News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A seventh-grader student found a beautiful proof to Thale... by matt3210 on Thursday May 30, 2024 @03:23AM (#40521061)
People seem to forget a lot that child math prodigies are being trained by parents to be math geniuses instead of enjoying being a kid. I had a 12 year old in my freshman CS class and he was the most miserable unhappy kid I've ever seen in my entire life.

Edit: Pretty good points in the replies. Probably a lot of latent jealousy on my side in this. I should have thought on this more before commenting.

Re:A seventh-grader student found a beautiful proof to Thale... by bradrn on Thursday May 30, 2024 @05:55AM (#40521897)
A counterpoint: I was accelerated by three year levels, and it was the best thing that could have happened to me. Otherwise I would have been intensely bored in high school for six years straight, with all the problems that would inevitably have brought.

Of course, this depends so much on the person in question. Acceleration can be great for some people and awful for others. But it’s not about ‘enjoying being a kid’ — that’s something I hear a lot, but I enjoyed myself a lot more in the higher grades where I was actually learning material I found interesting.

Re:A seventh-grader student found a beautiful proof to Thale... by WillAdams on Thursday May 30, 2024 @08:14AM (#40522781)
It is unfortunate that this is not a core principle of education.

The best school system I ever attended rigorously divided classes between social and academic --- for social classes (gym, health, social studies, homeroom) one attended at one's grade level, while for academic classes, (English, other languages, science, math) one worked at one's grade level (but with a cap of 4 grade levels through 8th grade, so a 4th grader couldn't take high school classes) --- after 8th grade this cap was removed, and students could take any classes which they could qualify for academically. To facilitate this, some teachers were also accredited as faculty at a nearby college, and if necessary arrangements were made either for college professors to come to the school and teach, or students travelled to the college.

Most students graduated with at least a little college credit, and many received a college degree along with their high school diploma --- until the Mississippi State Supreme Court decided that it was illegal because it conferred an unseemly advantage on some students with no corresponding compensation for students who were unable to avail themselves of it academically.

Re:A seventh-grader student found a beautiful proof to Thale... by gaurav_v on Thursday May 30, 2024 @10:58AM (#40524549)
Which school was this, and when did you attend?
Re:A seventh-grader student found a beautiful proof to Thale... by WillAdams on Thursday May 30, 2024 @11:02AM (#40524600)
The public school system near Columbus Air Force Base and I attended for 3rd and 4th grades (taking 7th and 8th grade English and science courses) in the '74 and '75 school years.
Re:A seventh-grader student found a beautiful proof to Thale... by smeej on Thursday May 30, 2024 @04:40PM (#40528419)
What did you do when you moved and your new school was expecting you to do 5th grade work?
Re:A seventh-grader student found a beautiful proof to Thale... by WillAdams on Thursday May 30, 2024 @06:00PM (#40529194)
For reading, worked through a box of SRA booklets in a couple of weeks time and then went to the library for the rest of the year --- mostly I was bored and coasted until my classes caught up, and even then, I was able to get decent grades w/ minimal effort.

Of course this all came to a head when I was a junior and the school system couldn't find a teacher for Calculus for myself and the couple of other students who wanted it which pretty much killed my college prospects, so aced the ASVAB, DLPT, and EDPT and enlisted.

Re:A seventh-grader student found a beautiful proof to Thale... by mwigdahl on Thursday May 30, 2024 @11:07AM (#40524645)
Chief Justice Diana Moon Glampers presiding, no doubt...
Re:A seventh-grader student found a beautiful proof to Thale... by WillAdams on Saturday June 01, 2024 @11:55AM (#40546785)
It wasn't too far off from that --- my understanding of the court case was that since some students got free college out of it, the tort demanded that free college tuition be afforded to those students who only graduated with a high school diploma.
Re:A seventh-grader student found a beautiful proof to Thale... by bradrn on Thursday May 30, 2024 @09:07AM (#40523216)
> The best school system I ever attended rigorously divided classes between social and academic

This is such a great idea! And it sounds like it works well in practise, too. I’ve often pondered the idea of separating classes by ability rather than age, and this is a really practical method of achieving it.

