News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Are animals conscious? How new research is changing minds by moi2388 on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @01:54AM (#40714449)
I’ve never understood these questions. “Are animals conscious?”

Well, could you give me the definition of consciousness? No you can’t. So now you’re asking me both to define it and show if animals have it or not.

Are animals aware of their surroundings? Yes. Are animals showing the behavioural signs of pain when you hurt them? Yes. Can animals direct attention? Yes. Can animals remember? Yes. Can animals learn? Yes. Are animals self-aware? Some of them, some only sometimes, some not.

To think of consciousness as a dichotomy instead of a spectrum is baffling to me. As is thinking of consciousness as being a single, indivisible thing.

Re:Are animals conscious? How new research is changing minds by tuatoru on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @02:07AM (#40714525)
Do animals have friends, enemies, cliques? Yes. Do animals play practical jokes on each other? Yes. I've seen all of these in cows.
Re:Are animals conscious? How new research is changing minds by BLKNSLVR on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @02:47AM (#40714766)
One my cats attempts to lure me around the back of the shed so that she can then race out the other side, down the driveway, and jump the fence to precious freedom.

She has a number of variations on this theme, and with each failure she tries something slightly different. Until I catch her and bring her back inside.

The reason I know this is because, before I was aware that it was happening, it succeeded at least twice. (I'm picturing people reading this saying, in Lisa Simpsons's voice, "is my brother dumber than a hamster? Hamster two, Bart zero" - because that's what my inner voice is saying right now).

Re:Are animals conscious? How new research is changing minds by sleepychu on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @02:10AM (#40714546)
Cow practical joke anecdotes, please! :-)
Re:Are animals conscious? How new research is changing minds by tuatoru on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @02:32AM (#40714677)
Real simple stuff. Luring a cow over near a bank and then pushing her down it. Pretending there's some lush grass in the gap between trees. Nudging each other into the electric fence, or into the gatepost when going through a gate.
Re:Are animals conscious? How new research is changing minds by King-Aaron on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @02:35AM (#40714697)
Cows are just big dogs
Re:Are animals conscious? How new research is changing minds by naikrovek on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @08:50AM (#40727808)
big, curious dogs, sorta like cats. they want to know what you're doing when they see you and they want to smell everything you're doing and they want to play all the damn time.

I did IT work on a farm for a few weeks and was there 3-5 days a week. The cows were far more active than any other animal I saw. They clearly liked each other and had friends and non-friends in the group. They would run and walk dozens and dozens of miles per day and a horse would move 1/4 mile in total over the course of an entire day.

Re:Are animals conscious? How new research is changing minds by naikrovek on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @08:48AM (#40727770)
Cows are flippin' amazing creatures and as I age I get closer and closer to ending all meat consumption. I consume very little these days and it would not be a large jump to stop completely.

Cows are intelligent, curious, and they have a sense of humor, a desire to play. They have friends, enemies, and .. well, everything, really. They have different capabilities because their brains and bodies are different than ours, but they're every bit as legitimate of a life form as ourselves, and every bit as conscious and self-aware.

Re:Are animals conscious? How new research is changing minds by King-Aaron on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @02:34AM (#40714693)
I once watched a spider in a web have to rapidly run around it's web and scoop up it's little baby spiders to escape a flame that was coming close to it. The reaction did not appear to be some kind of mechanical automated reaction - it very clearly had awareness of the danger, and an awareness of it's offspring, and made a coordinated effort to rescue them and move them away to safety.

To me - as someone who is not a biologist or a professional in this field - this appears to be consciousness. I couldn't imagine anyone trying to argue against that.

Re:Are animals conscious? How new research is changing minds by Vampiero on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @03:17AM (#40714963)
Optimize a creature for "survival" over billions of years and you get behavior like this. It doesn't require consciousness however. And it's quite hard to ask a spider whether it is conscious or not.
Re:Are animals conscious? How new research is changing minds by adrianN on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @03:47AM (#40715131)
As the top comment in this thread pointed out, we don’t have a definition of consciousness that allows you to tell whether a spider has it or not. As far as I know, no observable behavior requires „consciousness“ for most layman definitions of the term.
Re:Are animals conscious? How new research is changing minds by efilife on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @04:22AM (#40715320)
Just FYI, all the it'ses you used in this comment are the wrong ones. Should have been its
Re:Are animals conscious? How new research is changing minds by King-Aaron on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @09:09PM (#40723750)
Banging it out on my phone, it was automatically putting in apostrophes :(
Re:Are animals conscious? How new research is changing minds by nikkwong on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @02:25AM (#40714630)
I think you're over complicating it. When people generally talk about consciousness, they're talking about the phenomenology of awareness in the present moment. It's not really hard to define.

