News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:85% of People Want Global Ban on Single-Use Plastics by lowkey_ on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @03:20PM (#40589199)
I was skeptical of whether it was representative of 85% of the global population, or just the first-world.

I've often thought (and heard that) environmental concerns are secondary to economic, and that people in less prosperous countries don't care as much about environmental concerns as people in first-world countries who are secure in most areas of their lives. Surprisingly, this data says the opposite!

Sample size was: North America: 2000, Central & South America: 3500, Europe: 8000, Africa: 3000, APAC: 7700,

On banning unnecessary single-use plastics being 'important': Australia: 87%, South Korea: 86%, Mexico: 94%, Uganda: 93%,

This may be obvious to some, but I really had the opposite notion until seeing this data.

Re:85% of People Want Global Ban on Single-Use Plastics by dumbo-octopus on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @03:27PM (#40589323)
The response rate is so low as to be entirely meaningless. If you're content with sampling only 0.000001% of the population, you can get any results you want by simply selecting for the people who care the most by taking a bunch of time to lecture the individual if they seem like they'd vote the other way (oh no, you have to leave? but we didn't even have time to submit your vote yet... :( ), and wording the question in such a way to make the answer you want be the only reasonable response.
Re:85% of People Want Global Ban on Single-Use Plastics by pembrook on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @03:38PM (#40589523)
Yep, asking people vague questions about the boogieman du jour is a questionable excercise at best.

If a competing research team had gone out and done a survey with the question rephrased as, "Do you want a global ban on medical syringes and bottled water?"

You might find out, amazingly, 92% of people strongly support single-use plastics!

Re:85% of People Want Global Ban on Single-Use Plastics by lolinder on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @03:42PM (#40589564)
The actual question was [0]:

> The United Nations agreed in 2022 to develop a global treaty to end plastic pollution. How important or unimportant do you believe it is to have global rules to…

> Ban unnecessary single-use plastic products, e.g., shopping bags, cutlery, cups & plates?

As survey questions go, this is actually a pretty precise question.

[0] https://www.ipsos.com/sites/default/files/ct/news/documents/...

Re:85% of People Want Global Ban on Single-Use Plastics by dumbo-octopus on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @03:46PM (#40589642)
Providing the context about the UN treaty makes it unnecessarily loaded. People are biased towards being agreeable, if you start out saying "everyone in the world agrees X, do you also agree X?", people are more likely to say yes than if you asked the question in isolation.

The word "unnecessary" also adds bias, and skews the results: "Of course we shouldn't unnecessarily use plastic. Oh, but my personal water bottle and the bag I get my food in and the cutlery I use to eat it and the... well not those, those are very necessary: I need them to eat and drink!"

Re:85% of People Want Global Ban on Single-Use Plastics by TylerE on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @07:02PM (#40591642)
That's a horrible question. What exactly is "unnecessary"?
Re:85% of People Want Global Ban on Single-Use Plastics by lolinder on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @08:31PM (#40592181)
> e.g., shopping bags, cutlery, cups & plates?
Re:85% of People Want Global Ban on Single-Use Plastics by TylerE on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @08:56PM (#40592311)
Are trash bags nessesary or unnecessary?
Re:85% of People Want Global Ban on Single-Use Plastics by defrost on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @08:59PM (#40592324)
In what context? It's certainly possible to live without them given the existence of large bins, small bins, compost bins, etc.
Re:85% of People Want Global Ban on Single-Use Plastics by TylerE on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @09:25PM (#40592468)
At a huge cost to public sanitation - rats, etc.

That’s my point. These simple things are NEVER as simple as these trite push polls imply.

Re:85% of People Want Global Ban on Single-Use Plastics by defrost on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @09:55PM (#40592641)
> At a huge cost to public sanitation - rats, etc.

Not in my six decades of experience.

The majority of people about where I live don't use plastic trash bags and are well accustomed to keeping mice, rats, cockroaches, etc. at bay.

I must say, I'm surprised the rats of which you speak are apparently unable to chew through a plastic bag ... why are they so disabled wrt other rats about the globe?

