Furthermore, as an avowed enemy of “Clean Code”, I don’t want to see standardization because I fear that well-promoted ideas that I think are terrible would become required dogma. I prefer chaos over order that I don’t like.
Corporations can use that standard exam/license as a baseline and then focus their interviews on domain-specific questions and the like. The existence of standardization does not negate custom processes.
I'll give a very simple example. I did a few SWE interviews in 2020, and several companies did the initial screen over the phone, and the on-site over Zoom.
In both cases it was a remote interview. There was no reason not to do both over Zoom. The only reason was that the previous process was a phone interview and then an in-person onsite, and they realized they had to replace the in-person on-site with Zoom, but they didn't think to replace the phone screen. If you started from scratch it makes no sense though.
In this case, the whole origin of the Leetcode interview is "we're going to hire the smartest people in the world.". You can dispute whether that was true back in 2009 but it was certainly part of Google / Facebook's messaging. Now, in 2024, I think it has morphed much closer to a standardized test, and even if people might begrudgingly admit that, there's still the cultural baggage remaining. If a company used a third-party service, they'd be admitted they're hiring standardized candidates rather than the smartest people in the world. Which might be an "unknown known" - things that everybody knows but nobody is allowed to admit.
It entered the online cultural zeitgeist before that, with Microsoft talking about their interview processes, and indeed early interview books were written targeting the MSFT hiring process that many other companies copied afterwards.
I graduated college in 2006 and some companies still did traditional interviews for software engineers (all soft skills, and personality tests, no real focus on technology, except maybe some buzzword questions), and then you had the insane all day interview loops from MSFT and Amazon.
Back then, Google famously only hired PhDs and people from Ivy Leagues, so us plebs didn't even bother to apply. In comparison, Microsoft would give almost everyone who applied from a CS program at least a call back and a phone screen.
I don't think we found it a barrier to getting adoption from companies though - perhaps because "we're a really advanced company using this state of the art YC-backed assessment" satisfies that psychological need? Unclear.
This is only remotely true if you're looking at a very narrow slice of software development jobs. Those companies and jobs are overrepresented here, but remember that even in the US the majority of developers do not work at recognizable "tech companies." Much less the rest of the world.
I've been a professional software developer for over a decade, changed jobs many times, and never done an intense algorithm interview and I haven't been going out of my way to avoid them. I've even worked at some startups, though never one based in NY or SF. A handful of massive tech companies and their practices are disproportionately influential but they are not actually the norm speaking broadly.
But yeah, the entangling of algorithms questions and coding questions is unfortunate. They're just separate skills. Some people are excellent coders who think "big-O" means something obscene, and some people are a walking discrete math textbook who can't problem-solve to save their lives. Triplebyte split (and Otherbranch splits) the two into separate sections, with coding problems explicitly designed NOT to require any of the common textbook algorithms. It's sometimes a little darkly funny how quickly a particular sort of candidate folds when asked to do something novel that steps outside what they've been able to memorize.
Consider the problem that you're hiring a software engineer and the company has has openings in several different teams that only have the job title in common.
Do you have four different sets of problems that are related to job functions? Does the interview take four times longer? Or do you extend offers to a dozen software developers this week and then have the teams that have the most need / the applicant appears to be best suited for add the headcount there?
If you are giving the same interview to all the candidates (so that you're trying to eliminate bias of asking different questions of different people) ... would that not tend to be solved by asking more abstract questions that are then compared to an agreed upon rubric as to which candidates were "meets expectations"?
... And what if it is for one team that has one set of problems... Do you have the candidates sign NDAs so that you can show them the actual problems that you then go pursue if something leaks? And if today's actual problem is solved tomorrow (unrelated to the applicants solution ... though I've experienced some "here is some real problems we are having" and startups trying to get an hour or two of consulting time for free with no intent to hire), do you give a different interview for someone next week?
The standardized and unrelated work means that you're not accidentally getting in trouble with HR with some bias in the questions or running afoul of FSLA by having someone do uncompensated work that might be related to real things being done.
I think people really do underestimate how much FAANG and Silicon Valley practices have skewed the viewpoint of engineers and technology jobs in the United States. Not just in terms of comp, but in terms of architectural and technology approaches as well. Most of what the big guys do works for them at their enormous scales, but are plain dumb for the vast majority of companies and use cases. Yet we are all infected by the FAANG approach.
