News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Farmed salmon leads to loss of nutrients, instead eat 'fe... by meristohm on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @09:41AM (#39766343)
Author Bren Smith recommends this in his book Eat Like a Fish. He also recommends eating seaweed and mollusks, and that the water of the eastern seaboard may have been mostly clear due to all the filter-feeders.

My general recommendation is to treat meat like a luxurious delicacy and to instead rely on sprouted seeds (legumes, nuts) and other plant parts for protein, until human population and customs can scale back to a point where the carrying capacity of the land and sea can support not only us but so much other life we share the planet with. Strength and resilience through diversity of species. I'm willing to give up a lot of luxuries for this. At the end of the day it's nice to settle down in a shelter with loved ones, all having eaten enough.

Re:Farmed salmon leads to loss of nutrients, instead eat 'fe... by belorn on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @10:46AM (#39767348)
I always read general recommendation for diets as conditioned under the culture for which the author lives in. Without the cultural aspect, it always sound like telling people in rice eating cultures that they should all shift to wheat because of lower methane emissions (or asking wheat eating cultures to switch to rice because of lower CO2 emissions, both arguments has a point).

I do want to see a cultural change towards seaweed and mollusks on a global scale. Nutrition rich runoff from farms create a lot of damage in oceans, lakes and rivers, and both seaweed and mollusks are great in picking up that excess nutrition. I would also like to see a change towards consuming overpopulated fish. It is a completely cultural phenomenon that we can have both overfishing and fish overpopulations at the same time (usually not the same type of fish).

I would also like to see a return towards using domesticated animals in order to replace combustion. Waste food should be prioritized towards animal feed rather than bio gas. Household animals used to be a common practice, and it allowed people to eat meat with much smaller footprint. Chickens are also excellent lawnmowers that do not operate on fossil fuels.

Re:Farmed salmon leads to loss of nutrients, instead eat 'fe... by _3u10 on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @12:06PM (#39768485)
Agreed most countries don’t appreciate meat like Brazil, Paraguay, and Argentina. If everyone lived like us the planet would be a lot more healthy and enjoyable.

Ideally Europe would stop farming and restore its forests to an equal percentage of the land as Brazil. Sadly Europe has ignored the environment for millennia and is unwilling to change its ways.

[dead]
Re:Farmed salmon leads to loss of nutrients, instead eat 'fe... by goncalo-r on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @09:58AM (#39766616)
But this is obviously not scalable/sustainable. If everyone wanted to eat grassfed beef that lives in free range fields multiple times a week, we'd very quickly run out of space and other resources. Not to mention you're still contributing heavily to climate change, unless "bio-regenerative" also means restoring the atmosphere for a zero carbon impact.

At the end of the day, we all need to eat less meat.

Re:Farmed salmon leads to loss of nutrients, instead eat 'fe... by BurningFrog on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @10:11AM (#39766817)
These "if everyone did X" arguments are very tricky.

If everyone went to buy food at my local grocery store, the 7 billion people in such a small building would cause an enormous humanitarian catastrophe.

I don't think that means there is anything wrong with me shopping there, and I don't think there is anything wrong in eating grassfed free range beef either.

Re:Farmed salmon leads to loss of nutrients, instead eat 'fe... by AlecSchueler on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @10:15AM (#39766880)
> I don't think that means there is anything wrong with me shopping there, and I don't think there is anything wrong in eating grassfed free range beef either.

Why? The first example is absurd and the logic that someone would rely on in making an argument against you shopping somewhere would also be absurd. But the second point is not absurd, as enough people are already eating meat to the point that ecosystems are severely strained.

Re:Farmed salmon leads to loss of nutrients, instead eat 'fe... by __MatrixMan__ on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @10:26AM (#39767059)
We have many grocery stores. We have one planet. It's quite reasonable to discuss whether certain people tax it beyond their share.

It's really the size of the range that's a problem. Eating food that eats food is a really inefficient way to get your energy, so you have to offset it by letting that cow range widely. You have to ask: what this that space not doing because it's currently supporting a cow instead? What have you taken away that other people need?

Re:Farmed salmon leads to loss of nutrients, instead eat 'fe... by belorn on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @11:58AM (#39768367)
Those kind of discussions generally leads downhill unless people are very willing to partake in open and philosophical discussions. What is a fair share, and what is an efficient way?

