News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Polyfill supply chain attack hits 100K+ sites by willcipriano on Tuesday June 25, 2024 @03:36PM (#40792650)
It's a competence crisis not a complexity one.

https://www.palladiummag.com/2023/06/01/complex-systems-wont...

Re:Polyfill supply chain attack hits 100K+ sites by ykonstant on Tuesday June 25, 2024 @03:43PM (#40792720)
I see both, incentivized by the cowboy developer attitude.
Re:Polyfill supply chain attack hits 100K+ sites by conartist6 on Wednesday June 26, 2024 @03:44PM (#40803827)
Ironically I think you got that almost exactly wrong.

Avoiding "cowboyism" has instead lead to the rise of heuristics for avoiding trouble that are more religion than science. The person who is most competent is also likely to be the person who has learned lessons the hard way the most times, not the person who has been very careful to avoid taking risks.

And let me just say that there are VERY few articles so poorly written that I literally can't get past the first paragraph, and an article that cherry-picks disasters to claim generalized incompetence scores my very top marks for statistically incompetent disingenuous bullshit. There will always be a long tail of "bad stuff that happens" and cherry-picking all the most sensational disasters is not a way of proving anything.

Re:Polyfill supply chain attack hits 100K+ sites by SV_BubbleTime on Tuesday June 25, 2024 @04:07PM (#40792993)
We haven’t gotten smarter or dumber.

But we have exceeded our ability to communicate the ideas and concepts, let alone the instructions of how to build and manage things.

Example: a junior Jiffy Lube high school dropout in 1960 could work hard and eventually own that store. Everything he would ever need to know about ICE engines was simple enough to understand over time… but now? There are 400 oil types, there are closed source computers on top computers, there are specialty tools for every vehicle brand, and you can’t do anything at all without knowing 10 different do-work-just-to-do-more-work systems. The high school dropout in 2024, will never own the store. Same kid. He hasn’t gotten dumber. The world just left him by in complexity.

Likewise… I suspect that Boeing hasn’t forgotten how to build planes, but the complexity has exceeded their ability. No human being on earth could be put in a room and make a 747 even over infinite time. It’s a product of far too many abstract concepts in a million different places that have come together to make a thing.

We make super complex things with zero effort put into communicating how or why they work a way they do.

We increase the complexity just to do it. And I feel we are hitting our limits.

Re:Polyfill supply chain attack hits 100K+ sites by PaulHoule on Tuesday June 25, 2024 @04:19PM (#40793110)
The problem w/ Boeing is not the inability of people to manage complexity but of management's refusal to manage complexity in a responsible way.

For instance, MCAS on the 737 is a half-baked implementation of the flight envelope protection facility on modern fly-by-wire airliners (all of them, except for the 737). The A320 had some growing pains with this, particularly it had at least two accidents where pilots tried to fly the plane into the ground, thought it would fail because of the flight envelope protection system, but they succeeded and crashed anyway. Barring that bit of perversity right out of the Normal Accidents book, people understand perfectly well how to build a safe fly-by-wire system. Boeing chose not to do that, and they refused to properly document what they did.

Boeing chose to not develop a 737 replacement, so all of us are suffering: in terms of noise, for instance, pilots are going deaf, passengers have their head spinning after a few hours in the plane, and people on the ground have no idea that the 737 is much louder than competitors.

Re:Polyfill supply chain attack hits 100K+ sites by hypeatei on Tuesday June 25, 2024 @04:52PM (#40793467)
Okay but your entire comment is riddled with mentions of complex systems (flight envelope system?) which proves the point of the parent comment. "Management" here is a group of humans who need to deal with all the complexity of corporate structures, government regulations, etc.. while also dealing with the complexities of the products themselves. We're all fallible beings.
Re:Polyfill supply chain attack hits 100K+ sites by _DeadFred_ on Tuesday June 25, 2024 @05:25PM (#40793808)
Boeing management is in the business of selling contracts. They are not in the business of making airplanes. That is the problem. They relocated headquarters from Seattle to Chicago and now DC so that they can focus on their priority, contracts. They dumped Boeing's original management style and grafted on the management style of a company that was forced to merge with Boeing. They diversified supply chain as a form of kickbacks to local governments/companies that bought their 'contracts'.

They enshiftified every area of the company, all with the priority/goal of selling their core product, 'contracts', and filling their 'book'.

We are plenty capable of designing Engineering systems, PLMs to manage EBOMs, MRP/ERP systems to manage MBOMs, etc to handle the complexities of building aircraft. What we can't help is the human desire to prioritize enshitfication if it means a bigger paycheck. Companies no longer exist to create a product, and the product is becoming secondary and tertiary in management's priorities, with management expecting someone else to take care of the 'small details' of why the company exists in the first place.

