News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Earth is getting greener by TheOtherHobbes on Saturday February 24, 2024 @08:15AM (#39491265)
England is very green at the moment. At least the areas that aren't flooded are.

The issue for humans isn't the "amount of green", it's high quality crop yields.

Increasing CO2 increases plant growth, but also lowers nutritional value.

https://cupblog.org/2023/04/06/the-truth-about-rising-co2-an...

Re:The Earth is getting greener by DinaCoder99 on Saturday February 24, 2024 @08:25AM (#39491322)
We overproduce food for the human race by like 35% right now, we have a long ways to go before we hit a population issue. Regardless of all the hand-wringing certain rich people do about the birth rates in Africa. A much more pressing concern is our lack of any inclination to reasonably distribute it.
Re:The Earth is getting greener by onlyrealcuzzo on Saturday February 24, 2024 @08:52AM (#39491486)
Just the inefficiencies in beef yields alone could probably feed half of Africa.

We've got a long, long, long way to go before half the world is starving to death.

Re:The Earth is getting greener by ADeerAppeared on Saturday February 24, 2024 @12:51PM (#39493541)
It's so much more than that.

We produce ~77 million tonnes of beef, using (at the 1:25 ratio) 1925 million tonnes of feed.

Africa currently imports most of it's grains, let's take a generous estimate of ~75 million tonnes of grain. Add another 25 million tonnes for their local production.

And we're still off by a factor of 19x.

Food production capacity is a non-issue. Availability to the people who need it is the real problem, and that is primarily about our willingness to aid those who need it and make some personal sacrifices for the greater good.

Re:The Earth is getting greener by CalRobert on Saturday February 24, 2024 @08:43AM (#39491422)
The population of cattle is a bigger concern than the population of humans
Re:The Earth is getting greener by insane_dreamer on Saturday February 24, 2024 @11:23AM (#39492719)
spoken like a true "inner"
Re:The Earth is getting greener by Razengan on Saturday February 24, 2024 @08:56AM (#39491515)
> we have a long ways to go before we hit a population issue.

I wish people who say that would actually live in the overpopulated regions of the world for just 1 month.

Re:The Earth is getting greener by DinaCoder99 on Saturday February 24, 2024 @09:07AM (#39491579)
> I wish people who say that would actually live in the overpopulated regions of the world for just 1 month.

People need to stop dragging 19th century nonsense into a globalized economy. Regional carrying capacity is certainly a thing, but the primary constraint in most areas today isn't food (which is, after all, rather easy to ship and process) but water. Anyway, you can apply the same reasoning to migration as I did to food. It's just not really an issue outside of political utility. The US alone could support literally billions of people if we gave a shit about anything other than money.

Re:The Earth is getting greener by starluz on Saturday February 24, 2024 @09:38AM (#39491762)
I’ve heard this argument before and it is insane to me. Re comment above have you been to an overpopulated region? It is not just about food. Logically movement becomes more limited and difficult with people literally in each others way. Regions become incredibly inefficient. We are independent beings not meant to live like sardines
Re:The Earth is getting greener by throwaway2037 on Sunday February 25, 2024 @06:04AM (#39499787)
> Regions become incredibly inefficient.

Tokyo? Seoul? Manhattan? London? Paris? All very dense. Also very economically efficient. All have great metro systems, so it is easy to move around.

Re:The Earth is getting greener by Turing_Machine on Saturday February 24, 2024 @07:20PM (#39496390)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_and_dependen...

Of the top ten on that list, at least 5 would be considered desirable places to live by most people. If the criterion is "better than most other countries in the region", it's more like 9 out of 10 (Gaza Strip is pretty bad).

By contrast, many of the lesser-populated regions/countries are considered to be horrible places to live. As I scan down the list, it looks like there is only a very weak correlation, at best, between population density and "would I want to live there".

Obviously, your mileage is going to vary. Nonetheless, I bet you'd rather move to The Netherlands (#33) than Afghanistan (#153).