All major food production is taxing the planet beyond what it can handle, among those being the use of artificial fertilizers in farming. Using a limited resource like fossil fuels to feed people is extremely inefficient when the ocean and land has plenty enough nutrients already. Using land itself is also fairly inefficient use of space when land is only 30% of the earth, with 70% being covered by water. Nothing beats farming on water when it comes to land efficiency.

Looking at land efficiency a second time, the size of the range is not the only factor. Caribous uses a massive amount of land for very small amount of meat, but the land they use tend to have an average human population per square mile close to 0. Using land located in a rain forests is much worse than using land located within the polar circle. There is a argument that using animal ranges in some locations is both good in term of land efficiency and bio diversity.

Re:Farmed salmon leads to loss of nutrients, instead eat 'fe... by __MatrixMan__ on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @12:31PM (#39768861)
There are interesting philosophical conversations to have about fairness and efficiency, but they come up when you're in the ballpark of what some people would consider fair or efficient while some others would differ.

This is not that.

A cow spends its whole life radiating heat into the environment. That's energy that could be powering me. It's a pretty simple watts-in-watts-out calculation, and it's nowhere near efficient.

Sure, maybe no humans want to live where the cows typically graze, but there are other organisms which contribute to carbon capture and clean air and clean water and pollination and disease control... And they are displaced when you've got cows gobbling up all the new growth and preventing forests from forming.

What's unfair is that those ecosystem services are being degraded in service of a few people's dietary habits, and that their loss is subsequently impacting the rest of us.

Yeah, maybe there's a biodiversity benefit to controlling grazer population through hunting, but only as a stopgap until we manage to reintroduce natural predators which don't have to be policed or practice restraint: predator/prey population dynamics are better equilibrium seekers than government regulation re: permits and tags.

Re:Farmed salmon leads to loss of nutrients, instead eat 'fe... by belorn on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @01:10PM (#39769382)
Where the ballpark is a good starting question. Is a cow better or worse compared to artificial fertilizers? Looking at the devastation caused by run-off from farms in the baltic ocean, there is a man made underwater desert that is constantly growing with the current size of approximately 100,000 km2. Those dead zones (as they are called), lead to massive death of all aquatic organisms.

If we talking about fairness, food should be sustainable and not causing massive harm to the environment. That seems however to be outside the ballpark of what people consider possible. The question is then where we should start.

Re:Farmed salmon leads to loss of nutrients, instead eat 'fe... by exitb on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @10:18AM (#39766925)
There is not enough resources for everyone to eat sustainable beef. Some people need to eat unsustainably, so others can eat the sustainable stuff. Which is, obviously, unsustainable.
Re:Farmed salmon leads to loss of nutrients, instead eat 'fe... by throwaway5752 on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @10:29AM (#39767121)
There are actually 8.1 billion humans. Say that everyone wants beef for dinner, .5 lb / person, rounding down to 3 lbs weekly, rounding down to 150 lbs per year. That is 1.2 trillion pounds of beef per year. The real number is much lower due to age demographics, dietary choices, and poverty (about 60 lbs per person, per year in just the US) but let's keep it simple;, "If everyone in the world wanted 3 lbs of grass fed beef a week, how would that work out?"

400 lbs of meat per head of cattle is 3,000,000,000 cows. 5 acres per head of pure grass fed, double number of animals because of average slaugher at 2 years, and that is 30 billion acres devoted to grazing. For context 125 million acres are utilized for cattle (feed and grazing) in the US. Globally that is 3 times more than is used for all agriculture, globally. This is ignoring dairy.

So this is not very tricky. It is wildly unrealistic for grass fed beef to be anything but an extreme luxury food without large numbers of people starving.

Re:Farmed salmon leads to loss of nutrients, instead eat 'fe... by groestl on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @10:06AM (#39766736)
Classic tragedy of the commons.
Re:Farmed salmon leads to loss of nutrients, instead eat 'fe... by DarkNova6 on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @10:07AM (#39766765)
Grass fed beef does not add to Climate change, as all bio-emissions are bound in a cycle. Unlike typical mass production which is importing feed from far abroad, often burning a good chunk of rainforest in the process on doing so.

