News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Gabriel García Márquez Wanted to Destroy His Last Novel. ... by joe_the_user on Thursday March 07, 2024 @03:26PM (#39634187)
It's not unusual for authors to express a desire for their unpublished works to be destroyed. Kafka wanted all his unpublished works to be destroyed - consider these are most of his known works now, we're quite lucky his executor, Max Brod, defied his wishes.
Re:Gabriel García Márquez Wanted to Destroy His Last Novel. ... by chasil on Thursday March 07, 2024 @04:00PM (#39634518)
Virgil's Aeneid is the most famous example that I know...

"According to tradition, Virgil traveled to Greece around 19 BC to revise the Aeneid. After meeting Augustus in Athens and deciding to return home, Virgil caught a fever while visiting a town near Megara. Virgil crossed to Italy by ship, weakened with disease, and died in Brundisium harbour on 21 September 19 BC, leaving a wish that the manuscript of the Aeneid was to be burned. Augustus ordered Virgil's literary executors, Lucius Varius Rufus and Plotius Tucca, to disregard that wish, instead ordering the Aeneid to be published with as few editorial changes as possible. As a result, the existing text of the Aeneid may contain faults which Virgil was planning to correct before publication. However, the only obvious imperfections are a few lines of verse that are metrically unfinished (i.e., not a complete line of dactylic hexameter). Other alleged "imperfections" are subject to scholarly debate."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aeneid#Virgil's_death,_and_edi...

Re:Gabriel García Márquez Wanted to Destroy His Last Novel. ... by nescioquid on Thursday March 07, 2024 @05:07PM (#39635147)
It was the first example I thought of, as well.

I don't really mean this as an accusation, but I suspect these death-bed demands are simply a pose. Not that they are essentially insincere, but rather a final gesture of conscientiousness that should be ignored.

What is lost to the world by retaining the imperfect, incomplete?

Re:Gabriel García Márquez Wanted to Destroy His Last Novel. ... by csallen on Thursday March 07, 2024 @05:31PM (#39635393)
I think a better explanation is that authors and other creators of public works are concerned with how they will be perceived.

Otherwise, they wouldn't spend months and years meticulously editing and improving their works before release.

It's uncomfortable, embarrassing even, to have your unfinished work consumed and reviewed as if it were finished, and as if it were an accurate measure of your intentions and talent.

Re:Gabriel García Márquez Wanted to Destroy His Last Novel. ... by david-gpu on Thursday March 07, 2024 @05:54PM (#39635637)
> It's uncomfortable, embarrassing even, to have your unfinished work consumed and reviewed as if it were finished

Yes, but when the unfinished work is published, it is well known that it was incomplete.

That said, I can understand the author not wanting it to be published. If is a shitty thing to publish it against the author's will when they are alive, it is equally shitty to do it when they have died.

Re:Gabriel García Márquez Wanted to Destroy His Last Novel. ... by Aeolun on Thursday March 07, 2024 @06:48PM (#39636053)
I’m not sure about that. Presumably after they’ve died the only person that didn’t want it published has gone, so with only people left that want it punished, is that really such a bad thing?
Re:Gabriel García Márquez Wanted to Destroy His Last Novel. ... by dumpsterdiver on Thursday March 07, 2024 @06:17PM (#39635824)
> Yes, but when the unfinished work is published, it is well known that it was incomplete.

Just as a rose by any other name is still a rose, shit is still shit no matter how you frame it, and unfortunately shit tends to stick better than roses.

Re:Gabriel García Márquez Wanted to Destroy His Last Novel. ... by dustyleary on Thursday March 07, 2024 @07:09PM (#39636191)
> If is a shitty thing to publish it against the author's will when they are alive, it is equally shitty to do it when they have died.

It's definitely not _equally_ shitty. It's arguable whether it's shitty at all. For an action to be a shitty thing to do, someone must suffer as a result.

I can see a couple of ways to argue that the author's beneficiaries might suffer, and perhaps even that the author themself might suffer depending on your religious beliefs.

But surely it's not anywhere close to _equally_ shitty.

I am firmly on the side of releasing everything. Great works of art are so incredibly valuable (to the culture) that the chance of finding one that might have been missed trumps these other concerns.

GP mentioned that most of Kafka's best works would have been destroyed if his stated wishes were honored (it is debatable whether these were his actual wishes).

