News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Intel discloses $7B operating loss for chip-making unit by dimask on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @10:15PM (#39912956)
No big deal, it is going to be essentially covered by government (taxpayers'?) money as usual

https://techcrunch.com/2024/03/20/white-house-proposes-up-to...

Re:Intel discloses $7B operating loss for chip-making unit by zer00eyz on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @10:37PM (#39913071)
Note: I'm a left leaning liberal, who thinks that our system is fucked when it comes to taxes and how we distribute money...

Spend about a day catching up on where the Ukraine conflict is.

Up to speed: good! You will have noted that not having domestic chip production has fucked Russia, and the restrictions on china are to inhibit pass through and limit what they too can do.

You dont give a potential advisory (china) leverage (Taiwan as the sole place chips are made).

Re:Intel discloses $7B operating loss for chip-making unit by mellow-lake-day on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @12:08AM (#39913515)
Invading Ukraine fucked Russia

Even if Russia could make their own chips invading Ukraine would still be a very bad idea and has completely dragged down Russian future prospects. They have isolated themselves on the world stage.

Re:Intel discloses $7B operating loss for chip-making unit by ReptileMan on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @05:37AM (#39915228)
#define WORLD WESTERN_EUROPE_JAPAN_SOUTH_KOREA_AUSTRALIA_NORTH_AMERICA

Quite a big chunk of the world is happy to deal business with Russia and they are not that isolated.

Re:Intel discloses $7B operating loss for chip-making unit by MomoXenosaga on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @04:57PM (#39923025)
They became like Mongolia: China's bitch.
Re:Intel discloses $7B operating loss for chip-making unit by mellow-lake-day on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @04:59PM (#39923053)
Russia has resorted to selling oil to North Korea because they no one else will buy it. That is isolation.

Russia is also working to remove Taliban from list of terrorist states.

These are Russia's "friends".

But isolation here also applies in political sense. There is no political support for Russia's invasion from the rest of the world. Even China has not approved the invasion.

Re:Intel discloses $7B operating loss for chip-making unit by zrn900 on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @11:56PM (#39926373)
You people are delusional:

https://www.eiu.com/n/russia-can-count-on-support-from-many-...

https://www.nytimes.com/2024/02/22/us/politics/russia-war-an...

Its not Russia who is isolated.

https://www.politico.eu/article/west-more-united-also-isolat...

> Russia has resorted to selling oil to North Korea because they no one else will buy it

Literally delusional:

https://energyandcleanair.org/december-2023-monthly-analysis....

Let the Indian FM explain - the second biggest buyer of Russian oil on the planet.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GmsQaWZPvtQ

...

While the first link in my comment is the 4th result in the related Google search, the first one is this below horsesh*t that literally falsifies what the Economist's Intelligence unit and NYT and various others now openly state:

https://www.veridica.ro/en/fake-news/fake-news-russia-is-sup...

This is how they deceive your lot and have you live in delusion.

Re:Intel discloses $7B operating loss for chip-making unit by ReptileMan on Thursday April 04, 2024 @01:55AM (#39927006)
>But isolation here also applies in political sense. There is no political support for Russia's invasion from the rest of the world. Even China has not approved the invasion.

True. But there is support to replace the unipolar with multipolar world. So no one of the big and medium players outside the first world will be too sad to see that the massive amounts of face USA and EU have put on the line in Ukraine are lost.

Re:Intel discloses $7B operating loss for chip-making unit by johnkizer on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @11:03PM (#39913212)
I understand the argument for national security. Having said that...where's the accountability if what they build is terrible? Where's the return to the investor (the public) if they succeed?

I'm not saying the government should just take over businesses...but if the government is going to essentially be an investor in a business, it should be at least as rigorous as a private investor would be.

Re:Intel discloses $7B operating loss for chip-making unit by signatoremo on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @11:41PM (#39913389)
Maybe read this to try to answer your own question?

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39911733

Sometime I don’t understand HN. Such an informative article gets no traffic, yet people jump to a sensational article to discuss the very topic covered in details over there.

Re:Intel discloses $7B operating loss for chip-making unit by mattmaroon on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @12:56AM (#39913731)
Most of us don’t see articles that don’t hit the front page.
Re:Intel discloses $7B operating loss for chip-making unit by gruez on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @11:54PM (#39913458)
Presumably because it's cheaper to pay intel to set up a foundry in the US and allow them to keep all the money that results from it, than it is to pay them to set up a foundry and demand a % of the revenue.
Re:Intel discloses $7B operating loss for chip-making unit by konfusinomicon on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @10:48PM (#39913126)
left leaning liberal and fiscally responsible... I see you too are a member of the silent(ced) majority and i agree with your assessment
Re:Intel discloses $7B operating loss for chip-making unit by scoopdewoop on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @12:31AM (#39913606)
I would love to hear any explanation for why they should get a penny of taxpayer money after spending >$150B in stock buybacks. They spent their money on enriching the rich.
Re:Intel discloses $7B operating loss for chip-making unit by zer00eyz on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @01:23AM (#39913869)
Chip made here is a matter of national security.

Full stop.

I said I would like a better tax policy (that would address your issue) but that doesn't change the need.

You may not like it, I am not fond of it, but we are now Rome. THE US's military might is the same as Romes, the legion (the navy being the 2nd largest Air Force on the globe says it all). You know what happened when the legion got weak? The barbarians came in and ate Rome. It wasnt fast, and it wasnt pretty.

Re:Intel discloses $7B operating loss for chip-making unit by FactKnower69 on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @05:01AM (#39914998)
this is such a hysterical post dude. comparing america to the collapsing western roman empire, patriotically (Note: I'm a left leaning liberal)
Re:Intel discloses $7B operating loss for chip-making unit by Dalewyn on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @07:48AM (#39916200)
>Chip made here is a matter of national security.

Chips made in Taiwan is a matter of national security, or the lack thereof.

Chips made literally anywhere else, including China, are fine; China might blow up Taiwan, but Taiwan can't reciprocate and the west will not fight China.[1]

I say that as someone who likes Intel, wants to see Made in USA come back, and abhors Chinese geopolitical ambitions.

The bottom line that shall not be stated is nobody wants to deal with Taiwan and everyone is happy dealing with China.

[1]: https://www.tomshardware.com/pc-components/cpus/intel-staves...

------

>THE US's military might is the same as Romes

The US military can't do a single thing about a bunch of misguided cavemen lobbing missiles into and stealing freighters from the neighbouring shipping lanes. For that matter, the US military hasn't won a war since WW2.

The numbers might look impressive, but in practice it's vapid. Obama even went on record that the US is retiring from policing the world.

Note: I say this as an American.

Re:Intel discloses $7B operating loss for chip-making unit by zer00eyz on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @11:03AM (#39918418)
>>> The bottom line that shall not be stated is nobody wants to deal with Taiwan and everyone is happy dealing with China.

