News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:350 tons of of chocolate and wine arrive on world’s large... by agentultra on Saturday April 13, 2024 @12:01PM (#40023998)
Everyone is always concerned about scale.

But I sometimes wonder if we need to scale down. Are cargo ships full of essential goods or disposable items that will more likely than not enter a landfill without seeing any use at all? We’re really good at over producing items and goods that we don’t need or use.

It’s interesting to see businesses try things like this. It might not be efficient or affordable now. But someone had to break ground and move the needle somewhere.

There’s an interesting story in a similar vein behind the publishing of the card game, Earthborne Rangers. They wanted to print the game so that it was fully compostable. Save for the staples in the rulebook they succeeded despite industry veterans telling them it would be too expensive and not work. I’m glad they did it. I hope others will also try it.

Re:350 tons of of chocolate and wine arrive on world’s large... by cloverich on Saturday April 13, 2024 @12:06PM (#40024040)
This is where carbon tax helps. Having to pay the true cost of goods helps everyone make better decisions. Maybe, hopefully, it also pushes the needle towards higher quality, more essential items and hence less waste.

Yet, "make everything more expensive" is a challenging position to make progress on.

Re:350 tons of of chocolate and wine arrive on world’s large... by basisword on Saturday April 13, 2024 @12:33PM (#40024208)
Doesn’t this just drive up the cost for the people who are already struggling to afford these goods?
Re:350 tons of of chocolate and wine arrive on world’s large... by dghlsakjg on Saturday April 13, 2024 @04:18PM (#40025709)
It imposes the real cost of the goods including externalities. The costs will be borne by somebody, why not the consumer of the good?

It also encourages people to find ways to get goods to consumers that are more efficient.

Re:350 tons of of chocolate and wine arrive on world’s large... by thrance on Saturday April 13, 2024 @12:41PM (#40024265)
It does, but it is also supposed to bring up the hidden costs of buying things in their prices, so that greener products that would do less harm would be cheaper than more destructive goods.

For example, a plane ticket might be cheaper than a train one for the same trip but it costs more to the community in the long term because of global warming.

Re:350 tons of of chocolate and wine arrive on world’s large... by andrepd on Saturday April 13, 2024 @02:56PM (#40025176)
And pollution. People forget that pollution is not just the fuzzy and far-off consequences of global warming, but also very real and immediate deaths and illnesses.
Re:350 tons of of chocolate and wine arrive on world’s large... by makapuf on Saturday April 13, 2024 @12:43PM (#40024275)
One of the solution for this would be to pay them more, by example with direct aid (coming from carbon taxes). They will then be able to chose better products or higher quality ones.
Re:350 tons of of chocolate and wine arrive on world’s large... by jdlshore on Saturday April 13, 2024 @01:14PM (#40024487)
A carbon dividend pairs effectively with a carbon tax. You give people (not businesses) an equal proportion of the tax collected. People who consume less than the average end up earning more than they spent.
Re:350 tons of of chocolate and wine arrive on world’s large... by wiml on Saturday April 13, 2024 @01:21PM (#40024546)
How is "carbon dividend plus carbon tax" different from "cap and trade"? C&T seems to have gone very out of fashion, but it also seems to me to be the most equitable approach — I don't follow this closely enough, maybe I'm missing something.
Re:350 tons of of chocolate and wine arrive on world’s large... by jdlshore on Saturday April 13, 2024 @03:50PM (#40025516)
It’s similar in some ways, but very different in practice. I don’t study these things, but my understanding is that cap & trade puts a hard limit on emissions, then allows businesses to trade carbon allowance as a new sort of currency.

Carbon tax + dividend doesn’t put a hard limit, and it doesn’t establish a new currency/market. Instead, emissions are taxed at the business level and that revenue is paid out at the individual level. I like the way it plays to the strengths of our existing capitalistic system. It’s easy to ratchet up the taxes without affecting the little guy—even benefitting them. It seems easier to administer too.

