News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Inventing Cyrillic by keiferski on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @01:47AM (#40497701)
As a Polish-American guy, it’s a bit painful to use the Latin alphabet with Slavic languages. It works, but at the cost of your name being unintelligible to anyone west of Vienna.

Cyrillic is much more suited for Slavic languages, but of course there is so much historical baggage there that it’ll never happen. Cyrillic is a civilization-level thing tied to a lot of cultural elements, not merely a different set of symbols.

What will be interesting to see is if Bulgaria, Serbia, and Ukraine continue to use Cyrillic or gradually switch to Latin.

Re:Inventing Cyrillic by farmdve on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @01:51AM (#40497717)
Well, Bulgaria has a lot of borrowed words now, but I don't see even a hint of switching to the Latin alphabet. Not even a hint.
Re:Inventing Cyrillic by keiferski on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @01:53AM (#40497734)
I mean in the longer term. Bulgaria has a lot of population issues and seems somewhat torn between the West and the Russian spheres, so I don’t think it’s inconceivable that in 50 years (after generations grow up online familiar with computer-based Latin alphabets) they formally switch to using it.

Serbia would probably switch first, though. When I was there a half decade ago, Latin and Cyrillic were used interchangeably. But it’s my understanding that Latin is much more popular amongst the young.

Re:Inventing Cyrillic by dustark on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @02:33AM (#40497963)
It doesn't seem like you know what you're talking about. Have you ever been to Bulgaria, or are you just fantasizing? People in Bulgaria are already familiar with the 'computer-based Latin alphabet' and speak English decently well (at least anyone under 40). Also, I'm not sure what the population issue has to do with what alphabet they use. People will magically switch to the Latin alphabet because... there are fewer of them? By that same logic, should we expect Japan and South Korea to start using Latin characters too ?
Re:Inventing Cyrillic by keiferski on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @02:41AM (#40497996)
Let me state this again, because people really seem to have a difficult time understanding my comment:

I said it was plausible that Bulgaria could switch to the Latin alphabet in a long time. The word plausible implies that it could happen, but is not guaranteed, or even likely. It is conceivable, it is a possible future. It doesn’t mean I think it will absolutely happen.

The reasons I think this switch is plausible are:

- the growing adoption of Western and EU Latin-based culture amongst the youth. The government and institutional power structures in Bulgaria are still largely populated by people who are over 35 years old. In 50 years, this won’t be the case, and the people filling the jobs will have been influenced by Latin-alphabet culture for decades.

- The population decline of the country is going to present serious issues. Some of the solutions to it will probably be closer integration to the EU, which almost entirely uses the Latin alphabet. Also factor in the Bulgarian diaspora which is growing up in Latin-language places elsewhere in the EU.

- The current geopolitical situation, wherein future Bulgarians may (again, plausibly) want to distance themselves from the Russian-dominated Orthodoxy world, of which the Cyrillic alphabet is still a fairly strong connection. Also consider that Orthodoxy itself is in decline, and so having this connection might not be that important to the Bulgarians of 2074. I foresee a similar thing amongst the youth in Poland and Catholicism.

Re:Inventing Cyrillic by bluetomcat on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @04:27AM (#40498640)
As someone who is familiar with the political and social atmosphere in the country, I'll give it a try.

The growing adoption of "Latin-based culture" is not interfering with the usage of Bulgarian. Bilinguality is the norm for the newer generations. More than a decade ago in the pre-Unicode world, writing emails and communication in Bulgarian with Latin letters was acceptable because of encoding issues. Nowadays, it is no longer the norm, is frowned upon and is even ridiculed.

There is a considerable part of the intellectual elite that is pro-Western and seeks further integration with the west. They are perfectly fine with the alphabet and switching it is not on their agenda. These are, for example, professors, philosophers and linguists from Sofia university.

Re:Inventing Cyrillic by keiferski on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @08:06AM (#40499860)
Thanks for an actual reply, I appreciate it. I agree it’s unlikely for a switch (and my original comment expressed nothing more than saying it was plausible) but I do wonder if younger generations will be more Latinized. The bilingual approach is an interesting one and seems quite likely to continue, I agree.
Re:Inventing Cyrillic by dustark on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @02:51AM (#40498060)
No one is having difficulty understanding your comment. It's just very clear to someone who lives in Bulgaria that you don't have first-hand knowledge of what you're talking about, and your speculations about what might happen 50 years from now are not grounded in reality. No one in Bulgaria uses the Latin alphabet to write in Bulgarian, and there's no indication that this will change. As the French say, 'avec des 'si' on mettrait Paris en bouteille'.
Re:Inventing Cyrillic by keiferski on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @02:52AM (#40498072)
I’d be glad to hear your responses to my three points and why I am so far off.
Re:Inventing Cyrillic by farmdve on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @06:50AM (#40499372)
He did and so did I, you are just selectively ignoring them and gaslighting us.
Re:Inventing Cyrillic by horsh1 on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @02:58AM (#40498112)
50 years is a long time.

