> By far the cheapest, lightest, strongest reinforcement that we tried
In what sense is it strongest, strength-to-weight? Not sure the weight matters much compared to the weight of displaced concrete.
Also would be really curious to try nylon instead, could even beat the steel potentially
> In what sense is it strongest, strength-to-weight
Weight, size, and cost. The galvanized wire was the clear winner (hairline crack at 300lbs), but also cost significantly more than the acrylic yarn. Would be interesting to revisit this experiment with different densities of the acrylic weave to see where the limits are. We used a very sparse weave, but I could see tripling the weave density raising the weight limit closer to 300 than 225.If it's stretchy or wavy, the concrete may crack before it starts to produce tension
I hypothesize that one of the reasons the yarn performed so much better than the deer net is because it is more permeable and thus formed a better bond with the concrete.
In this scenario, I would imagine that it would be "locally tensioned" because the cement is effectively tightly bonded across any point of stress. Would be an interesting experiment!
If anyone has science fairs coming up, these seem like excellent experiments!
I'm always looking for fun STEM things to do with my kids and will keep this in mind.
In our experiment, we tried various reinforcements to concrete and tested the weight loading capacity before cracking. Quite surprising, at #2, was basic acrylic yarn layered perpendicularly in an overlapping "weave". By far the cheapest, lightest, strongest reinforcement that we tried!
[0] https://youtu.be/9QlzRT69X-I