What? No one wants to deal with china. Everyone is moving their manufacturing OUT as fast as they can. China in its desperate throws to remain relevant in the face of a massive population decline is desperate (the same way Russia is in the face of their population decline)...

No one wanted to sell the tech to china to make modern chips before all the wars and saber rattling of belt and road (facing). And china lacks the will, talent and now access to catch up.

ASee the Ukraine war and Russia. To see what "no chips" looks like. modern optics on tanks are now outside what they can do, never mind glass cockpits of 4th and 5th gen fighters, never mind gps and smart mentions, never mind drones...

>> Chips made literally anywhere else, including China, are fine; China might blow up Taiwan, but Taiwan can't reciprocate and the west will not fight China.[1]

China isnt stupid, they keep pouring money into missles in the hopes of being able to do exactly what you're saying. The problem is that without sea lanes then china runs out of oil, steel and food inside 6 months. If you pay attention to recent conflicts you will note that the patriot missile system has been shooting down the best Russia has to offer. You will note that the anti missile ships off the coast of Yemen are using the same system and missles. That the brits and French are in on the game. You will note that all the intel on chinas missile force (farce) has leaked everywhere... China wont invade shit.

>>> [1]: https://www.tomshardware.com/pc-components/cpus/intel-staves...

This is a holdover deal on the chip ban selling chips to china cause they cant make a thing. You aren't making a strong point with this.

Re:Intel discloses $7B operating loss for chip-making unit by Dalewyn on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @12:34PM (#39919557)
>What? No one wants to deal with china.

And yet everyone keeps dealing with China, because money talks and China has lots of it.

Whether it's Intel and Nvidia exporting their latest tech to China, Apple manufacturing iPhones in China, BYD poised to crowd out the car industry (sans America), or having our cheapass blue jeans produced in the finest sweatshops, everyone wants to deal with China.

No one wants to deal with the dynamite basket that is Taiwan. Initiatives like CHIPS are so we can eventually leave Taiwan out to dry, not because we want to overcome China.

>No one wanted to sell the tech to china to make modern chips before all the wars and saber rattling of belt and road (facing).

Except everyone wanted to sell to China because the monies involved was ludicrous and that is still the case today.

>And china lacks the will, talent and now access to catch up.

China has practical implementations of 7nm process and are shipping product today from what I understand. Pedantically, China is ahead of Intel and thus the US right now. This is something the west should be terrified of, now is not the time for coping or denialism.

Let alone the implied sentiments of "Ha ha, Intel's losing big bucks! Losers!" in threads like this which are the epitome of counterproductivity if the goal really is overcoming China instead of just ridding ourselves of Taiwan.

>See the Ukraine war and Russia. To see what "no chips" looks like. modern optics on tanks are now outside what they can do, never mind glass cockpits of 4th and 5th gen fighters, never mind gps and smart mentions, never mind drones...

And yet Ukraine still hasn't won. With western high tech.

Mind you, I want Russia to lose and lose hard because I hate the idea of warmongering validated as a means of diplomacy in the 21st century, but it is what it is.

It also goes without saying you don't need high tech to kill people and destroy entire landscapes.

>China isnt stupid, they keep pouring money into missles in the hopes of being able to do exactly what you're saying.

Yes? I said China might blow up Taiwan and they most likely eventually will. China couldn't care less about TSMC or really anyone and anything that exists on that island, they just want the island and they will invade if or when the geopolitical winds blow appropriately for them.

>If you pay attention to recent conflicts you will note that the patriot missile system has been shooting down the best Russia has to offer. You will note that the anti missile ships off the coast of Yemen are using the same system and missles. That the brits and French are in on the game.

Congratulations, we've managed to do the same thing as the misguided cavemen but did so behind schedule and over budget. Truly an achievement for the Nobel Peace Prize.

Yeah no.

Re:Intel discloses $7B operating loss for chip-making unit by zer00eyz on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @02:04PM (#39920800)
> And yet everyone keeps dealing with China, because money talks and China has lots of it.

https://apnews.com/article/china-economy-manufacturing-pmi-8...

Chinese manufacturing has been pummeled in the last 2 years. This is on the heels of their zero covid lockdowns that were screwing things up.

Here is port throughput in decline: https://www.fitchratings.com/research/infrastructure-project...

>> Whether it's Intel and Nvidia exporting their latest tech to China,

The Chinese are buying what they cant make and these companies like to sell things

>> Apple manufacturing iPhones in China,

Apple and foxcon moving to India: https://www.pbs.org/newshour/show/why-production-of-apple-ip...

>> BYD poised to crowd out the car industry (sans America),

BYD a state backed and funded company is loosing to Tesla. https://www.ft.com/content/4f1a2188-ced0-4018-998d-5148209a5...

And BYD has some... uhhh.. quality issues: https://insideevs.com/news/712148/byd-quality-problems-hit-i...

>> or having our cheapass blue jeans produced in the finest sweatshops, everyone wants to deal with China.

Clothing production went to Vietnam over a decade ago ... and china is so bad right now that Vietnam is having a bit of a migrant crisis of its own: https://www.rfa.org/english/news/china/workers-1029202011165...

>>> China has practical implementations of 7nm process and are shipping product today from what I understand.

Yes china made a 7nm chip. There has been quite an effort to figure out how they got an ASML machine to do that because they dont have the tech to build that locally. They also dont have the tech to build the lenses for it either (Zeiss holds that). So our German(Zeiss) and Dutch(asml) partners have the tech to build the chips on lock (and aren't cutting that loose). It's not like that chip got stellar reviews either... Furthermore china then went and banned most government workers (a large chunk of the population) from using iPhones at work. Even with all this the sales numbers and reviews out of china were ... mixed. It's hard to filter whats propaganda, but there are some legit complaints about the device. ... this doesn't help with cameras (chips) or band filters (5g, where the mate 20 really sucks) but these are less critical techs and easier to catch up on than something like EUV... A good primer on ASML and chip production is asianomitry on YouTube.

>> And yet Ukraine still hasn't won. With western high tech.

60 tanks and air defense isnt going to win them the war. The modern jets are coming but far too late. The long range weapons they have needed were also very late and in low quantity. If you haven't been paying attention their home grown drone program has made a mockery of the Russian navy and their long range air drones are now strking deep into Russia.

Everyone is afraid of "poking the bear" the French seem to be getting over that now. However you should be alarmed that the French are suggesting putting troops on the ground in Russia. Their nuclear policy is one that allows for them to use those weapons preemptively....

There has also be a fair bit of learning in the Ukraine war.... Drones have made 155 artillery into precision weapons with incredible impact. We also cant give the Ukrainians enough 155 to keep them in the fight, and there is some debate about who should foot the bill for building more factories to make shells. Our lack of "basics" has done as much to harm the war as limiting ranged and high tech weapons.

No one would win the fight with what the Ukrainians have been given... and we would not take the fight if that was what we had to work with.

>> Yes? I said China might blow up Taiwan and they most likely eventually will.

Their moment to do this was after Korea, or Vietnam. The problem is that they dont have the navy, missies or landing power to take the dam island from the Taiwanese.

