News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Indian Startup 3D Prints Rocket Engine in Just 72 Hours by jes5199 on Thursday June 13, 2024 @01:23PM (#40672241)
this might be 20th-century thinking. if you can build enough copies of a rocket cheap enough, maybe disintegrating a bunch of them isn't a showstopper
Re:Indian Startup 3D Prints Rocket Engine in Just 72 Hours by nordsieck on Thursday June 13, 2024 @01:28PM (#40672276)
> if you can build enough copies of a rocket cheap enough, maybe disintegrating a bunch of them isn't a showstopper

The problem with that idea is that you won't be legally allowed to launch again until you root cause and fix the failure, which can take months (or years if you're Blue Origin). Also, your insurance rates tend to go up a lot when your rockets blow up regularly, which tends to push customers away.

In practice it doesn't work.

Notes: Astra said they were going to pursue this strategy. It was not well received by potential customers and they basically had to walk it back.

Re:Indian Startup 3D Prints Rocket Engine in Just 72 Hours by schmidtleonard on Thursday June 13, 2024 @03:41PM (#40673725)
Doesn't work? It seems to be working great for the industry leader.
Re:Indian Startup 3D Prints Rocket Engine in Just 72 Hours by nordsieck on Thursday June 13, 2024 @04:28PM (#40674335)
> Doesn't work? It seems to be working great for the industry leader.

What are you talking about? SpaceX's Falcon 9 is arguably the most reliable rocket ever made. They've launched hundreds of times in a row without failure.

If your point is that they're blowing up Starship prototypes, well... they're in the middle of a development program and they're not flying customer payloads.

Re:Indian Startup 3D Prints Rocket Engine in Just 72 Hours by gus_massa on Thursday June 13, 2024 @08:34PM (#40676395)
They blow up a few of the early Falcons, and the explosions got a lot of news coverage.

Now they are launching an landing[1] safetly, but it's boring and the news show a cute puppy instead.

So for most people the rate of explosions vs launching is skewed.

[1] It's crazy that landing rockets is boring now.

Re:Indian Startup 3D Prints Rocket Engine in Just 72 Hours by ReptileMan on Friday June 14, 2024 @05:45AM (#40679210)
>The problem with that idea is that you won't be legally allowed to launch again until you root cause and fix the failure,

Only if you want to launch from US. I guess with a 160 countries there will some with the right area for a launch pad with way laxer requirements.

Re:Indian Startup 3D Prints Rocket Engine in Just 72 Hours by nordsieck on Friday June 14, 2024 @06:42AM (#40679502)
> I guess with a 160 countries there will some with the right area for a launch pad with way laxer requirements.

Good luck with that.

Exploding rockets are a very serious public safety risk since they're >90% propellant. Even Russia grounded Soyuz until they root caused its launch failure. From what I can gather China has the same policy, although they're very quiet about any launch failures that happen, so it harder to tell.

Re:Indian Startup 3D Prints Rocket Engine in Just 72 Hours by fullspectrumdev on Thursday June 13, 2024 @01:47PM (#40672503)
The issue isn’t the rocket: it’s what you have affixed to it (the payload).

The rocket itself is purely a delivery system for a payload after all.

Re:Indian Startup 3D Prints Rocket Engine in Just 72 Hours by locococo on Thursday June 13, 2024 @01:31PM (#40672302)
from the rocket perspective, sure, but not so much from the perspective of your cargo.

In many cases the cargo is more precious than the rocket so you need reliable rockets.

Re:Indian Startup 3D Prints Rocket Engine in Just 72 Hours by sandworm101 on Thursday June 13, 2024 @02:56PM (#40673231)
>> maybe disintegrating a bunch of them isn't a showstopper

But it isn't about destroying a bunch of them. Cut corners on checks and you very quickly blow up all of them. Any slight increase in the failure rate of individual parts, saving a few pennies, multiplies exponentially across the entire rocket into total system failure. So the money-saving approach is actually to test test and retest, to cram down the failure rates so low that the cumulative rate become acceptable (about 1%).

Re:Indian Startup 3D Prints Rocket Engine in Just 72 Hours by lesuorac on Thursday June 13, 2024 @01:27PM (#40672275)
Who pays when the payload disintegrates?
Re:Indian Startup 3D Prints Rocket Engine in Just 72 Hours by ruined on Thursday June 13, 2024 @01:37PM (#40672374)
this works for munitions, but not for payloads that anyone cares about.
Re:Indian Startup 3D Prints Rocket Engine in Just 72 Hours by switchbak on Thursday June 13, 2024 @02:15PM (#40672786)
Not sure exploding rockets on their launch platform is such a good thing when they're carrying a bunch of highly explosive / fragmentary warheads (in addition to the rocket itself, which is plenty dangerous).

Unless this was something like a cruise missile dropped at altitude where a failure isn't a big deal.

Re:Indian Startup 3D Prints Rocket Engine in Just 72 Hours by gridspy on Thursday June 13, 2024 @03:21PM (#40673495)
I'm sure even in this case, risking the air-frame of the bomber or friendlies on the ground below is not ideal. Bear in mind cruise missiles are usually launched from friendly territory.

Also, failures might reduce the accuracy of the missile, leading to potential civilian causalities.

Re:Indian Startup 3D Prints Rocket Engine in Just 72 Hours by sandworm101 on Thursday June 13, 2024 @03:22PM (#40673510)
>> cruise missile dropped at altitude where a failure isn't a big deal.

If failure isn't a big deal, then the weapon should no have been used. An ALCM costs millions. The destruction it causes is part of a larger battle plan. Should it not work properly then friendly forces may die. Should it work properly then enemy forces may die. The effectiveness of such a weapon is never not a big deal.

Re:Indian Startup 3D Prints Rocket Engine in Just 72 Hours by DrFalkyn on Friday June 14, 2024 @12:50AM (#40677570)
If it’s that critical then they aren’t launching one cruise missile.

If system A costs 1k quid but only works 50% of the time, while system B works 99% of the time but costs 10k quid, system A actually makes a lot more sense. On average you are going to spend a lot less money for the same outcome.

Re:Indian Startup 3D Prints Rocket Engine in Just 72 Hours by fragmede on Friday June 14, 2024 @05:18AM (#40679081)
What's the price on weapons technology falling into enemy hands? A dud is a gold mine of data for an enemy's reverse-engineers.
Re:Indian Startup 3D Prints Rocket Engine in Just 72 Hours by risenshinetech on Thursday June 13, 2024 @04:25PM (#40674311)
Right, because as one of your rocket customers, I'm totally fine with you disintegrating my one-of-a-kind payload
Re:Indian Startup 3D Prints Rocket Engine in Just 72 Hours by Iwan-Zotow on Thursday June 13, 2024 @11:29PM (#40677269)
what about payload?

ready to build many Webb telescopes?

Re:Indian Startup 3D Prints Rocket Engine in Just 72 Hours by BobaFloutist on Friday June 14, 2024 @01:22PM (#40682740)
So what you're saying is instead of inspecting the parts, you just try to launch the rockets and try again when they explode. Production is your testing ground. Statistically speaking, if a specific design succeeds a few hundred times in a row, it's probably sound? If it crashes, you just push a patch?

Day 1 patches for space travel?

Thanks, I hate it.