Re:The Earth is getting greener by api on Saturday February 24, 2024 @08:28AM (#39491335)
The whole environmental movement made a mistake framing things as a moralistic struggle to “save the Earth.” Like George Carlin famously said on this subject: “the Earth will be fine. We’re fucked.

The Earth has been far warmer with higher CO2 concentrations in its past and it was fine, but there were no humans then. It’s also been in an ice age fairly recently, but there was little civilization as far as we know and far fewer humans.

Environmental concerns are selfish. They’re about protecting our civilization and our quality of life. The Earth and its ecosystem will change and adapt as usual, but that doesn’t mean we will.

The biggest dangers I see from CO2 are ocean acidification leading to the collapse of ocean ecosystems that feed us, and insane heat waves causing crop failures or even deadly temperatures. Look up “wet bulb temperature limit.” There are heat conditions under which humans die without shelter and unlike cold you can’t fix it by bundling up and using simple tech. I could see heat waves where people without A/C die.

Re:The Earth is getting greener by Scarblac on Saturday February 24, 2024 @09:43AM (#39491789)
> Environmental concerns are selfish.

That's overstating it.

Yes, life will go on. But it's not only us that will die - as you say, much of the marine ecosystem will die off, we're not the only animal that has problems with wet bulb temperature (most don't even sweat), and humanity isn't going to die of starvation before we make everything remotely edible out there extinct first.

Life is going to look extremely different, it's not just us.

Re:The Earth is getting greener by exoverito on Saturday February 24, 2024 @10:22AM (#39492126)
Alligators have survived through many ice ages, with similar fossils dating back at least 65 million years. That should give people some perspective of what kinds of ecologies continually persist on Earth.

During the Carboniferous era CO2 levels were around 1500-3000 ppm, a time of vast forests and thriving life. This was also before fungi could digest lignin, so all the wood kept building up and became the coal deposits of today.

The apocalyptic climate change visions where we end up like Venus are unscientific. The atmosphere of Venus is 100 times as dense and 99% CO2. Furthermore, secular people are still humans and are susceptible to the same impulses found in religious people. The parallels between the climate change movement and millenarian eschatology is uncanny. More broadly, progressive and woke ideology has many of the same components as religion with their own unique forms of original sin, sacred victims, taboo facts, purifying speech, etc.

https://boghossian.substack.com/p/woke-religion-a-taxonomy

Re:The Earth is getting greener by Scarblac on Saturday February 24, 2024 @12:25PM (#39493298)
Yes, but it's not only climate change this time. We are also massively overusing every natural resource there is. We're in a mass extinction event and we would be in it even if there wasn't a CO2 problem at all.
Re:The Earth is getting greener by adastra22 on Saturday February 24, 2024 @01:20PM (#39493809)
There are effectively no limits to natural resources, as accessible resources are a function of technology and market price. And the solar system is vast.

Get out of the Malthusian thinking trap.

Re:The Earth is getting greener by silverquiet on Saturday February 24, 2024 @10:31AM (#39492212)
I’d note that stellar output was significantly lower during the Carboniferous and there’s a lot of range between the Earth’s current climate and Venus that are still really bad.

I don’t entirely disagree with the religious thing, but what always struck me as the most bizarre belief was denial of the basic science of climate change; did people really believe that humanity could dump unlimited amounts of carbon dioxide, a greenhouse gas, into the atmosphere with no consequence?

Re:The Earth is getting greener by arp242 on Saturday February 24, 2024 @11:16AM (#39492664)
> The apocalyptic climate change visions where we end up like Venus are unscientific

It is. It's also a fringe belief that's not held by anyone serious speaking on the subject.

Re:The Earth is getting greener by adastra22 on Saturday February 24, 2024 @01:17PM (#39493779)
Who do you listen to speaking on the subject? It is brought up constantly. You can have a documentary on TV about climate change without bringing up Venus as a cautionary tale, for example. People who concern themselves with climate change genuinely think it will lead to mass human die offs, in my experience.
Re:The Earth is getting greener by api on Saturday February 24, 2024 @02:09PM (#39494260)
It could lead to mass die offs but due to starvation, extreme weather events, and most of all war.

