News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'Zombie Fires' burning at an alarming rate in Canada by newsclues on Sunday February 18, 2024 @07:54AM (#39418639)
Canadian government has cut funding and forest management services, which leads to these fires, which the government blames on global warming and climate change.

But the government has stopped managing the forests, and is not putting forth the required effort to deal with the fires or the root issues.

Unfortunately this is a problem that the government appears reluctant to deal with because it feeds their ideological agenda of climate change.

Unfortunately as a Canadian, I can't trust the Canadian government as they maintain they are leaders in this sector, yet failing (on purpose imo) https://www.nytimes.com/2023/06/09/world/canada/canada-firef...

Re:'Zombie Fires' burning at an alarming rate in Canada by Retric on Sunday February 18, 2024 @08:26AM (#39418874)
That’s not really what’s going on, people always complain about the budget but the variability is vastly more than explained by budgets alone. In Alberta 30% more acres burned in 1983 than 2023, while 2020 was one of the lowest years on record.

Wildfires are just highly variable, and 2023 was ideal conditions for them while 2020 wasn’t.

Re:'Zombie Fires' burning at an alarming rate in Canada by lcnPylGDnU4H9OF on Sunday February 18, 2024 @08:32AM (#39418926)
> while 2020 was one of the lowest years on record

Kind of an interesting data point given that wildfires are often unintentionally started by humans and 2020 was the bulk of the lockdown from COVID.

Re:'Zombie Fires' burning at an alarming rate in Canada by respondo2134 on Sunday February 18, 2024 @09:41AM (#39419439)
Except that

1. the vast majority of forest fires in Canada are started by lightning strikes.

2. Canada did not have strict lock-down rules like much of the world; going off in the woods was one of the things you could definitey do

Re:'Zombie Fires' burning at an alarming rate in Canada by 1over137 on Sunday February 18, 2024 @12:32PM (#39421040)
> Canada did not have strict lock-down rules like much of the world

Canada is big. The covid rules were by province. Quebec in the east had lockdowns, but the fires discussed in the article are in the west.

Re:'Zombie Fires' burning at an alarming rate in Canada by thesz on Sunday February 18, 2024 @10:04AM (#39419605)
I remember (from videos of VivaFrei, a Canadian citizen) that it was prohibited to walk outside area of few blocks away from your home address. And there were curfews.

If so, going off in the woods was one of the things you could definitey not do.

Re:'Zombie Fires' burning at an alarming rate in Canada by goosedragons on Sunday February 18, 2024 @10:22AM (#39419759)
There was only curfews in Quebec. Really early on when things were more unknown some places put more restrictions on things like going to parks but that lifted pretty fast.
Re:'Zombie Fires' burning at an alarming rate in Canada by thesz on Sunday February 18, 2024 @11:02AM (#39420127)
"Lifted pretty fast" is a vague statement. When where these restrictions lifted? Before or after wildfires season?
Re:'Zombie Fires' burning at an alarming rate in Canada by gmfawcett on Sunday February 18, 2024 @11:30AM (#39420349)
I was there, and I definitely could do those things.
Re:'Zombie Fires' burning at an alarming rate in Canada by Steven420 on Sunday February 18, 2024 @10:54AM (#39420054)
Actually most are caused by human activity
Re:'Zombie Fires' burning at an alarming rate in Canada by sandworm101 on Sunday February 18, 2024 @10:50AM (#39420016)
Highly variable but the trend is increasing. And fires are becoming more costly, evacuations more frequent. More people are living, retiring, in remote places.
Re:'Zombie Fires' burning at an alarming rate in Canada by owisd on Sunday February 18, 2024 @08:37AM (#39418962)
Canada is the fourth largest oil producer in the world, if they have an ideological agenda against climate change they’re going about it all wrong.
Re:'Zombie Fires' burning at an alarming rate in Canada by nightowl_games on Sunday February 18, 2024 @12:15PM (#39420855)
Let me introduce you to the western/eastern Canada divide...

Alberta is the fourth largest oil producer in the world, Alberta/Saskatchewan/Manitoba are basically 100% conservative party.

Ontario/Quebec/BC are the political battlefield of Canada. The Liberal party uses Climate Change basically as anti-western-Canada/anti-conservative-party tool.

The Liberal Party is in power, and promotes a lot do climate change rhetoric. The Conservative Party is pro oil. Alberta & Saskatchewan are pro oil.

Re:'Zombie Fires' burning at an alarming rate in Canada by Hammershaft on Sunday February 18, 2024 @03:42PM (#39423059)
> The Liberal party uses Climate Change basically as anti-western-Canada/anti-conservative-party tool.

