News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by quotemstr on Thursday May 24, 2012 @06:58PM (#4021027)
Maybe Apple has a monopoly; maybe it doesn't. Regardless, what Apple is doing is _wrong_ and needs to be stopped. There are more antisocial business practices than are dreamt of in the Sherman Antitrust Act.
Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by chj on Thursday May 24, 2012 @08:34PM (#4021318)
I'll second this. Apple's doing causes a great deal of harm to small businesses that basically only live on its platform. That is a monopoly to these small businesses. I don't see why MS is punished like hell in the 90s for bundling IE only, but apple lives comfortably now.

The only solution is iOS platform must allow third party appstore, must allow third party browsers(not wrappers). Otherwise, shit will happen again tomorrow.

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by X-Istence on Friday May 25, 2012 @02:50AM (#4022268)
MS got punished for bundling IE because they provided it for free and Netscape at the time cost money. They also bundled IE with an OS that was installed by 90% of the computer using population thereby effectively shutting out competitors.

Apple doesn't have 90% of the market. If the users are unhappy or developers are unhappy there are plenty of alternatives. Sure you can't develop for iOS anymore, but if Windows didn't have 90% market share Netscape might have been able to stay in business simply by selling to customers running Solaris and Mac OS and then MS wouldn't have been raked over the coals because of bundling their browser.

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by chj on Friday May 25, 2012 @04:46AM (#4022604)
think about this, apple not only provide browser for free (perfectly ok for me tho), but also shut off any possible competition, because only webkit can have JIT.

I totally get it that this is not antitrust issue by law since their market share is not over 50% yet, however for indie devs live on this platform, it means 100%.

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by X-Istence on Friday May 25, 2012 @11:26AM (#4023864)
Then those Indie Devs need to re-evaluate their position. There are other platforms out there.
Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by chj on Friday May 25, 2012 @12:03PM (#4024045)
Totally agree, the simplest solution is to stop making new apps for iOS. However that doesn't make Apple's way of doing RIGHT.
Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by X-Istence on Friday May 25, 2012 @09:20PM (#4026075)
Why does it not make it right? What exactly is wrong with what Apple is doing? Apple can do as it wishes, its the consumers that are voting with their feet/wallets.
Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by no_more_death on Thursday May 24, 2012 @08:45PM (#4021345)
Problem easily solved. Build your apps for Android first. You can make almost as much money on Android, and you can be secure knowing they won't pull this kind of garbage on you. Free markets are great.
Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by Steko on Thursday May 24, 2012 @09:55PM (#4021524)
Here's another radical idea, build apps that don't rely on reverse engineering a proprietary protocol from the company that runs the store you want to sell your shit in.
Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by kaolinite on Friday May 25, 2012 @05:16AM (#4022695)
Which protocol is that?
Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by lukifer on Thursday May 24, 2012 @07:56PM (#4021214)
Well said. Law and policy are not holy scripture, and we should be unafraid to re-examine them from first principles, be it patent law, anti-trust, or even the Constitution itself.
Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by Steko on Thursday May 24, 2012 @07:20PM (#4021097)
Those are strong words without a lot of strong arguments or facts behind them.

I'm curious what exactly is Apple accused of doing that is so much worse then what every other store in the world does?

What should Apple be stopped from doing? Making awesome devices people want? Making APIs for developers? Having standards for their store?

Do we want Apple to never remove an App after approval? Are we ok with higher fees for developers to pay for more/better app screeners and a higher bar to clear for initial approval for everyone?

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by lukifer on Thursday May 24, 2012 @08:08PM (#4021247)
Apple should be stopped from creating an artificial barrier towards people selling apps to consumers without Apple's approval. There's no reason they couldn't separate the store APIs from the App Store itself, allowing the creation of third-party stores and direct sales. This would allow them to curate more, they way they do with the Mac App Store.

And for the record: Apple is merely the most obnoxious offender. I would happily apply to the same standard to Amazon, Nintendo, etc.