1 is obvious: if you need JS devs, most hiring managers won't want to hire Pascal devs and hope they figure it out. We can question the wisdom of this, but it is the reality.
2 is less obvious but not super obscure. Depending on how you structure your teams, similar positions at different companies might require more full-stack knowledge, or better people skills, or something else. IME there is little to no standardization here for developer roles, especially compared to something like HR or Accounts Payable, or even very similar IT-adjacent industries like game development.
Fix both of these issues and we would be able to have something more like a formal apprentice/journeyman/master system for various classes of software developer. As it is, each role actually is pretty much totally unique, at least compared to similar roles in other companies (there tends to be more standardization within the same company).
Every website stack, and the level of complexity under it, is unique, and there's also a huge pay differential.
*could be false assumption on my part
Not exactly, but that's why we have different certificates, endorsements, and type ratings that show demonstrated competence with each type of airplane.
Oh, wait, it does.
Then we’d know this set of language features you’re familiar enough with to hold that cert. It might cut down on the waste and proliferation of useless tech that seems to be strangling the industry because people just want it on their resume.
It would do enough to dissuade companies from hiring non-licensed engineers (hey you could actually call yourself and engineer and not feel like an imposter), and would put a hard liability on things that definitely need it: financial and health data, which seems to be ripe for exploit and disclosure.
One way or another the insanity of the current system needs to stop.
I could ask about how the class loader worked or the syntax associated with a particular construct (that that language level - not anything later) and get the correct answer.
They could pass tests and follow instructions.
Licensure for problem solving is difficult. Extend that to different domains and it is an even harder problem to solve.
https://www.nspe.org/resources/pe-magazine/may-2018/ncees-en...
> The Software Engineering PE exam, which has struggled to reach an audience, will be discontinued by the National Council of Examiners for Engineering and Surveying after the April 2019 administration. The exam has been administered five times, with a total of 81 candidates.
> NCEES’s Committee on Examination Policy and Procedures reviews the history of any exam with fewer than 50 total first-time examinees in two consecutive administrations and makes recommendations to the NCEES Board of Directors about the feasibility of continuing the exam.
> In 2013, the software exam became the latest addition to the family of PE exams. The exam was developed by NSPE, IEEE-USA, the IEEE Computer Society, and the Texas Board of Professional Engineers—a group known as the Software Engineering Consortium. Partnering with NCEES, the consortium began working in 2007 to spread the word about the importance of software engineering licensure for the public health, safety, and welfare.
> This collaboration was preceded by Texas becoming the first state to license software engineers in 1998. The Texas Board of Professional Engineers ended the experience-only path to software engineering licensure in 2006; before the 2013 introduction of the software engineering PE exam, licensure candidates had to take an exam in another discipline.
I think a lot of average programmers will end up accredited if they see it as a path to a job, just like we see with Microsoft certificate programs. And if that happens, I wouldn’t want the accreditation test to be my company’s hiring bar. I’ll still run my own interview to make sure candidates are actually good. And so will most companies. So the time consuming interviews won’t actually go away.
The one big problem licensing would solve is that we could insist some baseline amount of security knowledge is in the tests. Right now, plenty of people get jobs handling sensitive personal data without knowing the first thing about how to keep data secure. That just can’t continue. It’s insane.
It varies on your state but to become a Master X it often requires >5 years. (ex 5 for CO Master Plumber [2], 4 for TX Master Plumber [3], 7 or 5 + Bachelors in NY [4]). Imagine needing to pair program with somebody for 5 years before you could be considered Senior. That'd probably cause a lot more professional development than the current copy from stack overflow meta but also really irritate a lot of young professionals. You can't even quit and start your own business because you can't write software as a journeyman without senior supervision!
[1]: https://www.aopa.org/training-and-safety/active-pilots/safet...
[2]: https://dpo.colorado.gov/Plumbing/Applications
[3]: https://tsbpe.texas.gov/license-types/master-plumber/
[4]: https://www.nyc.gov/site/buildings/industry/obtain-a-master-...