Re:A seventh-grader student found a beautiful proof to Thale... by WillAdams on Thursday May 30, 2024 @03:53PM (#40527910)
It worked quite well --- helped that it was a small, cohesive school system with all grades in the same building/complex.

A similar idea is to group children by reading level which makes classes function more smoothly since students finish reading assignments in similar periods of time.

Re:A seventh-grader student found a beautiful proof to Thale... by smeej on Thursday May 30, 2024 @04:39PM (#40528399)
Ironically I think a version of this had to happen in the one-room schoolhouses of yore. If you're the only teacher, you can't afford to split everyone by age. You kind of have to roll people into whatever lessons they can handle and do your best.

It was "innovative," in a way I think we're coming to regret, to suggest that all 8-year-olds (for example) must be at the same level across every subject, and none of them should ever be taught alongside a group of mostly 6- or 10-year-olds.

Re:A seventh-grader student found a beautiful proof to Thale... by DontchaKnowit on Thursday May 30, 2024 @09:31AM (#40523522)
This is brilliant. Would love to see more of this in the US education system.
Re:A seventh-grader student found a beautiful proof to Thale... by smeej on Thursday May 30, 2024 @06:21AM (#40522047)
Can confirm: My parents made me go through the grades one at a time, despite the principal's recommendation that I start in 1st grade, move to 2nd mid-semester, do 3rd grade in the spring, and do two a year after that. It was intensely boring. I can see why they thought a bunch of teens and young adults wouldn't want to be friends with a much younger child, but I've always wondered if they would have been more willing to overlook the age difference than the other young children were willing to overlook the fact that the only thing we had in common was our age.

Ironically, I found it decent preparation for life, though, which seems to be occasional bursts of furious activity punctuated by long stretches of repetition, which could easily become boring. I ended up becoming very good at taking responsibility for making my own life interesting.

Re:A seventh-grader student found a beautiful proof to Thale... by bradrn on Thursday May 30, 2024 @06:42AM (#40522181)
> I ended up becoming very good at taking responsibility for making my own life interesting.

Oh yes… I also spent considerable time teaching myself interesting topics. It’s a good skill to have. But I was still bored a lot of the time, and being able to do the interesting stuff in school too was a much better experience for me.

Re:A seventh-grader student found a beautiful proof to Thale... by smeej on Thursday May 30, 2024 @04:33PM (#40528310)
Ultimately I've had to get to a point where I realize I'm grateful for the life I live now, and accelerating through school would have changed a lot of it, such that I probably wouldn't have met some of the people most important to me, so I'm grateful for it in the long run. But I don't know that I'll ever stop wondering, and it's not a comparative gratitude, because I'm sure my life could have become beautiful like this in other ways. It's more a practice of radical acceptance with gratitude.

I will say one of the things that always made me laugh was that at each milestone, like finishing elementary school and starting middle school, my parents would try to tell me now it would be different, because I was at a higher level. I remember pointing out to them all the same doofuses from the previous years were moving up right along with me, and it wasn't just that I was ahead of them, but that I was faster, so this didn't seem to help. I never did understand why they thought that would work!

Re:A seventh-grader student found a beautiful proof to Thale... by dhosek on Thursday May 30, 2024 @01:19PM (#40526257)
When I was in kindergarten, I was one of a handful of kids who were invited to come back to the school after lunch (this was in the days of half-day kindergarten being the norm) to learn math with the first graders. I got kicked out for being disruptive.

My mom, annoyed at not having her afternoons free, gave me math learning materials to keep me busy. Since she wasn‘t a teacher, she didn’t really know what she was doing and I ended up entering first grade reading at a fifth-grade level and doing math at a third-grade level.

I really should have been skipped ahead at least a year, if not two. The first-grade teacher had me teach the gifted kids in the back of the room while she taught the rest of the class, the second-grade teacher didn’t really know what to do with me and I was bored out of my skull as a result (first and second grade swapped between the two teachers at lunch time with the first-grade teacher focusing on reading and writing, the second-grade teacher focusing on math and science).

