News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Global AppleTalk Network: Pushing AppleTalk Across the ... by ThePowerOfFuet on Tuesday March 05, 2024 @06:26AM (#39602024)
Just because you can doesn't mean you should.
Re:A Global AppleTalk Network: Pushing AppleTalk Across the ... by AlbertCory on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @01:58PM (#39619718)
How about a global Corvus network? Or a global WangNet network?

Some things just died, as is the way of all flesh.

Re:A Global AppleTalk Network: Pushing AppleTalk Across the ... by johnklos on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @02:06PM (#39619858)
There are many, many more Macs than Wangs and Corvus systems.

The people who don't learn from the past are usually the people who aren't all that interested in learning how things work, learning the lessons people and companies made in the past, and applying those lessons to today and the future. I personally think this is neat!

Old technology can still be quite useful. I still use an ancient ImageWriter II because new printers suck, and having more options to use old hardware is always a good thing.

Re:A Global AppleTalk Network: Pushing AppleTalk Across the ... by AlbertCory on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @02:45PM (#39620392)
> The people who don't learn from the past are usually the people who aren't all that interested in learning how things work, learning the lessons people and companies made in the past, and applying those lessons to today and the future.

No, actually, I do know how things work. The problem for you is that the Internet is there now and the whole world is on it, to a first approximation.

Knowing what the Internet designers did wrong (btw, the internet-history mailing list does this subject regularly) doesn't help us much, because we're not going to be doing it again.

As for old hardware: right on. If it works, keep using it.

Re:A Global AppleTalk Network: Pushing AppleTalk Across the ... by cfr2023 on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @03:52PM (#39621269)
Not sure of the tone of this post, does the idea of a bunch of enthusiasts having fun with old computer hardware actually upset you? If so, do you feel similarly about hobbyists that tinker with things like old cars, old clocks, old musical instruments...
Re:A Global AppleTalk Network: Pushing AppleTalk Across the ... by AlbertCory on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @04:47PM (#39622046)
> does the idea of a bunch of enthusiasts having fun with old computer hardware actually upset you?

You said "hardware." I specifically gave thumbs-up to hardware. Did you not read that?

As for reinventing basic networking: no, it's not upsetting, but it IS self-limiting. The networks of the future will probably require brand-new thinking, not resurrected old stuff.

Re:A Global AppleTalk Network: Pushing AppleTalk Across the ... by cfr2023 on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @11:22PM (#39625028)
I read it all right but it is illogical ranting. You’re cool with people tinkering with hardware but any software work is out of line?

Writing software is a use for computer hardware, and people with minds broader than yours do it for pure enjoyment and exploration. The attitude expressed in your post is self-limiting.

Re:A Global AppleTalk Network: Pushing AppleTalk Across the ... by AlbertCory on Thursday March 07, 2024 @11:26AM (#39630955)
Inappropriate generalizing. What are you, the logic police? Let it go.
Re:A Global AppleTalk Network: Pushing AppleTalk Across the ... by cfr2023 on Thursday March 07, 2024 @01:24PM (#39632661)
What are you, the hobby police?
Re:A Global AppleTalk Network: Pushing AppleTalk Across the ... by AlbertCory on Thursday March 07, 2024 @05:25PM (#39635335)
That's right. My hobby is keeping people like you busy. See how well it works?
Re:A Global AppleTalk Network: Pushing AppleTalk Across the ... by cfr2023 on Thursday March 07, 2024 @06:50PM (#39636062)
Yes, I am proud to do the public service of helping troubled people see they are making senseless arguments about what other people do for fun.
Re:A Global AppleTalk Network: Pushing AppleTalk Across the ... by cfr2023 on Thursday March 07, 2024 @06:59PM (#39636126)
I will add that you are entirely projecting your goals and values onto this project in a way that makes absolutely no sense.

The post literally ends ends with:

"But most importantly, have fun!"

You think a bunch of people who are on record as setting out to have fun are "limiting themselves" by not inventing the future of networking.

In doing so, you've invented the future bad posting.

Re:A Global AppleTalk Network: Pushing AppleTalk Across the ... by Palomides on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @02:43PM (#39620377)
there's a global DECNet community still going (HECNet): http://mim.stupi.net/hecnet.htm
Re:A Global AppleTalk Network: Pushing AppleTalk Across the ... by mistrial9 on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @02:25PM (#39620114)
the reasoning at the time was that the protocols are "too chatty" .. they repeat msgs for discovery and also for transaction completeness more so than the carefully built TCP/IP in the 90s.

There is nothing wrong with most of the stack, if you go back before OpenTransport (a rewrite, didn't go far, imperfect)

Re:A Global AppleTalk Network: Pushing AppleTalk Across the ... by mannyv on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @05:30PM (#39622596)
The reason AppleTalk was chatty was to make discovery easier. Unlike the corporate solutions, AT was peer-to-peer. Ut who are your peers? Uh, well, hmm.

That was also when networking was new, and chatty on thinnet meant lower bandwidth.

To be honest, i doubt the chatty protocols really impacted anything...except that "network administrators" didn't like the idea of packets ie: they wanted a clean wire. This might have been due to the phone company origins of networking people.

Oh, and maybe the chattiness fired up those uucp links?

The world now is totally different. Even on my home network there's tons of crosstalk.

Re:A Global AppleTalk Network: Pushing AppleTalk Across the ... by duskwuff on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @05:40PM (#39622693)
> To be honest, i doubt the chatty protocols really impacted anything...

The "chattiness" of AppleTalk was a significant issue when it was running over a shared 115.2 kBaud serial line (LocalTalk).

