News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by lukifer on Thursday May 24, 2012 @04:04PM (#4020283)
This is the great irony of a free market: that it includes the creation of closed, private markets which are decidedly un-free. (Apple's the biggest jerk about it, but there are many others, such as the game console manufacturers, or Amazon's app store). And as evidenced by the App Store's enormous success, the market does not inherently select in favor of open markets versus closed ones.

Apple of the 2010s is much more deserving of DoJ investigation than 1990s Microsoft ever was. And if I had my druthers, ecosystem monopoles of this type would be blatantly illegal, and manufacturers would be obligated to include jailbreak capability in every single device. (Not holding my breath.)

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by Pewpewarrows on Thursday May 24, 2012 @04:28PM (#4020379)
People tend to conveniently forget that it's the consumers in an economy who define a monopoly. There's nothing inherently wrong with it. If a monopoly occurs because the majority of consumers are giving that product/service their money, then it must be deserving of it. If enough people are dissatisfied with the quality, they'll turn to new business, and the monopoly will cease to exist.

The market has and will continue to regulate itself without legislative interference. I see no reason for the government to get involved with Apple's private marketplace.

Edit: I'll put it this way: You don't like Apple's closed market because they can define arbitrary rules that makes it hard to compete. How is that any different than a Government defining arbitrary rules on the national marketplace?

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by chris_wot on Thursday May 24, 2012 @06:43PM (#4020977)
I must disagree. Except in a few cases, monopolies cause problems with deincentivization of innovation, uncompetitive behaviour, poorer outcomes for consumers and often higher prices than there would be otherwise were there a competitor.

Apple are beginning to show all these signs. I would suggest that given enough instances of incidents like these that the US DOJ would be within their rights to start another anti-trust case.

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by jwallaceparker on Thursday May 24, 2012 @07:40PM (#4021167)
> Except in a few cases, monopolies cause problems with deincentivization of innovation, uncompetitive behaviour, poorer outcomes for consumers and often higher prices than there would be otherwise were there a competitor.

I think you'll only find this is the case with government-granted monopoly.

Government-granted monopolies (US post office, some energy utilities, many transportation companies and so on) have little incentive to innovate and generally deliver poor service to consumers.

But how can you argue this about Apple? They're incredible innovators, they deliver great products that consumers love and the prices of those products generally fall over time.

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by beagle3 on Thursday May 24, 2012 @09:48PM (#4021508)
> I think you'll only find this is the case with government-granted monopoly.

That's demonstrably wrong; e.g., once Microsoft had a monopoly on the browser market (somewhere around IE5-IE6), they stopped innovating, whereas before that point (IE2-IE5) they made great efforts to innovate.

> But how can you argue this about Apple? They're incredible innovators, they deliver great products that consumers love and the prices of those products generally fall over time.

That's true. Despite what many people in this thread feel, Apple does not have a monopoly in any market: Macs are ~15% of all PCs. iphones aren't event 30% of the phone smartphone market.

What Apple did manage to do is dominate the lucrative parts of most markets -- but that doesn't make them a monopoly more than it makes Louis Vutton a monopoly on lucrative handbags.

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by emptyaccount on Thursday May 24, 2012 @10:29PM (#4021602)
Its important to note that many government granted monopolies are created to provide important services to all areas, not just those that are profitable.

For example, USPS delivers mail to all addresses. Competitors use USPS to deliver to remote locations.

They have their problems of course, but they also have their share of burdens competitors don't.

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by chris_wot on Friday May 25, 2012 @03:18AM (#4022354)
What you refer to here is known as a "natural monopoly": see Wikipedia for more information. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Natural_monopoly
Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by gizzlon on Friday May 25, 2012 @07:07AM (#4022966)
good link, thanks
Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by chris_wot on Friday May 25, 2012 @03:14AM (#4022342)
But how can you argue this about Apple? They're incredible innovators, they deliver great products that consumers love and the prices of those products generally fall over time.

While Apple may be incredible innovators, they have also setup a marketplace to allow others to innovate. This marketplace is the only place you can get software from (I don't speak for jailbroken phones, which void the warranty). As the ones controlling and participating in the marketplace, they have an extremely unfair advantage if they prevent others from selling products Apple also want to sell.

This is anti-competitive, and the reason I believe they need to be careful before someone tries to put together an Anti-Trust case for them to answer.

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by lukifer on Thursday May 24, 2012 @04:59PM (#4020528)
> If a monopoly occurs because the majority of consumers are giving that product/service their money, then it must be deserving of it.

"Deserving" is subjective, and that attitude doesn't seem far from "might makes right". Beta was better than VHS (or so I hear), but the consumers went where the content was, and the better format lost.

> I see no reason for the government to get involved with Apple's private marketplace.

Except it already is involved: the government issues currency and defends copyrights and patents, all backed by (heavily abstracted) violence. In fact, remove the threat of prosecuting NDAs alone, and I guarantee that Apple as we know it would collapse within a year.