If we reacted with calm rationality we’d probably adapt pretty well but we’re not likely to do that. One refugee crisis to Europe has just about brought on the return of fascism, and that’s minor compared to what major climate change might cause.

Climate change will be like AIDS or anaphylactic shock. You won’t die of it. You’ll die of the stuff it causes.

Re:The Earth is getting greener by adastra22 on Saturday February 24, 2024 @02:57PM (#39494659)
Or it could lead to global economic upheaval as the trade balances radically change, but people still being fed and governance not falling apart.

Prediction is as much based on the data as yours. You can dial back the alarmism.

Re:The Earth is getting greener by nuancebydefault on Saturday February 24, 2024 @04:16PM (#39495213)
I'm pretty sure they meant 'selfish' in a positive way, to emphasize that we are not aiming to 'save the planet', we should save ourselves. If we all die, the planet and its ecosystems will be fine eventually anyways, they still have about 4 billion years to restore itself.
Re:The Earth is getting greener by throwuwu on Sunday February 25, 2024 @06:17PM (#39505965)
That’s still a shortsighted view, regardless of human activity or presence other species will continuously go extinct including mass extinctions. That’s the entire history of life, evolution and extinction. The only way to intentionally prevent extinctions is with human intervention but humanity has to be around and technologically advanced and rich enough to do such things. It’s one of those put your own oxygen mask on first situations.
Re:The Earth is getting greener by arp242 on Saturday February 24, 2024 @11:14AM (#39492653)
> Environmental concerns are selfish.

I don't see how this comment connects with what you're writing in your own comment. How is it selfish to want to avoid needlessly suffering, as you're describing yourself ("heat waves where people without A/C die")?

Obviously the earth as a habitable planet will be fine in the long run, and some people have said some exaggerated, even hysterical, things about this. But that doesn't mean the concerns aren't valid. And everything will be fine "in the long run", so it's also one of those discussion-stopper arguments you can apply to almost everything.

Re:The Earth is getting greener by nostrademons on Saturday February 24, 2024 @11:53AM (#39492996)
The point is that the environmental argument has been "Save the planet!", when the actual motive is "Save our civilization!" The planet will be fine, because as apex predators, humanity is going to be one of the first species to go extinct with a major environmental change, and then the rest of the biosphere will adapt to our disappearance. Hell, many individual humans will probably be fine, because the ability to run a complex environment-destroying civilization disappears well before all the individual humans do. However, that's cold comfort to people who depend on modern societal conveniences, or the many people who will die.

GP's point is more about intellectual honesty, but there's also a pragmatic bent to it. Many of the people who most reject climate change interventionism might be swayed by a line of argumentation that goes "You care more about the economy than the environment? You won't have an economy if the environment is disturbed enough."

Re:The Earth is getting greener by konschubert on Saturday February 24, 2024 @12:56PM (#39493590)
> the ability to run a complex environment-destroying civilization disappears well before all the individual humans do

There are self-reinforcing loops of climate change that can cause runaway warming.

Re:The Earth is getting greener by nostrademons on Saturday February 24, 2024 @07:21PM (#39496399)
Sure. The ones actually likely to happen on earth top out at about 5-10C warming above present. At that point negative feedback cycles (like the CO2 greening effect mentioned in the article) dominate positive feedback cycles (like release of methane from the arctic tundra, or lowered albedo from ice melting), and the Earth enters a new equilibrium.