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by lnguyen on Thursday May 24, 2012 @08:23PM (#4021291)
Go develop your app and sell it on the Cydia App Store.

It's possible and Apple is clearly allowing it to exist. That doesn't mean Apple has to make it easy for you to switch over to it or support it in any way.

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by fpgeek on Thursday May 24, 2012 @09:13PM (#4021416)
Apple's triennial opposition to the jailbreaking DMCA exception makes it clear that they want jailbreaking (and Cydia with it) to be illegal. They kick companies do anything with Cydia out of their app store (IIRC, Toyota ran into this). They are harsh with jailbreaking and warranties and have released at least one update that bricked jailbroken phones, possibly intentionally. Apple's behavior doesn't say they're allowing Cydia to exist, it says there are limits to the tools they can use to shut it down.
Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by saurik on Friday May 25, 2012 @02:43AM (#4022246)
Apple certainly did not "purposely" or even knowing release an update that bricked jailbroken devices: te incident you are referring to was caused by a baseband upgrade that relied on some things that had been screwed up by the popular unlock at the time (not even the jailbreak). The unlock was fixed (and subsequent unlocks have not taken similar risks) and Apple seriously scrambled to release a second upgrade that fixed those devices.)

(And yes: "scrambled" is the right word for their reaction; in addition to them having large numbers of sad customers, it is actually /illegal/ in many major countries to pull the shenanigans you seem to believe Apple had a part in, and a class-action lawsuit was immediately put together by people who refused to believe it was just a mistake.)

As for your assertion that they kick companies that do things with Cydia around, that is absurd: major applications like uStream and Qik have either been cross-listed in both markets or launched on jailbroken devices first; Tapululous even has been on stage with Jobs, and they are the reason many users jailbroke on iPhoneOS 1.x.

Meanwhile, Apple actually did /not/ file opposition to the DCMA exemption this year: in fact, at the hearings (which I attended and even answered a question at), it was specifically brought up how none of the players with actual skin in te game (such as Apple or manufacturers of Android devices) care enough to participate this year.

Finally, Apple certainly won't help you with software issues (or even certain classes of hardware issues) of you are currently jailbroken, but they could easily blacklist your warranty, and yet they simply don't: I have never heard of someone being denied service by Apple unless they both refuse to restore their device (to see if jailbreaking caused the problem).

So, while I don't actually agree with the person you are responding to (that Apple actively allows the process), your post is sufficiently full of lies and FUD that you are not adding anything useful to the conversation by having responded. :(

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by Steko on Thursday May 24, 2012 @09:38PM (#4021480)
"Apple should be stopped from creating an artificial barrier towards people selling apps to consumers without Apple's approval. "

Here's how the free market really works:

(1) Apple makes a device at great capital investment and because of this

(2) Apple gets to decides how that device works, what it works with, which apps it can run, where users can get those from etc. Then

(3) consumers can assign whatever weight they want to the constraints Apple has built into the device and then they buy the device or not.

(4) developers can assign whatever weight they want to the ornerousness of the terms Apple has set vs the size of the potential market and then determine if they want to develop for that platform or not.

As it turns out in the case of iOS the devices have been very popular with users and developers. If Apple's terms were too ornerous and draconian we might expect that no one would be developing for iOS or no one would be buying the iphone.

This is again how the free market works.

"There's no reason they couldn't separate the store APIs from the App Store itself, allowing the creation of third-party stores and direct sales. "

There's also no reason they couldn't give all their money to sponsor poor children in developing countries.

There's reasons they shouldn't do either of these seemingly noble things though.

Re:Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App... by chris_wot on Friday May 25, 2012 @03:23AM (#4022368)
While this is how the free market works, ironically Apple have implemented the very opposite of the free market. Those who develop apps have also expended capital. If their app is suddenly yanked from the market then you can no longer claim that you are working in a perfect free market.

Incidentally, I disagree with you but I still had to think through my points. I am very surprised that you have been voted down. I upvoted you, I hope some other folks do too - your POV is actually quite germaine to this debate and I appreciate that you have expressed it!