Between the existence of Austria-Hungary empire, when the Latin alphabet was very relevant for all the Balkans, and the end of WW2, when the Cyrillic became much more relevant for them is just 1945-1918=27 years.

Re:Inventing Cyrillic by MilanTodorovic on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @02:39AM (#40497984)
In Serbia, Latin is "popular" because it is the default in all computers and phones. Most don't bother switching or don't know how. In the old days, when sending an SMS had a price, using cyrillic letters was expensive as hell. You could barely write one third of an SMS for the same price. And that adds up pretty quickly! On a side note, as someone who has to use multiple keyborad layouts each day, it is annoying.
Re:Inventing Cyrillic by keiferski on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @02:42AM (#40498003)
And in a few generations, you don’t think this usage of computers and phones is going to have a serious impact on how Cyrillic is used? People are going to use Latin on phones and computers all day long but still use Cyrillic just as much?
Re:Inventing Cyrillic by MilanTodorovic on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @07:04AM (#40499467)
It most certainly will have a big impact. It will take a few more decades, but at some point everybody will simply switch. Both formes are equal in the eyes of the consitution, but Cyrillic is prefered by official insitutions, except if you deal with a lot of foreign affairs. Then it is more practical to simply use Latin all the way.
Re:Inventing Cyrillic by gostsamo on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @01:56AM (#40497755)
This is part of the national identity. No chance in hell.
Re:Inventing Cyrillic by bogosmith on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @03:29AM (#40498314)
I remember back around 20 years ago someone on this radio station https://bg.wikipedia.org/wiki/%D0%9C%D0%B8%D0%BA%D1%80%D0%BE... was expressing support of the idea of switching to the Latin alphabet as a natural step in the integration of the country in Europe/ new digital age/ or something along those lines. His conclusion seemed to be that "society wasn't mature enough".
Re:Inventing Cyrillic by keiferski on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @02:00AM (#40497768)
Bulgaria’s population is set to halve by 2100, so again, considering the importance of Latin-based languages globally, integration into the EU, etc. I don’t think it’s that inconceivable. Maybe just not likely soon because of the historical connection to Cyrillic.

Again, I didn’t say it will happen, just that it seems conceivable to me.

Re:Inventing Cyrillic by gostsamo on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @02:50AM (#40498059)
Maybe reflect on what made you think that a nation would just scratch more than a thousand years of culture so that it is easier for facebook engineers to encode their web page. Have no other comment, really.
Re:Inventing Cyrillic by keiferski on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @02:57AM (#40498103)
There are plenty of other examples of countries switching to a new alphabet, even when it would cut people off from their history. Turkish being a prime example. It has nothing to do with making life easier for Facebook engineers and I’m not sure what that has to do with anything. It has everything to do with what real people do in their daily lives, and what government institutions mandate.

These sarcastic replies are so tiresome and intellectually uncurious.

Re:Inventing Cyrillic by gostsamo on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @03:20AM (#40498252)
When met with extreme obliviousness, sarcasm is the only escape of the mind.

Turkey switched lots of things as a deliberate act of cutting off with its past, including form of government, constitution, and legitimacy model, and after losing wars and territories for centuries. The fact that you disregard the context to arrive at the desired conclusion might have something to do with the intellectual difficulties you find yourself in.

Re:Inventing Cyrillic by keiferski on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @03:22AM (#40498259)
You can’t seem to leave any comment without adding some sort of sarcastic rude put down, which really isn’t in the nature of this site, nor is it conducive for having an interesting discussion about the future of language. Learn some manners and try again, this time with actual arguments.
Re:Inventing Cyrillic by farmdve on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @03:19AM (#40498242)
Ok, and just because a few countries did it, in what way implies that Bulgaria will? Your arguments have no basis other than "Country A did it, so Bulgaria is also more likely to do it".
Re:Inventing Cyrillic by keiferski on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @03:20AM (#40498250)
I said it was plausible.

Try reading the comment again.

