Re:Effect of Passenger Position on Crash Injury Risk in Airc...
by Qem on Friday June 14, 2024 @06:54AM
(#40679559)
I wish they had modelled the effects of installing the passenger seats facing backwards. Passengers have no need to see forward in a plane, different from pilots, and in the event of sudden deceleration the seat would help cushion the impact, what I believe would probably improve safety in most survivable crash scenarios.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Effect of Passenger Position on Crash Injury Risk in Airc...
by playingalong on Friday June 14, 2024 @06:57AM
(#40679582)
Wouldn't it make some people feel sick?
Not sure if there's any science to back people preferring to sit forward facing in trains
Re:Effect of Passenger Position on Crash Injury Risk in Airc...
by Qem on Friday June 14, 2024 @07:12AM
(#40679667)
A few seats could be left facing forward, for people who would feel sick, but backward facing probably should be default. It's hard to believe smashing your face against the hard back surface from the seat in front of you is better than being pushed hard against the soft cushion from your own seat. Also the load would be more evenly distributed across the whole body.
Re:Effect of Passenger Position on Crash Injury Risk in Airc...
by mathieuh on Friday June 14, 2024 @07:00AM
(#40679601)
Trains accelerate and decelerate relatively often compared to planes where you only really notice changes in velocity at take-off and landing so I don't think it would make a difference
Re:Effect of Passenger Position on Crash Injury Risk in Airc...
by Tor3 on Friday June 14, 2024 @07:03AM
(#40679619)
Japanese limited express trains and the bullet train have very few stops (or none, depending), and the ride is very smooth.. still, my wife (Japanese) can't sit backwards-facing without getting sick. Not sure what causes this.
Re:Effect of Passenger Position on Crash Injury Risk in Airc...
by Aeolun on Friday June 14, 2024 @07:11AM
(#40679655)
It would not surprise if there was something about human physiology that thinks it’s unnatural to go backwards. Our eyes are in front of our head for a reason.
Re:Effect of Passenger Position on Crash Injury Risk in Airc...
by Qem on Friday June 14, 2024 @07:20AM
(#40679707)
I don't know for sure, but is very common to see parents carrying children facing backwards in their arms, while walking, with no ill effects. No big deal.
Re:Effect of Passenger Position on Crash Injury Risk in Airc...
by Aeolun on Saturday June 15, 2024 @10:09PM
(#40694190)
Sure, but there’s a speed limit to that, and you sort of trust the person holding you implicitly.
Not really applicable to an aircraft hurtling along at 300m/s
Re:Effect of Passenger Position on Crash Injury Risk in Airc...
by Tor3 on Monday June 17, 2024 @06:41AM
(#40704211)
But you don't notice that speed.. (ref. Newton and Einstein and others). I agree with those saying it must be psychological.. well, mostly. Sometimes you do physically notice that you're facing backwards. At takeoff, for example. And, to some extent, landing. Maybe when banking too. I haven't tried, obviously (the backwards-facing unfolding seats for the crew would be the place to test this).
Re:Effect of Passenger Position on Crash Injury Risk in Airc...
by flemhans on Friday June 14, 2024 @10:38AM
(#40681339)
Tangentially related: The seats on Shinkansen trains can be rotated to adapt to the needs of the passengers.
Re:Effect of Passenger Position on Crash Injury Risk in Airc...
by dredmorbius on Friday June 14, 2024 @03:32PM
(#40684178)
Many US commuter-rail trains also have reversible seats. The train crew generally orient these to be forward-facing for the direction of travel, possibly excepting the first seat in a car.
(The trainsets reverse directions without being turned around themselves. Those using locomotives rather than electric traction operate in "pusher" mode for half their trips. There's an operator cab in the end car for such trips.)
Re:Effect of Passenger Position on Crash Injury Risk in Airc...
by Tor3 on Monday June 17, 2024 @06:38AM
(#40704174)
They can be rotated, but that's supposed to be done by train personnel when changing directions. That's the primary purpose. The only time you're allowed to rotate them yourselves is when you're e.g. a group of four - then you can have two sets of seats face each other.
Re:Effect of Passenger Position on Crash Injury Risk in Airc...
by BobaFloutist on Friday June 14, 2024 @03:45PM
(#40684318)
I thought about that, but then I realized that the acceleration is going to be (more or less) equal and opposite for take-off and landing, so it's more about which one you want first, no?
Re:Effect of Passenger Position on Crash Injury Risk in Airc...
by jacktribe on Friday June 14, 2024 @04:25PM
(#40684732)
The angle of descent is of about 3 degrees, that's far less than the angle at which the aircraft is taking off. Thus the rear facing passengers would be facing down quite steeply on takeoff, and thus likely to vomit the airport lounge food they just had :)
Re:Effect of Passenger Position on Crash Injury Risk in Airc...
by alamortsubite on Friday June 14, 2024 @08:23AM
(#40680215)
I think it would absolutely improve safety. Except for some very contrived scenarios, deceleration in a crash approaches infinity (mitigated only by the elasticity of the fuselage and whatever it impacts). Better to experience that spread out across a soft seat cushion than concentrated into an inelastic lap and shoulder belt.
Unfortunately, the psyche of the average passenger can't handle riding backwards. I've never understood it. Remove visual stimuli and it's impossible to tell the difference. Maybe we just need to close the window shades on takeoff and landing?
Re:Effect of Passenger Position on Crash Injury Risk in Airc...
by cyberax on Friday June 14, 2024 @02:41PM
(#40683653)
Belts are actually elastic. They just are not that easy to stretch, which is exactly what you want.
Re:Effect of Passenger Position on Crash Injury Risk in Airc...
by abdullahkhalids on Friday June 14, 2024 @04:30PM
(#40684803)
Many trains have backward facing seats. It's not common for people to have a problem sitting in them, certainly a minority. And train windows are usually several times larger than plane windows.
Re:Effect of Passenger Position on Crash Injury Risk in Airc...
by thejazzman on Saturday June 15, 2024 @10:55PM
(#40694347)
I get car sick almost immediately if I don't face forward.
Ditto amusement park rides that move backwards (eg The Mummy). This includes when there is no visual indicator (in the dark)
Re:Effect of Passenger Position on Crash Injury Risk in Airc...
by russdill on Friday June 14, 2024 @02:02PM
(#40683202)
There are some planes with a few backward facing seats. Takeoff is more comfortable in a forward facing seat
Re:Effect of Passenger Position on Crash Injury Risk in Airc...
by dredmorbius on Friday June 14, 2024 @03:29PM
(#40684149)
Military troop transports frequently utilise rear-facing seats, and I suspect there's enough incident data to arrive at useful conclusions.
Re:Effect of Passenger Position on Crash Injury Risk in Airc...
by nytesky on Saturday June 15, 2024 @12:27AM
(#40687521)
I suspect recruits susceptible to motion sickness don’t make it through basic training
Re:Effect of Passenger Position on Crash Injury Risk in Airc...
by dredmorbius on Saturday June 15, 2024 @02:44AM
(#40687941)
Or would be forced to walk ;-)
Fair point that the military can choose its subjects, or compel them.