Re:85% of People Want Global Ban on Single-Use Plastics by orhmeh09 on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @03:36PM (#40589481)
What do you think is a good sample size? How would you arrive at one?
Re:85% of People Want Global Ban on Single-Use Plastics by dumbo-octopus on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @03:52PM (#40589707)
If your question is asked entirely free of bias from a truly randomly selected population, you can use standard statistical methods to come up with a number based on your desired confidence interval. On the other hand, if you're an organization with your funding tied to the perception that people support your mission, and you're surveying whether people support your mission, I'm going to need damn near everyone in the population to respond to your survey before I'll buy it.
Re:85% of People Want Global Ban on Single-Use Plastics by aunty_helen on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @03:39PM (#40589534)
There isn’t one. Some things are not measurable by this standard and the stats relatively meaningless. 3000 people from a whole continent? Cmon
Re:85% of People Want Global Ban on Single-Use Plastics by kragen on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @05:20PM (#40590763)
please see the introduction to statistical methods linked above at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40590633
Re:85% of People Want Global Ban on Single-Use Plastics by GeoAtreides on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @05:06PM (#40590633)
> The response rate is so low as to be entirely meaningless.

This calculator says you need a 385 sample size for a billion (or infinite) population: https://www.calculator.net/sample-size-calculator.html?type=...

Please check the theory presented below the calculator, it explains why such a low number is enough for a confidence level of 95% that the real value is within ±5% of the measured/surveyed value.

Re:85% of People Want Global Ban on Single-Use Plastics by dumbo-octopus on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @07:07PM (#40591689)
Yes, if you had a list of all 8,000,000,000 people in the world and went to visit 385 truly randomly selected from that list and didn't leave until you got an answer, yes the theory says that would be a reasonably trustworthy sample.

But that theory is useless in practice, when the efficacy of the survey is entirely determined by the sampling bias. Here we have a survey of a few thousand people who had internet access and were on whatever websites promoted this survey and chose to click through the survey and had their votes counted by whatever "spam filtering" logic was used, and multiplied by whatever "population correction factor" was selected, and they're trying to somehow pass it off as "85% of People".

Its bogus through and through.

Re:85% of People Want Global Ban on Single-Use Plastics by Slyfox33 on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @06:02PM (#40591122)
That's extremely dependent on who the 385 people are.
Re:85% of People Want Global Ban on Single-Use Plastics by orhmeh09 on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @06:40PM (#40591465)
TFA goes into this a little

> The samples in Argentina, Australia, Belgium, Canada, France, Germany, Great Britain, Hungary, Italy, Japan, the Netherlands, Poland, the Republic of Korea, Spain, Sweden, and the United States can be taken as representative of these countries' general adult population under the age of 75.

> Due to the fact that the vast majority of the data was collected via Ipsos' online panels (India being the only exception, in which 1,800 were interviewed face-to-face and 400 were interviewed online), participation tends to consist of those who have access to the necessary technology. The samples in Brazil, Chile, Colombia, Indonesia, Ireland, Malaysia, Mexico, Morocco, Nigeria, Peru, Singapore, South Africa, Thailand, Turkey and Uganda are more urban, more educated and/or more affluent than the general population. While not nationally representative, the survey results for these countries provide a useful and unique indication of the direction of public opinion.

>

> Weighting has been employed to balance demographics and ensure that the sample's composition reflects that of the adult population according to the most recent census data.

>

> The precision of Ipsos online polls are calculated using a credibility interval with a poll of 1,000 accurate to +/- 3•5 percentage points and of 500 accurate to +/- 5.0 percentage points. For more information on the Ipsos use of credibility intervals, please visit the Ipsos website.

Ipsos is fairly reputable in the field, FWIW.