Re:Inventing Cyrillic by farmdve on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @03:23AM (#40498267)
It is only plausible based on your own subjective views and cultural projection. As of now, it has no basis on any fact.
Re:Inventing Cyrillic by keiferski on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @03:24AM (#40498283)
Ok. Well I’ve written a few long comments on why I think it is plausible, but you and the other commenter don’t seem to have actual responses, just insults. Hence this conversation is a waste of time.
Re:Inventing Cyrillic by b3orn on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @08:23AM (#40500011)
Your example using Turkish isn't that good. Turkic languages like Turkish or Kazakh switched to a latin alphabet because the arabic or cyrillic writing systems didn't suit them. The cyrillic script was explicitly created for slavic languages, so there's no need for slavic languages to switch to a latin based alphabet.
Re:Inventing Cyrillic by keiferski on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @10:16AM (#40500964)
Turkish switched to the Latin alphabet and thereby cut itself off from over a thousand years of history and interaction with the Islamic world via Persian and Arabic. This decision was made more for political reasons, as Ätaturk wanted to Westernize the country, than for strictly linguistic ones.

Atatürk also commented on one occasion that the symbolic meaning of the reform was for the Turkish nation to "show with its script and mentality that it is on the side of world civilisation".[26] The second president of Turkey, İsmet İnönü further elaborated the reason behind adopting a Latin alphabet: "The alphabet reform cannot be attributed to ease of reading and writing. That was the motive of Enver Pasha. For us, the big impact and the benefit of an alphabet reform was that it eased the way to cultural reform. We inevitably lost our connection with Arabic culture."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Turkish_alphabet#History

Re:Inventing Cyrillic by citrin_ru on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @03:28AM (#40498301)
It’s hard to see how switching alphabet would help euro integration. Looking at other countries - economical and political reforms required for EU membership is the real barrier, not the alphabet. And switching alphabet would have a huge cost not helping the economy.
Re:Inventing Cyrillic by farmdve on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @03:13AM (#40498205)
For a while in the early 2000s to late 2000s there was a very widespread usage of 4 and 6 replacing the ch and sh sounds. In hindsight, this was more likely to replace the letters 'ч' and 'ш' than Latin letters.

However it died out.

Re:Inventing Cyrillic by bluetomcat on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @02:07AM (#40497814)
There’s a new wave of nationalism emerging in Bulgaria. Any interference with the national identity would be seen as blasphemy, done by foreign agents paid by the “embassy”.
Re:Inventing Cyrillic by keiferski on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @02:13AM (#40497846)
That’s why I said in 50 years. 50 years ago, before Solidarity in Poland, before Reagan, etc. - the Soviet Union seemed like it would last centuries. It’s a long time.

And although I have only visited Bulgaria and not lived there, I do live in a neighboring country and see how much Western culture / EU culture dominates the local youth culture.

On the institutional level, it would likely take the efforts of an Ataturk-like figure that wants to tie Bulgaria more to the West.

Re:Inventing Cyrillic by bluetomcat on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @02:59AM (#40498117)
In the longer term, too many unpredictable factors can collide, so anything is possible.

Particularly in Bulgaria, the youth is dominated by western culture only at the surface level. It’s in their consumption patterns, the outfit and the slang. Apart from that, it’s not a western culture by a long shot. The competitive individualism is not there. The family is expected to give a good and steady start to their children, at the cost of the comfort of the parents. The national symbols like the alphabet are encoded and institutionalised through the educational system. For example, all schools are marching through cities on the 24th of May, to celebrate the alphabet and enlightenment (просвета) in general.

Re:Inventing Cyrillic by horsh1 on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @02:46AM (#40498026)
Why Latin? At the moment of EU dissolution, there will be an easy choice of switching to Arabic vs staying with Cyrillic.
Re:Inventing Cyrillic by vsnf on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @01:54AM (#40497746)
> What will be interesting to see is if Bulgaria, Serbia, and Ukraine continue to use Cyrillic or gradually switch to Latin.

Turkmenistan of all places is currently undergoing a gradual switch to Latin, which has happened in fits and starts with various mandates to do so, and then to stop doing so. But the culture seems pretty undeniably to be trending to romanization.

Re:Inventing Cyrillic by 331c8c71 on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @02:06AM (#40497804)
Kazakhstan as well if I understand correctly. These languages are Turkic though so cyrillic script is not such a natural fit.
Re:Inventing Cyrillic by culebron21 on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @02:58AM (#40498109)
I'd disagree that Cyrillic is not a natural fit. No writing system was a natural fit for Turkic languages.

Arabic script? Turkic languages have lots of vowels, which are very important, and a lot less fricative consonants. You must add a lot of "diacritics" (points above or below).

Latin adapted for Turkish has same issues: a lot of diacritics, and also the infamous i/I distinction (like peek & pick in English) that causes typos.