>> China couldn't care less about TSMC or really anyone and anything that exists on that island,

China thinks that Taiwan is filled with Chinese. Some of the tawinese see themselves as Chinese. Blowing up the island would be counter to decades of their narrative that Taiwan is part of china.... China blowing up the island is about as likely as the US blowing up purto rico.

The idea that this is the goal of china is deeply misinformed.

>> Congratulations, we've managed to do the same thing as the misguided cavemen but did so behind schedule and over budget. Truly an achievement for the Nobel Peace Prize.

Right. You really need to catch up on news and geopolitics.

1. China/russia/india all spent a lot of money on hypersonic missles with the idea that they would be a game changer in taking out carrier groups and bypassing missile defense.

2. The few patriot batteries that we gave to Ukraine have shot down Russias modern hypersonic missiles. This makes 2 decades of posturing by china and Russia moot.

3. Chinas rocket force have been all over the news. Some intel agency has leaked all sort of internal info about them. Chinas rocket force are their "defense" against a us carrier group, they are the tip of the spear to invade Taiwan. You can read the news yourself but the highlights are, corrupt, and unprepared.

4. Those patriots are now on ships. Our navy has the capacity to protect a carrier group from the biggest non nuclear threat hypersonic. And these folks are getting practical training off the coast of Yemen right now. Our allies are even in on the action, the people who would be blockading china with us in the event of a war.

China is saber rattling. We did it right back to them... and showed that our sabers work and showed the world theirs dont. It's a bit of detant but its working for now.

Re:Intel discloses $7B operating loss for chip-making unit by maxglute on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @02:56PM (#39921494)
Agree domestic semi is crucial national security. For disagreements:

>No one wants to deal with china

Everyone wants to deal with PRC so much that US literally had to impose sanctions and export controls to make it illegal. And then extra territorialize bans/frictions on partners who didn't want to by leaning on American origin tech %s until they had no choice.

> will, talent

PRC is minting more STEM/highskilled than OECD combined, and only actor projected to build enough talent to actually have fully indigenous semi supply chain while everyone else is projected to have shortages.

> what "no chips" looks like

Except military hardware use older harden nodes that PRC has domestic supply for, they're not running out of chips for military applications.

> patriot missile system

If you actually pay attention, you'll note patriot in UKR got penetrated by 6 shit tier kinzhals @mach3 and now multiple launchers are getting wiped from 80s hardware right after RU unfucked their primitive killchain, tier1 flight IIA/III DDGs in redsea are letting slip through enough uncoordinated old gen AShMs attacks that US can't guarantee redsea shipping. Old ghetto hardware that travels at a few maches or even subsonic, launched not in coordinated fashion, with even shittier kill chain than RU. Yet state of the art US missile defense interception isn't performant enough against these ordnances not used at scale and likely wholely inadequate for modern AShMs that travel much faster.

You'll note last round of PRC rocket force leaks are retarded, rocket fuel for hotpot? Conveniently leaked around TW election to send msg that PRC won't "invade shit". It's called motivated propaganda. Meanwhile actual Teixeira leak - the stuff US prosecutes because it's actually credibly damaging - allege US clocked PRC DF27 tests at mach 8+, and many signs point to PRC pursing global prompt strike with rocketry = no one's going to blockade PRC without their own energy infra getting blown up. Including US who goes from US to Yemen without a few hundred oil refineries and LNG plants. Or domestic semis, or data centres, or F35 factories.

TLDR western ABM performed about expected relative to threats (engaging slow targets up mach3), if anything less than idea since they're letting enough slip through that their performance has essentially validates PRC's focus on high end rocket force. You think this is US showing sabers work, but it's exposing they don't work remotely well enough against threats they were designed for, AKA, what PRC rocketry was specifically designed to defeat. Now they're thinking instead of sending salvo of 100 mach 6+ AShMs against a carrier group maybe only need to send 50. Or 300 cheaper AShMs/TLAMs. What recent conflicts has taught us is scale>wunderwaffe, lesson learned from previous wars.

Re:Intel discloses $7B operating loss for chip-making unit by zer00eyz on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @10:13PM (#39925808)
>> Everyone wants to deal with PRC so much that US literally had to impose sanctions

Everyone is happy to sell as much as they can to whomever they can. The number of western companies fleeing the PRC says that every one is excited to keep betting on china?

See: https://www.forbes.com/sites/betsyatkins/2023/08/07/manufact...

>> PRC is minting more STEM/highskilled than OECD combined, and only actor projected to build enough talent to actually have fully indigenous semi supply chain while everyone else is projected to have shortages.

What SEMI supply chain? Where are they getting hardware for litho? Lenses? They aren't building that, they have no idea how.

SMIC is state backed, they got one run of 7nm chips to huwei for the latest phone and fizzled....

https://www.cnbc.com/2023/11/10/chinas-smic-posts-a-80percen...

As for skilled labor ... where? China stopped publishing youth employment, all those fresh grads dont have JOBS and most of their tech base is in shambles. Any one with any skill went outside the PRC for work and are kept in restricted roles for fear of them stealing everything in sight (tech wise).

>> Except military hardware use older harden nodes that PRC has domestic supply for, they're not running out of chips for military applications.

https://www.forbes.com/sites/davidaxe/2023/08/07/a-shortage-... These are semi conductor based devices...

MEMS devices make cell phones work (filtering) https://www.digitimes.com/news/a20230811PD215/5g-china-huawe...

None of this particularly new tech. The problem is that just because you have the machines and undestand how it works doesn't mean you can operationalize it. The restrictions have been impactful across the board and "catching up" is not just "doing it". These are insanely complex processes and getting them to work, and then at scale is a multi year process....

>> If you actually pay attention, you'll note patriot in UKR got penetrated by 6 shit tier kinzhal

https://www.forbes.com/sites/davidaxe/2024/03/09/a-russian-d...

Spotted by a drone, at the front line (to take out Russian jets) and caught with its pants down. This is not the systems failure your portraying this is an intel win for the Russians.

As for the Red Sea, Live fire exercises are important, you can train all you want but doing it and proving it are another matter. The patriot tech for this sort of interceptions has had no live tests at sea till now...

Lastly Russia has tried on several occasions to take out patriot batteries. They have missles that supposedly have the ability to directly engage them then why have they not used them?

https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/air-defence-systems-rep...

> allege US clocked PRC DF27 tests at mach 8+

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NASA_X-43

Every one tests these technologies... putting them into production is another matter...

>>> no one's going to blockade PRC without their own energy infra getting blown up. Including US who goes from US to Yemen without a few hundred oil refineries and LNG plants. Or domestic semis, or data centres, or F35 factories.

At the point that the PRC striking a US target in response to a blocked ends in a nuclear exchange... Your making the point that the PRC wont try for tawain pretty clear here with this argument as there is no outcome that doesn't end in a global catastrophe.

