News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Great Migration from MongoDB to PostgreSQL by vmatsiiako on Friday March 29, 2024 @01:03AM (#39860890)
I wouldn't say "Mongo is on life support" – it's actually a very successful business growing 30% YoY on a massive scale. Yet, I agree that the license switch has definitely damaged their long-term ecosystem.
Re:The Great Migration from MongoDB to PostgreSQL by smt88 on Friday March 29, 2024 @01:13AM (#39860940)
They grew 30% if you look at revenue, but that's not how people determine whether a business is healthy.

EBITDA is a better metric, and that number was getting dramatically worse every year until 2023.

But even in 2023, EBITDA was -$202M. I don't see it ever approaching $0.

So it's still a shit business on top of a shit product that no one ever really needed.

Re:The Great Migration from MongoDB to PostgreSQL by otabdeveloper4 on Friday March 29, 2024 @03:06AM (#39861397)
MongoDB is great if what you need is a replicated log or queue. It's what Kafka should have been.
Re:The Great Migration from MongoDB to PostgreSQL by smt88 on Friday March 29, 2024 @11:51PM (#39871690)
As others have said, you can just use your RDBMS for that now. Mongo is a feature of better products.
Re:The Great Migration from MongoDB to PostgreSQL by otabdeveloper4 on Monday April 01, 2024 @12:52AM (#39891029)
Postgres doesn't have a sane and working replication story. (Mysql does, but it's full of legacy warts, of course.)

Mongodb is foolproof and works out of the box.

The other alternative here isn't Mongodb, it's Couchdb, but that isn't an RDBMS.

Re:The Great Migration from MongoDB to PostgreSQL by Joel_Mckay on Friday March 29, 2024 @04:02AM (#39861645)
I think anyone who administers mongodb would agree it has a list of very dangerous behaviors for novices.

Try to upgrade a running instance node between some versions, and one may thrash object keys or worse. Best to dump and re-load your data every major upgrade to recover all set properties... and there still may be slight differences in the query language later. Wait, your data sets are 1.5TiB per node.... that is a lot of downtime...

The cursor, projection, and re-format queries can be very good at reducing reporting traffic. However, the 3 page long syntax can be unreadable to the uninitiated. The json essentially jams a bunch of equivalent SQL queries in 1 transaction, but you still have to be careful as there is no real guarantee of ordering without auto-indices in clusters.

mongodb is not as clean as SQL, but works for storing constantly changing meta data. i.e. if you find your SQL schema ends up with tuples that have a lot of poorly designed null entries, table edits, and or simply implements an object storage class abstraction in massive meta-data and object-class catch-all tables.

And yes, the mongodb new licensing model telegraphs an unfavorable policy posture. However, I do understand not wanting fortune 500 companies exploiting your teams time for free.

Profit is not an indication of quality, but rather fiscal utility. ;-)

Re:The Great Migration from MongoDB to PostgreSQL by DrNash17 on Wednesday April 10, 2024 @01:07PM (#39993096)
what is mongo's new licensing model?
Re:The Great Migration from MongoDB to PostgreSQL by basil-rash on Friday March 29, 2024 @03:14AM (#39861426)
Why do you choose EBITDA? Last I heard it was utter nonsense”, at least according to Warren Buffet.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=tvnKylAyLbQ

Re:The Great Migration from MongoDB to PostgreSQL by roenxi on Friday March 29, 2024 @03:28AM (#39861486)
You'd probably save time if you directly suggest what income metric you want to use. In the video, Buffet is basically saying he cares about income after interest, tax, depreciation and amortisation. In other words, that he cares about actual income. That'd be very on-brand for Buffet.

That measure won't be good for MongoDB Inc. either; they've been millions in the red for years. Losing $100 million in a year would be the best result they've achieved in a while now.

Re:The Great Migration from MongoDB to PostgreSQL by ulucs on Friday March 29, 2024 @06:59AM (#39862597)
so by Buffet's metric, Mongo is doing even worse
Re:The Great Migration from MongoDB to PostgreSQL by phonon on Friday March 29, 2024 @03:28AM (#39861485)
Their "Comprehensive Losses" for the last 3 years are (in thousands)

(171,150)

(343,375)

(309,090)

So there you go...

