News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Kino: Pro Video Camera by zamadatix on Wednesday May 29, 2024 @06:28PM (#40517813)
I really appreciate that the app is just an up front price! I probably don't really need it but at that price and straightforwardness it's not really a big loss if I don't use it much so I grabbed it. I looked at the other apps and realized they had made Halide as well which I tried out for a bit, for some reason thought it was subscription only & decided I didn't want it that much while clearing out subscriptions, and just (re)noticed they say you can buy it outright too. Initially I probably saw a high price tag and wanted to see how long I'd really like it for but going back into the app I can't seem to find the straightforward purchase option (perhaps because my initial year subscription hasn't expired?) which means I can't find how much it is without searching the net.

Perhaps I'm just uneducated and there is a place to still see it in the app with an active subscription or see the IAP price on the app store but even if there were it'd all just be a pain compared to "It's $9.99, wanna buy?" in your face at the app store and anywhere you read about it.

The only other (very minor) thing that gave me a startle was the onboarding process asks if you want to go "starter" or some other more advanced category. I thought I missed that it would try to upsell you until I reread and saw it meant I could select either layout type out of the box. Not sure that's really the apps fault as much as my paranoia after having just checked through all the above and being left thinking I missed something.

Re:Kino: Pro Video Camera by selectodude on Wednesday May 29, 2024 @06:55PM (#40518055)
Halide has a lifetime IAP for $60 in there.
Re:Kino: Pro Video Camera by stefandesu on Thursday May 30, 2024 @05:19AM (#40521658)
Which was an about 10x increase from the original price. Sure, it was definitely underpriced back then, but it was still a... let's say bold move.
Re:Kino: Pro Video Camera by gregoriol on Thursday May 30, 2024 @08:28AM (#40522886)
I think I've read that the current price for Kino is "launch price" and will be higher in a few days
Re:Kino: Pro Video Camera by altairprime on Thursday May 30, 2024 @03:00PM (#40527419)
$70 is incredibly cheap for photography software. It's cheaper than Capture NX was twenty years ago, without accounting for inflation. I'm sad that they undervalued it at first, but at least they corrected course later on.
Re:Kino: Pro Video Camera by yreg on Wednesday May 29, 2024 @11:01PM (#40519686)
Unfortunately the freemium + subscription model usually works so much better money-wise that it's difficult to justify publishing a simple paid app with upfront cost.
Re:Kino: Pro Video Camera by ClassyJacket on Thursday May 30, 2024 @02:01AM (#40520561)
I'm totally fine with subscription apps, but the price has to be reasonable.

I'm not a video editor so I can't speak to that but here's one example:

Most calorie counting apps want ~16AUD a month from me. That's what Disney+ costs and they spend billions of dollars making content. It's 3$ more than Spotify charges and they have almost every song ever made. It doesn't have to be free, or even a one-off cost, but it has to be reasonable. I'd pay 4$ for calorie counting features. 16? No.

Re:Kino: Pro Video Camera by throw0101d on Thursday May 30, 2024 @08:10AM (#40522752)
> I'm totally fine with subscription apps, but the price has to be reasonable.

I'm fine with it if includes some monthly re-occurring service, like cloud storage/sync.

I purchased YNAB4 and I ran it just fine on my desktop. But YNAB5 went to subscription, and it included things like syncing multiple devices (which of course needs servers, which cost), but I have no need for that, and so I did not move to it. I'd much prefer I pay some one-time fee, and if I want syncing I can subscribe to just that.

I also understand that if I pay $x for Version Y, then if I want Version Z there may be an upgrade fee.

Re:Kino: Pro Video Camera by ryandrake on Thursday May 30, 2024 @08:23AM (#40522851)
> I'm fine with it if includes some monthly re-occurring service, like cloud storage/sync.

What sucks is when the developer adds some recurring service to their software that I don't want, purely as an excuse to justify moving to subscription, and then no longer offers the software without the "service" for a one-time price.

For most of the software I use, I specifically don't want to be tethered to some kind of online service, have to have a network connection to run it, and so on. And I'll actively look for the competing software that's a one-time cost and isn't Cloud-ified.