>> anything less than idea since they're letting enough slip through that their performance has essentially validates

Quick head count: Ukraine a massive country has enough patriots to basically defend a bit of critical infrastructure (5)... Taiwan a country of microscopic size in comparison has 14 at last count + their own home grown defense system, and the ability to fire retaliatory strikes at china (who has too massive of a cost line to deploy the same level of protection even if they had it).

>> PRC's focus on high end rocket force.

If it performs like everything else does in the PRC then they would have been better off buying bottle rockets.

>> You think this is US showing sabers work, but it's exposing they don't work remotely well enough against threats they were designed for, AKA, what PRC rocketry was specifically designed to defeat.

If Russia or china had a missile that could have taken out an active patriot battery it would have been used. Why? Because every country in the world would have bought them. The windfall for a cash strapped Russia or chines defense industry would have been huge.

TLDR: Active patriots have yet to meet a target that they cant take out. Chips, and chip manufacturing technology continues to hurt china and Russia. The decline of China has been sharp and painful for them.

Re:Intel discloses $7B operating loss for chip-making unit by maxglute on Thursday April 04, 2024 @12:07AM (#39926433)
>western companies fleeing

Western FDI constituted negligible part of PRC domestic investment as % of GDP for years. Like low single digit percentage of total investment. It largely doesn't matter. Of course western companies they're not excited after US made it geopolitically difficult to invest in PRC, because without literally making it legally difficult to do business in PRC, companies wouldn't have China+1ed/fled. That's not PRC not being attractive, that's US forcing their companies to take the L for geopolitics, which is fair. But questionable if it hurts PRC more or US.

>SEMI supply chain

They're chaining together entirely indigenous semi industry. 12/24nm under validation from SMEE. Every component has domestic ventures to replicate. A few years out, expensive/wasteful, might run late, but will eventually get there as with all PRC industiral policy that gets the manhattan project fast track. Pretty much the only country with entire semi supply chain development on horizon and talent base to man it. Huawei increased orders for 7nm phones, eating away at Apple shares. Opposite of fizzle.

>skilled labor/youth unemployment

PRC hard tech sectors have exploded in employment and compensation. Broad unemployhment 5% which means new graduates get jobs eventually. There's new youth unemployment stats to discount students in tertiary like west, it's fine at ~20%. Even at 50% that includes youth in fulltime school, that's multiple times new talent than US. Meanwhile you have sea turtles / skilled talent from abroad going back to PRC and they're retaining more high end talent than ever due to domestic opportunities. Youth unemployment breakdown also biased towards low skilled. High skill are generally fine.

>operationalize it.

PRC's has operationalized domestic MIC for 10+ years now. This is old boring news talked endlessly by US thinktanks for years. You're imagining they're learning to crawl when they're near sprint. That's why they're recognized as the pacing peer threat. No one credible thinks PRC isn't operationalizing modern capabilities at scale.

> Spotted by a drone

This this was reference to attack last year that damaged active patriot batteries. RU haven't used them more because they don't have good ISR/fast kill chains for how mobile patriots are, can't build high end missiles fast enough unlike west/PRC. So not worth commitiment. They have hardware, but limited, theres like 100 Kinzhals total and they used 20?. TLDR is they lack capability to coordinate strikes. PRC tests more high end missiles a year than RU can produce. This looks extra bad for patriots because even RU, as incompetent as they are at ISR still managed to penetrate patriot when they dedicated some highend (really medium end) hardware to the task.

> Live tests

USS Mason shot down shit tier Yemen cruise missiles (like old PRC 80s tech) in 2016, shooting down similar missiles and drones doesn't bring new learning except from PLA sigint in region gathering data on US weapon systems since they weren't in Djibouti at the time. Really shotting down primitive single digit clusters of cruise missiles is not even a useful live stress test.

>NASA_X-43

Many reports on PLA rocketforce expansion, they're making them at scale, hitting moving targets at sea. Leaks verify speed/performance. Putting up 100s of ISR for kill chain. What hasn't been verfied is US building capabilites to defend mach 5+ threats, especially at scale.

>US target in response to a blocked ends in a nuclear exchange

At the point US tries to blockade PRC ends in a nuclear exchange. See how that works. Point is PRC already deters US from even attempting blockade by making CONUS as vunerable as PRC is to SLOC blockades. SLOC blockade math works on rationale that US can enforce unilateral/existential damage to PRC without damage to herself. Now US can't without basically being in same energy deprived state as PRC. Hence US likely won't. Only real deterrence catchup is nuclear parity.

>Quick head

Quick headcount, PRC has magnitude more missile inventory and missile defense relative to RU:UKR, focused on island 16x smaller with even less perimeter to preposition defenses. The geography and math here isn't difficult, PRC can trivially overwhelm launchers TW has, assuming they even work when sensors are gone in first strike - PRC can hit anywhere in TW in 7 minutes.

> like everything else does

I mean they can land on mars first go, so I think it'll land on a carrier fine.

>windfall

PRC doesn't export high end, and RU not in position to export in middle of war with their limited industrial base.

TLDR patriots and SM2 working as intended, with expected limitations. Which is to say overwhelmable by power that can coordinate more than a handful of high performance missiles at a time. Which is actually pretty high ask but certainly includes PRC. PRC semi doing fine, catching up faster than anticipated, remember how they were suppose to be capped at 28nm. Meanwhile, they're still climbing up on the supply chain ladder, displacing more and more high tech from west, growing in S&T/innovation indexes. They crippled their R/E with 3RL and soft tech on purpose and still chugging along.

Re:Intel discloses $7B operating loss for chip-making unit by zer00eyz on Thursday April 04, 2024 @03:01AM (#39927369)
>> Western FDI constituted negligible part of PRC domestic investment as % of GDP... US made it geopolitically difficult to invest in PRC

Foxconn leaving at apples behest (and the Foxconn owner getting vocal with the prc in a rare move). The banking exoudus from Hong Kong (now deep into its 2nd year). And the impact to the GDP... its a literal house of cards with the failure of ever grand with country garden hot on its heels...

Meanwhile the retail apocalypse has hit china. High end luxury brands. Out. Grocery chains, shutting down.

Finally the iron bowl, the local government workers are getting pay cut. (because land sales are a shitty source of funding)...

Post pandemic there was going to be a realignment of global supply chains to be multi source and closer to home. Chinas covid zero policy just accelerated a decisions already made.

>> Every component has domestic ventures to replicate.

These have been facing up for decades. Without EUV they have no path forward. There is no EUV without Zeiss and ASML. Meanwhile unless your TSMC with their knowledge your going to have dismal yeilds.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dQGnwKBxAKk Probably one of the best high level insights into tech mfg in Asia.

>>PRC hard tech sectors have exploded in employment and compensation. Broad unemployhment 5% which means new graduates get jobs eventually. There's new youth unemployment stats to discount students in tertiary like west, it's fine at ~20%.

Youth?

https://www.reuters.com/world/china/china-stop-releasing-you...

Tech sector:

https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-china-58381538

https://www.thinkchina.sg/big-tech-changing-china-and-so-are...

