnodi on Saturday June 29, 2024 @08:28AM (#40829953)
>...directed at the company and not any specific people in their employ.

They are the same thing, until you get to the upper levels, that own the place ie 'take full responsibility'. We are fa-mily. Until the shit hits the fan.

Re:How to waste bandwidth, battery power, and annoy sysadmins by tgv on Saturday June 29, 2024 @06:43AM (#40829268)
> I thought firefox on ios was just safari with a reskin

It is. It does avoid some of the tracking/ad content, so I guess it does do some things somewhat differently. But if it's such a scourge, add a favicon.

BTW, I've never seen this, and I regularly use Firefox on iOS to test.

Re:How to waste bandwidth, battery power, and annoy sysadmins by chithanh on Saturday June 29, 2024 @06:51AM (#40829307)
Firefox on Android is not amazing, it is on the contrary quite annoying and has gotten more so over the years

* Tabs get stuck frequently, and can only be revived by closing, then undoing close.

* Can no longer access about:config in release builds

* Bookmarks got demoted in favor of Pocket, can no longer set bookmarks as default home page

* URL autocompletion got dumbed down, first on mobile and then also on desktop

* etc.

Re:How to waste bandwidth, battery power, and annoy sysadmins by erinaceousjones on Saturday June 29, 2024 @07:16AM (#40829480)
My experience with Firefox Nightly for ~1 year below. Ironically, the nightly sounds more consistently stable than the current release build then!:

* Never had this tabs problem

* I can see about:config

* Bookmarks are fine and there's no mention of Pocket. Bookmarks show up ON the homepage, but yeah not being able to set a bookmark / any URL AS a homepage is a bit of an annoying feature lack

* URL completion works as I expect it to, although it does bug me how it strips the protocol from the URL so I have to manually type in `http://` for plaintext sites even when I've visited them before; depending on who you ask that is considered a "security feature" but kinda annoying. Other than that, I start typing in a URL and it shows me suggestions from my history followed by option to use my preferred search engine to search it.

All in all, I've not really felt FF (even nightly) be particularly different or unstable to using chrome.

Second comment I've made in this thread where I'm replying (ever so helpfully) "Huh, but it works for me" so I'll stop now :-). I promise the Mozilla Foundation aren't bribing nor blackmailing me.

Re:How to waste bandwidth, battery power, and annoy sysadmins by oldmariner on Saturday June 29, 2024 @07:43AM (#40829651)
I don't remember seeing Pocket, so I went back to the settings to look. There's an option to have "Thought-provoking stories" which in smaller text says "Powered by Pocket".

Considering I didn't even realize it said Pocket the first time around, I think bookmarks are more prominent over Pocket, so I don't see bookmarks being demoted in favor of Pocket.

Re:How to waste bandwidth, battery power, and annoy sysadmins by csande17 on Saturday June 29, 2024 @08:17AM (#40829888)
For a while, bookmarks were demoted in favor of Collections, a jankier version of bookmarks that didn't sync properly to desktop and included a button to open all of them at once in multiple tabs.

Collections are still there, but they've made it easier to use regular bookmarks too, so now Firefox for Android just has two versions of bookmarks in it for some reason.

Entirely unrelated to Pocket, as far as I know, except in the general sense of Mozilla having bad ideas related to bookmarks.

Re:How to waste bandwidth, battery power, and annoy sysadmins by Aardwolf on Sunday June 30, 2024 @02:55AM (#40835563)
> Bookmarks show up ON the homepage

How? For me the closest thing I can get is "recent" bookmarks, but if you didn't bookmark a page recently it shows nothing at all, not even a link to all bookmarks, on the new tab page

Re:How to waste bandwidth, battery power, and annoy sysadmins by jgalt212 on Saturday June 29, 2024 @08:45AM (#40830068)
Pocket is the worst. It tried to get me to read some article where the author was whinging that her daughter was pretty and people were complementing her as such.

https://time.com/6990734/ugly-side-of-pretty-essay/

Re:How to waste bandwidth, battery power, and annoy sysadmins by Geezus_42 on Saturday June 29, 2024 @11:45AM (#40831386)
You clearly did not understand that woman's point.
Re:How to waste bandwidth, battery power, and annoy sysadmins by ndriscoll on Saturday June 29, 2024 @01:19PM (#40832078)
I don't understand her point. I guess that she's uncomfortable with human aesthetics? Why would being pretty require sacrifices in health and self-respect? One of the largest factors in looking good is being in good shape/physically healthy. Avoiding skin damage from UV is also a big one. Why would you lose self-respect for looking good?
Re:How to waste bandwidth, battery power, and annoy sysadmins by butterNaN on Saturday June 29, 2024 @07:20AM (#40829505)
Firefox on Android is a godsend to me, and the secret is that I can install uBlock origin and noscript on my mobile. I get a whiplash when I see someone else browsing the web without these, it is absurd how much attention people will allow to be just stolen away.
Re:How to waste bandwidth, battery power, and annoy sysadmins by Twirrim on Saturday June 29, 2024 @09:04AM (#40830185)
I'm another who loves firefox on android. It annoys me that to some degree Android forces chrome on you, even if firefox is set as your default. The full plugin support that got added in the last year really took it up a notch too.
Re:How to waste bandwidth, battery power, and annoy sysadmins by sirn on Saturday June 29, 2024 @10:43AM (#40830971)
iOS requires a browser to use the OS-provided WebKit, but you can still use your own networking layer, and doing your own scripts injection (e.g. for extensions, like what Orion is doing). Firefox for iOS used to use Alamofire as its networking engine, but switched over to NSURLSession/URLSession at some point. Chrome for iOS uses Cronet which was extracted from Chromium's networking stack (or maybe used, I have not followed the development recently).
Re:How to waste bandwidth, battery power, and annoy sysadmins by nanidin on Saturday June 29, 2024 @02:02PM (#40832389)
iOS allows third party browser engines since iOS 17.4 in the EU.
Re:How to waste bandwidth, battery power, and annoy sysadmins by Two4 on Saturday June 29, 2024 @04:10PM (#40833048)
No one is splitting their codebase for a single market if it doesn't make business sense. For a nonprofit with limited resources, I don't think it would make sense.
Re:How to waste bandwidth, battery power, and annoy sysadmins by nanidin on Saturday June 29, 2024 @04:24PM (#40833133)
That is Firefox's decision then, not a restriction by Apple as indicated by GP.
Re:How to waste bandwidth, battery power, and annoy sysadmins by HeatrayEnjoyer on Saturday June 29, 2024 @04:31PM (#40833171)
Apple doesn't restrict it at all outside the EU too?