It's difficult to establish whether or not an animal is conscious in the way that it's difficult to establish whether another person is conscious. The only evidence we have for consciousness is the fact that we personally experience it ourselves. And because of that, we can't truly know if other's are conscious from a philosophical sense (i.e.—philosophical zombies) but we can posit scientifically that they must be since they share the same brain structure that we do.

Now when we're trying to establish scientifically whether or not an animal is conscious or not, it's more difficult because we don't have the subjective experience of being that animal, and we can't philosophically transfer the phenomenology of the experience our brain creates onto theirs. So, while I think the question "are animals conscious?" is well-bounded, it's not one that is currently answerable due to the currently private nature of consciousness.

> Are animals aware of their surroundings? Yes. Are animals showing the behavioural signs of pain when you hurt them? Yes. Can animals direct attention? Yes. Can animals remember? Yes. Can animals learn? Yes.

Reacting to stimuli is all possible without consciousness—just like crabs react to noxious, painful stimuli without nociceptors. So the phenomena you're describing is not what people are talking about when they're debating consciousness

Re:Are animals conscious? How new research is changing minds by biztos on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @03:49AM (#40715147)
I recently learned that some people do not have an inner monologue.

This knowledge now affects my assumptions about consciousness and whether it’s really knowable.

Re:Are animals conscious? How new research is changing minds by alfiedotwtf on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @07:02AM (#40716264)
As an Aphantasian, this!

Because there’s no rigorous scientific definition of what consciousness is, and you can’t even just roughly point to it, just like most quasi-sciences it’s all up for debate.

From my perspective, the only people questioning whether or not non-humans have consciousness are coming from a religious perspective trying to reconcile their cognitive dissonance

Re:Are animals conscious? How new research is changing minds by navane on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @03:01AM (#40714853)
Do all people experience your version of consciousness, awareness in the present moment? Or is this overly represented among people debating whether animals have it? Some people don't have an inner monologue.
Re:Are animals conscious? How new research is changing minds by nikkwong on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @03:38AM (#40715078)
That's totally true and something I don't know the answer to. But it's interesting to ponder if the experience of consciousness is the same for each individual. We believe that consciousness is possibly an emergent phenomena of cognitive processing, but since there is a wide amount of heterogeneity in the makeup of the human mind, it isn't extraordinary to claim that this 'presence in the current moment' may have different flavors for different individuals.

The claim that certain individuals lack an inner monologue is a testament to this—I can't imagine what that would be like but that is certainly nothing like my conscious experience is. To me, the lack of an inner monologue sounds very much like the 'dark universe' in which the brain is doing all of the processing and there is no conscious observer to witness the unfolding. I'm sure people without a inner monologue are still conscious.. but—it's interesting to think about how different their experience may be like.

Re:Are animals conscious? How new research is changing minds by nprateem on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @03:48AM (#40715142)
Do you ever watch a movie/event or listen to music and notice you're not internally narrating what's happening because you're so engrossed in the action?

Voila, consciousness without the inner monologue.

Re:Are animals conscious? How new research is changing minds by navane on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @05:16AM (#40715595)
In one way, that sounds like more consciously present, in the other way it sounds like less. You are more here and now as you lack distracting commentary, or are you more here if you sit and ponder it?
Re:Are animals conscious? How new research is changing minds by nprateem on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @07:12AM (#40716340)
The fact it's possible to not ponder shows consciousness doesn't depend on pondering.

I can't see how distracting yourself with something else (thoughts) could make you more conscious.

Re:Are animals conscious? How new research is changing minds by rusticpenn on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @03:15AM (#40714941)
As a former owner of several cats, I can say that the cats I had definitely had consciousness. They were able to read my emotions and react to it. They knew how to get what they wanted. One of them loved looking at a mirror while wiping its face (It had observed me doing it). I could go on.
Re:Are animals conscious? How new research is changing minds by nikkwong on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @03:29AM (#40715024)
Well—there's a thought experiment of something like a 'dark universe'—a universe devoid of conscious observers, with the absence of awareness and perception while the physical processes continue unabated just as ours does with all of the people walking around, doing business, living cosmopolitan lifestyles, etc. This is theoretically possible because humans are just agents with brains that bring in stimuli, process it, and react. I.e. consciousness is not a necessary part of the equation to realize the universe is currently realized. The only reason we know consciousness is part of the equation, is because we experience it ourselves.