Re:A Global AppleTalk Network: Pushing AppleTalk Across the ... by mannyv on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @08:19PM (#39623992)
I remember those days, and really, slow file transfer > no file transfer. OTOH I was on thinnet at the time.

And who really had 115kbps at the time? That'a dual ISDN, which was used by pretty much nobody. It's not like IPX would have been better over that link.

Re:A Global AppleTalk Network: Pushing AppleTalk Across the ... by duskwuff on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @08:43PM (#39624147)
> And who really had 115kbps at the time?

LocalTalk LANs.

Re:A Global AppleTalk Network: Pushing AppleTalk Across the ... by mistrial9 on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @06:39PM (#39623236)
no, the objection was from network administrators of very large networks aka the Internet.

At that time, TCP/IP itself was also failing to scale, so I imagine there was a lot of blame in every direction. "Heroic" efforts at cleaning up different aspects of TCP/IP and then DNS are the only reason we have a world network now.

chattyness on local networks was not awful, and you can read here how UCLA and others managed fairly large networks after Appletalk 2.0x zones were implemented.

Re:A Global AppleTalk Network: Pushing AppleTalk Across the ... by mannyv on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @08:18PM (#39623975)
Well, people needed to filter out AppleTalk on the WAN side. I wouldn't be surprised if a lot of people didn't - and those T1s were expensive.
Re:A Global AppleTalk Network: Pushing AppleTalk Across the ... by just_steve_h on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @02:28PM (#39620161)
I love this! Reminds me of the campus network at Harvard. Around 1994-95 we had multiple zones, but only spotty understanding of networks by most users. I had a blast one day mocking up what looked like a Mac on-screen error message which said “Sorry, this Document could not be printed,” which I then printed on randomly-chosen printers across the University. Good times!
Re:A Global AppleTalk Network: Pushing AppleTalk Across the ... by bombcar on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @03:21PM (#39620908)
It was a few years later, but we had some fun when we realized you could communicate with Laserjet printers and change what they said on the display.
Re:A Global AppleTalk Network: Pushing AppleTalk Across the ... by VWWHFSfQ on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @03:30PM (#39621008)
you would go to prison for that now
Re:A Global AppleTalk Network: Pushing AppleTalk Across the ... by LordGrey on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @04:10PM (#39621511)
I'm moving in a few weeks and just found new homes for my stash of 30+ year old Macs, CRTs, and LaserWriters.

Now I want it all back so I can go play....

Re:A Global AppleTalk Network: Pushing AppleTalk Across the ... by morphle on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @04:26PM (#39621720)
Please, can you tell me where?

I need to find a home for my 40 year old Macs (almost every model), CRTs, cables, etc.

Re:A Global AppleTalk Network: Pushing AppleTalk Across the ... by LordGrey on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @05:04PM (#39622273)
I found homes via Mastadon! I posted what I had, including pictures, and added tags like #vintageapple, #retroapple, and #retrocomputing.

YMMV depending on where you live, but I'm sure you will get some positive responses.

Re:A Global AppleTalk Network: Pushing AppleTalk Across the ... by latchkey on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @04:42PM (#39621961)
Re:A Global AppleTalk Network: Pushing AppleTalk Across the ... by latchkey on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @04:40PM (#39621927)
Wow, this brings back memories. Back in 1991, I was freshly into a cal state college in the Los Angeles area. We had access to the entire cal state AppleTalk network, which included a bunch of high schools as well. That AppleTalk zone list had hundreds of networks in it all up and down California.

Around 1992/93, I started working for a department in school that had it's own budget and lots of money. The head of the department loved Apple. I built out Mac labs and networking and had us hooked onto all of this.

It was a bit of this whole hidden world and quite fun in the pre-internet explosion days. Mind you, this was all back before Windows even had a native tcp/ip stack, so it felt even more us vs. them isolated.

Re:A Global AppleTalk Network: Pushing AppleTalk Across the ... by Dalewyn on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @09:50PM (#39624552)
>a cal state college in the Los Angeles area.

CSUN?

Re:A Global AppleTalk Network: Pushing AppleTalk Across the ... by latchkey on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @10:18PM (#39624708)
CSUDH. I didn't get good grades in school so that was about the only place I could go. They have a velodrome that I could train on and I got small scholarships for cycling. It turns out going there was the best thing I could possibly do for my future career in tech. Definitely not the best place to be during the riots though.
Re:A Global AppleTalk Network: Pushing AppleTalk Across the ... by api on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @05:18PM (#39622457)
You can do this with ZeroTier too, which can emulate L2 Ethernet and carry AppleTalk, IPX, and lots of other old and unusual protocols. It can be bridged to physical networks to connect old devices like this.
Re:A Global AppleTalk Network: Pushing AppleTalk Across the ... by kalleboo on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @09:00PM (#39624267)
This is tons of fun, currently we're up to 16 networks with 29 machines around the world all connected together, printing, sharing files, chatting, playing Bolo and Risk, all over good old AppleTalk.

Theres definitely a bit of old-school LAN party or BBS feel to everything, checking out what fun stuff people have on their file share, leaving a note "hey I was here" etc. That excitement of "ooh I'm logging into a machine way over there!" that was lost when the World Wide Web became the norm.

Re:A Global AppleTalk Network: Pushing AppleTalk Across the ... by watersb on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @09:03PM (#39624291)
CYBERDOG!
Re:A Global AppleTalk Network: Pushing AppleTalk Across the ... by jmbwell on Wednesday March 06, 2024 @11:38PM (#39625102)
Well I’ve hosed my MacOS 9 machine trying to do this.

Note, it doesn’t work with Mac OS 9!

Now I get to enjoy the retro activity of getting a Mac to boot again after a botched installation…