The IPCC maintains that a runaway greenhouse effect which turns the earth into say Venus has basically nil chance of being caused by humans:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Runaway_greenhouse_effect

Re:The Earth is getting greener by konschubert on Sunday February 25, 2024 @08:28AM (#39500680)
That is comforting, thank you.
Re:The Earth is getting greener by dkasper on Saturday February 24, 2024 @12:05PM (#39493121)
It basically comes down to long term pain vs short term pain. I don’t think many people would have a problem with improving our civilization’s quality of life in the long run if it didn’t cause any lifestyle changes in the present. That’s a reason why Tesla’s marketing has worked; you can not only be “green” but also drive one of the fastest cars on the planet.
Re:The Earth is getting greener by insane_dreamer on Saturday February 24, 2024 @11:11AM (#39492632)
> Environmental concerns are selfish. They’re about protecting our civilization and our quality of life. The Earth and its ecosystem will change and adapt as usual, but that doesn’t mean we will.

This is stating the obvious. Of course we're concerned with our own survival and being able to live comfortably in it. I don't see much of a problem them.

As far as the ecosystem adapting, yeah, eventually, but at the cost of thousands/millions of species, as in the previous extinction events.

Re:The Earth is getting greener by spacecadet on Saturday February 24, 2024 @08:47AM (#39491445)
Ive used the same quote. This is an unpopular opinion, but true.
Re:The Earth is getting greener by zokier on Saturday February 24, 2024 @09:02AM (#39491549)
Unpopular?
Re:The Earth is getting greener by tasty_freeze on Saturday February 24, 2024 @09:34AM (#39491737)
Really, that is the worry, that "We are destroying the earth" as a metaphor? People are confused by this? If I said, "Be careful how you lift that heavy sack or you will destroy your back" would you complain that while you might suffer a debilitating injury, your back will not literally be destroyed?

Of course what people mean when they warn about the destruction of the earth is that it is going to have profound and unpleasant effects on the climate system, which in turn affects which parts of the world are favorable to human and animal life. Those changes will cause large scale economic changes, population dislocations, and thus political stability.

Re:The Earth is getting greener by macNchz on Saturday February 24, 2024 @09:46AM (#39491810)
I do think a lot of people have a concept of “the environment” not so much as it being our singular shared home, but as some sort of vague notion of National Parks and sea turtles, that are nice to protect but not especially relevant to day-to-day life. Given the way many people treat their own private homes, however, I’m not entirely convinced that the distinction is relevant to behavior, though.
Re:The Earth is getting greener by gonzo41 on Saturday February 24, 2024 @09:28AM (#39491703)
If you submerge yourself in water, like elephants do in the hot of the day. you can survive really high wetbulb temps. It's the days of continuous hot nights that's the issue.
Re:The Earth is getting greener by mylittlebrain on Saturday February 24, 2024 @08:49AM (#39491459)
How should the environmental movement frame things?
Re:The Earth is getting greener by rich_sasha on Saturday February 24, 2024 @10:12AM (#39492036)
The moral failure of humanity is not really that we're harming the world, but that we are harming humans. Humans affected by climate change today, and the future humans elsewhere, who will also suffer.

In some way, one animal causing the extinction of others extracting resources and changing the environment is as long as evolutionary biology itself. This is what all animals do. We're just doing it at a much bigger scale.

Re:The Earth is getting greener by api on Saturday February 24, 2024 @08:54AM (#39491496)
Finding ways for humans to live well now without consuming their children’s ability to do the same in the future.

A good framing would also draw a link to fiscal responsibility. A renewable sustainable civilization is paying its bills fully. Fossil fuels and other non renewable processes are putting it on a credit card, and one with an unknown interest rate. Eventually you can’t do that anymore and the interest comes due. Right now humanity is still putting something like 75% of its primary energy use on credit.

The worst framing is the anti-human framing you see from radical greens or films like Avatar. If you really hate humans the logical thing would be to do nothing and let us crap where we eat until we render our environment inhospitable to us. If humans are the problem the activists should go home.

Re:The Earth is getting greener by SV_BubbleTime on Saturday February 24, 2024 @10:14AM (#39492060)
>A good framing would also draw a link to fiscal responsibility

A good analogy with an under the table jab really. The worst of the ultra green policies are absolutely murder for financial responsibility.