I think another issue is that there's no feasible inspection process or liability management. We have crap like SOC2 and PCI compliance but they're so dependent on self reporting that they mean little practice. Mountains of spaghetti code accumulated over decades are not inspectable like a building is. Software salary costs are already very high and this would push it even further up. It would eliminate offshoring/outsourcing as an option from businesses and they would lobby hard against it. Uncertified software products from other countries would need import controls, and all other sorts of issues that don't exist in our unregulated environment right now
It's also hard to imagine what sort of massive software failure would be required to spur regulatory change that we haven't already experienced and collectively shrugged and did nothing about.
>“Hello, I am a certified pilot.”
>“Great! You start tomorrow!”
Even the most minimal pilots license, a.k.a. the PPL, still requires approximately 40 hours give or take of instruction, taking the ground school exam, and finally passing a check ride with a certified flight instructor.
Flying a passenger airliner as you seem to be alluding to basically means that you have a commercial license and likely an ATP - we're talking hundreds if not thousands of hours of flight experience.
Unbelievable.
That said, at least with airplanes you have to put in the flight hours and they have to be documented. Most commercial pilots start off at very low pay doing puddle jumpers and regional jets. Military experience might give you a leg up because it shows you've spent a lot of hours going through a very regimented program.
My dad was fortunate to get in the industry right before it became an option for the masses rather than luxury and business. It was high paying, glamorous job.
Edit: grabbed the wrong link from my history. Updated to the correct link.
My best reading experiences involve arguing with the book. And talking about those books and my disagreements with them has been useful, too.
Orthogonally, all humans tend to overuse new knowledge/skills. That's part of how humans learn. We try to find out how far the use stretches and in what ways we can apply our new toys! I would expect any successful book on practices to be seen as overused.
Opposite of that is the idea that work and interpersonal habits, communication skills, and domain knowledge are more important than raw programming skill for most jobs.
The last question on the grading form for our interviewers is, to quote it exactly in its current form:
-----
Full interview overall score
(Would you vouch for this person's skills?)
* No no no no no
* Some redeeming qualities but not someone you'd recommend even as a junior hire
* Good for a junior role, still a bit short of a senior one
* Would recommend for a senior role
* Incredible, get this person a job right now
-----
That, to me, is the opposite of what you're talking about. Expert opinion is a central part of what we do, and a big part of what I think gives us an advantage over something like an automated coding test. We just take treat expert opinion as a type of data in its own right so that we can, for example, adjust for whether one interviewer grades more harshly on average than another and make sure that it is actually producing valid results down the line.
Well, the medial profession has a standardized licensing process. It's not perfect, but it certainly keeps the interview process to (mostly) mutual interest.
I think we can learn from the medical profession here. Otherwise, "I prefer chaos" implies that the incompetents are the ones who are the ones who will lose.
Who is having whom? Having a portfolio of work is a well understood benefit, and a lot of candidates have been doing it for some time.
I find treating software engineering like art is a very dangerous approach and bound for failure.
A lot of software engineering comes down to being comfortable with code and how the computer works. That has little to nothing to do with art.
Management puts up with us and they pay us because even though they think they can do our work, they wouldn't want to.
Plumbers are licensed and unionized, two possible solutions to the problems posed in this thread.
Cataloging a list of skills is insufficient information to determine if a person is suited for a role. I don't find it likely that software engineers will be subjecting themselves to a battery of standardize cognitive function tests any time soon.
And that's a skill that's incredibly hard to test for.
The airplane pilot interview process on top of the standardized government certifications includes:
- On-line application (resume and cover letter)
- On-line Psychometric/Aptitude testing (sometimes this is hands-on, on site for some airlines)
- Video Interview, SKYPE or Telephone interview
- Assessment Day (includes: Technical Questions / Panel Behavioral Interview / Scenario Based Questions / Flight Planning Exercise and sometimes a Clinical Assessment)
- Sim Test
- Referee Check
- Medical Check
The exact details differ by airline and I'm assuming the risk profile of the cargo (ie: passengers or not).
Gosh, not so different from software engineers, is it? Except you also need to do a bunch of bureaucratic certifications on top of that.
It’s amazing how often I hear about how easy interviews are in other professions, according to engineers who dislike coding interviews.
Then you look into those other professions and it turns out changing jobs is actually a lot harder than the internet comments would lead you to think.
I'll take having to study Leetcode every few years over all of that any day of the week.
Because I don't know what’s out there, or who will give me the best offer. If you’re skilled and in the middle of your career, it’s easy to find a job, but if your options are wide open, a matchmaking service like this with a wide pool of companies is very valuable.