A web search turns up that Monet destroyed a lot of his works before he passed.

How many Aeneid's are we 'missing' because the author was successful in destroying their unfinished work?

Re:Gabriel García Márquez Wanted to Destroy His Last Novel. ... by david-gpu on Thursday March 07, 2024 @07:28PM (#39636316)
> For an action to be a shitty thing to do, someone must suffer as a result

Does somebody suffer if you urinate on the grave of a random person who died a hundred years ago? Is it a shitty thing to do?

Re:Gabriel García Márquez Wanted to Destroy His Last Novel. ... by gsinclair on Thursday March 07, 2024 @11:40PM (#39637848)
Society as a whole suffers because of the disrespect shown. Every person committing the act you describe edges society marginally closer to a world in which little respect is shown at all.

(I acknowledge this is specious!)

Re:Gabriel García Márquez Wanted to Destroy His Last Novel. ... by djur on Friday March 08, 2024 @01:12AM (#39638280)
Nobody suffers, but it might be indicative that somebody is a shitty _person_ who might maliciously or carelessly cause harm in other ways. (Obviously intent matters here, because would we ever consider it "shitty" to unknowingly urinate on an unmarked grave?)
Re:Gabriel García Márquez Wanted to Destroy His Last Novel. ... by dustyleary on Friday March 08, 2024 @04:16AM (#39639367)
It is a shitty thing to do, but there is nothing particularly special about the fact that it is a grave, or that there is a particular person involved.

Society suffers, because people do not wish to be subjected to the sight and smells associated with urination.

A cemetery is usually something of a public park, of sorts. Urinating on a random grave is around the same order of shittiness as urinating on any part of a public park meant to be appreciated or contemplated by people.

If the grave of the random person matters a lot to you, ask yourself, would it matter if the headstone were not there? Would it matter if you did not know there was a grave there?

Every time you urinate on the ground, you are urinating on the remains of millions of people.

With every breath you take, you are inhaling the remains of everyone who has ever been cremated longer ago than it took for their burn gases to homogeneously mix in into the atmosphere (which really does not take very long).

Re:Gabriel García Márquez Wanted to Destroy His Last Novel. ... by JumpCrisscross on Friday March 08, 2024 @09:13AM (#39641207)
> Does somebody suffer if you urinate on the grave of a random person who died a hundred years ago?

If the intent is to insult a group of people or that person’s descendants, yes. If not, honestly, no. Which is why we generally chase drunk teenagers out of graveyards instead of jailing them.

Re:Gabriel García Márquez Wanted to Destroy His Last Novel. ... by brigandish on Thursday March 07, 2024 @07:07PM (#39636178)
I think the more likely explanation is that they care about the work itself. If I were to write a book that no one else would ever read, I would still want it to be as good as can be.

I wonder how many devs on here publish their feature branches prior to merge? Do they push up all the WIPs too?

Re:Gabriel García Márquez Wanted to Destroy His Last Novel. ... by virgildotcodes on Thursday March 07, 2024 @05:26PM (#39635345)
Presumably the image that the dead person was attempting cultivate about themselves and their work.
Re:Gabriel García Márquez Wanted to Destroy His Last Novel. ... by Jerrrry on Thursday March 07, 2024 @05:07PM (#39635151)
>most famous

>It is unlikely that Marcus Aurelius ever intended the writings to be published.

It is lore that one of his jesters burned himself to save the writings from a fire.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meditations

Re:Gabriel García Márquez Wanted to Destroy His Last Novel. ... by rzzzt on Thursday March 07, 2024 @04:02PM (#39634527)
Add Chopin to the, ahem, list: https://youtu.be/x93pwAvUkAA
Re:Gabriel García Márquez Wanted to Destroy His Last Novel. ... by perihelions on Thursday March 07, 2024 @04:31PM (#39634815)
Brahms was successful at destroying large parts of his work product [0]. Kuhlau was too [1], thought he didn't intend to—his house burned down.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Johannes_Brahms#Works ("...once claimed to have destroyed 20 string quartets before he issued his official First in 1873...")