The decline of Chinese tech from stem to stern has been in process since 2000. Again the pandemic was a blast of orders for them but it was the last one.

> Meanwhile you have sea turtles / skilled talent from abroad going back to PRC

This has always been the case, they go home with any trade secrets that aren't bolted to the floor. https://www.smics.com/en/site/news_read/4334 << there's SMIC stealing its "progress" from TSMC.

> PRC's has operationalized domestic MIC for 10+ years now.

https://www.digitimes.com/news/a20230811PD215/5g-china-huawe...

This is tech that was hardly new and sexy when the first iPhone came out, china JUST joined this party. This isnt pzrticlulary hard silicon issue but it is process intensive... Again, based on how they did it likely stolen IP.

>> This this was reference to attack last year that damaged active patriot batteries. RU haven't used them more because they don't have good ISR/fast kill chains for how mobile patriots are

https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2023/5/17/patriot-missile-sys...

The damage was minor enough to be repaired locally, the battery was not rendered inactive by this attack (read they did not destroy it). Per later reports the damage was not from one of the missles fired at it rather it was from an Iranian drone shot down in a separate intercept (oops). The reason that Russia does not have good intel on the patriots is NOT their mobility, it's their reliance on human intel (never change Russia).

Do not that even AlJazer wont call the Russian attacks "effective" and hints at US shoot downs (that no one is gonna confirm publicly, because its bad politics).

PS: This guy, locked up cause his missles dont work as promised, not because of china sale of info. https://www.reuters.com/world/russian-hypersonic-scientist-a...

>>> Really shotting down primitive single digit clusters of cruise missiles is not even a useful live stress test.

No one has seen the new block of Patriot missiles, ship board, be effective... https://www.fdd.org/analysis/2023/10/25/u-s-deploys-addition...

SO yes seeing them work in this context regardless of target size is saying 'look we did and we can'.

>>> Many reports on PLA rocketforce expansion...

https://www.iiss.org/en/online-analysis/online-analysis/2023...

This is the only credible source for their expansion into this territory... And again most of the leadership is gone, and did they or didn't they have to buy missile tech from the Russians. Meanwhile the bigger threat is in theater ICBM's with MREV's ... https://www.popularmechanics.com/military/weapons/a34702702/...

We have a lot of carriers, and have managed to keep pouring money into tech that will keep them safe (as they are large, slow, expensive targets).

> ends in a nuclear exchange

China invades tawian, china gets the blockade. People starve or china does something dumb that ends in nukes. It's a zero sum game for them and they know it. Same bluster from them since Nixon...

>> PRC has magnitude more missile inventory and missile defense

To be clear: the US navy (just the navy) has more Tomahawk's than all of the theater (medium and larger) missiles of the rocket force. Chinas combine anti missile systems (unproven) are enough to stop an attack from Taiwan (who has about half the missles of chinas rocket force). At a 50% shoot down rate, the rocket force would have to commit a significant amount of its inventory to overwhelm that defense. Thats a very precarious position to put yourself in if you expect the US to respond....

>> PRC semi doing fine, catching up faster than anticipated, remember how they were suppose to be capped at 28nm.

Nothing of the sort, see above, see the current state of china semi... They have had DUV for a long time (5 ish years from asml). They used it for 14nm, to get 7nm and can get down to 5nm.... Can isnt volume, can isnt yeild.

>> Meanwhile, they're still climbing up on the supply chain ladder, displacing more and more high tech from west, growing in S&T/innovation indexes.

The only people making this claim are china state propaganda. This is right out of the little pinks hand book. There is over a decade of court cases (both civil and criminal) for theft of intellectual property... Copying by theft isnt innovation. Meanwhile they can barely make the filters for 5g (see above, mems, 20 year old tech at this point, brand new in china). That isnt catching up, that's isnt even keeping pace... it's throwing money and espionage at a problem. China cant make camera lenses, they cant clone DU, how are they going to get to EUV (all for litho for chips).

Re:Intel discloses $7B operating loss for chip-making unit by maxglute on Thursday April 04, 2024 @04:39AM (#39927900)
>GDP impact

RE impact is 2-3%, which is what you get when RE demand gets crushed from 15T to 12T in a 100T (RMB) economy. That's it, the sum of PRC RE house of card "collapse" inefficiency is 3%, aka how PRC growth goes from wreckless 8% to fine/good 5%. PRC luxury spending up 12% last year vs 7% for US. Grocery chains are fine, some Carrefour leaving, but as if PRC relies on western grocery chains. Disposable income up 6% nominal, while inflation negligible. Supply chain was reorienting to PRC+1 pre covid, meanwhile PRC during covid exports increased 1T in 3 years, more than previous 10 years combined. Held on to most of gains / wasn't hit as hard by export decline vs others in last few years. Q1 exports up, PMI positive. It's fine. Closer to home supplies chains, i.e. Mexico has large % of transtripped PRC exports to evade tarrifs.

>decades

No really, big fund semi push only in last 10 years, build uncoordinated base, but lots of players for entire chain. 7nm yields are fine according to forensics extrapolating from quality of production. Production only one component of price, PRC not paying IP fees for domestic chips to west/US = it's economical to produce domestically even with lower yield. EUV/SSMB 5-10 years away. Questionable if <5nm has any major benefits vs PRC brute force computing and making up operation costs on the power end with massive renewable rollouts.

>youth, tech

You need to follow space more closely if you don't know about new youth unemployment data. Ditto with tech sector, especially hard tech hiring and compensation.

>tech decline

Every S&T, R&D, innovation index/ranking and reality of PRC moving up supply chain in just about every sector in last 10 years contradicts this. PRC went from like 10m STEM in 2000s/ high skill talent to 40m matching US, most in the last 10 years, and that's translating to PRC moving up tech in every sector, not just software which they deliberately slapped so people moved to more strategic sectors. Next 20 years they're adding another 40m+ STEM/high skill to workforce. There's a reason ppl freaking out about PRC EVs, green energy, mature chips - because PRC is encroaching on all the encumbant high tech previously dominated by west, and that's just PRC fucking around for a few years after spamming STEM in from academic reforms ~15 years ago.

>always been the case

PRC talent from west have never returned back to PRC on this scale before. Amount of PRC talent retention and inability for west to brain drain due to domestic opportunities have never been this high.

>stolen IP

Who cares? It's MIC, and huawei leads in 5g / telco which is what it focuses on. Working on filters was contingency post sanctions and they did it in a few years. It's a good example of how fast PRC catches in critical sectors it wants to - timeline for sanctions against PRC is more limited than most hoped - they indigenize fast. This is like people wanking about PRC finally making ballpoint pen tip (which US also can't make), when that was cover for LKQ bemoaning state didn't focus enough on precision manufacturing for advanced munitions. A year later state developed that capability.