Re:85% of People Want Global Ban on Single-Use Plastics by GreatLdisisp88 on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @08:25PM (#40592142)
The calculator also assume random selection. Don't trust statistics math too much. Even in acccounting where only arithmetic is being used, with legal auditing done yearly or quarterly basis, fraud is incredibly common (working in corporates for decades, they even termed it as massaging numbees by financial engineers). This kind of surveys without any audit and legal framework backing it, at 385 sampling is just inviting fraud. At least 2 to 3Mil needed and back by local election boards or local enforcement agencies. If this is done even in communist countries like China or Vietnam will still be way more legit than done in California or Oslo.
Re:85% of People Want Global Ban on Single-Use Plastics by CSMastermind on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @03:48PM (#40589665)
You should consider that this is obviously a "study" meant to manufacture data to support the organization's favored position not a real investigation into what actual people think.

Their conclusion is based on multiple surveys with different questions and methodologies but consider they did things like ask first, ": Before today, had you heard about a challenge called Plastic Free July, which encourages people to refuse and reduce single use plastics?" Told them about the harm single use plastics cause and then asked them, " How important or unimportant do you believe it is to have an internationally binding treaty to combat plastic pollution?" To which a large percentage of people obviously responded that yes it is important.

In another survey they asked, "The United Nations agreed earlier this year to develop a global treaty to end plastic pollution..." with the following question then referencing this treaty, "The treaty will include global rules for participating countries. How important or unimportant do you believe it is to have global rules to:" To which one of th responses was, "Ban unnecessary single-use plastics.", another was, "Ban types of plastic that cannot be easily recycled", etc.

And then they interpret agreeing that there should be a treaty to stop plastic pollution immediately after being given information about how bad it is to be the same as "Ban on Single-Use Plastics" which by and large no one surveyed actually said they wanted explicitly, nor were they asked.

Re:85% of People Want Global Ban on Single-Use Plastics by lolinder on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @03:37PM (#40589502)
Keep in mind that in the methodology [0] the survey company emphasized that "the samples in Brazil, Chile, [...] Mexico, [...] and Uganda are more urban, more educated, and/or more affluent than the general population." It was an entirely online survey, so respondents in poorer places are more likely to be those with internet access and the spare time to be poking around on the internet.

If you restricted the survey in wealthy countries to only the comparatively affluent I would expect you'd see similar percentages as we have here in poorer countries.

I do love that Japan is such a major outlier (only 60% say it's important). They don't have the litter problem that the rest of us have constantly reminding us about the problem.

[0] https://www.ipsos.com/sites/default/files/ct/news/documents/...

Re:85% of People Want Global Ban on Single-Use Plastics by londons_explore on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @03:29PM (#40589352)
Poorer parts of the world have (typically) much worse problems with litter.

Poorer nations typically have no/few refuse collection services, and people often just pile up and burn their own refuse or dump it in rivers to take it away.

That means poorer people see directly the litter rather than an 'out of sight, out of mind' approach.

Re:85% of People Want Global Ban on Single-Use Plastics by buildsjets on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @04:08PM (#40589910)
Poorer parts of the world also purchase a LOT more products packaged in single use packaging than industrialized countries. In the Philippines, pretty much every consumer product that could be sold in a multi-use jar, tube, or bottle instead comes in a single-use plastic sachet like you would get for ketchup in McDonald's. Laundry detergent, toothpaste, hair products, you name it. When you combine that with a lack of waste collection infrastructure, you end up with the Pasig river full of single-use plastic sachets every time it rains.

Here's a well researched report that dives into a lot of the issues of why these plastics are used. It is a combination of economic and societal factors.

https://www.no-burn.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/11/Sachet-Ec...

And here's a article that names and shames which companies produce most of the single use plastic waste found in the Philippines.

https://www.rappler.com/environment/findings-philippines-pla...

https://www.newsecuritybeat.org/2020/09/turning-tap-plastic-...

Re:85% of People Want Global Ban on Single-Use Plastics by wannacboatmovie on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @03:32PM (#40589427)
> Poorer nations typically have no/few refuse collection services, and people often just pile up and burn their own refuse or dump it in rivers to take it away.

Would it not make sense then if they had a container with which to collect and responsibly dispose of the refuse? A plastic bag perhaps?

