News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:MIT abandons use of DEI statements by blackhawkC17 on Sunday May 05, 2024 @05:11AM (#40263319)
Race is a distraction from the ultimate divide: class. IMO, every policy that wants to promote equality should revolve solely around class.

In every place on earth, richer upper-class people are more advantaged than those from the lower classes. Every social policy should focus on lessening that gap (I recognize that the gap can't be closed entirely).

Re:MIT abandons use of DEI statements by nojvek on Sunday May 05, 2024 @11:45AM (#40265697)
100% ^.

But then it ends up being tied to race since black folks are on average coming from a less wealthier class than white people.

And class is hard to judge objectively. If you go by income tax, many wealthy people show very little income since they live on their family wealth. E.g a house fully paid off and only earning meager income from a side business, while their stocks they inherited are climbing millions in valuation.

The rich are really good at hiding they are rich.

Re:MIT abandons use of DEI statements by blackhawkC17 on Sunday May 05, 2024 @03:19PM (#40267399)
> And class is hard to judge objectively.

Very simple, actually. $1 million+ in annual income or $10 million+ in assets is an objective starting point, all the way to mega billionaires like Musk and Bloomberg.

Re:MIT abandons use of DEI statements by svieira on Sunday May 05, 2024 @03:51PM (#40267641)
Congratulations, the small-time local farmer with 10 acres, two quality high tunnels, a mid-sized tractor, and a couple of trucks and trailers is now wealthy. Assets are not necessarily liquid.
Re:MIT abandons use of DEI statements by blackhawkC17 on Sunday May 05, 2024 @04:17PM (#40267880)
Edge cases do not negate the whole point. For example, I'm pretty sure you can find a billionaire who's very cash-poor, i.e., wealth is locked up in the value of a private company. Does not change the fact that anyone with $1 billion+ of net worth is ultra-rich.

Whatever the edge case may be, anyone with $1 million+ annual income and $10 million+ in assets is undeniably upper-class, including your hypothetical farmer. Note that I never claimed their assets should be taken...just stating an objective definition for upper class.

Re:MIT abandons use of DEI statements by Detrytus on Monday May 06, 2024 @07:05AM (#40273260)
> For example, I'm pretty sure you can find a billionaire who's very cash-poor, i.e., wealth is locked up in the value of a private company

Donald Trump comes to mind, struggling to pay $464M bond set by New York judge.

Re:MIT abandons use of DEI statements by michaelmrose on Sunday May 05, 2024 @08:37PM (#40269980)
10 acres of farmland is worth around $30,000 its also 200 meters by 200 meters they probably don't need much of a tractor and can probably do with one truck for what amounts to a hobby nobody could live on.

The USDA says a small family farm averages around 231 acres or about $693,000 in land. Even adding the equipment its a long way from 10M in assets and that isn't even accounting for the elephant in the room DEBT.

Any sole proprietorship which is net positive to the tune of 10M is in fact by any reasonable measure wealthy.

Re:MIT abandons use of DEI statements by bawolff on Sunday May 05, 2024 @03:53PM (#40267663)
Most of those situations the student wouldn't own those assets. If you go by how much money relatives have, then you end up being unfair to kids who have been disowned or if the kid has a rich uncle that has never given anyone a penny, etc.
Re:MIT abandons use of DEI statements by michaelt on Sunday May 05, 2024 @03:34PM (#40267507)
> But then it ends up being tied to race since black folks are on average coming from a less wealthier class than white people.

Yes, addressing class inequality will also help to address racial inequality.

Seems like a strength, not a weakness.

Re:MIT abandons use of DEI statements by HDThoreaun on Sunday May 05, 2024 @01:05PM (#40266367)
Even lebron james gets the n word spray painted on his house. Class may be the main divide, but race is still an absolutely huge one that transcends class.
Re:MIT abandons use of DEI statements by dudeinjapan on Sunday May 05, 2024 @03:44PM (#40267588)
Nit: it was spray-painted on his gate, not his house (mansion).
Re:MIT abandons use of DEI statements by twotwotwo2 on Sunday May 05, 2024 @03:39PM (#40267542)
How?
Re:MIT abandons use of DEI statements by dang on Sunday May 05, 2024 @03:48PM (#40267620)
> How can you even remotely believe that wasn't a false flag?