>AJ/patriots

Quoting US officials, as if that's AJ position. It's he said she said, of course Kirby wants to play down damage, because in your words, admitting is patriots can get overwhelmed by mach3 duct taped RU missiles is "bad politics". Mobility and ISR goes hand in hand, the point of mobility is to be faster than opponent ISR, to pack up before they can plan mission. Hence RU intel failure + patriot mobility is linked. When RU ISR picked up, patriots started getting hit, of course in transit, pants down because ISR tells you thats best time to strike.

>locked up

You should look up all the CSR reports and think tank analysts who track PRC missile developments. Or former Pac fleet deputy chief Fanell who confirmed tandem PRC hypersonics struck moving ships at sea - they work fine. Like this isn't hard technology for country that has space program.

>we did we can

We already kenw that. Carney used boring old SM2, same as Mason in 2016. We already know SM2 can hit shit tier cruise missiles. Intercepting TLAMs and slower ballistics is not new. What we learned is it's not enough to deter Houthis whose still hitting ships despite USN protection. This isn't patriot test - Lockheed pitched to navy, but not integrated - no one's seen them because they don't exist. Deploying more THAAD/Patriot in MENA is not because they're peak, it's just what US have. BTW same system got overwhelmed by Houthis when they hit Saudi refineries, but we'll just blame Saudi operators because that's convenient.

>rocketforce leadership gone

For corruption, which in PRC =/= RU. Their corruption is graft of contracts not replacing rocket fuel with water or selling tires. The former requires a signiture and gets you a few years in jail, the latter bullet to the head, and for 1/100 the money. If anything PRC corruption is associated with overcapacity, grafting building more hardware. PRC has grown way past RU tech in everything except maybe sub quieting, but anything electronic/higher tech they're better, see PRC modernized flankers. Look up latest airforce university report on rate of PLA rocket force modernization.

>ICMB/MIRV

IMO Glide vehicles that defeats interceptors is more dangerous to carriers, and direction US missile defense/advanced interceptor programs are targetting. MIRVs is fine, but mostly for nukes. Conventional strikes against navy targets going to be just saturating limited local defense / magazine depth. US pours a lot into ship defense, but no indication they work against high end missile threats right now. We're up to FTM48 which hit a couple short range ballistics, but still controlled conditions, no countermeasures etc. Ultimately it doesn't matter how much US spends, amount of VLS cells in a fleet is known/finte and can be weaponeered around to saturate.

>China gets the blockade

China runs the blockade, dares US to do something, with next run on escalation ladder hitting US critical infra. US loses all oil refining capabilities and downstream inputs like fertilizer. US starves by doing somethign stupid like trying to blockade PRC. It's a zero sum game for everyone. Diffrence is PRC actually fought with every NPT nuclear state over issues less important than TW. Including US in Korea when PRC wasn't nuclear power herself. I mean if that's bluster... PRC knows US won't eat nukes for TW... and US won't risk losing her own energy supplies and not eat for TW. Hence blockade won't likely happen because US interest caluclus less suicidal vs adversaries who can strike CONUS at scale. This isn't 2010s when that argument had merit.

>navy has more Tomahawk

No USN has more coutnable VLS, people think US Navy has more Tomahawks, which btw is close to nothing even if 11k VLS cells were loaded for that mission. PRC can produce that in 11 days. 20 days and they have enough to overwhelm entire US security architecture in 1st island chain, most of which will be in range (nearly all of SKR/JP/most of PH from mainland). Ultimately 11k doesn't buy you very far when estimates for just taking out SCS island bases (missile sponges) run into 500+ for just temperoary degrading runways, let alone mainland targets. The fundmental inbalance in theatre is PRC makes more stuff, can hit more stuff, has more stuff to hit and therefore more difficult to proportionally degrade, even if you throw entire USN + get agile basing in region. Ultimately we don't know what we don't know, but we know relative to industrial output, USN can't throw enough at the problem. Like it took 5 carriers + good regional basing 3 weeks to degrade Iraq, scale that up to PRC and that's a 5 year campaign assuming nothing PRC makes work. But if they work advertised (not hard), then 11 carrier groups and 11k VLS cells is defeatable.

Also PRC does their own FTMs, they intercept cruise missiles (easy, known party trick) and balistics themselves. Reality is no one knows PRC missile stocks, because unlike ship/planes they can't be easily counted via imagery. All we know is they just showed an automated factory that can make 1k cruise/TLAM components A DAY. It's trivially easy for PRC to stockpile enough that interception is meaningless due to saturation. And for all we know, they have, because munitions factories aren't sitting idle. Having a 100k cruise missiles lying around is trivial cost. They don't even have to be advanced at that point since quantity > quality of interception. The reality is we don't know how much actual missiles PRC has, only they can make alot, and even most competent western analysts down to estimating launchers/TELs, but that's like counting guns without knowing how man bullets. Rocketforce also barely has to invest any stockpile to TW, airforce and army MLRS has most of the TW distance fires covered. And really it's matter of satuating patriots, again magazine size known quantity, and mop up uncontested.

>can isn't volume

See huawei increasing handset production to the point of eating at Apple share. Techinsights breakdown of SMIC N+2 that suggests decent yield. Now HW also planning to hammer their own AI cards. That's sufficient volume short medium term on ASML. Once they have their own twinscan DUV equivalents they'll hammer 7nm at scale even. Litho 1/3 of production cost when doesn't accoutn for other cost (licensing) etc that PRC will save on by just not using western products. When Nvidia is selling AI chips for 400% markup, there's plenty of room to be profitable at lower yield.

>china state propaganda.

I mean these are western reports on PRC export composition. Trade data/flows has to balance, they know what's coming out of PRC since... it's going into their borders. Steal IP and innovate where they lead isn't mutually exclusive. And per your filters / MEMs example, PRC fine buying from west, but when it sees strategic need to indigenize, they do it in record time. If you don't think PRC can make camera lenses then you haven't kept up. Lots of buzz in photography circles last few years of PRC lenses catching up to Japanese. That's just commercial sector end spamming for commodity. As for EUV, see SSMB. They don't need to match EUV when they can just jump it. EUV is great and all but it's also failure in sense it was suppose to be cheaper tech that ended up as 200m machines due to development difficulties. You're pretending it's blackmagic when it's an engineering problem like every other. One that's IMO much more manage than something like turbojets, commercializng EUV took ASML had ~10k employees, Zeiss SMT had ~3k, Cymer had ~1k, who worked without strategic urgency for 20 years. It's really a modest effort vs Manhattan or even Boeing/Lockheed/Airbus at 100-150k employees for aviation. It's a problem that PRC can throw people at money at and do in ~10 years, as hinted by ASML CEO himself. So trend so far is western experts overestimate.

E: Last post to not bother Dan. You can have last word.

Re:Intel discloses $7B operating loss for chip-making unit by mike_hearn on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @05:26AM (#39915137)
They probably also spend the money on pay rises. Does that also bother you?

When investors buy shares, they are in effect giving money to the company. It might be indirect if they purchase from some other holder of the share, but ultimately those shares were issued by the company and the initial purchasers gave the company that money.

