For twenty-somethings ideas are easy and all opportunity is in front. Might as well swing for the fences and yes people do hit home runs. At this stage, debating the actual statistics is misguided use of energy. Because justifying a reason not to play still means you're not playing.
And the older you get the more gray this calculus is. There's more reasons not to do something. We put the filters on ourselves.
This isn't a moral argument. No one really knows how the statistics will land, we can only back analyze them. Yes it's statistically very unlikely you're going to get funded. So you stopped trying. Maybe your ideas really weren't very good. That's ok, you've got a lifetime.
edit: fwwiw I've always wanted to be an entrepreneur and now decades later when I'm more financially secure and the reality is here, I really really really question if I am cut out to be an entrepreneur. I don't think I care all that much. Not really.
It's the equivalent of singing with a guitar outside of Columbia records. It's not like Paul McCartney is going to just tell you to step into his office and record a demo.
I do plan on taking some time off to work on my side projects though. Maybe I'll try again...
I may apply to this YC round for giggles, but totally get the same feeling as you that I’m probably not good enough in their eyes. As Paul Graham said, if you are out chasing VC funding, you are not building your product. So just going to focus on making my life comfortable and launching another successful product or service.
Good luck!
I'm basically a hobbyist game dev outside of work and games are just so risky as a business.
- Hospice
Games should be developed for fun. I would totally fund game development with profits from another venture.
Otherwise the way to get to them is via accelerators like YC. And the way to get into accelerators with no credentials is to launch something and get some traction. It doesn’t even need to be a lot of traction. Just having users who use your product regularly puts you near the top of the pile.
The only way that would happen is a bug. YC always responds to applicants. Rejections usually aren't personalized because that can't scale - but not hearing back at all should never happen.
If you want me to look into what might have happened there, I'd be willing to try if you email [email protected].
I double checked my emails.
Anyway, I'm realistic in knowing my ideas aren't going to garner investment.
I would love if you had a YC Junior for just getting help on ideas vs capital.
Your best bet is to go to onto Reddit, Discord etc, find the startup communities and ask for advice there. There are a lot of people who want to support other founders. Or even better go on Linkedin, find some prospective customers and ask them for advice. I've had about 10% of people reply back some with page long answers.
If you are willing to spend money there are plenty of services like Kintell, Intro.co which will allow you to book an hour with investors or successful founders. But there are plenty of free options that I would start with first.
That depends on what you mean by "specific."
Several Sand Hill Angels members, who are investors, provide feedback almost every month. (It's in the context of a pitch, but...)
See https://www.sandhillangels.com/raw
("pitch practice" is somewhat misleading.)
[edited to add some detail]
The typical angel-group pitch has three parts, the pitch, the Q&A, and then the "with the entrepreneur out of the room" discussion.
This event lets participants listen to that discussion, as well as those three parts for the other folks pitching the same night.
Then there's an "ask investors anything" session at the end.
In addition to the application, it's worth exploring https://www.startupschool.org/ if you're looking for a "YC Junior"
It fails us in two very distinct ways. It encourages us to think that is the only viable option and it's unethical. Primarily because it requires the perception of customers (and often employees) as a means to an end (not humans).
However, the possibility for ethical, sustainable business models is still very real. I tend to believe we're going to see another wave of those soon as people figure out that it's actually easier to make a living that way.
Those exist everywhere in the trades. Every major city has dozens of small businesses doing plumbing, electrical, roofs, etc., with the goal of sustainable, loyal customers based on doing a good job at a fair price.
The real value is probably in new product models that can only exist given an ethical perspective. Perhaps reviving the mostly dead pay once use forever model of software would work well.
That model requires abandoning DRM which the unethical companies will never do.
The main difference in the software world is that you can potentially build things "once" (or rather, keep building it forever) for a huge global market, which means that it's hard to know when something is good enough. With roofing or coffee, you do good enough work (differs between companies, sure) and move on to the next customer.
But you don't think about adding continuously running rainfall test for the roofs you do to ensure no regressions (leaks) appear.
But yeah, I'm not building out and MVP without pay for 1%.
Startup equity is pretty much objectively a terrible deal except for founders. Be a founder or get paid market comp in cash.
There are different roles founders hire for under the "founding engineer" umbrella.
There is your fresh out of bootcamp "founding engineer" brought on during pre-seed or seed stages to help bash out POCs and mocks used to sell the vision.
Then there is the "founding engineer" they bring in post money and customer commitments to actually deliver the MVP and help build out a professional engineering program.
I'm in the later category and those roles can pay very well for early stage startups.
The problem with startup equity is that this is a very rare scenario, and most of the other scenarios aren't so good. If the company doesn't exit, your equity is worthless. If they exit at a value below your strike price, and you exercised your options, you could end up in debt. Lots of ways for this to end badly.
I assume you are referring to employees who have an equity stake in the company. Can you explain how the scenario you describe happens?
You end up spending alot of time trying to pitch your work. I've had a few idea guys expect me to build MVPs for free with an offer of like 1% or something silly like that. Never any pay, poorly thought out concepts.
I've accepted I'm never going to be rich, it's easier this way.