It was "just" an offer with a large premium over the current stock price.
So I suppose if you were sitting on 300k in equity it was now worth 480k, but it's not like going from illiquid paper wealth to a liquidity event...and given the company's growth trajectory it seemed likely at the time that it would get there in a year or two on its own, without a (risky) acquisition.
Dunno, doesn't seem like a slam-dunk case of F-you money to me.
Exits are for founders / top-level guys.
They didn't do it for the personal money, they did it because they thought their shareholders would sue them, at least in part, for turning out a deal that was too good to be true.
Note that I'm not saying that others who don't avoid those things are wrong -- they're not at all. They just have different business goals and priorities than I.
> Williams wasn’t a game designer, but a visionary who saw the company always moving forward, leading the market with other genres, other software, online worlds connecting every kind of person. That Sierra is instead remembered, basically entirely, for these 2D adventure games from the eighties and nineties is, he says, because the company was killed.
With respect to Ken, I think his ambition outstripped his ability. He prided his company on being something it wasn't, and himself being something he wasn't either. Sierra had to be something big, he had to be something big; his favored fraudster knew exactly how to exploit that self-illusion. In reality, Ken's own wife hints that Ken was struggling as CEO even before selling, e.g. failing to see through people, over-relying on lieutenants when making decisions, etc.
For all the talk of murdering Sierra, I find it interesting Ken doesn't name the culprit. Not the fraudster or his cronies. I think that's because Ken is the one who let them in his house.
If you loved the company, it's a very interesting book.
To be fair to Sierra, some of their final acts were publishing Half Life, Homeworld, and an expansion for Diablo. They may well have become an enormous publisher if not for the CUC mess.
Ken ambitions killed Sierra, Ken wanted that G5. This https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sr9_GfeoCjk [Tropic Thunder Tom Cruise Dancing to Flo Rida Low] is an accurate reenactment of how Walter Forbes lured Ken Williams into selling
As many people point out, the CEO has some level of fiduciary duty to investors. If you refuse an offer with a 40% or so premium, you are going to be facing down lawsuits.
Finally, while Roberta was enjoying her position, Ken really wanted to quit all of the CEO crap. Finding a CEO to hand things over to is just as fraught as a buyout and probably more likely to bump into bad actors than a buyout.
Put it all together and there really was no good reason to refuse the buyout. If the purchasing company hadn't been a fraud, we'd be lauding the decision to sell instead of castigating it.
I think a simple way to avoid this is to ask for a all-cash offer. Naturally it will be either non-existant or much smaller value. If the offer is still good, it is not a problem to accept it.
The problem here was that the sellers were accepting stock as a payment, which was garbage.
not if the offer is all garbage stock
> Ken really wanted to quit all of the CEO crap.
Article contradicts that spending a lot of paragraphs on Ken fighting for position in new company.
>there really was no good reason to refuse the buyout
Nobody looked for one, nobody wanted to find one due to greed. Otherwise they would be balls deep in CUCks books.
It was plain old accounting fraud.
> And nobody saw it coming.
Nothing to see if you do not look.
> Put it all together and there really was no good reason to refuse the buyout.
He claimed he did it to secure Sierras financial future, but didn't see it as an issue when CUC refused to share its financial data.
It might be a hindsight thing, but it seems that at least nowadays larger companies spend a lot of time going over finances and other economic data before they agree to that kind of deal.
> If the purchasing company hadn't been a fraud
They could have been completely honest and still been in a state where the buyout itself would have been enough to break both. Wouldn't be the first time a company overextended itself.
"The love of money is the root of all kinds of evils."
[1] https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=1%20Timothy%206...
"root of all evil" or "root of all evils" would seem to be more precise translations than "root of all kinds of evils".
The Russian Synodal bible gives: ибо корень всех зол есть сребролюбие which would translate to "root of all evils"
NIV Bible: "For the love of money is a root of all kinds of evil..."
KJV Bible: "For the love of money is the root of all evil..."
Crude translation almost word for word: 'root of all the evil is the greed'.
The translation process would have gone:
1) root of all evil is greed [eliminate non-English articles]
2) greed is root of all evil [swap to SVO syntax]
3) greed is the root of all evil [add required English article]
4) The love of money is the root of all evil ["translate" the vocabulary word into simpler terms]
There simply isn't any more faithful way to render that thought. You could stop at step three, but the KJV's genius lies in what a small vocabulary it uses. (I just checked: "greed" appears nowhere in the KJV, so the word was on the hit list.) The goal was to make the text understandable to the broadest audience possible - the vast majority of whom, at the time, were uneducated. That the translators were able to maintain that constraint while also creating something of incredible literary power is awe inspiring.
If you want to break it down a bit further, the phrasing in step three puts two stressed syllables ("greed is") together, which can be awkward, while the final version puts the verse into an iambic pattern (unstressed syllable preceding a stressed syllable), which rolls off the tongue much easier. The word "evil" then reverses that, which breaks the rhythm and calls attention to the end of the thought. (And, maybe, if you want to get especially literary or theological about it, provides a subtle commentary on the nature of evil.) It's so good.
Hebrew and aramaic doesn't have a word that directly translates to greed, but the meaning of philargyria is related to money rather than the metal and Ecclesiastes obviously describes 'love of silver' as a form of addiction and that's what Paul (or whoever actually wrote the epistle) had in mind when he wrote to Timothy and the jews he hung around with.
I was intrigued by the idea (elsewhere in the thread) that the root difference is translation from the vulgate vs translation from Greek, though I don't have the background to evaluate the claim. Regardless, absent really good reasoning I'll defer to the KJV, for reasons of historical importance and literary quality. So many phrases in the NIV (and other modern versions) set my teeth on edge.
> “They hated it,” he remembers of the board’s reaction. “Because we were on a roll. We were unstoppable at that point.” If it was an acquisition where Sierra would retain control, that’d be one thing, but a merger with three major developers under a parent with no software experience? "It was beyond bad inside Sierra."
Fundamentally, dude took stock. Which, unlike cash, made him and the shareholders dependent on ongoing competent execution, from a coupon company that was going to merge multiple software companies and magically continue shipping excellent software. When people asked what expertise does a coupon company have at shipping multiple types of software, it turns out the real answer was their expertise was selling to greedy fools. Pretty good expertise!
Why not?!?
It seems like everyone in this story - Roberta, people who love games, (most especially) the employees who lost their savings, and even Ken - would be happier today if they had continued earning an honest profit doing what they did best. The scramble for more, more, MORE undid them all.
There's wisdom in the proverb "the love of money is the root of all evil". This story is a cautionary tale.