So I don't know if the fact that your cats are agents that are reacting to stimuli is proof that they're conscious. Again, if we were an outside observer, like an alien, we would have no way to prove humans are conscious. The only reason we believe scientifically that other humans are conscious is because we personally perceive conscious, and since other humans have the same neurological structures that we do, we can posit that they experience the same thing. Philosophically though we can't 'prove' other people are conscious, which gets us back to the philosophical zombie thought experiment.

Re:Are animals conscious? How new research is changing minds by __s on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @08:49AM (#40717208)
My father had a siamese cat growing up, smart, would open drawers from behind to get food, tease dogs outside by standing just out of range of their leash. One day it slipped on a jump, his brother laughed at it. It ran away humiliated. That night while they were asleep it attacked his brother
Re:Are animals conscious? How new research is changing minds by moi2388 on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @11:05AM (#40718640)
Now you’ve just replaced “consciousness” with “awareness”. Self-awareness? Awareness of stimuli? Awareness of demarcation of animate and inanimate objects?

I understand it sounds simple, but there are so many different systems interplaying to give rise to whatever definition of consciousness you give, it’s really hard to give exact definitions.

Also, you still talk as if this “awareness in the moment” might be a simple dichotomy. I seriously highly doubt this is the case, especially when it comes to stuff like reflexes and instincts.

Re:Are animals conscious? How new research is changing minds by a_cardboard_box on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @04:40PM (#40722013)
When I say "consciousness", the concept that I mean isn't reducible to other concepts. It's a concept that can only be found through introspection. And it seems like many have noticed the same concept, so we can label it with a word. But we can't define it such that someone who hasn't already noticed the concept will understand it. We can only describe it in such a way that those who already noticed it can confirm we're talking about the same thing. I think the parent's comment has done this adequately, and I don't think it's a problem that the definition is incomplete.
Re:Are animals conscious? How new research is changing minds by the_gipsy on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @01:04PM (#40719948)
So how do you define "aware"? Some inner model reflecting the environment?

A stone is "aware in the present moment". Its temperature is an inner state reflecting the environment, short-term. Its composition is an inner state reflecting the environment, long-term.

Re:Are animals conscious? How new research is changing minds by Vegenoid on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @02:02PM (#40720475)
> When people generally talk about consciousness, they're talking about the phenomenology of awareness in the present moment. It's not really hard to define.

People often find this line much harder to draw after they have experienced qualia that is radically different from from what they have experienced before. The most common avenues for such an experience are psychedelics or deep meditation, and the experience is often called ego death.

There is much written on people's subjective experiences, but many people would say that they have experienced qualia which was not based on either awareness or the present moment. Of course, the experience still happened within a human brain, which is known to exhibit awareness of the present moment - but the subjective experience can feel as if neither of those concepts matter, or even exist, while still feeling very real.

These experiences often cause people to start thinking a lot more about the distinctions between consciousness, awareness, and qualia. I get that most people use 'awareness' to mean 'experiencing qualia', but I think most people using 'awareness' in that way have not experienced qualia that is bafflingly different from normal human qualia.

Re:Are animals conscious? How new research is changing minds by b800h on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @02:20AM (#40714596)
This problem is compounded by a certain class of neuroscientist, who upon hitting the hard (scientifically unresolvable) problem of consciousness, declares that consiousness is something else, like neural correlates of stimulation. This invariably causes disappointment when attending mainstream lectures with the word "consciousness" in the title.
Re:Are animals conscious? How new research is changing minds by slumberdisrupt on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @03:06AM (#40714895)
If there is such a thing as consciousness, no matter its variety (like how the viscosity of water varies on a "spectrum" without become its opposites ice or steam), there is by necessity such a thing as non-consciousness. That's just how concepts go.
Re:Are animals conscious? How new research is changing minds by Simon_ORourke on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @02:34AM (#40714691)
Again, without definition then anything measured against an invisible yardstick are just words on a page. Then again, the few months I spent living in Bakersfield CA, led me to question whether some or indeed most of the folks there were just low fidelity NPC's.
Re:Are animals conscious? How new research is changing minds by BLKNSLVR on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @02:43AM (#40714735)
Consciousness must be mipmapped. It only starts to present at a reasonably close distance.
Re:Are animals conscious? How new research is changing minds by ysofunny on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @02:50AM (#40714781)
energy most certainly is "mipmapped" but this would be a funky way to think about inverse square type of laws
Re:Are animals conscious? How new research is changing minds by dandanua on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @04:06AM (#40715244)
I presume many people actually mean self-consciousness when they talk about consciousness. It's the concepts of "I" and "will" that puzzle the most. Anything else can be treated as automatic actions (yet very complicated).
Re:Are animals conscious? How new research is changing minds by LawrenceKerr on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @12:17PM (#40719512)
Can we deduce from your comment that you are in fact, not conscious?