Re:A seventh-grader student found a beautiful proof to Thale... by smeej on Thursday May 30, 2024 @04:45PM (#40528499)
One of the last times my parents moved, they sent me this big box they had of papers from my childhood.

One of the ones that fascinated me was dated from when I was in 2nd grade. It was a big printout with rows and columns. Some of them contained numbers, but most of them just said "PHS."

It was an oddly folded poster-size thing, and once I finally got it open, I found out the numbers were grade levels, and "PHS" stood for "Post High School."

I had been 8 when I sat for this test. My parents had staunchly refused to accelerate my education.

And they continued to refuse for ten. more. years.

I might recommend that parents not send their children proof if they went out of their way to stymie them.

Re:A seventh-grader student found a beautiful proof to Thale... by euroderf on Thursday May 30, 2024 @01:58PM (#40526703)
> I was accelerated by three year levels

And you avoided being bullied ? Nice!

Re:A seventh-grader student found a beautiful proof to Thale... by vidarh on Friday May 31, 2024 @12:29PM (#40537130)
I was handed math textbooks a few years above my grade when I was in 5th grade, and it kept me interested longer. I think I overall preferred that, to being moved. Socially I was definitely not ready for being moved into higher grades etc. In highschool my maths teachers mostly let me do my own thing, other than asking if I'd be interested in helping others on occasion, and frankly, that was probably more valuable to me than advancing faster in the subjects. Not trying to contradict you, btw., just another option.
Re:A seventh-grader student found a beautiful proof to Thale... by bradrn on Friday May 31, 2024 @06:16PM (#40540904)
This is completely valid. Like I said, acceleration isn’t right for everyone! I also started out by reading more advanced maths textbooks, and it’s a great thing to do for students where acceleration isn’t a good option.
Re:A seventh-grader student found a beautiful proof to Thale... by blueflow on Thursday May 30, 2024 @04:31AM (#40521416)
As someone who was enrolled in university starting from 9th class - i agree that this is not what children should be made to do. Adults were projecting weird ideas of success onto us.
Re:A seventh-grader student found a beautiful proof to Thale... by TrackerFF on Thursday May 30, 2024 @05:22AM (#40521672)
When I was tutoring HS kids (as a grad student myself), we also had afternoon practices for the kids that wanted to compete in the math olympiads.

Truth be told, some of the kids loved it - but those were the kids that were really passionate about math, for the sake of math.

But you also had a bunch of kids that seemingly hated every second of it. So why did they do it?

- Some had pushy parents that wanted them to excel in extracurricular activities. Think typical tiger parenting...

- Some had big ambitions about certain schools, and felt that they had to compete on a national level in something, in order to stand out in the selection/application process.

Granted, this was over 15 years ago. A couple of years ago I checked up on some of the kids (LinkedIn), and the most passionate kids were either now math/physics Ph.Ds, or Ph.D track.

Re:A seventh-grader student found a beautiful proof to Thale... by graemep on Thursday May 30, 2024 @06:07AM (#40521966)
The post may not make it clear that this was a student of Paul Lockhart's whose main aim is not make maths fun. This is a good teacher, not parental training.

It was also similar to how I taught my home educated kids - do fun stuff. It worked very well. Both love maths (and hugely enjoyed studying in general). My older daughter is doing a degree apprenticeship in electronic and electrical engineering[1] and the younger one got a 9 in IGCSE maths[2] and plans to do A level maths and further maths[3]. The younger one hated maths while she was in school, which is common, and which is the problem Lockhart was trying to solve.

This is not about pushing kids or making them prodigies, it is about making them enjoy what they do, which leads to higher achievement and and happiness.

That said, not all prodigies are miserable. Ganesh Sittampalam who broke the UK record for youngest graduate taught himself for fun until he got into university!

[1] UK term for degree paid for by employer done while working (and getting paid). Good for parental wallet!