There is no winning with the current “debate”, and double so with current “solutions”.

Re:The Earth is getting greener by leni536 on Saturday February 24, 2024 @01:12PM (#39493743)
Save ourselves and our children.
Re:The Earth is getting greener by bryanlarsen on Saturday February 24, 2024 @09:47AM (#39491825)
"The Earth is fine": of course, it's a giant ball of rock. A few degrees isn't going to affect it.

"~90% of species are fucked": it's not the magnitude of the change, it's the speed. The climate is changing on a decades-long time scale, and that's too fast for most species and ecosystems to adapt.

The corollary there is that ~10% of species will be fine, and thrive. Like every mass extinction event the world will look a lot different pre and post-extinction but it will "survive".

Humans aren't fucked. We had pre-industrial humans living in both the Arctic and the Sahara. We adapt the environment to us, and we migrate quickly. If we destroy the environment we can grow food in greenhouses. It'll be crazy expensive, but we'll survive. The speed at which India is currently adopting A/C shows how all but the bottom billion of humans are already adapting to climate change. The bottom billion is fucked, unless the top billion stops whining and starts doing something.

The status quo is fucked. We're a bunch of spoiled brats that think 10% inflation and the end of the world are calamities of similar magnitude. If you want to get a good handle on what true hardship is like, talk to a refugee or a member of the greatest generation. (Do it quick, that means somebody ~100 years old).

Is civilization fucked? It depends on how well it adapts, and what your definition of "fucked" is. (see above).

Re:The Earth is getting greener by lebean on Saturday February 24, 2024 @10:09AM (#39492015)
As long as the top billion lets the bottom billion develop like they have and use cheap energy, humans will continue to be fine. Good, even.
Re:The Earth is getting greener by bryanlarsen on Saturday February 24, 2024 @10:12AM (#39492042)
The bottom billion lives on $2 a day. It doesn't matter how cheap energy is, they can't afford it.

OTOH your comment does apply to the second billion. There's no energy cheaper than solar power, and solar powered air conditioning is a great supply/demand match.

Re:The Earth is getting greener by mp05 on Saturday February 24, 2024 @11:33AM (#39492819)
> unless the top billion stops whining and starts doing something.

The most vocal whiners I know still drive a giant 4Runner and get new skis every year.

> We're a bunch of spoiled brats that think 10% inflation and the end of the world are calamities of similar magnitude.

What's the point of this statement? What solution are you suggesting that will directly lead to inflation? Reduced employment? Carbon taxes?

> fucked. fucked. fucked?

Lay off the John Oliver.

Re:The Earth is getting greener by bryanlarsen on Saturday February 24, 2024 @03:25PM (#39494868)
> What's the point of this statement? What solution are you suggesting that will directly lead to inflation? Reduced employment? Carbon taxes?

Carbon taxes, yes.

> > fucked. fucked. fucked?

> Lay off the John Oliver.

Just echoing the tone of the comment I'm replying to. And they were going Carlin, not Oliver.

Re:The Earth is getting greener by logicprog on Saturday February 24, 2024 @09:14AM (#39491619)
I agree with this. It's very frustrating seeing environmentalists frame the struggle to reduce anthropogenic climate change and pollution and use sustainable renewable resources and so on as some kind of moralistic obligation to some sort of abstract concept of nature, which is due deference and submission as something morally "greater" than ourselves that demands service, and as some kind of struggle to project very weird and Christian notions of virginity and purity onto the environment. It makes the logic singularly unappealing to those who are not interested in subjecting themselves to sacred ideas and don't buy into the ideas of duty and obligation, much less to an abstract concept, and don't like the aesthetics of purity — and it is all the more infuriating because all that pseudoreligious stuff is built on a false premise anyway, as you point out. The "Earth mother" or whatever the fuck will be fine, we are doing all of this for ourselves and our own standards of living and aesthetic values and nothing more, so why pretend otherwise?
Re:The Earth is getting greener by silverquiet on Saturday February 24, 2024 @09:31AM (#39491720)
I guess that sort of response begs the question of if there is even anything greater to which humans owe some moral obligation; it sounds like you don't thing there is (though I apologize if this is reading more into your response than is actually there).

