News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FTC proposes new protections to combat AI impersonation o... by cyanydeez on Monday February 19, 2024 @05:02PM (#39435362)
indeed, almost no novel criminality or fraud is occuring.

robocalls should just be illegal. unidentified propaganda should be banned. ads with fraudulent claims should be prosecuted.

you can argue about "to what degree" but AI isn't doing anything but exposing the true lack of enforcing of existing laws because of capitalism grease.

Re:FTC proposes new protections to combat AI impersonation o... by kube-system on Monday February 19, 2024 @06:12PM (#39435971)
I don't think we need to ban robocalls. People do want to know when their school closes, when their prescription is ready to pick up, when their utilities will be undergoing maintenance, etc. The ban should be on unsolicited calls, which sort of does already exist, but has two major problems: too many exceptions, and calls from outside of US jurisdiction.
Re:FTC proposes new protections to combat AI impersonation o... by wyre on Monday February 19, 2024 @06:59PM (#39436357)
all of those things can be communicated just as easily over text message. A solution could be opt-in on the customer side, and the business could need a license from the telecom to robocall. Otherwise the FTC could fine the telecom and/or the business for unsolicited robocalls.

I would go as far to say unsolicited business calls, automated or otherwise, should be banned.

Re:FTC proposes new protections to combat AI impersonation o... by JoBrad on Tuesday February 20, 2024 @04:38AM (#39439411)
Not everyone can receive or read a text message.
Re:FTC proposes new protections to combat AI impersonation o... by terribleperson on Tuesday February 20, 2024 @06:07AM (#39439905)
Not everyone can hear a voice-mail. My partner is deaf, and if Google Voice can't transcribe a voice-mail, they don't know what it says until I listen to it.
Re:FTC proposes new protections to combat AI impersonation o... by kube-system on Tuesday February 20, 2024 @10:47AM (#39442691)
Many automated messages that I get come via both text and voice, I presume, for this reason.
Re:FTC proposes new protections to combat AI impersonation o... by plagiarist on Monday February 19, 2024 @07:12PM (#39436451)
It should be possible to hit a button and receive $1 for every unwanted phone call. If the carrier cannot come up with a liable party, they are responsible for the $1.

Ban robocalls, though, and just pay real humans to make those calls instead of overpaying superintendents.

Re:FTC proposes new protections to combat AI impersonation o... by godelski on Monday February 19, 2024 @08:30PM (#39436990)
I've always wondered why Google and Apple don't build a report button into their dialer that allows you to generate a FCC complaint. This seems like a pretty easy task but doesn't seem useful from a third party app. It would auto fill a fair amount of information for you. I'm sure this would burden the FCC system, but I'm not sure that's a big concern and rather just would force the FCC to recognize the scale of the problem. Hard for politicians to argue against too: "We need to defund the FCC because companies like Google and Apple are over burdening the systems with reports of spam callers!"

It would also be nice if they streamlined the ability to add yourself to the DNC list.

Google engineers that are here, is there a reason you don't do this? If not, can you do it in your 20% time? 350 million of us will thank you.

Re:FTC proposes new protections to combat AI impersonation o... by htrp on Monday February 19, 2024 @09:10PM (#39437240)
20% time died a decade ago
Re:FTC proposes new protections to combat AI impersonation o... by godelski on Tuesday February 20, 2024 @12:27AM (#39438329)
Ahh classic Google, killing everything that made it the thing it is today (or maybe better put, yesterday)
Re:FTC proposes new protections to combat AI impersonation o... by thfuran on Monday February 19, 2024 @08:00PM (#39436810)
It's hard to collect, but you're actually entitled to something like $500 per violation of the do not call list. I do wish there were a button on my phone to collect all that money.
Re:FTC proposes new protections to combat AI impersonation o... by plagiarist on Monday February 19, 2024 @10:53PM (#39437882)
That would be rad. The problem is all the guys trying to contact you about your car's warranty are outside US jurisdiction or hidden. If the phone companies were liable at all that would end immediately. I'm fine if it's $500 instead of $1, but it has to be easy to collect.

You used to be able to collect direct from spammers if you could hunt them down, too. I think CAN SPAM ended that, which is a shame.

Re:FTC proposes new protections to combat AI impersonation o... by thfuran on Tuesday February 20, 2024 @02:08AM (#39438729)
Yeah "hard to collect" is something of an understatement.
Re:FTC proposes new protections to combat AI impersonation o... by nonrandomstring on Monday February 19, 2024 @09:35PM (#39437417)
I really like this idea because it has a sassy, unusual, creative and useful logical structure.

As we know, a weakness in all free-entry point systems (like email) is freeloading. The somewhat broken "solution" is charging a small fixed fee to the initiator. But this doesn't work in systems we would like to keep at zero cost because it's a blanket response to an acute problem - most coms are welcome and legitimate.

Giving the callee the power to charge the caller a small "handling charge" if they don't like being bothered makes a lot of sense.

Of course it has its own modes of abuse, but the best way to avoid that is not to send to people you don't know.