> How is that any different than a Government defining arbitrary rules on the national marketplace?

In theory, the rules are not arbitrary, but driven by democratic processes. In practice, such rules might as well be arbitrary, if not openly hostile, and I will stipulate this as unfixable (for now).

But we already have marketplace rules all over the place, whether by law or by convention: don't false advertise, don't market poison as candy, etc. I don't see why "you're not allowed to encrypt everything so you're the only game in town" can't be one of them. Moreover, I don't see a difference between a tyrannical Apple and a tyrannical government, except in details and scale, and I'm not willing to settle for either.

For the record: I am typing this on a MacBook Pro. I think curtailing Apple's monopolistic tendencies would be not only be good for users and the ecosystem, but in the long run, good for Apple itself. For instance: if users are allowed to side-load any old app, they can curate their App Store to their heart's content, including only the best of the best, and regular users would be more satisfied their experience as a result.

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by mgkimsal on Thursday May 24, 2012 @10:52PM (#4021658)
they might be more satisfied, but use it less, and provide less revenue. "highly satisfied" users of a system that is optional to use will most likely provide less revenue than a system people are forced to use, but provides less overall satisfaction to the users.
Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by wslh on Thursday May 24, 2012 @04:45PM (#4020451)
> People tend to conveniently forget that it's the consumers in an economy who define a monopoly. There's nothing inherently wrong with it.

Yes there are issues with monopolies. This is why new laws must be created to protect against these monopolies.

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by FuzzyDunlop on Thursday May 24, 2012 @07:57PM (#4021219)
I'd also say that the GP's statement isn't wholly true.

Inorganic growth is a different road to monopoly power. Vertical integration, another. As is abuse of existing monopoly power to gain a monopoly in a different market (see Internet Explorer).

The consumer isn't accountable for the actions of a monopoly. The main problem is that the monopoly becomes less accountable as a whole.

Hence legislation and regulation.

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by efsavage on Thursday May 24, 2012 @05:59PM (#4020808)
You're right in that there's nothing inherently wrong with a monopoly. There's only things wrong with how you got it, and more importantly, how you use it. When you use collusion to build one (or a cartel), that's a problem. When you start using it to preclude people from turning to an alternative, that's a problem.

Right now Apple is the dominant player in the mobile phone space, but it's definitely not a monopoly, and AFAICT they aren't really doing anything that is preventing competitors from entering the market. iCloud is a step in that direction, but it's not very good right now so we'll have to wait and see. Android basically lets Apple do whatever they want, and is the credible competitor that Microsoft was lacking.

Where Apple was a monopoly was in mp3 players, and where they were abusing it was with their DRM, by also having the dominant music store, and not allowing other devices to get music from it, or to let other stores sell DRM music for the iPod. They removed it, and I don't think it had anything to do with consumers, it was simply an anti-trust target that was growing larger by the day. They were smart and fixed that.

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by Steko on Thursday May 24, 2012 @06:37PM (#4020958)
"Where Apple was a monopoly was in mp3 players, and where they were abusing it was with their DRM.... They removed it, and I don't think it had anything to do with consumers, it was simply an anti-trust target that was growing larger by the day."

You seem to have gotten the history wrong. DRM on itunes was mandated by the music companies. After a very public push from Steve Jobs, the music companies tested DRM free with Amazon and after that they gave Apple the green light.

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by efsavage on Thursday May 24, 2012 @10:53PM (#4021660)
DRM may have been mandated, but Apple's refusal to license FairPlay to other manufacturers, and refusal to allow the iPod to support any other DRM, was not.

Jobs' spinning this into a victory for the little guy rather than an anti-trust dodge is just another example of his PR prowess.

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by X-Istence on Friday May 25, 2012 @02:46AM (#4022258)
I don't see why I should be required to license my IP to anyone, let alone companies that may compete with me. I also don't see how a product I design would need to support a format that is licensed by a competitor and is something I'd have to pay money for.

You want content for your iPod, you can purchase it from iTunes, which will be DRM'ed according to the music industry, or you can purchase your music on a CD and rip it to MP3 and transfer it to your iPod that way.

There is no rule that any company should be required to license their IP, nor is there a rule that a company should be required to purchase a license to someone else's IP.

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by efsavage on Friday May 25, 2012 @08:08AM (#4023127)
"There is no rule that any company should be required to license their IP"

...unless you're a monopoly. That's the point of anti-trust laws, that they are special cases. When you're using dominance in one market to maintain dominance in another, they change the rules to stop you, unless you stop yourselves as Apple did.

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by X-Istence on Friday May 25, 2012 @11:27AM (#4023870)
Apple has a dominance in iOS, since it is their OS, but they don't have a monopoly in the world since only about 30% of mobile devices are iOS devices.

Thus no special case required. When iTunes was around there were other options for purchasing music, hence no monopoly.

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by gizzlon on Friday May 25, 2012 @07:00AM (#4022952)
> If a monopoly occurs because the majority of consumers are giving that product/service their money, then it must be deserving of it.