Cyrillic for Turkic languages simply introduced more letters. For example, in Kazakh the vowels а, о, у, э, е, ы were extended with ә, ө, ұ, ү, і. Consonants got their fricative counterparts: к, г => қ, ғ. The only inconvenience I see is Latin "h" (e.g. жиhаз, furniture) which can't be capitalized -- it will collide with Cyrirllic Н (N). I actually find it easier to transcribe German in Kazakh letters than in pure Russian ones.

The flip side is you need a bigger keyboard, the number row gets used for letters too.

In Kazakhstan, the transition to Latin lost traction even in the state organs: every legal document is written in Cyrillic. In Uzbekistan the attempt was made ~25 years ago, IIRC, and still even state organs print a lot in Cyrillic. They allowed writing in both systems as legally equal for 10 years, but had to extend the transition period for another 20, IIRC.

So supposing it's the cultural trend is quite disputable -- I'd say only nationalists with decolonization agenda may want it (but then why not the old Arabic writing system?). The majority doesn't care nor want to switch.

Re:Inventing Cyrillic by thaumasiotes on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @02:44AM (#40498015)
> These languages are Turkic though so cyrillic script is not such a natural fit.

What do you mean? It's a set of symbols. No different from any other set, except potentially in size. What would a "natural fit" between a script and a language look like?

Re:Inventing Cyrillic by sampa on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @01:59AM (#40497766)
but they have a Turkic family language there, not a Slavic one
Re:Inventing Cyrillic by vsnf on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @02:22AM (#40497900)
Right, but like a sibling poster pointed out, they've been using Cyrillic, so the migration is similar, at least.
Re:Inventing Cyrillic by kgeist on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @02:47AM (#40498033)
Not quite - several Slavic languages have so called contrastive palatalization, i.e. almost all consonants come in palatalized/non-palatalized pairs, and they're hard to express using unmodified Latin alphabet. Some Slavic languages lost most of the contrastive palatalization (say, Serbian), and Turkic languages never had it to begin with, so they're easier to switch.

In Europe, Polish and Irish are two examples of a language with extensive contrastive palatalization which uses the Latin alphabet, and they're probably among the least readable/elegant writing systems in Europe.

Re:Inventing Cyrillic by culebron21 on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @05:55AM (#40499078)
Turkic languages do have constrastive palatalization system, going together with "soft" & "hard" vowels. (Example from German: a, e, o, u would be "hard", ä, ö and ü would be "soft" vowels for Kazakh speaker) In Kazakh, kerek (need) is palatized completely, while in kara (black) consonants are not. In "shanyrak" (yurt roof top window) consonants aren't palatized and "k" is fricative, in shelek (bucket) "k" is palatized and non-fricative. Since palatized consonants go together with "soft" vowels, one may omit this distinction in writing. But the difference is still there. N.B. Some Turkic languages have lost this feature.
Re:Inventing Cyrillic by kgeist on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @06:16AM (#40499174)
>Since palatized consonants go together with "soft" vowels, one may omit this distinction in writing. But the difference is still there.

Sure, many languages have palatalized consonants, influenced by surrounding phonetic context (such as, vowel harmony in Turkic makes surrounding consonants "softer" too).

The true "contrastive palatalization" I was referring to is about having minimal pairs where words have totally different meanings based on whether the consonants are palatalized or not.

For example, in Russian (where I specify the palatalization of a preceding consonant with ʲ):

  mer "a mayor"
  mʲer "of measures"
  mʲerʲ "measure!" (imperative)
Latin alphabet has no means to express it naturally, while in Cyrillic there're already all the required letters for it. Just omitting it in writing will introduce confusion.
Re:Inventing Cyrillic by Koshkin on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @03:48PM (#40504831)
Cyrillic was not a bad choice for Tajik. In any case, I think it is better (than Arabic script) suited for Indo-European languages like Persian. (On the other hand, it would have been fun to see Spanish also use Arabic script. :)
Re:Inventing Cyrillic by larodi on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @03:07AM (#40498168)
This switch in other Slavic countries, you must understand, is thanks (caused by) the adoption of Catholicism. So nothing to do with what people decided, really, it was a political/church decision. I doubt Bulgarians would ever toss the Cyrillic away, as it gives so much identity to the country and the people there.
Re:Inventing Cyrillic by postepowanieadm on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @02:51AM (#40498064)
> It works, but at the cost of your name being unintelligible to anyone west of Vienna.

Same thing would still be true with cyrylic I believe.