Here's [1] our practice coding problem. It's quite similar to the one we use on our interview, and not too far from the one Triplebyte used in the past (ours is tuned to be slightly harder at the beginning and slightly easier at the end). The vast majority of candidates, even with some reasonable pre-filtering, do not get past the first step. A very non-trivial number would not even get that far.
Still, seems better then most of the 'leet code' type stuff I see :-)
If you were slow but high-quality on the coding section but crushed the knowledge and system design, we'd probably recommend you - or at least, recommend you to clients that aren't specifically looking for fast coders. Someone we recommended to a client recently had the equivalent of like 1.75 steps on the task linked here, but got consistently high scores everywhere else.
I do wish we could do a more complex, longer coding problem, and one of the things I've been considering is cutting some other stuff to get it up to 45 minutes or something. The current length isn't a principled decision, it's a resource constraint - keeping interviewing costs manageable is essential when you're trying to bootstrap a company in a rough market. Speed matters, but speed over such a short timescale is absolutely artificial (I'd much rather measure speed over a day instead, it's just not practical to conduct a top-of-funnel interview for so long.)
First, you massively underestimate the range of coding speed you see in an interview. The slowest programmers weren’t senior people who were out of practice. (I interviewed plenty of them). It was people who just seem bad at programming. Like, so bad it takes them 25 minutes to make a hello world program run. (In their favorite language, on their computer and with full access to the internet during the test).
A 2x programming speed difference would have rarely changed the outcome of our overall assessment.
Second, there was an aspect of triplebyte’s interviewing process that I’d love to see replicated elsewhere in the industry that resolves this. And that is, we should be assessing debugging ability. At triplebyte we gave candidates a smallish program (few hundred lines) with 4 bugs and a failing test case for each one. The candidates had half an hour to fix as many of the bugs as they could.
Watching people debug was fascinating.
One clear pattern that emerges is exactly what you are predicting. Smart kids right out of school were great at the programming section. But it was always the more senior engineers who smashed the debugging section. Junior engineers would get lost in the weeds and struggle to get very far in the time we gave them. Some of the senior people I interviewed dived straight in, and even found some bugs we didn’t even know about in our own test.
It seems to me that being able to read unfamiliar code and fix bugs in it is a hard to learn skill that matters on the ground. And frankly I suspect it’s more useful skill than a lot of leetcode problems. I’d rather hire someone who’s amazing at debugging than someone who’s amazing at data structures. Well, I suppose I want one of each on my team.
If I was ever making a programming test, this is something I’d include for sure.
However, looking at Other Branch example test, it's another data structure question which I would totally bomb. Is this really the end all be all to dev hiring? If they can't do Data Structures, are they worthless to Silicon Valley companies? I'm honestly stumped because we get dev candidates that crash and burn with Fizzbuzz or our REST API test.
I MUST KNOW.
(For the record, we do ask about DBs and system design in other sections of the interview. The coding is one portion of three for the interview as a whole.)
Maybe I'm just thinking too much problem, overloaded my small attention brain and misread it. I wouldn't call Fizzbuzz data structure-y however.
I'm also mostly outsider looking in. Never worked at FAANG and working with YC companies, I come on much later and tends to be more keeping the lights on and stopping the duct tape rocket from exploding.
A “data structure problem” would involve more exotic data structures, usually of the kind the candidate has to implement themselves. For example, b-trees, heaps, skip lists, and so on.
The reason a lot of people don’t like custom data structure questions is that they come up rarely in most people’s jobs. Lists, structs and enums on the other hand are used everywhere. Your programming job will almost certainly require you to understand them.
But even then, while BFS would definitely work here, so would DFS and that’s simpler. A simple, unoptimised recursive DFS flood fill would be like 8 lines or something given by that stage you already have a function to reveal a cell. You just have to call it on all the adjacent cells. I don't see that as a data structure problem. You could argue it’s an algorithm problem, but it’s about as easy as those come.
Edit: beaten, yes they were overthinking it.
thereby making it a data structure problem
A data structure problem is a problem where designing and implementing an appropriate data structure is in some way hard. A 2d array doesn’t fit the bill. It’s not exotic enough.