[2] UK exams sat at 16. 9 is a top grade.

[3] Closest American thing is APs.

Re:A seventh-grader student found a beautiful proof to Thale... by graemep on Thursday May 30, 2024 @09:08AM (#40523229)
Cannot edit anymore, and spotted a rather bad typo. It should read "whose main aim is TO make maths fun"
Re:A seventh-grader student found a beautiful proof to Thale... by lostlogin on Thursday May 30, 2024 @02:20PM (#40526992)
Having just been caught in a situation where a ‘does’ versus ‘doesn’t’ typo in an email lead to a painful misunderstanding, this made me laugh.
Re:A seventh-grader student found a beautiful proof to Thale... by seszett on Thursday May 30, 2024 @03:48AM (#40521199)
Just to provide another data point, I also had a "math genius" friend at school and he was a well-balanced, fun and reasonably happy person.
Re:A seventh-grader student found a beautiful proof to Thale... by knightoffaith on Thursday May 30, 2024 @04:06AM (#40521291)
Some more data - the math geniuses I knew were actually happier, more well-rounded, and fitter than the average person at my former school.
Re:A seventh-grader student found a beautiful proof to Thale... by junon on Thursday May 30, 2024 @04:48AM (#40521507)
There was a trope - track and math.
Re:A seventh-grader student found a beautiful proof to Thale... by aj7 on Thursday May 30, 2024 @08:53AM (#40523075)
No parent can “train” a kid to be a math genius. There is a wide divide between a “math genius” and having a high SAT score for instance.
Re:A seventh-grader student found a beautiful proof to Thale... by JadeNB on Thursday May 30, 2024 @09:40AM (#40523600)
> No parent can “train” a kid to be a math genius.

While that's true, there's lots of parents who don't believe it, or don't care if the end result isn't actual mathematical genius as long as it's some sort of distinction. (I'm in the happy position where my parents encouraged me to pursue the paths that I enjoyed, which wound up with some acceleration, but my getting in the local newspaper meant that we were besieged by the kind of parents who do just want to push their kids towards some pre-determined "success.")

Re:A seventh-grader student found a beautiful proof to Thale... by lern_too_spel on Thursday May 30, 2024 @10:42AM (#40524355)
While I might quibble with the parenting technique because I believe an interest in useful topics can be cultivated, I'm not going to knock those parents for developing the ability to do hard work. The rest of the world is better off with these kids becoming competent professionals due to parental control than it would be if they became wastrels due to parental neglect or encouragement to pursue useless hobbies. In the US at least, the much larger problem is the latter.
Re:A seventh-grader student found a beautiful proof to Thale... by JadeNB on Thursday May 30, 2024 @03:03PM (#40527443)
> While I might quibble with the parenting technique because I believe an interest in useful topics can be cultivated, I'm not going to knock those parents for developing the ability to do hard work. The rest of the world is better off with these kids becoming competent professionals due to parental control than it would be if they became wastrels due to parental neglect or encouragement to pursue useless hobbies. In the US at least, the much larger problem is the latter.

I think that's a very optimistic view of the outcome of this sort of thing, although it could be that I just didn't describe the parental behavior well. This wasn't parenting telling their kids "hard work is worth it!", but parents who decided on the specific honors that their child would achieve, and would permit no deviation from the path, as a result of which most of these kids either burned out before achieving their goal, or rebelled, usually in self-destructive ways, as soon as they were given a little freedom from parental control.

Different parenting styles work for different people, but for me (as a child in the US in the '80s) I think that my parents did the best possible thing, which was to instill in me lessons about the value and importance of hard work, but to make it clear that, in the end, the decision about whether I would pursue those values was up to me. It probably helped that, despite the many other advantages I enjoyed, my family was insufficiently well off to represent a guaranteed financial fallback for me, so that I knew that, one way or the other, I'd have to make my way in the world—which made it particularly appealing to me to be able to find a way to earn my keep by working hard for something I loved.