Why exactly? The argument works if you make it circular (they deserve it because they get it), but so what?

It's not like consumers always do whats best for them, especially in the long run. Even if if the consumer did what was best for him or herself, that might not be what's best for everyone.

Honestly, I don't get where this seemingly naive faith, that everything will just take care of it self, comes from. Personally I can't see any evidence of that.

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by no_more_death on Thursday May 24, 2012 @08:40PM (#4021329)
Yes, you can choose from multiple options. Android, Meego, Boot2Gecko (soon). Windows Mobile, Blackberry, iOS, Bada, etc.

So: some people choose Apple for its advantages, and others choose Android for its advantages. As a matter of fact, openness was the whole purpose of Android, way back when the G1 was released. Android is an incredible success story for open source cooperating with commercial interests and gaining huge public mind share.

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by cooldeal on Thursday May 24, 2012 @04:40PM (#4020424)
> If enough people are dissatisfied with the quality, they'll turn to new business, and the monopoly will cease to exist.

Wish it were so simple, but the problem is the ecosystem. A new business will not start out with 500K apps and developers won't develop apps till a platform has a lot of users, a chicken-and-egg problem. Users don't like buying devices with only a few apps available. Looks at WebOS, it was a good platform but died.

This is not even mentioning the real costs of switching, like not having access to already purchased apps and content because they're locked down(music, movie, ebook purchases).

It was a big problem with Windows in the 90s, you had to get a Windows computer to run software needed to be compatible with others.

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by nraynaud on Thursday May 24, 2012 @08:19PM (#4021280)
Wait, when Apple started the iPhone they had no 3rd party application, people begged them to allow that. They got to that number from zero. They are not preventing anyone to create a phone so compelling that everybody is asking for a SDK. moreover hundreds of mobile allowed 3rd party apps before the iPhone was there(I remember those cheesy java apps). They sold a very expensive phone that had less feature than the others and everybody wanted one. I don't know exactly what more proof we can get than the market is free than that. It was more expensive and had less feature than the other. The only extra stuff was Steve Jobs, sorry but the marked for that was destroyed a few month ago.
Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by MBCook on Thursday May 24, 2012 @11:13PM (#4021715)
Remember, when Apple started, the market basically didn't exist. Not many people had smartphones. The programs available for, say, Windows CE, had costs of $10-$20 at the low end. Feature phones had games, but they were often $5+. On a feature phone, if you replaced it with a new model you may have lost whatever you purchased.

I distinctly remember one of my Sprint feature phones having a version of Tetris (or some similar complexity of game) for $3 a month.

It was the rise of Apple's mobile app store that made apps an important factor in which phone to buy. Before the iPhone app store, what percent of users in the US spent $10 a year to buy phone apps? What percent do now?

Ignoring the fact I love my iPhone, I would be hesitant to go to another plstform because of all the games I'd have to either give up or re-buy.

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by astrodust on Friday May 25, 2012 @02:58AM (#4022290)
It's hard to remember that when Apple started the RIM BlackBerry was the undisputed Ph.D. of the smartphone market compared to the relatively high-school smart challengers of Danger and Palm.

Palm had an app store first and it was amazing for its time. It's an interesting case study to deconstruct how they could botch such an amazing product so thoroughly. They even missed the tablet bandwagon completely.

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by jopt on Friday May 25, 2012 @02:50AM (#4022269)
Those are just reasons Apple is more attractive to consumers than the competition is. Nobody said competing has to be easy, or even possible for everyone.

Free competition is not a guarantee that anyone will be able to outperform incumbents; it only means that if you do (as defined by consumers) you won't be held back by regulations/legal monopolies.

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by jwallaceparker on Thursday May 24, 2012 @07:45PM (#4021180)
> Wish it were so simple

The process takes time, but it is that simple.

Granted, it would take an enormous effort to start a new company that competes against Apple, but one could do it.

But just because it takes an enormous effort that doesn't nullify the fact that consumers would indeed turn to other products if Apple products failed to satisfy.

I think a big issue to consider is that people are very satisfied with the quality of Apple's products at this point.

If somehow the government decided that people could only buy Apple products, then we'd have monopoly, and then we should be angry.

But they haven't. So we should relax.

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by astrodust on Friday May 25, 2012 @02:30AM (#4022208)
Apple is in a very strong position, they have an amazing product that people will literally line up to buy. What they don't have is a lock on the market, though, and they know it. They either innovate, keep pushing themselves, or they'll end up steamrollered by someone else.

Remember that in 1995 people did line up to buy Windows 95 and while future launches weren't met with as much fanfare, people would actively seek out computers with Windows on it and had no time for side-show attractions like MacOS or Linux.

Amazing how that can come collapsing down just because of a few mis-steps. You have Vista, you have a near decade of focusing aggressively on the server market and leaving the consumer side to twist in the wind, neglecting their important and dominant Internet Explorer product for the better part of six years.

In other words, Apple is just one Steve Ballmer away from total irrelevance.