Re:350 tons of of chocolate and wine arrive on world’s large... by sva_ on Saturday April 13, 2024 @12:29PM (#40024191)
> We’re really good at over producing items and goods that we don’t need or use.

Overproduction of essential things like food is by design as it makes a famine much less likely.

About non-essential stuff, I would agree with you.

Re:350 tons of of chocolate and wine arrive on world’s large... by ianburrell on Saturday April 13, 2024 @01:06PM (#40024424)
One thing to keep in mind is that cargo ships are one of the most efficient ways of transport stuff. It is likely that any advantage from this sailing ship was lost driving the cargo to warehouse and then shipping it to destination. It is strange to worry about the cheap part of shipping and ignore the expensive parts.

Also, there are lots of disposable goods that are essential like food and toilet paper. Lots of food is shipped by container. What is the difference between a mango and an apple? Clothing is frequently shipped by container. How are you going to decide what clothing is frivolous fast fashion and what is essential?

Re:350 tons of of chocolate and wine arrive on world’s large... by rmah on Saturday April 13, 2024 @01:08PM (#40024440)
At end of life, cargo ships are cut up into scrap steel. That scrap is then melted down and re-used to make new steel. I strongly suspect that, if you take into account the energy used to manufacture the ship, sailboats will turn out to have a far higher carbon footprint per ton-mile of shipping than normal cargo ships. Cargo ships, as dirty as they seem on a per-ship basis, are crazy efficient on a per ton-mile basis.

But all that aside, sailing cargo ships are nothing more than a curiosity. Their capacity is tiny, they are very slow, are limited in their routes, etc. And as far as I can tell Grain de Sail's business is NOT shipping. It's some sort of luxury wine & chocolates with an eco theme. I suspect the boat is just a way for the owner to have the company pay for his yachts (the boats only make 2 cargo trips a year) .

Re:350 tons of of chocolate and wine arrive on world’s large... by kryptiskt on Saturday April 13, 2024 @01:44PM (#40024702)
Up until WWII, Finnish shippers were competitive using sailing ships for long range bulk transport of grain, Eric Newby details one such voyage as a sailor in The Last Grain Race (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Last_Grain_Race). I see no particular reason why sailing ships with a little optimization couldn't be competitive these days if they were back then, especially since the fuel prices comparatively is higher now.
Re:350 tons of of chocolate and wine arrive on world’s large... by bobthepanda on Saturday April 13, 2024 @02:00PM (#40024816)
The real kicker is labor cost per ton. Bigger ships don’t have a proportionately bigger crew. And sailboats were quite labor intensive.
Re:350 tons of of chocolate and wine arrive on world’s large... by qmmmur on Sunday April 14, 2024 @02:02AM (#40029020)
Sounds like you just “created some jobs”
Re:350 tons of of chocolate and wine arrive on world’s large... by gofixurcode on Sunday April 14, 2024 @12:17PM (#40032197)
It’s totally possible that manipulating the sails and rigging is motorized and automated on these ships. Would be interested to see a demo of the operation of this ship.
Re:350 tons of of chocolate and wine arrive on world’s large... by bobthepanda on Wednesday April 17, 2024 @01:26PM (#40067675)
I think the next thing you run into is height.

Sailboats are much taller than fossil fuel cargo ships of the same size. A lot of harbors have bridges in their path.

Re:350 tons of of chocolate and wine arrive on world’s large... by tokai on Saturday April 13, 2024 @01:48PM (#40024730)
Don't know about CO², but scrapping of cargo ships is a huge polluter. Places like Alang ship breaking yard are nightmarish on both the human and environmental level.
Re:350 tons of of chocolate and wine arrive on world’s large... by boudin on Saturday April 13, 2024 @04:08PM (#40025623)
Do you have any number that can back up your claims? And any real info about the owners having yachts? If not, you should really delete your conspiracy shitty comment
Re:350 tons of of chocolate and wine arrive on world’s large... by chris_wot on Saturday April 13, 2024 @02:02PM (#40024835)
The cost of scrapping a massive cargo to reuse its materials is going to produce an enormous amount of CO2.