We all know what it's like to be conscious (I presume - my theory of mind is intact but may be flawed). It's obviously the quality of being, i.e. experiencing qualia.

And since we as human beings are conscious, it stands to reason that there are probably other living beings (or matter in general) who are not. (Living) matter that doesn't experience the world, basically. No frame of reference. Unless you believe in panpsychism; then everything is conscious and we can ask ourselves what it's like to be a rock.

It's just that the hard problem of consciousness states that we haven't been able to define this "state" in its exact physical, neural correlates, but just because we haven't been able to do that yet, doesn't mean it doesn't exist. It quite literally is the only thing we can know for sure exists, because otherwise no one would be there to ask or hear the question to begin with.

And sure, you can try to break it down into behavior and other properties of a living being, but that is simply side-stepping the hard problem and just ignoring the question of qualia.

Then again, there's something like "aphantasia": some people do not have the capacity to mentally visualize anything, and often aren't even aware of that themselves. I can imagine there's something analogous with the quality of consciousness, i.e. literal "NPCs" who do not experience the world from a frame of reference, but are basically non-sentient, human, autonomous agents. That's just a very dangerous line of thought, so don't take that too seriously :)

Re:Are animals conscious? How new research is changing minds by Vegenoid on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @01:46PM (#40720323)
> And since we as human beings are conscious, it stands to reason that there are probably other living beings (or matter in general) who are not.

I'm not following this line of reasoning. It seems be exactly opposite to panpsychism, which reasons "since I experience qualia, it stands to reason that everything experiences qualia, because I don't know of a state that does not result in qualia". I'm not a confident panpsychist, but that logic seems to make more sense. Unfortunately, it is just as unproveable as the opposite view, just like pretty much everything around qualia.

Re:Are animals conscious? How new research is changing minds by senordevnyc on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @01:03PM (#40719937)
It quite literally is the only thing we can know for sure exists

To be precise, it's the only thing I can know for sure exists. I can't know for sure if anyone else knows it.

Re:Are animals conscious? How new research is changing minds by moi2388 on Monday June 24, 2024 @02:18AM (#40773016)
What is? Consciousness? Are you conscious when asleep? No? Then how do dreams work?

The only thing you can be sure of is that you experience some qualia; that you are conscious is an assumption.

Re:Are animals conscious? How new research is changing minds by Saturdays on Thursday June 20, 2024 @09:53AM (#40738823)
I'm reading this book "The Origin of Consciousness in the Breakdown of the Bicameral Mind" and it's quite fascinating to think deeply about what is Consciousness. I think the book does a good job of defining and explaining Consciousness.

Highly recommend it to think critically about the subject, but I think your point is valid, consciousness occurs for many things, and then it doesn't have to many other things. You don't need consciousness to nearly instantly detect that b comes after a sequence of {a,b,a,b,a,?}. You need consciousness to think about _why_ b comes after though. When you go for a swim and then recall the event, you most likely recall it in an objective or third person way mentally - the image or visual in your memory is that third person view.. but that's not actually how you experienced it.

I wonder how much of that applies to animals, and I wonder if we can ever get that answer.

Re:Are animals conscious? How new research is changing minds by zzo38computer on Friday June 21, 2024 @12:21AM (#40746112)
Of course that is a good question, although I would expect that with the most useful or most reasonable or best definition (which is itself not entirely clear, though), that the answer will probably be, yes, animals are conscious (although not always all the time; unconsciousness and partial consciousness can occur too).

Scientific experiments can detect specific things and specific details (if tested in an appropriate way), but this would be something specific rather than just being called "consciousness", is what I should think.