I think you might be overthinking this - understanding how to model a problem with a data structure is a core competency of any developer. This isn't a "gotcha" question where you need to know union find sets or how to invert a linked list in place.
If the question was rephrased, "design a JSON schema for the state of the board" would you know how to approach it? Because that's essentially what step 1 is asking.
I really, really, really wish I had a better solution for this sort of thing.
I do wonder how my “part time” output would compare the expectations from full-time output. During the periods I've worked more conventional jobs, the vast majority of the value I brought was during the oddball times/contributions. Surely there must be some way I can be exploited (in a good way) without implicitly bundling ancillary seat warming into the contract. :D
My email is the obvious one given my username, on the off-chance I made a typo.
...it might have been me, I was writing those emails in the year 2018. That was my first job there.
Jokes aside, we generated those emails largely from a template. If I remember right, "saw some real strength" was "got at least an OK score for code quality", while the negative feedback below was about number of steps. The number of mishaps with that system is part of why we do the feedback a bit differently [1] at Otherbranch, at least for now. I think we did revamp it very late in that team's lifetime, just before Triplebyte pivoted and laid off most of the team that did those (two of us, me + one of my colleagues, moved over to a different team, which is why I'm in a position to tell the whole story).
[1] https://framerusercontent.com/images/ARBLIder7AsO5KlaEpClZ3W...
(As an aside I wish Framer'd let me link images directly on the proper domain.)
Combine that with the fact that the upper bound on pay for SWEs is considerably higher than pilots...
Airline pilots are selected to be entrusted with many lives, with the utmost professionalism, and to perform with ability under stress.
And it shows, in the amazing track record of aviation safety.
Most software developers, on the other hand, are mainly paid to mechanically type out code, cribbing from StackOverflow or ChatGPT whenever they don't know something, to "get it done".
And it shows, with the atrocious track record of the entire industry at information security, for one obvious metric.
On the other hand, I'm posting my content post here in part because I know the HN candidate pool is about a trillion times better than I'll get anywhere else. So perhaps I've already lost that battle.
In my more cynical moments I think a lot of the tech hiring process is just a complex IQ test dressed up as a skill test to work around the fact that IQ tests are illegal.
And there’s only so many great engineers around. More companies fighting over the same candidates doesn’t result in a lot of high quality teams.
Thats basically what I was saying. Recent grads don't (typically) have a lot of work experience to look at. So they're looking for the ones that learned/remember the most from their education.
>>In my more cynical moments I think a lot of the tech hiring process is just a complex IQ test dressed up as a skill test to work around the fact that IQ tests are illegal.
Heh - I never thought of that...
>> And there’s only so many great engineers around. More companies fighting over the same candidates doesn’t result in a lot of high quality teams.
True - where I am now we have an awesome team ... some really great talent but oddly, this is one of the places we don't do leet code/take home crap. Its mostly talking about how you solved real problems...IBM on the other hand, was a total cluster f*ck. Anyway, just what I've encountered running around Wall St. and Silicon Valley - your mileage may vary :-)
I have no college experience whatsoever.
It's not actually a mystery. The problem is that that sort of test is de facto illegal (in the US) due to the "4/5ths rule".
Implement Bubble Sort, in 2 Languages of your choice, with multithreading or other language-provided parallelism, with the correct number of parallel threads to be most algorithmically efficient
Would that really not weed out a lot of people? I think it would. I know the above algorithm is hardly production-ready, but the requirements are easy to understand. (It's also a bit of a trick question - there is no optimal algorithmically efficient number of threads in a bubble sort, only the number of CPU cores in the system.)
The same was true of all three of the standard coding problems Triplebyte used. They're not quite literal fizzbuzz, but they require - at best - some basic critical thinking and basic language features, and that is a filter that eliminates 90+% of applicants to dev jobs. Now, granted, this is under time pressure. I imagine, given several hours, most could finish it (although maybe even that is overestimating things). But still.
There's an old Randall Munroe article quoting a physicist:
> The physicist who mentioned this problem to me told me his rule of thumb for estimating supernova-related numbers: However big you think supernovae are, they're bigger than that.
and I feel like this applies to recruiting: however bad you think the average applicant is, they're worse than that.
If anything I think it would have lowered the triplebyte passing rate.
Also arguably the “customer” for triplebyte was the company that eventually hires the candidate. They’re paying in part for the screening process triplebyte did. We wouldn’t have been doing our job if we skipped the interview part of the process.