Investors do this because they want a return. Either dividends or price growth or both. If there's no prospects for growth they will pull out their money and this will seriously hurt Intel, creating a downward spiral.

The US Government is subsidizing Intel because they don't want it to die. An Intel that has crushed its investors will end up on permanent subsidy life support because nobody will trust it with their money again. An Intel that uses some of those subsidies to keep investors on-side will retain their trust, and give it a pathway off government support and back onto raising funds from the markets.

So whilst this sort of thing makes the left very unhappy (often because they don't think of themselves as holding equities even when they do via pensions/insurance funds), it does make sense over the long run. Investors aren't an ATM that can just be raided at will. They're a coalition that can break.

Re:Intel discloses $7B operating loss for chip-making unit by paulmd on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @06:02AM (#39915424)
Because the money isn’t a bailout, it’s to incentivize intel to do a financially suboptimal thing that the US finds strategically desirable.

If building and running the fab in Arizona versus Ireland is going to cost intel $8b more, the options are do nothing and don’t get the fab, or pay the difference. Even if they are doing stock buybacks it doesn’t mean you can force intel’s shareholders to take a $8b loss without compensation - that’s a clear takings clause violation.

Re:Intel discloses $7B operating loss for chip-making unit by pokstad on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @12:41AM (#39913652)
Part of the USAs superpower is letting the market decide where to invest. China micromanages its economy and can’t anticipate everything the market can.
Re:Intel discloses $7B operating loss for chip-making unit by zrn900 on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @11:50PM (#39926352)
> You will have noted that not having domestic chip production has fucked Russia, and the restrictions on china are to inhibit pass through and limit what they too can do.

You must have caught up on the Ukraine conflict from the places that have been claiming that the next Wunderwaffe (TM) will surely change the war for 2 years now. Russia is perfectly able to feed its own domestic daily demand on chips and everything else, not only Chinese but even European products are entering Russia through intermediaries still, and their economy doubled its growth. The smoke screen that the corporate media creates on this conflict is much bigger than the one they created on the Iraq war.

Re:Intel discloses $7B operating loss for chip-making unit by voisin on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @10:17PM (#39912963)
> government (taxpayers'?) money

The question mark makes me think there is some uncertainty here and I am irrationally upset about the ambiguity. Of course it is taxpayers’ money! What is possibly unclear about the situation?

Re:Intel discloses $7B operating loss for chip-making unit by dragonwriter on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @10:54PM (#39913165)
> Of course it is taxpayers’ money!

No, its the government’s money. Or, viewing the government as merely an agency for collective action, it is the citizens’ money.

Obviously, the citizenry and the taxpayers have substantial overlap in most real systems, but they aren’t the same group.

Re:Intel discloses $7B operating loss for chip-making unit by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @06:52AM (#39915764)
By that logic it's actually Intel's money, because it used to belong to the taxpayer, but the law says that Intel gets it now. The trillion dollars spent on the F-35 was quite an inefficient use of Lockheed's money.
Re:Intel discloses $7B operating loss for chip-making unit by foobarian on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @10:39PM (#39913083)
How is it just taxpayers? What about non-tax paying citizens? And what about government revenues from non-tax sources?
Re:Intel discloses $7B operating loss for chip-making unit by wizzwizz4 on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @10:45PM (#39913110)
> What is possibly unclear about the situation?

While that's how things work at the district or even state level, that's not quite how money works at the federal level. To a first-order approximation, federal government spending is a tax on dollar-holders, with federal tax corresponding roughly to fealty (such service being delivered to dollar-holders). They're decoupled because the US federal government, via the Treasury, is able to create and destroy dollars.

The IRS is responsible for collecting taxes, but delivers them to the Treasury for reallocation or destruction. Since money is fungible, only the net change in extant money matters, and they don't actually have to destroy and reprint notes… though in unrelated news, they do also do that.

Though, at organisational levels below the central bank… once money has been set aside for the interests of the commons, does it truly still belong to those it was appropriated from? If I give money to a malaria charity, I don't then get to say "hey, spend that money on vaccines instead of nets": it's theirs to allocate as they see fit. If I don't like how a charity organises money, I'll choose a different one: just like how, if you don't like how your local government organises communal resources, you should vote accordingly (which, in theory, works) and otherwise take political action.

Re:Intel discloses $7B operating loss for chip-making unit by dragonwriter on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @10:57PM (#39913179)
> While that’s how things work at the district or even state level,

Aside from the fact the fiscal argument you are making isn’t the most important reason why the “taxpayers’ money” thing is wrong at all levels, its also not accurate even within the narrow view of “where does the money come from” at the district or state level, either, since those entities get funded by sources that aren’t “the taxpayers” as well, including other levels of government, like the feds, for whom you acknowledge (correctly) that it is not true because of money creating power.

Re:Intel discloses $7B operating loss for chip-making unit by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @06:58AM (#39915821)
But "other levels of government" are also getting the money from taxpayers, and money printing is constrained by its propensity to cause inflation, so in practice the amount of it that happens will correspond to the amount necessary to hit the Fed's inflation targets rather than scaling with the amount of government spending. Consequently any incremental increase or decrease in government spending would have to correspond to the same increase or decrease in tax collection, whether as the full amount in the current year or as future interest payments via deficit spending.
Re:Intel discloses $7B operating loss for chip-making unit by wizzwizz4 on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @11:36PM (#39926282)
Inflation is when the number of dollars increases faster (or decreases slower) than the amount of value in the (USD) economy does. If the money is invested in a way that creates over a dollar's worth of value per dollar, printing money can actually reduce inflation.

In typical circumstances, such investment possibilities do not exist. However, in disasters (e.g. a 4-year-old virtuoso needs surgery to repair a ventricular septal defect; an average person is homeless and needs a place to live; an asteroid's on a collision course with the planet), creating additional money is often the correct decision. Experts disagree whether the recent pandemic was such an opportunity and – if so – what the correct response was: we saw lots of different strategies playing out in lots of different countries, but I don't think that's helped resolve the controversy.

Re:Intel discloses $7B operating loss for chip-making unit by AnthonyMouse on Thursday April 04, 2024 @04:12PM (#39935252)
You're combining two different things. If you print a dollar and use it to improve productivity by more than a dollar, this might not cause inflation, but the same is true of raising general taxes by a dollar and using it for the same purpose. And those purposes are scarce, because by definition they have to have above-average productivity.

If you have one then it makes sense to fund it regardless of whether the money comes from printing or taxes, and the inflationary/deflationary consequences of that spending being priced in. And then we're back to the amount of printing being set by the desired amount of inflation, and any incremental spending on top of that coming from taxpayers.

Re:Intel discloses $7B operating loss for chip-making unit by wizzwizz4 on Thursday April 04, 2024 @10:11PM (#39938027)
> but the same is true of raising general taxes by a dollar

No, because taxes pull resources out from specific, easily-measurable areas of the economy, and that has effects on people's motivation. Increasing the value of the dollar applies deflationary pressure. High taxes on economic activity, combined with deflation, is not a good combination: people will stop spending money, and while that does relieve more opportunities for the government to invest in the economy… the competence of governments tends to be concentrated in a few specific areas, and things tend to go wrong when an unprepared government tries to run an entire economy directly.