The company best situated to take down Apple doesn't exist yet, not in the form it will ultimately be. Maybe Samsung will finally go beyond emulating and will build their own platform that resonates with consumers as well as they'd have you believe in the marketing... Maybe Microsoft will hire new leadership and straighten out the train-wreck that Windows Phone 7 is...

As much as Apple is doing a great job, it's frustrating when there really isn't any competition. We need a market where there are two or three very good choices.

Like Xbox 360 or PS3 or Wii where each have their merits. What will the world be like if that's reduced to just one?

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by wslh on Thursday May 24, 2012 @04:44PM (#4020442)
> Apple of the 2010s is much more deserving of DoJ investigation than 1990s Microsoft ever was.

Not only that. Google, Twitter, Facebook et al are in the same situation. I am always arguing that with Microsoft you can reverse engineer their software. No more support for DOS? you can find a way to have a working application. You can't reverse engineer the cloud.

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by quotemstr on Thursday May 24, 2012 @06:58PM (#4021027)
Maybe Apple has a monopoly; maybe it doesn't. Regardless, what Apple is doing is _wrong_ and needs to be stopped. There are more antisocial business practices than are dreamt of in the Sherman Antitrust Act.
Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by chj on Thursday May 24, 2012 @08:34PM (#4021318)
I'll second this. Apple's doing causes a great deal of harm to small businesses that basically only live on its platform. That is a monopoly to these small businesses. I don't see why MS is punished like hell in the 90s for bundling IE only, but apple lives comfortably now.

The only solution is iOS platform must allow third party appstore, must allow third party browsers(not wrappers). Otherwise, shit will happen again tomorrow.

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by X-Istence on Friday May 25, 2012 @02:50AM (#4022268)
MS got punished for bundling IE because they provided it for free and Netscape at the time cost money. They also bundled IE with an OS that was installed by 90% of the computer using population thereby effectively shutting out competitors.

Apple doesn't have 90% of the market. If the users are unhappy or developers are unhappy there are plenty of alternatives. Sure you can't develop for iOS anymore, but if Windows didn't have 90% market share Netscape might have been able to stay in business simply by selling to customers running Solaris and Mac OS and then MS wouldn't have been raked over the coals because of bundling their browser.

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by chj on Friday May 25, 2012 @04:46AM (#4022604)
think about this, apple not only provide browser for free (perfectly ok for me tho), but also shut off any possible competition, because only webkit can have JIT.

I totally get it that this is not antitrust issue by law since their market share is not over 50% yet, however for indie devs live on this platform, it means 100%.

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by X-Istence on Friday May 25, 2012 @11:26AM (#4023864)
Then those Indie Devs need to re-evaluate their position. There are other platforms out there.
Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by chj on Friday May 25, 2012 @12:03PM (#4024045)
Totally agree, the simplest solution is to stop making new apps for iOS. However that doesn't make Apple's way of doing RIGHT.
Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by X-Istence on Friday May 25, 2012 @09:20PM (#4026075)
Why does it not make it right? What exactly is wrong with what Apple is doing? Apple can do as it wishes, its the consumers that are voting with their feet/wallets.
Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by no_more_death on Thursday May 24, 2012 @08:45PM (#4021345)
Problem easily solved. Build your apps for Android first. You can make almost as much money on Android, and you can be secure knowing they won't pull this kind of garbage on you. Free markets are great.
Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by Steko on Thursday May 24, 2012 @09:55PM (#4021524)
Here's another radical idea, build apps that don't rely on reverse engineering a proprietary protocol from the company that runs the store you want to sell your shit in.
Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by kaolinite on Friday May 25, 2012 @05:16AM (#4022695)
Which protocol is that?
Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by lukifer on Thursday May 24, 2012 @07:56PM (#4021214)
Well said. Law and policy are not holy scripture, and we should be unafraid to re-examine them from first principles, be it patent law, anti-trust, or even the Constitution itself.
Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by Steko on Thursday May 24, 2012 @07:20PM (#4021097)
Those are strong words without a lot of strong arguments or facts behind them.

I'm curious what exactly is Apple accused of doing that is so much worse then what every other store in the world does?

What should Apple be stopped from doing? Making awesome devices people want? Making APIs for developers? Having standards for their store?

Do we want Apple to never remove an App after approval? Are we ok with higher fees for developers to pay for more/better app screeners and a higher bar to clear for initial approval for everyone?

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by lukifer on Thursday May 24, 2012 @08:08PM (#4021247)
Apple should be stopped from creating an artificial barrier towards people selling apps to consumers without Apple's approval. There's no reason they couldn't separate the store APIs from the App Store itself, allowing the creation of third-party stores and direct sales. This would allow them to curate more, they way they do with the Mac App Store.

And for the record: Apple is merely the most obnoxious offender. I would happily apply to the same standard to Amazon, Nintendo, etc.

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by lnguyen on Thursday May 24, 2012 @08:23PM (#4021291)
Go develop your app and sell it on the Cydia App Store.