Re:A seventh-grader student found a beautiful proof to Thale... by saagarjha on Thursday May 30, 2024 @03:39AM (#40521152)
You don't have to be miserable to come up with a proof like this.
Re:A seventh-grader student found a beautiful proof to Thale... by Larrikin on Thursday May 30, 2024 @03:43AM (#40521173)
What's the take away you want from this comment? Advancement of humanity, feeling bad for missed childhood fulfillments, some mix? Did the child actually meaningfully contribute anything to your class? Were they a real person? Right now there's a lot we've "forgotten" about child geniuses that we should all know from our interactions from them ?
Re:A seventh-grader student found a beautiful proof to Thale... by admissionsguy on Thursday May 30, 2024 @04:50AM (#40521516)
I was an extremely miserable 12 year old in a shit environment. Would have preferred to be miserable in a university class.
Re:A seventh-grader student found a beautiful proof to Thale... by fardinahsan on Thursday May 30, 2024 @03:42AM (#40521165)
Conversely, you can't come up with a proof like this if you don't love math.
Re:A seventh-grader student found a beautiful proof to Thale... by croes on Thursday May 30, 2024 @04:32AM (#40521428)
Why not?

It may be more likely but not impossible.

Re:A seventh-grader student found a beautiful proof to Thale... by bmacho on Thursday May 30, 2024 @12:58PM (#40525956)
Very untrue.
Re:A seventh-grader student found a beautiful proof to Thale... by dhosek on Thursday May 30, 2024 @01:29PM (#40526366)
My son who is just finishingh fourth grade has been demanding harder math problems than he gets in school. He learned how to calculate square roots by hand from a YouTube video and enjoys doing these problems on his own, checking his answers against a calculator. When I pick him up from school, when we’re walking home, he demands that I teach him algebra. I’ve taught him how to solve basic linear equations (ax + b = cx + d) and also I have him take a number and try to find all the sums and differences of pair-wise factors (I haven’t told him why but people who remember high school algebra will recognize this as a skill essential to factoring quadratics) We’re going to learn Trachtenberg Speed Math over the summer. He also enjoys coding and I remember being astonished watching him—without guidance—figure out how to rewrite a program he’d done in Scratch using Python (although right now JavaScript has become his favorite language).

I’ve not pushed him into any of this (I really would prefer that he not pursue programming as a career as I fear that we’re heading to a dark ages of software development, but he can do what he likes).

His twin sister, meanwhile, has been demanding that I teach her social studies so I’ve been doing my best to give her bits and pieces of history and government from my memory. She doesn’t demand the math, but I’ve noticed that she is paying attention during the algebra on the walk lessons as she’ll occasionally jump in with an answer herself.

My purely selfish side wouldn’t object to them skipping a grade as my ex-wife seems committed to them doing K–8 in private schools (even though our local public schools are quite good except at the junior high level, but 6–8 is hell at any school) and skipping a grade would save me a year’s tuition expenses.

Re:A seventh-grader student found a beautiful proof to Thale... by jacobolus on Thursday May 30, 2024 @02:45PM (#40527271)
I recommend you find a copy of Lenchner's book Creative Problem Solving in School Mathematics (2nd ed.). Lenchner ran math olympiads for late elementary school / middle school for decades, and does a good job of covering a wide variety of useful strategies for approaching nontrivial word problems (i.e. real math problems, not just arithmetic drills). But you don't have to be interested in contests per se to get a lot from the book. In my opinion that's going to be more pedagogically valuable and more fun than Trachtenberg Speed Math. Here's an Internet Archive scan https://archive.org/details/creativeproblems0000lenc

Your kid would also probably really enjoy The Number Devil, a breezy novel about a kid who gets trapped in his dreams with a devil who won't stop telling him about elementary number theory, using various dream-world props.

If you want more problems after that, there are a lot of great puzzles in The Moscow Puzzles, or you could take a look at Mathematical Circles: Russian Experience which your kid could probably just about handle.

There are also some great puzzles and games explained at the website of the Julia Robinson Math Festival, https://jrmf.org which can be played with fairly basic easily available materials.