Not to take away from your primary point, though. I'd much rather have meat be valued as a high quality nutrient source rather than something cheap you can take for granted.

Re:Farmed salmon leads to loss of nutrients, instead eat 'fe... by lp4vn on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @10:18AM (#39766935)
>Grass fed beef does not add to Climate change, as all bio-emissions are bound in a circle. Unlike typical mass production which is importing feed from far abroad, often burning a good chunk of rainforest in the process on doing so.

There are many studies that show that beef, grass fed or not, add to Climate change.

The grass fed meme crowd thinks they are saving the rainforest by not eating beef fed with soy from monocultures in Latin America but conveniently forget that in order to feed the whole world with grass fed animals you would need more land than the world can provide. Much of the amazon is being cut down to create pastures for cattle. It's a complete tragedy.

>Beef cattle use nearly 60% of the world’s agricultural land but account for less than 2% of global calories and 5% of global protein consumed.

https://grazingfacts.com/land-use

Re:Farmed salmon leads to loss of nutrients, instead eat 'fe... by dr_kretyn on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @10:20AM (#39766957)
It adds a lot. Cows produce a lot of methane which is more destructive than CO2 (though lasts shorter). Also, in transportation, the main contributor is the last mile so "local" produce doesn't necessarily have less contributions per transported unit.
Re:Farmed salmon leads to loss of nutrients, instead eat 'fe... by michaelbrooks on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @10:20AM (#39766951)
Grass-fed cows still produce methane and require vehicles to transport them when bought and when slaughtered. The fields they are kept in will also need trees to be cleared and plants killed in favour of grass. How does that not add to climate change?
Re:Farmed salmon leads to loss of nutrients, instead eat 'fe... by voisin on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @10:15AM (#39766874)
Two can play at this game:

Animal protein raises pressure on your kidneys for hours after consumption. By eating that you are inflaming your kidneys and increasing the likelihood of a wide range of consequences.

Turns out living has consequences no matter how you live. Choose what you are willing to die for.

Re:Farmed salmon leads to loss of nutrients, instead eat 'fe... by AlexandrB on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @10:20AM (#39766958)
Also heme iron is carcinogenic[1].

[1] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21209396/

Re:Farmed salmon leads to loss of nutrients, instead eat 'fe... by dayjaby on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @10:06AM (#39766740)
Toxins get accumulated in animals in around a 10:1 ratio. 1kg meat contains 10x more toxins than 1kg plants. A good rule of thumb to remember.
Re:Farmed salmon leads to loss of nutrients, instead eat 'fe... by xenonite on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @10:08AM (#39766779)
Depends on the toxin. For example, tuna is loaded with heavy metals because it is at the end of the food chain.

However, I think the OP rather meant plant defense chemicals like phytic acid, oxalic acid etc., which as far as I know are not found in meat.

Re:Farmed salmon leads to loss of nutrients, instead eat 'fe... by TheHumanist on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @10:13AM (#39766851)
Tigers better watch out too... I hear tuna are working on developing a series of breathing apparatus so they can go on land to hunt and kill tigers.
Re:Farmed salmon leads to loss of nutrients, instead eat 'fe... by ch4s3 on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @10:00AM (#39766648)
This is almost certainly not true. Outside of heavy metals there are very few things that "accumulate" in the body and I can't find any papers mentioning nut toxins having this effect.
Re:Farmed salmon leads to loss of nutrients, instead eat 'fe... by Solvency on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @10:05AM (#39766731)
There is literally an article on the front page about PFAS bio accumulating. Look harder.
Re:Farmed salmon leads to loss of nutrients, instead eat 'fe... by Unconstrained on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @10:10AM (#39766802)
Where is the evidence that these are higher in nuts and fruit than in meat and dairy?

The article you mention doesn't answer this question. Read harder

https://medicalxpress.com/news/2024-03-pfas-blood-ubiquitous...

Re:Farmed salmon leads to loss of nutrients, instead eat 'fe... by sf_rob on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @10:31AM (#39767143)
The first study[1] I could find that included analysis of vegan vs non-vegan diets' correlation with blood PFAS levels suggest that vegan diets are negatively correlated with some classes of PFAS (and neutral with the other classes analyzed): "The strongest correlations with food groups, derived from a food frequency questionnaire, were observed between levels of PFOA and water consumption (in case of the total study population, n = 72), and between levels of PFOS as well as PFNA and the consumption of ‘meat and meat products’".