Re:Inventing Cyrillic by keiferski on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @02:55AM (#40498094)
One interesting consequence of the Latin-Cyrillic split in America is that Cyrillic names got transliterated into English-understandable ones, whereas Polish Latin names often didn’t. With the result that the originally-Cyrillic names are actually easier to understand in daily life.

Compare for example, Kuznetsov (fairly easy to say in English) vs. Kwiatkowski (ported directly from Polish.)

Re:Inventing Cyrillic by postepowanieadm on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @05:48AM (#40499049)
It's a different issue not related with alphabet only with American tradition regarding Surnames. Same issue exists for example with Polish and Lithuanian both using latin alphabet.
Re:Inventing Cyrillic by Koshkin on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @04:10PM (#40505027)
But compare:

The Polish "chrząszcz" vs. the Cyrillic "xрущ" vs. its usual transliteration into English as "khrusch".

Re:Inventing Cyrillic by BerislavLopac on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @02:54AM (#40498083)
It's a shame that Glagolitic hasn't caught up and remained relevant like Cyrillic did. On the upside, at least now we have our own historically accurate fantasy script. ;)|
Re:Inventing Cyrillic by holoduke on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @02:19AM (#40497882)
Ukraine switching to Latin? I have never heard that before. It would be very annoying. Latin alfabet is not suited for eastern slavic languages. My Latin Russian is already so rusty. There are 10 different ways to write certain letters in latin. In Cyrillic just one.
Re:Inventing Cyrillic by usrnm on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @03:00AM (#40498123)
> In Cyrillic just one

That's not true. Depends on the language, of course, but at least in Russian there are definitely more than one way to express many sounds using different letters. For example, there is no difference in pronunciation between "ёлка" and "йолка", although only one of them is accepted as correct

Re:Inventing Cyrillic by keiferski on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @02:26AM (#40497924)
Linguistically it would be pretty annoying, I agree. Although perhaps not dramatically different from the romanization of Slovak or Polish.

The point is more that there are many obvious political reasons why a future Ukraine might go down this path.

Re:Inventing Cyrillic by andrewl-hn on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @04:35AM (#40498678)
Ukrainian written in Latin really highlights the fact that it has more common words with Polish than with Russian. In general, the two languages look remarkably similar and sound close to each other, too.

Some Ukrainian writers used Latin script for their works in 19 century, so at least there’s a precedent.

Re:Inventing Cyrillic by holoduke on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @11:37AM (#40501798)
99.9% of the Ukrainians never ever would have a latin version or their language. Maybe some extremists from Kiev. Sponsored by the west probably.
Re:Inventing Cyrillic by agapon on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @04:43AM (#40498724)
There have been several Latin based scripts proposed for Ukrainian over many decades. So, if you haven't heard, you just haven't been interested.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ukrainian_Latin_alphabet

Re:Inventing Cyrillic by GoblinSlayer on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @02:48AM (#40498040)
Write it in Greek?
Re:Inventing Cyrillic by TheMatten on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @10:20AM (#40500988)
I don't think it's really about Latin vs Cyrillic. Cyrillic is indeed very natural even for Slavic languages that only use Latin (modulo language-specific tweaks), but same results can be achieved with diacritics in Latin - take a look at Czech, Slovak and Serbo-Croatian alphabets. On the other hand, Polish alphabet really feels painful to an outsider, but that seems to be more about how it uses Latin, not about Latin itself.
Re:Inventing Cyrillic by Koshkin on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @03:42PM (#40504765)
> diacritics

Tiếng Việt hay Việt ngữ là một ngôn ngữ thuộc...

Re:Inventing Cyrillic by broken-kebab on Tuesday May 28, 2024 @06:03PM (#40506097)
>bit painful to use the Latin alphabet with Slavic languages. It works, but at the cost of your name being unintelligible to anyone west of Vienna.

I'm not sure what you mean. Using Cyrillic would make it more unintelligible.

Re:Inventing Cyrillic by mmaniac on Thursday May 30, 2024 @09:19AM (#40523359)
It's interesting to observe how foreign writing systems fit the needs of the languages they are were designed to record.

Korean Hangeul is the gold standard here. Letter shapes represent their articulation and harmony and modify in regular ways to represent related pronunciations. You find similar observations in the writing systems for Arabic, Hindi, and Chinese. In the case of Cyrillic, it's that vowels come in soft and hard pairs.

Perhaps it's bias, but the Latin alphabet seems unopinionated by comparison. It has a good spread of characters for consonants and vowels and is amenable to diacritics or even novel characters. The only thing it's seriously lacking is a good way to transcribe tones. Chinese characters are great for writing a language with a near-1:1 morpheme:syllable correspondence, but its adaptation to write Japanese was famously clumsy.