It's possible and Apple is clearly allowing it to exist. That doesn't mean Apple has to make it easy for you to switch over to it or support it in any way.

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by fpgeek on Thursday May 24, 2012 @09:13PM (#4021416)
Apple's triennial opposition to the jailbreaking DMCA exception makes it clear that they want jailbreaking (and Cydia with it) to be illegal. They kick companies do anything with Cydia out of their app store (IIRC, Toyota ran into this). They are harsh with jailbreaking and warranties and have released at least one update that bricked jailbroken phones, possibly intentionally. Apple's behavior doesn't say they're allowing Cydia to exist, it says there are limits to the tools they can use to shut it down.
Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by saurik on Friday May 25, 2012 @02:43AM (#4022246)
Apple certainly did not "purposely" or even knowing release an update that bricked jailbroken devices: te incident you are referring to was caused by a baseband upgrade that relied on some things that had been screwed up by the popular unlock at the time (not even the jailbreak). The unlock was fixed (and subsequent unlocks have not taken similar risks) and Apple seriously scrambled to release a second upgrade that fixed those devices.)

(And yes: "scrambled" is the right word for their reaction; in addition to them having large numbers of sad customers, it is actually /illegal/ in many major countries to pull the shenanigans you seem to believe Apple had a part in, and a class-action lawsuit was immediately put together by people who refused to believe it was just a mistake.)

As for your assertion that they kick companies that do things with Cydia around, that is absurd: major applications like uStream and Qik have either been cross-listed in both markets or launched on jailbroken devices first; Tapululous even has been on stage with Jobs, and they are the reason many users jailbroke on iPhoneOS 1.x.

Meanwhile, Apple actually did /not/ file opposition to the DCMA exemption this year: in fact, at the hearings (which I attended and even answered a question at), it was specifically brought up how none of the players with actual skin in te game (such as Apple or manufacturers of Android devices) care enough to participate this year.

Finally, Apple certainly won't help you with software issues (or even certain classes of hardware issues) of you are currently jailbroken, but they could easily blacklist your warranty, and yet they simply don't: I have never heard of someone being denied service by Apple unless they both refuse to restore their device (to see if jailbreaking caused the problem).

So, while I don't actually agree with the person you are responding to (that Apple actively allows the process), your post is sufficiently full of lies and FUD that you are not adding anything useful to the conversation by having responded. :(

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by Steko on Thursday May 24, 2012 @09:38PM (#4021480)
"Apple should be stopped from creating an artificial barrier towards people selling apps to consumers without Apple's approval. "

Here's how the free market really works:

(1) Apple makes a device at great capital investment and because of this

(2) Apple gets to decides how that device works, what it works with, which apps it can run, where users can get those from etc. Then

(3) consumers can assign whatever weight they want to the constraints Apple has built into the device and then they buy the device or not.

(4) developers can assign whatever weight they want to the ornerousness of the terms Apple has set vs the size of the potential market and then determine if they want to develop for that platform or not.

As it turns out in the case of iOS the devices have been very popular with users and developers. If Apple's terms were too ornerous and draconian we might expect that no one would be developing for iOS or no one would be buying the iphone.

This is again how the free market works.

"There's no reason they couldn't separate the store APIs from the App Store itself, allowing the creation of third-party stores and direct sales. "

There's also no reason they couldn't give all their money to sponsor poor children in developing countries.

There's reasons they shouldn't do either of these seemingly noble things though.

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by chris_wot on Friday May 25, 2012 @03:23AM (#4022368)
While this is how the free market works, ironically Apple have implemented the very opposite of the free market. Those who develop apps have also expended capital. If their app is suddenly yanked from the market then you can no longer claim that you are working in a perfect free market.

Incidentally, I disagree with you but I still had to think through my points. I am very surprised that you have been voted down. I upvoted you, I hope some other folks do too - your POV is actually quite germaine to this debate and I appreciate that you have expressed it!

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by idspispopd on Friday May 25, 2012 @03:45AM (#4022423)
I agree they're being dicks(even though we have famously never received a straight-story from Rogue Amoeba), but this is not anti-trust/anti-competitive or monopolistic.

To get into the hot water that Microsoft did, you need to have a monopoly on an open market, which requires that there is no reasonable choice in the market. Android proves every day that there is indeed choice - and it's actually cheaper and easier to get involved with Android. Android is 56% of the market in comparison to iOS's 23% market share. iOS is only a revenue leader, which is like saying DM Chrysler has a monopoly on rich people.

Secondly the monopolistic abuses need to influence situations that would normally be out of their control. Anyone can choose to stop selling Brand X in their own store for example, it doesn't matter how popular the store is/or how much revenue they earn.

Once those are satisfied they need to do things which leverage their position to trample competition. E.g. Microsoft deliberately changed the function of their APIs to make quicktime unstable. Microsoft deliberately fragmented Java with their own flavour to stifle Sun and the cross platform movement, Microsoft deliberately enforced a web browser on their users as a way to prevent Netscape innovating the web-app scene. Microsoft deliberately forced vendors to sell Windows-only systems by threatening them with severe price hikes if they packaged OS/2.