Re:Polyfill supply chain attack hits 100K+ sites by _DeadFred_ on Tuesday June 25, 2024 @05:13PM (#40793677)
Boeing is a kickbacks company in a really strange way. They get contracts based on including agreements to source partly from the contracties local area. Adding complexity for contracts and management bonus sake, not efficiency, not redundancy, not expertise. Add onto that a non-existent safety culture and a non-manufacturing/non-aerospace focused management philosophy grafting on from a company that failed and had to be merged into Boeing replacing the previous Boeing management philosophy. Enshitifaction in every area of the company. Heck they moved headquarters from Seattle to Chicago, and now from Chicago to DC. Prioritizing being where the grift is over, you know, being where the functions of the company are so that management has a daily understanding of what the company does. Because to management what the company does is win contracts, not build aerospace products. 'Someone else' takes care of that detail, according to Boeing management. Building those products in now secondary/tertiary to management.

I did ERP/MPR/EBOM/MBOM/BOM systems for aerospace. We have that stuff down. We have systems for this kind of communication down really well. We can build within a small window an airplane with thousands of parts with lead times from 1 day to 3 months to over a year for certain custom config options, with each parts design/FAA approval/manufacturing/installation tracked and audited. Boeing's issue is culture, not humanity's ability to make complex systems.

But I do agree that there is a complexity issue in society in general, and a lot of systems are coasting on the efforts of those that originally put them in place/designed them. A lot of government seems to be this way too. There's also a lot of overhead for overheads sake, but little process auditing/iterative improvement style management.

Re:Polyfill supply chain attack hits 100K+ sites by lawlessone on Tuesday June 25, 2024 @05:33PM (#40793911)
>Example: a junior Jiffy Lube high school dropout in 1960 c

Nowadays the company wouldn't hire a junior to train. They'll only poach already experienced people from their competitors.

Paying for training isn't considered worthwhile to the company because people wont stay.

People won't stay because the company doesn't invest in employees , it only poaches.

Re:Polyfill supply chain attack hits 100K+ sites by chrisweekly on Tuesday June 25, 2024 @03:41PM (#40792704)
Probably both, IMHO.
Re:Polyfill supply chain attack hits 100K+ sites by irskep on Tuesday June 25, 2024 @03:52PM (#40792814)
I'm predisposed to agree with the diagnosis that incompetence is ruining a lot of things, but the article boils down to "diversity hiring is destroying society" and seems to attribute a lot of the decline to the Civil Rights Act of 1964. Just in case anybody's wondering what they would get from this article.

> By the 1960s, the systematic selection for competence came into direct conflict with the political imperatives of the civil rights movement. During the period from 1961 to 1972, a series of Supreme Court rulings, executive orders, and laws—most critically, the Civil Rights Act of 1964—put meritocracy and the new political imperative of protected-group diversity on a collision course. Administrative law judges have accepted statistically observable disparities in outcomes between groups as prima facie evidence of illegal discrimination. The result has been clear: any time meritocracy and diversity come into direct conflict, diversity must take priority.

TL;DR "the California PG&E wildfires and today's JavaScript vulnerability are all the fault of Woke Politics." Saved you a click.

Re:Polyfill supply chain attack hits 100K+ sites by UweSchmidt on Tuesday June 25, 2024 @04:21PM (#40793139)
A more fundamental reason is that society is no longer interested in pushing forward at all cost. It's the arrival at an economical and technological equilibrium where people are comfortable enough, along with the end of the belief in progress as an ideology, or way to salvation somewhere during the 20th century. If you look closely, a certain kind of relaxation has replaced a quest for efficiency everywhere. Is that disappointing? Is that actually bad? Do you think there might be a rude awakening?

Consider: It was this scifi-fueled dream of an amazing high-tech, high-competency future that also implied machines doing the labour, and an enlightened future relieving people of all kinds of unpleasantries like boring work, therefore prevented them from attaining high competency. The fictional starship captain, navigating the galaxy and studying alien artifacts was always saving planets full of humans in desolate mental state...

Re:Polyfill supply chain attack hits 100K+ sites by PaulHoule on Tuesday June 25, 2024 @04:57PM (#40793511)
My own interpretation of the business cycle is that growth cause externalities that stop growth. Sometimes you get time periods like the 1970s where efforts to control externalities themselves would cause more problems than they solved, at least some of the time. (e.g. see the trash 1974 model year of automobiles where they hadn’t figured out how to make emission controls work.)