Re:Kino: Pro Video Camera by domador on Thursday May 30, 2024 @12:24PM (#40525546)
This is a widespread and recurring problem when a software tool that should be a product gets artificially turned into a service.
Re:Kino: Pro Video Camera by ErigmolCt on Thursday May 30, 2024 @10:02AM (#40523851)
And price is often do not come up with this criteria
Re:Kino: Pro Video Camera by joshspankit on Thursday May 30, 2024 @08:44AM (#40523010)
One of my most-used apps is $2/yr and I’m very happy about it
Re:Kino: Pro Video Camera by ErigmolCt on Thursday May 30, 2024 @10:07AM (#40523890)
One of mine is for $10/yr and is not too much but still... And do not have another choice
Re:Kino: Pro Video Camera by sundvor on Thursday May 30, 2024 @04:59AM (#40521569)
Yeah, thanks for reminding me - cancelling MyFitnessPal trial - it's 130 AUD for a year, way more on a monthly basis.

There are some apps in this genre that are absolutely insane - $300 or so for an AI image analyser, which you have no way to try unless you sign up for a trial where you are committed to that amount unless you remember to cancel.

Re:Kino: Pro Video Camera by yreg on Thursday May 30, 2024 @08:26AM (#40522868)
I have an app and I'm trying to figure out the pricing.

I’m offering a one-time in app purchase of life-time subscription. Currently it costs 6x the monthly subscription cost.

I'm worried that makes it too expensive for a simple app, at the same time lowering it would make the monthly subscription less sensible.

I'm curious if anyone has indie experience and thoughts regarding this.

Re:Kino: Pro Video Camera by jessesbye on Thursday May 30, 2024 @12:03PM (#40525277)
I recently discovered Lose It. The pricing is much more reasonable compared to other calorie counting apps - $10USD/year. There's also an option for lifetime purchase but I haven't used it long enough to justify locking in for that much time.

The only annoying thing is you have to get the free app, wait a day or two and then it will offer you the discounted premium subscription.

Re:Kino: Pro Video Camera by FpUser on Thursday May 30, 2024 @10:26AM (#40524140)
I use way too many applications. IF I was subscribing it would be nightmare for me. So I only buy from companies that offer perpetual licenses and upgrade whenever I feel the need.
Re:Kino: Pro Video Camera by ThinkBeat on Thursday May 30, 2024 @01:03PM (#40526019)
It does not work as well anymore as it once did, and it will continue to flatten out.

People can only afford a limited number of subscriptions at a time, and with an ever-increasing number of companies putting their hand into that pocket, there is less to go around.

Re:Kino: Pro Video Camera by augustohp on Wednesday May 29, 2024 @11:32PM (#40519811)
They did the same thing with Hallide.

Give enough time (1-2y) and they will charge a subscription from you and lock you away from the app you've purchased.

Re:Kino: Pro Video Camera by rlt on Thursday May 30, 2024 @04:24AM (#40521374)
That's a rather cynical take. Halide has been around for 7 years and they haven't gone to subscriptions.
Re:Kino: Pro Video Camera by NikxDa on Thursday May 30, 2024 @04:49AM (#40521513)
Halide is 2.99 a month, or 12.49 a year, and has been a subscription model since 2020. Sure, you have a one-time purchase option, but it is $70. I believe people who bought before the subscription got one year free, but things like widgets aren't supported. So unfortunately, that is likely the same fate for Kino.

This post introduces the subscriptions: https://medium.com/halide/introducing-halide-mkii-30f9f2bcea...

Re:Kino: Pro Video Camera by zamadatix on Thursday May 30, 2024 @05:35AM (#40521753)
I'm fine if I can get a reasonable number of years out of it. I'm not expecting infinite updates forever for $9.99. 1-2y for this would be disappointing but not even a bad deal. On Halide it seems the problem is more "pricing in general" - a 1 year subscription costs more than the one time purchase in this app so naturally expecting get and keep the app plus years of updates is a bit eyewatering for a camera app (but not necessarily because of the pricing model/that it switches major versions in long cycles).
Re:Kino: Pro Video Camera by gcr on Thursday May 30, 2024 @10:46AM (#40524404)
There's "I expect to get three years of value for $9.99", and then there's the "Halide isn't a subscription product, what are you talking about" people in this thread.

The unpredictability of the pricing model itself is an important point.