> And those purposes are scarce,

Assuming the Efficient Market Hypothesis applies, yes. In practice… no, they really aren't. The average person contributes more to the economy than they are paid (a corollary of the theory of mutually-beneficial trade), housing costs less than ¾ of the average person's income, and people are a lot less effective at producing economic value when they have poor living conditions. The only way it would make economic sense to leave people living on the street, or constantly in and out of hotels, is if we assume the currently-homeless are inherently inferior at economic activity. Every UBI study ever has yielded evidence contrary to this assumption… and yet, we still have homeless people and we aren't doing large-scale UBI, because… reasons.

(Note that I'm ignoring the moral, human rights argument. I actually care more about human rights than numbers-go-up: it's possible that my bleeding heart is interfering with my cold, hard rationality, letting me overlook some logical flaw in this explanation.)

> If you have one then it makes sense to fund it regardless of whether the money comes from printing or taxes,

Yes! But humans are not ideal rational economic actors, and groups of humans are even worse. There is so much low-hanging fruit, you don't even need to get into the controversial things (like how exactly to fix / avert a recession) to take advantage of them. We've got years-long waiting lists for chronic health conditions that can be solved by a single drug, or a three-hour surgery. Public transport is eschewed in favour of just increasing the width of roads, leaving people shackled to slow, expensive-to-maintain, time-consuming-to-drive private cars for their travel needs. I have never seen an economic argument that supports the status quo: only political ones.

For some reason, there's usually political will to reduce taxes. (There's currently a European Citizens' Initiative to increase taxes,[0] which has reached the required threshold in France and half the required threshold in Belgium,[1] making it the most popular Citizens' Initiative currently running,[2] but politicians tend to get elected by promising tax cuts.) There's also political will to keep inflation in check. There is rarely, if ever, political will to reduce the numerical quantity of money in circulation (except as it impacts inflation), so I predict that's where many of the resources will come from, if one of the currency-controlling governments (UK, US, EU, Sweden, etc) figures out how to fix some of these problems.

[0]: https://feps-europe.eu/news/tax-the-rich-a-european-citizens...

[1]: https://citizens-initiative.europa.eu/initiatives/details/20...

[2]: https://citizens-initiative.europa.eu/_en

Re:Intel discloses $7B operating loss for chip-making unit by dimask on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @05:47AM (#39915306)
That is the government that decides to spend the money is a fact. Whether the "taxpayers" (and what "taxpayers" means) are the ones that will pay for it, is an interpretation up to perspectives on political economy.
Re:Intel discloses $7B operating loss for chip-making unit by russellbeattie on Tuesday April 02, 2024 @11:10PM (#39913246)
This comment is an absolutely perfect example of Brandolini's Law [1]:

The amount of energy needed to refute bullshit is an order of magnitude bigger than that needed to produce it.

One sentence of the same tired myopic cynical trolling bullshit causes 20 responses and paragraphs of explanation to try and refute. Absolutely perfect.

1. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brandolini's_law

Re:Intel discloses $7B operating loss for chip-making unit by dimask on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @05:55AM (#39915366)
Partly yes, I mean my effort was just to search for a link about the subject to something that seems reputable enough to share.

On the other hand, I just stated a fact. If by "explanation to try and refute" you mean just the story around china and geopolitics, it is not any high effort one. It is just repeating the same official story over and over. It does not change the fact of who is paying for it, as any sort of geopolitical justification for a war (or supporting a side in a war or supporting the continuation of a war) does not change the fact of who dies for it. Or who profits.

Funny note: your comment being self-referential.

Re:Intel discloses $7B operating loss for chip-making unit by 65a on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @12:35AM (#39913626)
There would be an ironic twist if nvidia (who first competed with AMD nee ATI) was forced to license their IP to intel for national security reasons, but it would rhyme with history (x86 licenses to AMD) and benefit the consumer.
Re:Intel discloses $7B operating loss for chip-making unit by UncleOxidant on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @12:56AM (#39913729)
Why couldn't Intel fab GPUs for Nvidia? Taiwan just had 2 7+ earthquakes this morning, so we can add that to the geopolitical risk of having a large number of the world's most advanced chip fabs on the island of Taiwan.
Re:Intel discloses $7B operating loss for chip-making unit by 65a on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @01:25AM (#39913875)
Other than process specifics, they could, and that's exactly what happened when the 1980s US Government got worried about a single CPU supplier. The result was (to some extent) modern cheap computing.
Re:Intel discloses $7B operating loss for chip-making unit by twelve40 on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @12:36AM (#39913630)
Yes, it seems they are following the large defense dinosaurs of the past into this perpetual too-big-to-fail mode of milking the public for free money. However, we've found ways before to push some things back into the private sector, to find people with energy and new ideas to run circles around stagnating boeings and lockheeds, and show them how it's done in space and other areas. It's been pretty fascinating to watch. Maybe the USG will find some way to light fire under Intel's ass too, like maybe with a little help from Taiwan or something. How these companies go from a super-innovative disruptor to a welfare program and then back has been fascinating and scary to watch. Doesn't really fit into any of the "left" or "right" cliches.
Re:Intel discloses $7B operating loss for chip-making unit by UncleOxidant on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @01:05AM (#39913769)
Given the geopolitical (and seismic) risk of having many of the world's most advanced fabs in Taiwan, it seems like it makes sense to try to locate more of them in the US from a national security standpoint (I guess that would be a 'right' argument - or at least traditionally the right was concerned about national security). Given that Intel (for better or worse) is the US' most advanced semiconductor company and that they know how to build fabs it seems like it makes sense to send some $$ their way to build more fabs in the US (I guess that would be a 'left' argument?). The market doesn't seem like it's going to optimize for the national security issue so the gov stepped in with the CHIPs act.

Can you imagine any market-based mechanism that would address this problem on it's own? Keep in mind that it takes at least 5 years from the time a fab is planned until it's operational. And it takes about $10B to build a competitive fab. The market prioritized social media from about 2005 to 2020 or so, and seemed to de-prioritize investment in things like semiconductor production. That doesn't seem to have worked out so well for us.

Re:Intel discloses $7B operating loss for chip-making unit by twelve40 on Wednesday April 03, 2024 @01:38AM (#39913965)
it feels terrible when incompetent people take over and start pissing away our money, essentially holding whatever defense concern they managed to monopolize as a hostage. So that part to me is very depressing.

My bigger point was that this process is not linear or predictable. Saturn rocket was a miracle that seemingly no market forces could afford to build. Organizations that built that miracle have exhausted and are nowadays essentially welfare. Now, SpaceX and starlink are a private miracle that was hard to imagine just a couple decades ago. Not sure what the moral is here, but somehow we seem to find a way, whether private or public.