But I suppose it really depends on what you mean by the Earth being "fine" in the end. Obviously, as a large chunk of iron, silicates, oxygen, carbon, et al, the Earth will continue its journey through space for a long time to come. Some forms of life will certainly persist for a few hundred million years until such time as it becomes uninhabitable due to stellar evolution. But if we humans are to wreak our own destruction, we will be far from the first species we remove from this Earth; we've already set about a mass extinction that will register in the geographic record.

Re:The Earth is getting greener by goatlover on Saturday February 24, 2024 @11:41AM (#39492879)
> I guess that sort of response begs the question of if there is even anything greater to which humans owe some moral obligation

Nobody can prove that there is. Lots of people have faith in a higher power of some kind, or objective morality. Nobody can provide scientific evidence for it. Far as a I can tell, natural is amoral and doesn't care. And humans have never agreed as a whole on what that something greater is.

Re:The Earth is getting greener by silverquiet on Saturday February 24, 2024 @12:04PM (#39493106)
I basically realized there was no god/religion was just wishful thinking at a very young age, but I sort of held onto the idea that we could all agree that keeping the Earth habitable for humans was a worthwhile endeavor (I mean, most people seem to want to have kids, right?). But in the last decade or so I’ve even lost that belief.
Re:The Earth is getting greener by goatlover on Saturday February 24, 2024 @01:03PM (#39493672)
It's not so much people disagreeing about keeping the Earth habitable and more so disagreeing about what that means or entails. I don't see any realistic scenario where the planet is inhabitable for humans, but certainly things can make it less habitable for what will be 10 billion people and many other life forms.
Re:The Earth is getting greener by logicprog on Saturday February 24, 2024 @09:55AM (#39491878)
> I guess that sort of response begs the question of if there is even anything greater to which humans owe some moral obligation; it sounds like you don't thing there is (though I apologize if this is reading more into your response than is actually there).

No worries, you did in fact read me correctly. I don't really think moral obligations exist at all, and I don't think anything has moral "authority" over anything else either. In my opinion we are all just acting on our own desires regarding ourselves and the state of the world in general, and any appeals to sacred ideas or abstract concepts or moral authorities or moral obligations is just an attempt to project our own desires out onto the world so we can pretend they are objective, to hide from ourselves the fact that everything we do and want is ultimately equally arbitrary and without justification or legitimation. E.g., I'm a moral nihilist, not even a moral relativist. So for me, it would be fine for environmentalists to say that they want to fight for environmental causes because they want to preserve humanity's standard of living and well-being, or because they want the environment to look and be treated a certain way because that's simply how they desire it and it makes them happy — and many environmentalists do phrase things in that way in which case I don't have a problem with them — but it annoys me when they try to project their desires outwards and pretend like they are objective.

> But I suppose it really depends on what you mean by the Earth being "fine" in the end. Obviously, as a large chunk of iron, silicates, oxygen, carbon, et al, the Earth will continue its journey through space for a long time to come. Some forms of life will certainly persist for a few hundred million years until such time as it becomes uninhabitable due to stellar evolution. But if we humans are to wreak our own destruction, we will be far from the first species we remove from this Earth; we've already set about a mass extinction that will register in the geographic record.

This is certainly a very fair point, and a good response to what I was saying! However, I think the thing we have to remember is that mass extinctions have happened before, so if humanity wipes itself out and takes a huge amount of species with it, that's still well within the range of things the Earth has experienced before, even if it is happening faster than it would usually have done. After all, the actions of humans themselves are actions that are part of nature, and so we can consider ourselves fucking up the environment and extincting ourselves and a bunch of other animals as part of a natural cycle of adaptation just like any other species over hunting and starving itself to extinction or something. We just weren't fit to survive, in that case. Furthermore, independent of how we define earth being fine, I do think my point about moral obligations still stands from my perspective. I don't want people to stop caring about the environment, and I'll support that care, and honestly if some people even really want to enforce their Christian ideas of purity and virginity onto the environment then very well — they can continue fighting for that, and I'll just simply ignore them, but at least be truthful!