Though, there are already sail technologies you can add to existing shipping. I’m amazed more haven’t been retrofitted, quite frankly.

Re:350 tons of of chocolate and wine arrive on world’s large... by 1vuio0pswjnm7 on Saturday April 13, 2024 @07:18PM (#40027097)
"Cargo ships, as dirty as they seem on a per-ship basis, are crazy efficient on a per ton-mile basis."

As I understand it, this reinforces the parent's comment about scaling down. Efficiency facilitates scaling up, increased demand, supply and consumption, and inevitably, increased carbon footprint and other environmental issues. The comment is not only directed at the footprint of "normal" cargo ships, it's directed at the footprint of the consumption that they enable.

When it is cheap and efficient to ship goods, then more goods will be produced, shipped and consumed; this has an enviromental impact. If it becomes more expensive and less efficient, then perhaps less goods would be produced, shipped and consumed, with reduced environmental impact.

Re:350 tons of of chocolate and wine arrive on world’s large... by rcxdude on Saturday April 13, 2024 @08:45PM (#40027657)
it'll still grow to the limits of the system: impact on the environment is not unique to post-industrial civilisation. It'll saturate either way, with the same effects, just less people.
Re:350 tons of of chocolate and wine arrive on world’s large... by 1vuio0pswjnm7 on Sunday April 14, 2024 @01:48AM (#40028969)
If scale down, the limits of the system might be less, lowering total environmental impact when compared with the total impact from a system with higher limits.
Re:350 tons of of chocolate and wine arrive on world’s large... by gofixurcode on Sunday April 14, 2024 @12:16PM (#40032184)
In the article it states they make 5 trips per year.
Re:350 tons of of chocolate and wine arrive on world’s large... by hn_throwaway_99 on Saturday April 13, 2024 @01:14PM (#40024483)
> Are cargo ships full of essential goods

This article is about a company transporting luxury coffee, chocolate and wine from France - hardly what I would call "essential goods". And given that coffee and chocolate doesn't grow in France, dollars to doughnuts the commodities for those products was originally brought to France on traditional cargo ships.

Totally agree with another commenter, this is simply greenwashing.

Re:350 tons of of chocolate and wine arrive on world’s large... by Thorrez on Saturday April 13, 2024 @01:55PM (#40024771)
> then down through the Caribbean, where the sailboat will dispatch humanitarian aid, working alongside local NGOs. The sailboat will also restock its coffee and cacao supply on its journey through the Caribbean. That supply is then brought back across the sea to France
Re:350 tons of of chocolate and wine arrive on world’s large... by andrepd on Saturday April 13, 2024 @02:26PM (#40024995)
The current economic system optimises and rewards this kind of overproduction. That's the simple truth. As long as this is the case fighting this issue is a losing battle
Re:350 tons of of chocolate and wine arrive on world’s large... by jdietrich on Saturday April 13, 2024 @02:43PM (#40025112)
>Are cargo ships full of essential goods

Yes, for any reasonable definition of "essential".

https://atlas.cid.harvard.edu/countries/43/export-basket

https://comtradeplus.un.org/Publication/ITSY

Re:350 tons of of chocolate and wine arrive on world’s large... by fashion-nugget on Saturday April 13, 2024 @08:24PM (#40027542)
Keeping climate change mitigation separate and off-topic, no, that's absurd. Hand-wringing about too much success or too much efficiency is contrary to the nature of business. If scaling down were essential, it would need to be imposed by consistent regulation so all legitimate participants are held to the same standard. Instead, greater efficiencies, less pollution, faster transit times, and less costs are positive values to optimize for.