Re:Kino: Pro Video Camera by domador on Thursday May 30, 2024 @12:20PM (#40525481)
Speaking of infinite updates forever, I am frustrated that software publishers and users have come to expect that all software should either be free, subscription-based, or a one-time purchase with permanently free updates. Each of these models can make sense for different kinds of software-based products and services, but they are problematic in the case of standalone tools (such as cameras, multimedia editors, productivity software, etc.) Some of the problems:

a) Free: Due to lack of revenue, the company that makes your favorite tool may stop developing new features, add intrusive ads, sell your personal data, and/or sell itself to a nasty buyer that will end up killing your tool’s future in one of various ways.

b) Subscription-based: Many software tools are naturally products, not services, yet this model can artificially and unnecessarily turn them into services. Users may end up paying too much over the long run, the software publisher is not necessarily motivated to keep improving the tool, and if the company or a future owner decides to kill off the product, you won’t be able to keep using it (regardless of how much more you’d be willing to pay to do so.)

c) One-time purchase with permanently free updates: Though it provides the software publisher with revenue and users may appreciate the ability to keep using the tool they bought forever, the product may experience market saturation at some point, and the publisher may stop receiving revenue from new users. The publisher will not be motivated and/or financially able to improve the program and may be tempted to switch to the subscription-based model.

I really wish more companies would go back to the old-style model where users can buy the current version of a software tool but would need to pay a discounted price to upgrade to a newer version of that tool (a major-version upgrade.) Along with this, customers would get free upgrades for a limited time (such as year) or all minor upgrades during the current major version. I believe this model creates a healthy incentive for a software publisher to keep improving its products while receiving revenue from both new and existing customers (reducing the market-saturation problem.) Unfortunately, both publishers and especially users may have grown unaccustomed to this model and may not appreciate its benefits.

Re:Kino: Pro Video Camera by bonney_io on Saturday June 01, 2024 @07:40AM (#40544884)
> I really wish more companies would go back to the old-style model where users can buy the current version of a software tool but would need to pay a discounted price to upgrade to a newer version of that tool

We can thank Apple for this! They refused to adopt upgrade pricing on the App Store (which developers have been asking for since the App Store launched!) and instead introduced Subscriptions.

I like Apple, overall, but they absolutely decimated their software market by forcing apps to either be free with ads or paid subscriptions.

Re:Kino: Pro Video Camera by itsoktocry on Thursday May 30, 2024 @12:46PM (#40525801)
>I'm fine if I can get a reasonable number of years out of it. I'm not expecting infinite updates forever for $9.99.

"Reasonable number" implies that you're fine with it. But where is that threshold? I bet it's different for everyone.

Companies need to be up front with what they are charging for. "Let's say $9.99 because we're not even sure if we'll be around in 5 years" is not a good model.

Re:Kino: Pro Video Camera by zymhan on Thursday May 30, 2024 @01:44PM (#40526534)
> you have a one-time purchase option, but it is $70

That is a perfectly reasonable amount of money for consumer software to cost.

Re:Kino: Pro Video Camera by sandofsky on Thursday May 30, 2024 @07:35AM (#40522500)
We have never, ever locked away Halide from people who already purchased it. If you bought Halide 1.0 in 2017, you can still use it today, with all the features you bought, without paying another penny.
Re:Kino: Pro Video Camera by jsjohnst on Thursday May 30, 2024 @08:48AM (#40523033)
Personally, for the tiny amount I paid back in 2017 for the app, $59.99 one time now is cheap to me. That’s under $1/month over that time which is well worth it to me. If I got “locked out” if I stopped paying, then I’d feel different, but that isn’t the case so keep up the good work!
Re:Kino: Pro Video Camera by jsjohnst on Thursday May 30, 2024 @08:41AM (#40522988)
I’ve been a Halide customer since the first week it was released. I’ve gotten numerous updates since and not been locked out of anything available when I purchased (and including many new things since too) without having to pay another dime. In fact, the app has never even mentioned the option to subscribe, I only learned of that option via this thread and found it buried deep in settings. I value their work, so I’ll now pay as I heavily use the app (among other of their products), but to say I’ve been forced to and/or “locked out” is dare I say grossly inaccurate at best.