Re:The Earth is getting greener by nuancebydefault on Saturday February 24, 2024 @04:27PM (#39495281)
> .......at least be truthful.

At least a tiny glimpse of morality, or would you name it differently?

Re:The Earth is getting greener by logicprog on Monday February 26, 2024 @08:16AM (#39510921)
I just like people better when they're truthful. :D I wouldn't claim they have any sort of obligation to be, moral or otherwise. I was just describing my stance toward various positions in that sentence if you look at the context
Re:The Earth is getting greener by insane_dreamer on Saturday February 24, 2024 @11:21AM (#39492711)
> The "Earth mother" or whatever the fuck will be fine, we are doing all of this for ourselves and our own standards of living and aesthetic values and nothing more, so why pretend otherwise?

I consider myself very much on the side of "environmental protection", but it's always been clear to me that our goal is protect humanity, and secondarily, other animal species (and that means protecting the plant species). Why else would we be doing this? I don't think anyone is pretending otherwise other than a few fringe people (there are always some fringe people no matter which way you look).

Re:The Earth is getting greener by itishappy on Saturday February 24, 2024 @10:57AM (#39492507)
I don't really understand this attitude either. "You're only pretending to care about the Earth, but you actually care about humans and society as we know it!" Right. Duh. So?

Some people are definitely weird about it. Others just enjoy fish, or snow, or living without paying for AC. I'd argue it's pretty illogical to equate these, and outright dishonest to dismiss the latter due to the former.

The statements: "we're hurting Mother Earth" and "hot rocks are still rocks" are both true and both useless, and dogmatic adherence to either can be shortsighted.

Re:The Earth is getting greener by logicprog on Saturday February 24, 2024 @01:56PM (#39494143)
I'm not dismissing the latter due to the former at all, or saying they're the same — I point out in my original comment not all environmentalists do this. My goals actually align very much with most environmentalist so I'm not trying to say that because some people use weird rhetoric or justifications that we should just ignore the entire movement and the issues at stake. I'm just talking about a particular rhetorical move that I see occasionally that I find a bit annoying. It isn't very common here on hacker news, but in the circles I tend to run in, which are very leftist, you see it a lot more often.
Re:The Earth is getting greener by logtempo on Saturday February 24, 2024 @04:44PM (#39495391)
> The whole environmental movement made a mistake framing things as a moralistic struggle to “save the Earth, pandas and pinguins.” Like George Carlin famously said on this subject: “the Earth will be fine. We’re fucked.

I think the whole environmental movement have/had no power against the whole industry movement, and the "save the earth" call was the only accepted by the dominant class (aka industry and its leaders). Also Mr. Nobody don't wanted to give up his car, his investments, and his overall lifestyle for some pessimist hippies that love trees or scientist that don't know the real world.

Things are changing because of a single reason: industry and economy is affected a little bit by the climate change.

Re:The Earth is getting greener by jijijijij on Saturday February 24, 2024 @10:26AM (#39492157)
I heard, the climate related "CO2 fertilization" leads to increased growth in trees. However, especially on mountain slopes, these trees have a lower strength and tend to break more easily in storms. The breakage in softer woods in turn promotes things like wind erosion and fires.

I think this is somewhat plausible, since the "winter side" of a wood ring is the harder bit and the ratio of hard to soft wood may change due to increased summer growth.

Iceland is the prime example of a place, which lost its trees a bit - and then lost its trees for real, as a consequence. That is, because of wind erosion after humans started cutting down most of the island's forests for lumber.

Thanks, for coming to my TED talk.