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Friedrich_Kuhlau

Re:Gabriel García Márquez Wanted to Destroy His Last Novel. ... by TheCaptain4815 on Thursday March 07, 2024 @04:05PM (#39634566)
Roberto Bolaño wanted 2666 to be 5 split novels
Re:Gabriel García Márquez Wanted to Destroy His Last Novel. ... by csdvrx on Thursday March 07, 2024 @03:59PM (#39634507)
> It's not unusual for authors to express a desire for their unpublished works to be destroyed. Kafka wanted all his unpublished works to be destroyed - consider these are most of his known works now, we're quite lucky his executor, Max Brod, defied his wishes.

Are we lucky, or was Kafka unlucky?

I find the lack of respect about authors' wishes very shocking.

Re:Gabriel García Márquez Wanted to Destroy His Last Novel. ... by drunkpotato on Thursday March 07, 2024 @04:04PM (#39634560)
Why? They’re dead. Not trying to be flippant, I honestly don’t get why the deceased’s desires should be elevated over the living’s. It’s a moral choice I don’t agree with and don’t entirely understand.
Re:Gabriel García Márquez Wanted to Destroy His Last Novel. ... by hosh on Thursday March 07, 2024 @04:11PM (#39634623)
This is less about the deceased's desires over that of the living and more about creative control. Any creator will want to polish their work. It's already difficult enough to articulate and express the source of inspiration, and even polished, the material expression almost never matches its source.
Re:Gabriel García Márquez Wanted to Destroy His Last Novel. ... by ghaff on Thursday March 07, 2024 @04:19PM (#39634701)
I can see both views. On the one hand, authors aren't always the best judges of their own work and executors can hire someone who may do a good job of polishing. On the other hand, there are unfinished works that are relatively mediocre (True at First Light) or just clearly unfinished (The Last Tycoon).

Of course, a movie studio is almost certain to finish off a movie if a director dies and may remove them for other reasons.

Re:Gabriel García Márquez Wanted to Destroy His Last Novel. ... by hosh on Thursday March 07, 2024 @04:40PM (#39634898)
It’s true, a good editor or producer collaborates with the creative to get it across the finish line, flawed as it is.

It works better if there is mutual respect.

My point though is when generalizing and reframing this about the deceased vs living, more often than not, it is no longer about respecting (even respectfully disagreeing) with the creative and more about disrespecting the deceased.

Re:Gabriel García Márquez Wanted to Destroy His Last Novel. ... by ghaff on Thursday March 07, 2024 @04:54PM (#39635011)
>It’s true, a good editor or producer collaborates with the creative to get it across the finish line, flawed as it is.

If it's a studio film, they may well fire the director and hire a new one. And, of course, screenwriters are casually script doctored with or without their consent.

Re:Gabriel García Márquez Wanted to Destroy His Last Novel. ... by hosh on Thursday March 07, 2024 @04:59PM (#39635067)
Sure, because it is funded by a commercial concern and they are in the business of selling entertainment.

With books, the balance of power isn’t so skewed to the publisher, though I suppose it depends on what it is.

I don’t know what circumstances Tolkien’s unfinished work was released, though it seems like his son toiled away at them for years.

Re:Gabriel García Márquez Wanted to Destroy His Last Novel. ... by ghaff on Thursday March 07, 2024 @05:09PM (#39635163)
True, and there's typically far less money (or big expenses) involved with books.

I always assumed Christopher Tolkien had some sort of "do with them what you think best" agreement with his father although I don't actually know. Not that there's anything particularly special in written word beyond Tolkien's originals.

Re:Gabriel García Márquez Wanted to Destroy His Last Novel. ... by chasil on Thursday March 07, 2024 @05:19PM (#39635260)
Well, I guess that we all need to stop listening to Schubert's unfinished symphony.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Symphony_No._8_(Schubert)#Earl...

Re:Gabriel García Márquez Wanted to Destroy His Last Novel. ... by vidarh on Thursday March 07, 2024 @04:18PM (#39634687)
I've published two novels, and I have tons of notes for all kinds of things, and frankly while there is lots I have written that I don't want to publish until/unless I rework it, and some things I don't want to publish at all, I couldn't give a shit what gets published after I'm dead other than to the extent it'd harm or embarrass anyone I care about. I don't think I have anything that'd harm anyone, but I do have things that might embarrass some. Like love poems written in my youth that has sentimental value for me, but might be embarrassing to my present or then girlfriend, for example.