Re:The Great Migration from MongoDB to PostgreSQL by librasteve on Friday March 29, 2024 @04:27AM (#39861783)
they lost 300 million in one year?
Re:The Great Migration from MongoDB to PostgreSQL by christkv on Friday March 29, 2024 @08:05AM (#39863024)
Stock compensation cash flow was positive meaning they added cash to their account.
Re:The Great Migration from MongoDB to PostgreSQL by jeltz on Friday March 29, 2024 @07:09AM (#39862655)
Are they literally setting money on fire?
Re:The Great Migration from MongoDB to PostgreSQL by jpgvm on Friday March 29, 2024 @03:31AM (#39861501)
Buffets point is that it can be gamed to look good. In this case even if they are gaming it to look better than it is.... well it's still awful.
Re:The Great Migration from MongoDB to PostgreSQL by blitzar on Friday March 29, 2024 @04:55AM (#39861917)
People who use EBITDA are either trying to con you or they're conning themselves.
Re:The Great Migration from MongoDB to PostgreSQL by aerhardt on Friday March 29, 2024 @06:45AM (#39862532)
Probably not used in a conning context when it’s 200-300 million in the red.
Re:The Great Migration from MongoDB to PostgreSQL by DrNash17 on Thursday April 11, 2024 @07:10PM (#40007798)
Hedge fund investor here chiming in for all of you financial wizards. Hint: don't look at EBITDA. Look at (Atlas) revenue, billings, (current) remaining performance obligations, and operating cash flow. On cash flow, some people decide they want to subtract stock comp (i.e. don't add it back in the GAAP Net Income > OCF reconcilation), but that's a whole other philosophical debate that the investing community has not settled on.

Can someone tell me what their licensing changes are?

Re:The Great Migration from MongoDB to PostgreSQL by airstrike on Friday March 29, 2024 @08:08AM (#39863047)
Buffett's criticism is that EBITDA is just accounting and he cares about cash flow, specifically also after paying for CAPEX (which is Investing Cash Flow so comes after Operating Cash Flow)

EBITDA is used in the industry because it is a proxy for operating cash flow. Sometimes you don't have all the available data needed to get to OCF, or you're looking at company guidance (for future EBITDA values) or analyst estimates. It's easier to keep the conversation at the EBITDA level because it requires fewer assumptions. Generally the revenue line is ~easy to estimate because you can conceptualize how to go from the current number of customers to some future number of customers, how many dollars per customers and so on and so forth.

Then as you work your way to EBIT (Operating Income) you still have to assume some gross margin, R&D expense, etc. These are pretty tangible. It should be pretty easy to get to estimated EBIT from what the company discloses in guidance or what analysts forecast. Since D&A is pretty linear over time, people generally assume it just remains constant as a % of revenue, so now you have EBITDA which is very much like cash flow

EBITDA is similar to cash flow because it adds back to EBIT the non-cash expense that is D&A. The reason it's good to look at it before interest and taxes is because you're also thinking about how much cash the whole enterprise generates, not how much cash goes to equity holders at the end (which is often called "Free" Cash Flow because it's not tied up with commitments to others)

Coming back to Buffett, in the industries he tends to pick stocks from, CAPEX is a major thing. Companies need to build factories, buy equipment, etc. So if you just look at future EBITDA without accounting for future CAPEX needs, you're fooling yourself.

Truth be told, in those industries everyone also looks at "EBITDA minus Capex". Maybe they do so now that he's bemoaned everyone for not doing it in the first place, but IMHO his criticism largely doesn't apply among valuation professionals. Maybe it does for stock traders, but not for valuation purposes like in an M&A context

Re:The Great Migration from MongoDB to PostgreSQL by rrr_oh_man on Friday March 29, 2024 @04:36AM (#39861825)
I was totally expecting someone to come up with some vanity metric here, but a negative EBITDA of several HUNDRED MILLION? Jesus. How did that happen. B2B business should be a symphony of ka-chings for them.
Re:The Great Migration from MongoDB to PostgreSQL by dangtony98 on Friday March 29, 2024 @08:41AM (#39863357)
I'm actually very bullish on MongoDB.

While the article and significant sentiment in threads suggest a push off MongoDB toward PostgreSQL, I do think MongoDB has its own place in the stack and that it won't be obsoleted. I've personally had many pleasant experiences working with it in past projects.

Regarding business metrics, I may have a slight bias coming from the startup world but we often value revenue the most, especially in the earlier stages of a company; we can reduce costs and perform various optimizations in the future but what stays at the foundation is whether or not there is strong product market fit such that more customers keep coming in and coming back to use the underlying product — I would say MongoDB's current growth trajectory is in line with that.

I'm hopeful overall that they can turn profitable (maybe not this year or next but eventually so).

Re:The Great Migration from MongoDB to PostgreSQL by smt88 on Friday March 29, 2024 @11:50PM (#39871686)
HN should be full of Mongo's users and advocates, and yet this site loathes it. That by itself is a sign that it's a zombie.

The reason we don't just look at revenue is that you can "buy" revenue with ads and sales teams. But if that revenue growth costs more than it pays because your customers aren't sticky, then your business doesn't work. You can't apply startup principles to this large, aging public company.

Re:The Great Migration from MongoDB to PostgreSQL by mushi on Monday April 01, 2024 @09:04AM (#39893729)
“This site” loved ReThinkDB. How is it doing?