That is anticompetitive, and they were excellent at it. Apple always wanted a curated store and have deliberately structured their store for this reason.

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by lukifer on Friday May 25, 2012 @02:26PM (#4024804)
My comparison to Microsoft may be a bad analogy: while they did act anti-competitively, it's different than what Apple is doing now. As bad as Windows lock-in was, they never set themselves up as the only store in town, and they were seldom hostile to developers building a business on their platform (if anything, it was the opposite).

I know Apple doesn't hold even the majority of the market, and they won't be king forever, as the MS story demonstrates. What concerns me is that they're defining the new norm (the Windows 8 store follows heavily in their footsteps). If the next OS vendor to take the crown successfully practices the same "our way or the highway" approach, it will be bad for the marketplace, consumers, and society.

Maybe it's a self-correcting problem. But make no mistake: it is a problem.

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by idspispopd on Saturday May 26, 2012 @07:16AM (#4027063)
I generally follow and agree with the gist of your point, it's bad business to shut down people who have invested money into your ecosystem or something that helps sell your product. Fortunately market forces correct this, which is why there has been a trend for developers (especially smaller ones) to switch to Android, or boycott iOS outright. (E.g. If you have budget for one implementation of a title that may be risk rejection by Apple, then you'd naturally choose to develop for Android first, or exclusively.)

However the comparison statements given are off the mark, such as this one regarding Microsoft:

>they were seldom hostile to developers building a business on their platform (if anything, it was the opposite).

Noting my examples from the above comment - Microsoft were entirely hostile to software titles which could compete or create competition for Microsoft's products, or fields they were interested in owning. This isn't a matter of speculation, it was tested in court and proven as fact. Microsoft's deliberate interference were found to have damaged (in many cases permanently) the competitors that they targeted. Of all the 'evil' stuff that Apple/Google/Oracle/etc have done, it does not even compare with what Microsoft did, heck the halloween document alone is trove of a corporation acting evil.

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by wmeredith on Thursday May 24, 2012 @04:37PM (#4020411)
You may want to be careful who you sick the DoJ on, the less they do in tech, the better.

Additionally, Apple is far from a monopoly. The App store is where everyone wants to be so it can seem that way, but it's not.

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by lukifer on Thursday May 24, 2012 @06:21PM (#4020901)
In the strict legal sense, Apple is not a monopoly. However, they do have a monopoly on iOS app distribution. While they're not the only game in town for users, they are for developers (who will go where the users go).

We would all cry foul if the government shut down your business because it conflicts with interests of state. Why should we not also cry foul for a corporation to de-facto shut down your business because it violates their interests?

I'm not sure that Apple has violated any existing laws (IANAL). But even so, I think the rules need re-thinking when we talk about not just technical platforms, but their marriage to business platforms.

At the end of the day, it makes little difference to Rogue Amoeba whether they were shut down by government tyranny or by corporate whim: it matters that they were shut down at all, and we all suffer for the economic output which they (and others) are unable to create for themselves and society. It's antithetical to the very purpose of capitalism.

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by Steko on Thursday May 24, 2012 @06:51PM (#4021009)
"We would all cry foul if the government shut down your business because it conflicts with interests of state."

This is a bit of a straw man. If your business is disposing of toxic waste or printing dollars or forming a private army then no, we will not all cry foul if the government comes in and shuts down your business.

"Why should we not also cry foul for a corporation to de-facto shut down your business because it violates their interests?"

Maybe because that business signed up for it? If I operate a hot dog stand at Yankee Stadium and Yankee Stadium decides to close I guess I'm out of business?

"At the end of the day, it makes little difference to Rogue Amoeba whether they were shut down by government tyranny or by corporate whim: it matters that they were shut down at all, and we all suffer for the economic output which they (and others) are unable to create for themselves and society. It's antithetical to the to very purpose of capitalism."

I'm not sure how you've turned RA's app removal into a bad soliloquy from an Ayn Rand novel but what you're actually suggesting here is a massive intrusion into private markets by the government... the Law of Unintended Consequences is a bitch like that. If Apple doesn't stock my new app we get to sue them? If Macy's doesn't stock my new line of clothes do we get to sue them too? Methinks where this train of thought goes is not "the very purpose of capitalism" that you're seeking...

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by lukifer on Thursday May 24, 2012 @07:50PM (#4021197)
> If your business is disposing of toxic waste or printing dollars or forming a private army then no, we will not all cry foul.

Of course. And if RA was selling something illegal or dangerous, we'd be fine with Apple removing it; that goes without saying.

The purpose of capitalism is creating wealth via trade. I can still sell hot dogs at places other than Yankee Stadium; however, Rogue Amoeba cannot take their software and sell it elsewhere. Yes, in theory they could make a new Android app from scratch, but (a) their work on the iOS app is still lost, and (b) they permanently lose access to the customer base, which is different than merely losing one sales venue of many.