I'm not proposing that a single study is proof, but I'm default-skeptical of dietary claims without strong evidence, especially ones that comport with other aspects of worldview or preference.

[1] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S143846392...

Re:Farmed salmon leads to loss of nutrients, instead eat 'fe... by mistercow on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @10:14AM (#39766860)
PFAS is a “plant defense mechanism”?
Re:Farmed salmon leads to loss of nutrients, instead eat 'fe... by ch4s3 on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @10:29AM (#39767117)
Plant deFense mechAniSm
Re:Farmed salmon leads to loss of nutrients, instead eat 'fe... by ch4s3 on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @10:29AM (#39767100)
You'll note I wrote "there are very few things", not NO things. Read more carefully before rage posting, please.
Re:Farmed salmon leads to loss of nutrients, instead eat 'fe... by teddyh on Friday March 22, 2024 @08:51AM (#39790211)
If he had said “Very few people has actually been to the moon”, would you had commented “Here’s an article about an astronaut.”?
Re:Farmed salmon leads to loss of nutrients, instead eat 'fe... by micromacrofoot on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @10:08AM (#39766781)
These are all mitigated by a balanced diet, while deriding diets high in nut content you also neglect to mention that eating large amounts of beef significantly raises your risk of multiple forms of cancer.

Not to mention that side effects like those caused by almond consumption, would require eating hundreds of grams of almonds a day.

So you're not quite being fair here.

Re:Farmed salmon leads to loss of nutrients, instead eat 'fe... by markstos on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @10:11AM (#39766827)
What amount of optional toxins is balanced? Why not just eat less toxins?
Re:Farmed salmon leads to loss of nutrients, instead eat 'fe... by KMag on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @10:26AM (#39767051)
You'd be hard pressed to find anything absolutely toxin-free. Many toxins have non-linear effects, negligible at very low doses, so there are advantages to diversification.

Even if you could find a handful of foods that are absolutely toxin-free, eating only those would greatly reduce the diversity in your diet.

The obvious optimum is a diet minimal in the effect-weighted sum of its toxins, subject to the constraint of also providing healthy levels of all essential nutrients... which the GP is attempting to reasonably approximate without requiring years of research into the exact diet by proposing toxin risk diversification.

Re:Farmed salmon leads to loss of nutrients, instead eat 'fe... by markstos on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @10:47AM (#39767379)
Eating a primarily organic, whole-food, plant-based diet avoids lots of toxins that build up along the food chain, while still offering a huge diversity of foods.

There are far, far, more species of plants to eat than species of animals in human diets.

Re:Farmed salmon leads to loss of nutrients, instead eat 'fe... by AlecSchueler on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @10:16AM (#39766896)
Simply avoid all protein sources?
Re:Farmed salmon leads to loss of nutrients, instead eat 'fe... by markstos on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @10:22AM (#39766982)
Do you mean animal protein sources? Yes, that's a good idea.

There's plenty of protein in plant foods.

Re:Farmed salmon leads to loss of nutrients, instead eat 'fe... by AlecSchueler on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @11:34AM (#39768060)
I thought we agreed above that plants were also toxic.
Re:Farmed salmon leads to loss of nutrients, instead eat 'fe... by micromacrofoot on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @10:47AM (#39767380)
Water is a toxin in high quantities, it's not a "poison or not poison" situation
Re:Farmed salmon leads to loss of nutrients, instead eat 'fe... by markstos on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @11:03AM (#39767626)
Right, but it's also "all diets have some level of toxins so they are comparable".

Primarily whole-food, plant-based diets have the lowest level of toxins.

