The article says they will use a byproduct from a local industry, perhaps it's available for cheaper.
"The sand itself will also be sustainably sourced – it’ll consist of crushed soapstone, which is a manufacturing byproduct of another local industry. This material can apparently conduct heat even better than regular old sand.".
Cheaper than water?!
Also, water tends to make for a horrible heat battery as it is much more thermal-emissivity than rock particles. You need all sorts of additional insulation to retain the heat, whereas the sand will insulate itself.
Hot sand / crushed rock doesn't have the same problem. If you read in the linked article it says
> with the sand heated to somewhere around 500-600 degrees Celsius (932-1112 °F).
That would be extraordinarily hard to do with water as you'd need significant containment and safety measures.
As to cost, the article does note that they're reusing crushed soapstone from a local byproduct, so maybe that helps reduce the cost?
That said, their FAQ says it's about heat capacity: https://polarnightenergy.fi/sand-battery
> Why do you use sand?
> Many solid materials, such as sand, can be heated to temperatures well above the boiling point of water. Sand-based heat storages can store several times the amount of energy that can be stored in a water tank of a similar size; this is thanks to the large temperature range allowed by the sand. So, it saves space and it allows versatile use in many industrial applications.
So perhaps they're also specifically targeting future applications where they would need to supply > 100C heat.
Sand? If some spills just grab a skid loader and stuff it back in.
Sand is also a really good insulator if I'm not mistaken. That could also be a factor somehow.
But if ever the need arose it needs to be higher than 100C so it can generate steam for the turbine? Maybe I’m way off, I’m just a guy.
At a guess, and I confess I'm not capable of running the numbers, this offsets the much higher temperature delta of sand.
The higher density of rock probably plays a big role.
Here, this is actually the problem.
Water can store many times the amount of energy per volume or mass, per degree Celcius, than rock.
What you see is that rock has much lower thermal conductivity. It can be hot inside but it is not as good at transferring that heat outside. It means when you have hot rock it will stay hot for longer than equivalent amount of water. That because water emits that energy faster.
But put that rock and water in a well insulated vessel and you will find that the properties of the insulation and the vessel will start dominating the process and what counts now is how much energy you can store in the material inside.
-Order of magnitude smaller coefficient of thermal expansion.
-No real risk of phase change - freezing or boiling.
-No problems with corrosion/scale in high temperature. On one hand regular water contains minerals which can build up on the heat exchanger element, on the other demineralized water sucks in carbon dioxide and oxygen from the atmosphere, causing corrosion of steel parts. You would need an airtight container to alleviate this.
Sand is great because it's largely inert in a huge range of temperatures.
On the other hand the thermal expansion of water does not matter because water, you know, is a liquid -- it conforms to whatever vessel you put it in.
> -No real risk of phase change - freezing or boiling.
In a vessel that is meant to store thousands of tonnes of water that is hot and that is very well insulated to store energy for months, there is no real danger that the water will freeze. On the boiling side, water make it easy to monitor the temperature and you just stop adding energy if it starts boiling. Your kettle can do that reliably, we can do this for a huge battery.
> No problems with corrosion/scale in high temperature
It is hard to put 5 thousand tonnes of sand in a container and ensure it is dry. There is always going to be water that will be evaporating when you heat the sand in the middle and condensing on the sides that are cold.
There is no possibility of scale when you do not heat water to boiling.
> Sand is great because it's largely inert in a huge range of temperatures.
Crushed rock will release water when heated up.
Scale is important here, as you'd need an array of sensors immersed in the water so that there's no local pocket of close to boiling temperature.
> There is always going to be water that will be evaporating when you heat the sand in the middle and condensing on the sides that are cold.
That's a slow process, but even if - as long as the temperature is considerably above ambient the water will condense elsewhere.
> There is no possibility of scale when you do not heat water to boiling.
Actually it forms at temperatures as low as 28 °C.
I’ve got a few trucks in which I could transport tons and tons of and but I’d struggle to move more than a few hundred gallons of water at a time. I’d guess most transportation outfits are similar and costs in accordance. Point: sand.
sand's heat capacity = 830 J/kg degree C
sand battery size is "13m tall and 15m wide". Assuming most voluminous possible shape that's 13m * 15m * 15m = 2925 cubic meters of sand (100% fill, no account for insulation, etc.)
Dry sand density is about 1600kg/m3
Total weight of sand would be 2925m3 * 1600kg/m3 = 4.7Mkg (4.7kt)
4.7Mkg of sand has a heat capacity of 830J/kg * 4.7Mkg = 3.9 * 10^9 joules / degree C (it takes this much energy to heat up entire battery by one degree C)
So from this, we get that 100MWh of energy would heat up the battery by (3.6 * 10^11 J) / (3.9 * 10^9 J/C) or about 100C.
If we include a different shape (a cylinder), and account for a thick insulation needed, this becomes closer to 200C of temp diff.
I guess it checks out... It is going to be more difficult to estimate heat loss.
But sand is quite expensive so my question is, why sand and not water? Water has 5 times higher specific heat per weight, about 3 times per volume. Water is way cheaper than sand and much easier to find, transport and extract energy from. The only real problem with water is you can only heat it up to 100C.