It's ironic that you indict me for parroting Ayn Rand when I thought I was doing just the opposite. :) Libertarians like to think that tyranny is only created by governments. I take the broader view that concentrated private power will always emerge, like the T-1000 that never dies, taking whatever form is convenient, be it state, company, church, or something else entirely, and we must be constantly vigilant to rebalance power when it crosses a certain anti-social threshold.

Might there be unintended consequences to intervening? Of course. But there can also be unintended consequences to inaction as well. Even if government intervention isn't the right solution, it doesn't mean we shouldn't pay attention to the problem, which is not limited to Apple, and which is likelier to spread than die on its own (refer to the overlapping problem of DRM lock-in).

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by astrodust on Thursday May 24, 2012 @10:58PM (#4021678)
Microsoft in the 1990s controlled the only mass-market desktop operating system and there was a very real concern that they were going to take over every operating system, period, something they might've accomplished if Windows NT gained even more traction in the server space.

Apple is still a niche player. They just happen to absolutely own the most profitable end of the market and leave the majority, over 80% of it, to the rest. They're only a monopoly in a subset of the market. Nobody is going to cry because you only have one choice for an expensive product when there's hundreds of choices in the low end of the market.

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by shinratdr on Thursday May 24, 2012 @05:38PM (#4020710)
> Apple of the 2010s is much more deserving of DoJ investigation than 1990s Microsoft ever was.

Except Apple is nowhere even close to a monopoly in any of the markets it participates in. Also, if you're including console manufacturers and gaming then Apple is nowhere close to the biggest jerk. Getting a game listed in Steam, WiiWare, PSN or XBLA is more expensive and way more of a crapshoot than getting your iOS app listed in the App Store.

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by lukifer on Thursday May 24, 2012 @06:38PM (#4020964)
In my comparison, WiiWare is guilty, and Steam is not. If WiiWare kicks me out because they think I'm a jerk, I have no recourse: their store, their console, their rules. If Steam does the same, I'm free to sell a PC game on my own website, or whatever other stores there are.

Perhaps we need a new term beside "monopoly". Obviously it's not a monopoly to consumers. Rather, they are the sole gatekeeper to thousands of businesses. The closest analogy I can see is company towns, or as many others have said, plantations.

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by junto on Thursday May 24, 2012 @04:21PM (#4020360)
Your comments are absolutely spot on.
Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by rimantas on Thursday May 24, 2012 @04:57PM (#4020518)
> And if I had my druthers, ecosystem monopoles of this type > would be blatantly illegal,

Good thing you don't, because you don't know what monopoly is not to mention knowing what's legal and what's not.

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by lukifer on Thursday May 24, 2012 @06:32PM (#4020947)
I do know what it is; I was speaking broadly, not intending the strict legal definition. And I'm aware that Apple may not be guilty of violating existing anti-trust laws. However, that doesn't mean Apple hasn't violated their spirit or intent, and if so, I believe those laws need rethinking.
Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by a3d6g2f7 on Thursday May 24, 2012 @06:29PM (#4020935)
Maybe the ecosystem just isn't big enough yet. Too much of the market is still not yet using Apple's products.

Maybe when Apple reaches Microsoft-level penetration, and of course that is their goal (Exhbit A: Apple pricing trends), you might get your druthers.

It really should not be necessary to "jailbreak" a device in the first instance. The user should be able to easily install their own choice of software on the hardware they have paid for: e.g., applications, OS, bootloader and BIOS. If you want to install Apple's software, you can. If you do not want to install their software, you can install something else. Simple.

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by jonhendry on Thursday May 24, 2012 @09:26PM (#4021453)
"(Exhbit A: Apple pricing trends)"

Apple's prices have been pretty steady, and are frequently decried as being too high.

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by jodrellblank on Thursday May 24, 2012 @06:59PM (#4021033)
The user should be able to easily install their own choice of software on the hardware they have paid for: e.g., applications, OS, bootloader and BIOS.

Why should they? You don't get to easily put any ingredient of your choice in packaged food, or any instrument of your choice in finished songs, or any cloth of your choice in premade clothing, or any engine you like in a car.

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by mikeash on Thursday May 24, 2012 @09:24PM (#4021445)
Your analogies are highly broken.

You can mix packaged food with whatever you want. You can choose to eat only the left half of your TV dinner. In short, once it's yours, you can do what you like.

You can take a song and remix it to your heart's content. That is, unless the song contains DRM which prevents you from extracting the raw audio data. This is something most people around here frown upon rather strongly.

Nothing prevents me from taking pre-made clothing and using it in ways the manufacturer didn't envision and doesn't desire. I can use store-bought pants to make rope or filter water or anything I wish.

As for putting any engine you like in a car, I don't know where that came from. Of course you can put any engine you like in a car, as long as you have the resources and the skills.

Nobody is saying Apple must explicitly support third-party stuff like this. They shouldn't go out of their way for it. All we want is for them to stop going out of their way to prevent it.