Please don't edit your comments to deprive replies of context. That's unfair to both repliers and readers.

Edit: It's always fine to add an edit, as I did here.

Re:MIT abandons use of DEI statements by acdha on Sunday May 05, 2024 @03:42PM (#40267576)
What evidence is there that it’s not what it seems? Its not like there’s a shortage of people who’d try something like that in this country.
Re:MIT abandons use of DEI statements by sobriquet9 on Sunday May 05, 2024 @03:35PM (#40267515)
> every policy that wants to promote equality should revolve solely around class.

That was the case in USSR. There were university admission quotas for workers, peasants, etc. In practice, they resulted in discrimination agains Jewish applicants.

To fulfill the class quotas, the examiners had to fail a disproportionate number of some of the strongest applicants. A whole set of "Jewish problems", colloquially known as " coffins", was developed. At MIT, Tanya Khovanova has written on this subject.

Re:MIT abandons use of DEI statements by Avicebron on Sunday May 05, 2024 @04:00PM (#40267715)
Not sure exactly how this relates, but you're still saying with people being failed that the class representation was more equitable? Not sure what them being jewish has anything to do with it?
Re:MIT abandons use of DEI statements by jimbokun on Sunday May 05, 2024 @04:40PM (#40268138)
A brutal truth is that wealthy, upper class people have resources for training their kids that legitimately better prepare them for academic success than poorer kids.

The rich, smart kids in this example were Jews.

Re:MIT abandons use of DEI statements by sobriquet9 on Sunday May 05, 2024 @04:50PM (#40268217)
In USSR, nobody was rich.
Re:MIT abandons use of DEI statements by skissane on Sunday May 05, 2024 @11:02PM (#40270767)
> In USSR, nobody was rich.

Despite Soviet propaganda to the contrary, social class continued to exist in the USSR.

At the top of the class hierarchy, were senior party officials and their families.

Next rung down were university-educated professionals (doctors, engineers, scientists, etc)

Then came skilled factory workers, etc

Unskilled labourers were near the bottom of the Soviet class hierarchy

Re:MIT abandons use of DEI statements by sobriquet9 on Monday May 06, 2024 @12:37PM (#40276518)
Those distinctions are irrelevant. Education was free in USSR. Access to math circles and specialized math schools was also free. It was not necessary to hire a tutor or pay for advanced classes to get admitted, unless we’re talking about the Conservatory or MGIMO.

Source: I was born and received education in USSR, so can tell Soviet propaganda from reality.

Re:MIT abandons use of DEI statements by sobriquet9 on Sunday May 05, 2024 @04:52PM (#40268229)
Class based admission meant discrimination against Jews.
Re:MIT abandons use of DEI statements by Gibbon1 on Sunday May 05, 2024 @04:52PM (#40268227)
Friend of mine's boyfriend was born in the USSR and was Jewish. To get into college he had to pass a mathematics test that anyone who learned math in high school wouldn't be able to pass. He got in. Then his dad applied for a visa to move to Israel and they kicked him out.

Guy hates communists, leftists, f*scists, Putin, and anything like DEI. Basically anyone that seems to have a habit of doing to people what the communists did to him.

I think it's a good point to be really suspicious of systems that categorize people into convenient boxes based on things that have no control over. That then determines what happens to them.

Re:MIT abandons use of DEI statements by dudeinjapan on Sunday May 05, 2024 @03:38PM (#40267538)
Class is a distraction from the ultimate divide: Hogwarts house sortation.
Re:MIT abandons use of DEI statements by bozhark on Sunday May 05, 2024 @03:51PM (#40267644)
It’s by design