The other problem is that implementing bubble sort will tell you about their skills in a particular dimension, but being a software engineer these days may look very different depending on the job.
After that I ask a super difficult or niche trivia question like “in CSS, what two overflow properties cannot be used together?” If I’m hiring a mid-level frontend developer and they nail that one, I go “fantastic, great answer, do you have any questions for us?” And the interview can end early.
But if they miss that, no sweat, I’ll start asking more mid-level technical questions to figure out where they’re at.
It tests for pure coding ability, when most organizations should be optimizing for engineers that are going to be productive-if-not-spectacular, that can design and build maintainable systems.
Could I have written the above problem back in my engineering days? Probably not, since I went years not working with threads. But I also wasn't working on problems that would ever have benefited from knowing that. Most software engineering roles are essentially building CRUD or ETL systems, maybe with a user interface. Any coding problems given should be optimized for weeding out bozos (which are still plentiful), not for weeding out the most people.
It’s a form of hazing and rarely does it have any connection to the day-to-day work you do in the job. All of our tests or questions relate directly to the work we will ask you to do in the job, anything else is just trying to be clever and I dislike cleverness in both job interviews and code in general. Cleverness almost always means inscrutable and unmaintainable.
2. 2 Languages of your choice is enough to show you aren't a frameworker and can think in more than one box. Doesn't matter if you do it in JavaScript and C#, Go and Rust, Python and Haskell. It's a chance to show off, while being quite obtainable for a competent developer.
3. The parallelism trick question merely shows that you actually understand what you are talking about. A leetcoder might make the trap of assuming it's log(n), or the square root of n elements, or some other overly-thought-through math that is bogus. If you think it through though, bubble sort is simple enough, that it's very easy to realize (in my opinion) why more threads than CPU cores doesn't really help.
Bubble sort is quite interesting from an algorithm analysis perspective (prove it completes, prove it gets the right answer, prove how it scales with N) but I’d almost rather a programmer I work with not know about it from a coding perspective because it increases the chance they code up a bubble sort than use the sort function that comes with the standard library.
So the mathematically-correct answer would be a minus while "in my opinion" would be a plus?
I think your interview question brings you to your intended answer: the reason why every company makes their own process is because what's good for you would probably get you an instant fail in NASA and would get you labeled as "experience not relevant" in some research settings.
My opinion was only that it would be relatively easy to figure out. As far as I know, it is a certainty that sectioning a bubble sort, more or less than CPU cores, is less efficient. 16 threads on an 8 core CPU just means balancing 2 threads on every CPU core, each doing their own sorting and needing eventual merging back together. There's no way that can be more efficient.
Even your question isn't something I'd necessarily ask on the spot. Many engineers don't use parallelism in their day-to-day work(webdevs). The part about making it efficient is interesting, but feels borderline like a trick question that a good engineer could fumble.
True, it's more of a backend role question. The reason I threw it in there, is from my assumption a leetcode grinder would be very likely to immediately go, "well, the most efficient number of threads is log (n)" or "the most efficient number of threads is the square root of n" or some other plausible-sounding BS answer. But the reason I chose bubble sort, is that it's so simple to understand, that you can fairly easily (I would hope) figure out there's no benefits to more threads than CPU cores at all, as long as you stop and actually think about what it is doing.
Compare [0, 1] [2, 3] [4, 5] ... in parallel and swap if necessary, compare/swap [1, 2] [3, 4] [5, 6] ... in parallel, then go back and forth until no more swaps are made - second element in pair is always greater/less than the first.
That does suggest that the theoretical ideal number of threads is n / 2 ignoring cores, though you'll also want to consider things like cache line size, cache coherency, and actual problem size so it's probably less.
At the end of the day, the important thing would be to actually benchmark your attempts and seeing how it scales with processors/problem size and checking the isoefficiency.
I think it was a bad question.
There are many more job positions posted than will ever be hired for, despite the availability of suitable talent.
Unlike airline pilots (or I'm certain many other professions), every company in the valley insists on re-interviewing a candidate in their own custom and unique way, instead of trusting some sort of an industry-wide certificate only achievable through a standardized test. Wonder if this will ever be solved.
I remember way back in the day where it felt like Triplebyte might finally figure that one out, but it unfortunately never happened.