It's not just a matter of Apple not inviting third-party OSes and bootloaders. The problem is that Apple locks down the platform using digital signatures so that the only way to use anything but an Apple OS or bootloader is to find and exploit a bug in Apple's lockdown code. There is no similar situation in the world of packaged food, music (except for DRM, which is generally considered bad), clothing, or cars.

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by jodrellblank on Friday May 25, 2012 @02:53PM (#4024917)
Your analogies are highly broken.

That's because computing is a new thing in human history. There isn't anything quite like it. But there is matter, and matter is sold with lots of disparate bits built into one product all the time. Things which could be reconfigured by a skilled person, but it's widely accepted that people don't/can't/shouldn't do that.

Your arguments are similarly broken. You can mix your iOS device with any pair of glasses, 3.5mm audio device, wifi AP, or cover, or choose to use only part of it. You can't have a TV dinner without the gravy browning and you can't get an iOS device without the Apple firmware.

The problem is that Apple locks down the platform using digital signatures so that the only way to use anything but an Apple OS or bootloader is to find and exploit a bug in Apple's lockdown code.

And one of the reasons they do that is so they can provide a curated, malware free, beginner-unbreakable, trustable-updating, partly-sandboxed-app experience for their paying customers.

You have complained about my analogies, but you haven't said why "they should" do that, just that "you want them to".

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by mikeash on Friday May 25, 2012 @03:18PM (#4025028)
Apple can easily provide the curated experience without locking the device down. Sideloading can be available while still off by default.

The reason Apple has the App Store and restricts distribution channels is to provide a good experience. The reason Apple locks down the platform so hard that the only way even an expert can customize the OS is to exploit bugs is to retain control of the platform, nothing to do with a good experience for users.

As for why they should do it, it's because I want them to, and because I think the walled garden approach is frighteningly dangerous for computing in general. Everybody is following suit. In a couple of decades it's not inconceivable that it will be impossible to publish any software without permission from a big corporation.

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by jodrellblank on Friday May 25, 2012 @06:05PM (#4025548)
It's pretty likely that the moment sideloading is "available but off by default" is the moment phishing messages take off seriously. "Just go to settings, then enable sideloading!". Most people won't know what it means, but will use it if told to.

That's not something I can cite peer reviewed evidence for, but from the number of people with unwanted toolbars and junkware on desktops, it seems likely.

So I disagree that it has "nothing to do with a good experience for users".

the walled garden approach is frighteningly dangerous for computing in general.

It has made something widely regarded as the best non-technical computing experience of the decade. It's not 'frighteningly dangerous' while there are still lots of ways to get computation you want done, done. (Albeit not as slickly).

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by mikeash on Tuesday May 29, 2012 @11:21AM (#4037871)
Sideloaded apps could still be sandboxed. It is the sandboxing which helps against malware, not the App Store approval process (which is not at all thorough and not equipped to detect malware at all).
Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by beedogs on Friday May 25, 2012 @01:10AM (#4022027)
This may be the worst argument I've seen on HN in weeks.
Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by jodrellblank on Friday May 25, 2012 @02:30PM (#4024822)
Someone asking a question is the worst argument you've seen in weeks? Leave the hyperbole at the door, would you?
Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by a3d6g2f7 on Thursday May 24, 2012 @07:26PM (#4021123)
What is the product? Is it the hardware? Or the software? Are you saying they are one product, not two?

We've been through this countless times. Microsoft and the OEM's. Apple and their locked down hardware. Consumers are not fools. They know the difference between a software company and a hardware company.

Does your packaged food come with silverware?

Do your finished songs come with an mp3 player?

Does your premade clothing come with laundry detergent?

I find these type of comparsions (e.g. of computers and software to food, music, clothing) very strange. We are talking about cheap, programmable consumer electronics. And then we are having an argument over whether the consumer should have the ability to program them. It is absurd.

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by dpark on Thursday May 24, 2012 @09:30PM (#4021462)
Should Honda be obliged to support installing custom engine control software? Overwriting the radio firmware? Reprogramming the odometer?

Should GE obligated to support installing new firmware on your dishwasher?

There's a long history of integrated devices. It may be the case that consumers know the difference between hardware and software. It's also the case, though, that they often do not care, and don't want to see with the difference.

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by jodrellblank on Friday May 25, 2012 @02:27PM (#4024809)
What is the product? Is it the hardware? Or the software? Are you saying they are one product, not two?

Yes I'm saying they are one product not two. They are made as one product, advertised as one product, sold as one thing for one price, supported as one product. Where do you get the idea that they could reasonably be thought of as two products?

We are talking about cheap, programmable consumer electronics. And then we are having an argument over whether the consumer should have the ability to program them. It is absurd.

No we aren't. We are talking about dozens of components, both software and hardware, put together into one product which is not sold as "programmable electronics" anymore than a dishwasher is sold as "reconfigurable matter". It's a nonsense idea that you want to be the case but you haven't justified why it "should" be the case at all.