Re:FTC proposes new protections to combat AI impersonation o... by plagiarist on Monday February 19, 2024 @10:49PM (#39437861)
Like the worst case scenario for individuals is their friends do it to them as a joke or they misdial and lose $1. I doubt most people would exercise the option for a wrong number though. I need to iron out some edges cases, like it must be ineligible for 800 and 900 numbers. But then I am pretty certain all carriers will be able to miraculously trace and block unwanted calls on midnight of the day it takes effect.
Re:FTC proposes new protections to combat AI impersonation o... by GoblinSlayer on Tuesday February 20, 2024 @03:40AM (#39439175)
Maybe apply it only to call centers?
Re:FTC proposes new protections to combat AI impersonation o... by bobthepanda on Monday February 19, 2024 @06:37PM (#39436171)
whatever happened to SHAKEN/STIR and why didn't that fix everything like people said it would?
Re:FTC proposes new protections to combat AI impersonation o... by soupsranjan on Monday February 19, 2024 @11:36PM (#39438102)
I believe SHAKEN/STIR was mandated only for calls originating from within the US, however, most of these fraud calls are originating over VOIP (or SIP) from outside the US.
Re:FTC proposes new protections to combat AI impersonation o... by PeterisP on Tuesday February 20, 2024 @03:59AM (#39439258)
IIRC it's still being slowly implemented, as slowly as things are made mandatory - because any telecoms that can make money by forwarding fraudster calls to other telecoms don't want to support it.
Re:FTC proposes new protections to combat AI impersonation o... by hx8 on Monday February 19, 2024 @07:35PM (#39436629)
> robocalls should just be illegal

I would pay extra to be part of a phone network that guaranteed humans only and displayed First + Last Name & Organization (if any) of the caller.

Re:FTC proposes new protections to combat AI impersonation o... by IG_Semmelweiss on Monday February 19, 2024 @06:53PM (#39436312)
I contribute my grain of sand by reporting every single spam SMS that I get . I know those are much harder to spoof so its valuable when they get reported.

This is a nice little resource for quick reporting that an HNer put together recently. I have the abuse report email templated now, so all it takes is 2 minutes to report every new one.

https://reportphonespam.org/#Reporting-abuse-to-your-wireles...

Shout out to Telnyx staff for actually processing my requests with a reasonable SLA. Your CS team should be the industry norm.

Re:FTC proposes new protections to combat AI impersonation o... by antifa on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @03:02PM (#39458734)
I use to report spam SMS, then my next phone didn't have a report spam SMS option, and I've not seen the option on any phone since.
Re:FTC proposes new protections to combat AI impersonation o... by IG_Semmelweiss on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @09:01PM (#39532989)
the link makes it someone easy to report. Try it out!
Re:FTC proposes new protections to combat AI impersonation o... by antifa on Thursday February 29, 2024 @02:38PM (#39553984)
No sane person is going to intentionally touch a potentially malicious link on their phone.
Re:FTC proposes new protections to combat AI impersonation o... by Xeoncross on Monday February 19, 2024 @06:03PM (#39435888)
> unidentified propaganda should be banned

Oh man, this sounds bad. Who gets to decide that something is the real, real truth and not propaganda? The US? China? Germany? a PAC? A company? Your neighbor?

Re:FTC proposes new protections to combat AI impersonation o... by Nevermark on Monday February 19, 2024 @09:52PM (#39437514)
I think the easily provable part of this is “unidentified”.

Unsolicited and unidentified should be banned, with users being able to opt-in to any lowered bar (which would count as solicited) if they like.

If businesses or political actors start sending robots to shout messages into your home from the street, without some opt-in, they would be banned.

I would be happy for all unsolicited messages (mail, email, text, voice) without a specific purpose related to a relationship or related to unavoidable impact on the receiver be outlawed.

Citizens that were ok with unsolicited or unidentified advertising or political messages could opt into the mediums they were ok receiving such messages on.

Re:FTC proposes new protections to combat AI impersonation o... by cyanydeez on Tuesday February 20, 2024 @05:41PM (#39447951)
_unidentified_
Re:FTC proposes new protections to combat AI impersonation o... by bobthepanda on Monday February 19, 2024 @05:41PM (#39435705)
This is a legal clarification. Impersonation has always been illegal, but they didn't specify AI because they didn't exist back then, so now they do.
Re:FTC proposes new protections to combat AI impersonation o... by ethanbond on Monday February 19, 2024 @05:13PM (#39435465)
> but AI isn't doing anything but exposing the true lack of enforcing of existing laws because of capitalism grease.

This is just a dismissive way of saying “AI isn’t doing anything but making the problem worse.”

Re:FTC proposes new protections to combat AI impersonation o... by cyanydeez on Monday February 19, 2024 @05:48PM (#39435771)
right.

I guess my opinion is "they already weren't tracking the type of fraud AI is capable; they weren't enforcing fraudulent activity..."

AI just makes it more numerous. a non story.

"sorry guys, we're still not regulating white color fraud"

Re:FTC proposes new protections to combat AI impersonation o... by batch12 on Monday February 19, 2024 @06:25PM (#39436085)
> white color fraud

white-collar fraud

Re:FTC proposes new protections to combat AI impersonation o... by cyanydeez on Tuesday February 20, 2024 @01:46PM (#39445159)
i prefer mine as more apropos.
Re:FTC proposes new protections to combat AI impersonation o... by batch12 on Wednesday February 21, 2024 @07:31PM (#39461583)
I don't get it, sorry.