Re:85% of People Want Global Ban on Single-Use Plastics by dumbo-octopus on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @03:35PM (#40589471)
They have to put the bag somewhere. Paying for a guy to come around and haul your garbage away every week to be responsibly disposed in a secure landfill is laughably out of budget for a huge chunk of the world population.
Re:85% of People Want Global Ban on Single-Use Plastics by Jackim on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @03:36PM (#40589482)
Or maybe we could tackle the root of the problem, avoid waste that doesn't decompose on the human timescale.
Re:85% of People Want Global Ban on Single-Use Plastics by wannacboatmovie on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @03:45PM (#40589632)
Places that still have open defecation and garbage in the streets have bigger issues to be solved before we deduce plastic bags are the problem. E.g. third world.

Seattle and SF have banned plastic bags and the streets are still littered with human feces. Maybe for their next initiative they should pass out reusable bags for people to poop into. Sorry but a feel good measure to make grocery bags illegal doesn't move the needle for me when I still have to play hopscotch with literal logs of human shit.

These priorities are hilariously out of order.

Re:85% of People Want Global Ban on Single-Use Plastics by dumbo-octopus on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @03:32PM (#40589421)
More importantly, the folks who take the time to response to these surveys in poorer countries are much more likely to be the affluent class who spends time in the kind of areas the surveyors are willing to visit, and has spare time on their hands to talk to people.
Re:85% of People Want Global Ban on Single-Use Plastics by ben_w on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @03:58PM (#40589794)
Yeah, was going to say similar.

A decade ago I had the opportunity to visit Nairobi, thanks to my partner at the time.

The place is highly varied, the best looking like any western city, while the worst is basically people living on top of a not-yet-sealed landfill site:

https://www.google.com/maps/@-1.2785067,36.7500781,3a,71.6y,...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Kibera_Nairobi_Kenya_slum...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:MathareValleySlum.jpg

Her brother is involved with a startup whose mission is to help with this, might be interesting to some folks here: https://www.sargasso-reclamation.com

Re:85% of People Want Global Ban on Single-Use Plastics by Havoc on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @03:45PM (#40589630)
Opinions/desires expressed and actual behaviours are very much two things.

Spent most of my life in Africa & actual behaviours line up a lot closer with your instinct. If you're close to the poverty line practicality trumps environment. Choice between paper bag and plastic? Plastic obviously - it's more durable and has more uses later

Re:85% of People Want Global Ban on Single-Use Plastics by primitivesuave on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @03:44PM (#40589612)
Honestly, to me, the 85% statistic is meaningless because the survey is simply asking if you believe "plastic = bad" - a pretty common sentiment, especially in a third world country like India where plastic pollution is visible everywhere. I'd be more interested to see a survey that asks "would you be willing to pay 5% more at the grocery store for plastic-free packaging?"

In less prosperous countries, the majority of consumers are more interested in saving money than saving the environment.

Re:85% of People Want Global Ban on Single-Use Plastics by coolspot on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @09:34PM (#40592525)
Realistically 20-30% more if you pack for example a yogurt into glass instead of plastic. Glass would be like half of net weight.
Re:85% of People Want Global Ban on Single-Use Plastics by Sparkyte on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @03:29PM (#40589349)
Lots of medical supplies are single use plastics.
Re:85% of People Want Global Ban on Single-Use Plastics by verandaguy on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @03:38PM (#40589514)
Medical supplies also tend to have much better-defined disposal processes and ends-of-life than, say, plastic bags or coke bottles.
Re:85% of People Want Global Ban on Single-Use Plastics by Sparkyte on Sunday June 09, 2024 @02:11PM (#40626319)
Irony is depending on what country you're in coke bottles might have a better disposal process than even medical supplies.
Re:85% of People Want Global Ban on Single-Use Plastics by snapplebobapple on Wednesday June 05, 2024 @06:23PM (#40591303)
The key word is "unnecessary". Everyone thinks we should get rid of unecessary plastic. Everyone also disagrees on what is unecessary. ask them if they would pay some percent more for a good to not have some specific plastic and it will be a resounding near unanimous no.