For example, see the Cleveland's Clinic recommendation for a low-inflammation diet which recommends diets like Mediterranean, DASH and whole-food vegetarian.

https://health.clevelandclinic.org/anti-inflammatory-diet

Re:Farmed salmon leads to loss of nutrients, instead eat 'fe... by Unconstrained on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @10:04AM (#39766718)
This is complete pseudo-science BS.
Re:Farmed salmon leads to loss of nutrients, instead eat 'fe... by Solvency on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @12:58PM (#39769236)
How do plants defend themselves? Do you know what apple seeds contain? Have you researched cashews yet? Do you cherry pick what science you think is real science!
Re:Farmed salmon leads to loss of nutrients, instead eat 'fe... by FredPret on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @09:58AM (#39766621)
Cows do an outstanding job turning grass and other inedible things into a foodstuff that not only has extreme nutritional value, but resonates with me on a cellular level.

It'd be cool if we can grow steak in future, but I think it'd be very hard to replicate an actual cow without adding toxins, and I worry that they'll make some ridiculous low-fat or low-cholesterol version based on nutritional "science".

Re:Farmed salmon leads to loss of nutrients, instead eat 'fe... by Unconstrained on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @10:06AM (#39766750)
Cows are extremely inefficient. How can you say they do an outstanding job? Outstandingly high emission of Methane belching?
Re:Farmed salmon leads to loss of nutrients, instead eat 'fe... by FredPret on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @10:10AM (#39766800)
Efficiency isn't the only way to do an outstanding job.

When Michelangelo painted the Sistine Chapel, it took him forever to paint a small surface. Any old housepainter could have been more efficient.

The point is that grass is inedible and grows all over the place, and cows turn this abundant and useless resource into wonderful steaks.

Re:Farmed salmon leads to loss of nutrients, instead eat 'fe... by cube2222 on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @10:32AM (#39767160)
Cows are literally one of the least calorie-per-CO2 efficient means of getting meat. Here's some actual data: https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/ghg-kcal-poore

You'll note that beef is by far the worst.

Here's one that better describes the components of that CO2 footprint (whether it's methane production, or transport overhead, etc.): https://ourworldindata.org/food-choice-vs-eating-local

Re:Farmed salmon leads to loss of nutrients, instead eat 'fe... by FredPret on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @10:37AM (#39767225)
I refer you to my reply to your sibling comment.

Michelangelo did a less efficient job painting the Sistine Chapel per square meter than a housepainter would have.

Re:Farmed salmon leads to loss of nutrients, instead eat 'fe... by rickydroll on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @01:34PM (#39769701)
> sprouted seeds (legumes, nuts) and other plant parts for protein

Doing so will drive demand for better diabetes treatments. Managing diabetes is a longer and more nuanced conversation than one can have here. The rule of thumb is that all carbohydrates harm blood glucose control. The best diet is based on your body type. For me (and many others), a low-carb, inulin-rich diet (unprocessed meats, low-starch vegetables) seems to give lower blood glucose increases.

Some claim a low-fat vegan diet will put diabetes into remission, and I'm sure it does for some body types. I can not judge the validity of that claim except that I do not have that body type, and it made my diabetes control significantly worse.

Re:Farmed salmon leads to loss of nutrients, instead eat 'fe... by molloy on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @01:59PM (#39770008)
> The rule of thumb is that all carbohydrates harm blood glucose control.

This is untrue. Only simple carbohydrates harm blood glucose control. Complex carbs such as whole grains and fruit aid in it, in part thanks to their fiber. If you have a source that supports your claim, please share it, it must be bleeding edge nutritional science.

Re:Farmed salmon leads to loss of nutrients, instead eat 'fe... by rickydroll on Wednesday March 20, 2024 @06:39PM (#39772882)
I've not seen any research showing that whole-grain carbohydrates have a lower impact on blood glucose than quick carbohydrates. We have only proof by repeated assertion.

My freestyle Libra CGM has recorded the impact of whole-grain products on my body. Whole-grain products consistently spike my blood sugar. 40 g of oatmeal or Bob's Red Mill 10-grain mix will push me up to 100-120 milligrams per deciliter. Whole-wheat pasta, 60g, will push me up about 150-200 mg/dL.

Eating more than 25 g carbs per meal pushes me up beyond 50 mg/dL at the one-hour mark. If I consistently let my blood sugar climb between 75 and 100 mg/dL at the one-hour mark, my fasting blood sugar starts to climb. This is how I learned that low-fat vegan was a bad diet for me. My A1c went from 6 to 7.8 in less than a year.

Too much dietary advice for diabetics is, at best, mythology.