Frankly, all I'd ask of a literary executor would be that they 1) humor my requests while I'm alive, 2) respect the wishes of my family. Other than that, whether they actually follow through on my wishes? Put it this way, if I find myself in an afterlife, as an atheist, I doubt whether my executor stuck my wishes will be high on my list of things to care about. And without an afterlife it's not as if I'd be able to care. Or know,

Re:Gabriel García Márquez Wanted to Destroy His Last Novel. ... by westhanover on Thursday March 07, 2024 @05:34PM (#39635424)
Do I have permission to desecrate your corpse? You are dead after all.
Re:Gabriel García Márquez Wanted to Destroy His Last Novel. ... by NavinF on Thursday March 07, 2024 @07:15PM (#39636238)
I don't see why not. My body is no different from my other possessions
Re:Gabriel García Márquez Wanted to Destroy His Last Novel. ... by GloomyBoots on Thursday March 07, 2024 @07:40PM (#39636410)
Are you fine with desecrating the bodies of others against their wishes?
Re:Gabriel García Márquez Wanted to Destroy His Last Novel. ... by bitzun on Thursday March 07, 2024 @08:42PM (#39636870)
Not GP but: Dead bodies? Sure, they're dead. Everything meaningful and special about them is gone.
Re:Gabriel García Márquez Wanted to Destroy His Last Novel. ... by saberience on Friday March 08, 2024 @12:20AM (#39638044)
Ok so you’d be fine with having sex with a dead child’s corpse then? You seem like quite a guy.

I mean they’re dead right? Everything meaningful and special about them is gone.

Re:Gabriel García Márquez Wanted to Destroy His Last Novel. ... by reilly3000 on Friday March 08, 2024 @12:45AM (#39638151)
I hope you remember the night when you made the pedonecrophila strawman argument fondly, but I trust you won’t.
Re:Gabriel García Márquez Wanted to Destroy His Last Novel. ... by saberience on Friday March 08, 2024 @07:52AM (#39640606)
I mean, it was a response to people saying it was ok to desecrate a corpse because they’re dead and won’t know about it. So where do these people draw the line? If it’s OK to desecrate a corpse but necrophilia is “too far” then what is their argument?

The corpse doesn’t know if it was desecrated nor does it know if it was subject to necrophilia. So if desecrating a corpse is “ok” according to the above commentators, why is necrophilia not ok too? And if necrophilia is not ok, then perhaps there’s a flaw in their argument.

That is, some things are morally wrong, even if there is no apparent “victim” as the victim is dead.

Re:Gabriel García Márquez Wanted to Destroy His Last Novel. ... by pfdietz on Thursday March 07, 2024 @05:41PM (#39635511)
Do what Steven Wright plans and donate your body to science fiction.
Re:Gabriel García Márquez Wanted to Destroy His Last Novel. ... by jkestner on Thursday March 07, 2024 @05:38PM (#39635488)
I'm donating my body to art, so sure.
Re:Gabriel García Márquez Wanted to Destroy His Last Novel. ... by BeFlatXIII on Friday March 08, 2024 @12:54PM (#39643707)
…but destroying it deprives a future creative from putting in the polishing touches. Shoulders of giants and all.
Re:Gabriel García Márquez Wanted to Destroy His Last Novel. ... by itishappy on Thursday March 07, 2024 @04:21PM (#39634723)
Does this apply to inheritance too? Why should we care what happens to our kids once we die?
Re:Gabriel García Márquez Wanted to Destroy His Last Novel. ... by drunkpotato on Thursday March 07, 2024 @04:24PM (#39634745)
While we’re alive, we care. When we’re dead, it’s up to our children to care. Inheritance wishes are generally respected, but also can and do get overridden. I’m not saying that an author’s wishes shouldn’t be taken into account, the living still care about how they felt while they were alive, but it shouldn’t be the one and only priority that gets respected. Again, the dead can’t care anymore. Only the living can.
Re:Gabriel García Márquez Wanted to Destroy His Last Novel. ... by hosh on Thursday March 07, 2024 @04:50PM (#39634971)
That really depends upon your beliefs and understanding of the cosmos. Not everyone agrees with that.

To be fair, I have practiced shaivasana (“corpse pose”), specifically including “corpse don’t care” as a response to existential anguish arising and passing. But I also know quite a good bit about what it means to regret and long for second chances or a path not taken. I think it is quite rare for anyone (regardless of beliefs) to die without regrets. If you are able to pull that off for yourself, I’m glad for you.