I’d credit the success of Reagan in the 1980s at managing inflation to a quiet policy of degrowth the Republicans could get away with because everybody thinks they are “pro business”. As hostile as Reagan’s rhetoric was towards environmentalism note we got new clean air and clean water acts in the 1980s but that all got put in pause under Clinton where irresponsible monetary expansion restarted.

Re:Polyfill supply chain attack hits 100K+ sites by astrange on Friday June 28, 2024 @02:03AM (#40818141)
> My own interpretation of the business cycle is that growth cause externalities that stop growth.

The evidence seems to be against this.

https://eml.berkeley.edu/~enakamura/papers/plucking.pdf

Re:Polyfill supply chain attack hits 100K+ sites by tivert on Wednesday June 26, 2024 @12:11PM (#40801572)
> along with the end of the belief in progress as an ideology, or way to salvation somewhere during the 20th century.

That 20th century belief in technological progress as a "way to salvation" killed itself with smog and rivers so polluted they'd catch on fire, among other things.

Re:Polyfill supply chain attack hits 100K+ sites by rytor718 on Tuesday June 25, 2024 @05:57PM (#40794139)
Thank you for summarizing (I actually read the whole article before seeing your reply and might have posted similar thoughts). I get the appeal of romanticizing our past as a country, looking back at the post-war era, especially the space race with a nostalgia that makes us imagine it was a world where the most competent were at the helm. But it just wasn't so, and still isn't.

Many don't understand that the Civil Rights Act describes the systematic LACK of a meritocracy. It defines the ways in which merit has been ignored (gender, race, class, etc) and demands that merit be the criteria for success -- and absent the ability for an institution to decide on the merits it provides a (surely imperfect) framework to force them to do so. The necessity of the CRA then and now, is the evidence of absence of a system driven on merit.

I want my country to keep striving for a system of merit but we've got nearly as much distance to close on it now as we did then.

Re:Polyfill supply chain attack hits 100K+ sites by SV_BubbleTime on Wednesday June 26, 2024 @02:24AM (#40796974)
>Many don't understand that the Civil Rights Act describes the systematic LACK of a meritocracy. It defines the ways in which merit has been ignored (gender, race, class, etc) and demands that merit be the criteria for success

Stealing that. Very good.

Re:Polyfill supply chain attack hits 100K+ sites by astrange on Friday June 28, 2024 @02:05AM (#40818148)
The word "meritocracy" was invented for a book about how it's a bad idea that can't work, so I'd recommend not trying to have one. "Merit" doesn't work because of Goodhart's law.

I also feel like you'd never hire junior engineers or interns if you were optimizing for it, and then you're either Netflix or you don't have any senior engineers.

Re:Polyfill supply chain attack hits 100K+ sites by defrost on Friday June 28, 2024 @02:23AM (#40818234)
FWiW Michael Young, Baron Young of Dartington, the author of the 1958 book The Rise of the Meritocracy popularised the term which rapidly lost the negative connotations he put upon it.

He didn't invent the term though, he lifted it from an earlier essay by another British sociologist Alan Fox who apparently coined it two years earlier in a 1956 essay.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Rise_of_the_Meritocracy

Re:Polyfill supply chain attack hits 100K+ sites by kbolino on Wednesday June 26, 2024 @12:04PM (#40801509)
I think this is the wrong takeaway.

Everything has become organized around measurable things and short-term optimization. "Disparate impact" is just one example of this principle. It's easy to measure demographic representation, and it's easy to tear down the apparent barriers standing in the way of proportionality in one narrow area. Whereas, it's very hard to address every systemic and localized cause leading up to a number of different disparities.

Environmentalism played out a similar way. It's easy to measure a factory's direct pollution. It's easy to require the factory to install scrubbers, or drive it out of business by forcing it to account for externalities. It's hard to address all of the economic, social, and other factors that led to polluting factories in the first place, and that will keep its former employees jobless afterward. Moreover, it's hard to ensure that the restrictions apply globally instead of just within one or some countries' borders, which can undermine the entire purpose of the measures, even though the zoomed-in metrics still look good.

So too do we see with publically traded corporations and other investment-heavy enterprises: everything is about the stock price or other simple valuation, because that makes the investors happy. Running once venerable companies into the ground, turning merges and acquisitions into the core business, spreading systemic risk at alarming levels, and even collapsing the entire economy don't show up on balance sheets or stock reports as such and can't easily get addressed by shareholders.

And yet now and again "data-driven" becomes the organizing principle of yet another sector of society. It's very difficult to attack the idea directly, because it seems to be very "scientific" and "empirical". But anecdote and observation are still empirically useful, and they often tell us early on that optimizing for certain metrics isn't the right thing to do. But once the incentives are aligned that way, even competent people give up and join the bandwagon.