Re:Gabriel García Márquez Wanted to Destroy His Last Novel. ... by hosh on Thursday March 07, 2024 @04:55PM (#39635027)
It’s interesting you bring up kids.

In a belief system where there is a Creator, and the Creator is a Mother, all of Creation are her children. Thus, as humans, raising and nurturing a child is as much of an act of creation as art, music, etc. And conversely, our artistic creations tend to develop a life of its own.

Re:Gabriel García Márquez Wanted to Destroy His Last Novel. ... by nottorp on Thursday March 07, 2024 @05:21PM (#39635281)
But but... our copyright lords at the Mouse's castle have decreed that copyright lasts 75 years after the author's death.

That means it's illegal to not respect the dead person's wishes. The copyright is theirs, not their descendant's.

Re:Gabriel García Márquez Wanted to Destroy His Last Novel. ... by pfdietz on Thursday March 07, 2024 @05:42PM (#39635523)
Copyright lasts for that period, but it doesn't continue to belong to the dead person.
Re:Gabriel García Márquez Wanted to Destroy His Last Novel. ... by jzb on Thursday March 07, 2024 @05:57PM (#39635674)
They weren't deceased when they expressed the desire. You usually don't know when, exactly, you're going to die. Nobody would argue, I hope, with "I'm going on a trip, don't publish anything I'm not done with until I get back and finish it." This just happens to be a very long, one-way trip.

That said, I do think once someone is dead, there's some argument whether you have to respect that. But I at least understand the desire.

Re:Gabriel García Márquez Wanted to Destroy His Last Novel. ... by brigandish on Thursday March 07, 2024 @07:09PM (#39636190)
Because other people's wishes - especially about their own stuff - are to be respected?
Re:Gabriel García Márquez Wanted to Destroy His Last Novel. ... by joe_the_user on Thursday March 07, 2024 @04:21PM (#39634721)
Aside from "they're dead, how can it hurt them" factor, there's the point that if an author well and truly wants a given work out of the public eye, they can destroy it themselves when they're alive.
Re:Gabriel García Márquez Wanted to Destroy His Last Novel. ... by jl6 on Thursday March 07, 2024 @05:07PM (#39635140)
Usually we’re talking about things like the author’s private notes and rough drafts, which they may well wish to keep around while they are alive (because they are useful).
Re:Gabriel García Márquez Wanted to Destroy His Last Novel. ... by kryptiskt on Thursday March 07, 2024 @05:14PM (#39635210)
He put them in the care of Brod, who had told him that he would refuse to burn them. If he really wanted the work burned he wouldn't have put it in the hands of his biggest fan.
Re:Gabriel García Márquez Wanted to Destroy His Last Novel. ... by melagonster on Thursday March 07, 2024 @08:01PM (#39636557)
yes, this even is not a good example in this thread. both of them familiar with this process. Kafka just played same tricks at his end of life.
Re:Gabriel García Márquez Wanted to Destroy His Last Novel. ... by timetraveller26 on Thursday March 07, 2024 @06:04PM (#39635721)
One interesting case, an outsider artist, is Henry Darger "In the Realms of the Unreal"

> In the Realms of the Unreal is a 15,145-page work bound in fifteen immense, densely typed volumes (with three of them consisting of several hundred illustrations, scroll-like watercolor paintings on paper derived from magazines and coloring books) created over six decades. Darger illustrated his stories using a technique of traced images cut from magazines and catalogues, arranged in large panoramic landscapes and painted in watercolors, some as large as 30 feet wide and painted on both sides. He wrote himself into the narrative as the children's protector.[3]: 64

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Henry_Darger#In_the_Realms_of_...

Re:Gabriel García Márquez Wanted to Destroy His Last Novel. ... by Onavo on Thursday March 07, 2024 @06:20PM (#39635856)
Since this is HN, what are the legal, game theoretic, and technical means to ensure that your will is executed to the letter?

Bind the executor to a contract before hand? Perhaps have two additional watchdog entities setup to sue if the executor disobeys? Have a smart contract oracle escrow on the blockchain to automatically pay out to the law firm for suit if the number of ISBNs associated with your name increases?