It isn't used by the liberal party as an anti western tool. It's an actual threat that is creating serious problems across Canada today.

Here in Alberta today, we are facing an unprecedented drought in 2024 as a product of record low snowpack that itself is a product of 2023 being the hottest year in recorded history.

Pine beetle infestations are destroying forests across the BC / Alberta border because in the last decade our winters have simply no longer been cold enough to kill them off.

The revenue neutral carbon tax is the most effective market oriented policy for decarbonizing economic growth, as demonstrated by economic study after economic study.

Re:'Zombie Fires' burning at an alarming rate in Canada by nightowl_games on Tuesday February 20, 2024 @10:16AM (#39442272)
> It isn't used by the liberal party as an anti western tool. It's an actual threat that is creating serious problems across Canada today.

It is both.

The question is, if Canada completely shut down everything, would that change anything? Would Canada literally ceasing all oil extraction fix any of the issues you bring up? Would it measurably help anything?

Re:'Zombie Fires' burning at an alarming rate in Canada by bostonwalker on Sunday February 18, 2024 @09:25AM (#39419318)
This is currently our biggest unsolved political issue IMO. Without a focus on the supply side, all of our current consumption-focused climate change policies (carbon tax on consumption, electric vehicle mandates, most recently infrastructure issues etc.) effectively amount to weak virtue signaling that has mostly succeeded in dividing voters and provinces against each other, when we should instead be tackling the 500 lb gorilla in the room (Alberta’s oil sands). Hence the well-deserved Greta Thunberg snark towards Trudeau a while back.

How do we do that? Some think we should just leave the oil in the ground. Others think we should avoid building further export infrastructure (i.e. pipelines). These options strike me as politically unpalatable, and even our current government stepped in at one point a few years ago to bail out the troubled Trans Mountain pipeline.

One option I am strongly in favour of is nuclearizing the oil sands. AFAIK right now the process for extracting crude from the oil sands is very energy-intensive and is currently powered by nat gas since the producers have it on hand. There was a proposal a while back to power this process by nuclear energy, which failed because: a) nuclear energy was scary, and b) crude prices took off and reduced the economic incentive for cost savings.

I imagine that the nuclear option could be resurrected now alongside government investment in LNG infra as well as a supply-side carbon tax to provide extra incentive to push producers on board. Since we’re not going to leave the oil in the ground anyway, this would allow us to extract it in the cleanest possible way, while actually creating jobs and making our energy exports more competitive overall.

Now, if only Canada could elect a visionary government that actually cared about climate change and not just about virtual signaling…

Re:'Zombie Fires' burning at an alarming rate in Canada by acdha on Sunday February 18, 2024 @09:59AM (#39419561)
> Without a focus on the supply side, all of our current consumption-focused climate change policies (carbon tax on consumption, electric vehicle mandates, most recently infrastructure issues etc.) effectively amount to weak virtue signaling that has mostly succeeded in dividing voters and provinces against each other

This is a very bad-faith read of what actually happened. There’s been decades of interest in the supply side, but this isn’t happening in isolation: the fossil fuel industry is massive and has enormous political clout, and they know that there’s no path to a better world which doesn’t involve the fossil fuel industry making trillions fewer dollars. That means that supply side improvements have both been prevented or steered in infeasible directions which conveniently mean fossil fuel consumption won’t drop in the slightest until decades in the future when something very hard finally happens (hydrogen, nuclear). Any time you’re about to repeat a right-wing trope about virtue signaling, know that you’re contributing your time and credibility to assist their propaganda campaign entirely pro bono instead of doing anything which could help.

Re: tar sands, nuclear takes too long to construct and if you did get a plant through you’d want to use it to decarbonize usage directly rather than encourage more oil consumption.

Re:'Zombie Fires' burning at an alarming rate in Canada by matthewdgreen on Sunday February 18, 2024 @11:44AM (#39420524)
Overall you’re right about fossil fuel interests blocking progress. But you’re wrong about nothing changing until “far in the future” as well as the part about “hydrogen, nuclear”* being key drivers. China has now built so much solar PV and wind that their emissions are set to peak and enter a structural decline this year. Similar trends are occurring everywhere in the world, just a couple of years behind. It’s just taking time for people to realize this is happening, because the exponential phase of an S-curve produces such fast change that even being one or two years out of date is like reading news from last century.

* As a note, hydrogen and nuclear will be relevant, but only for the last (hard) fraction of it. Ironically, promoting hydrogen and nuclear as the “only viable technology” seems to be the latest PR campaign pursued by fossil interests.

Re:'Zombie Fires' burning at an alarming rate in Canada by acdha on Sunday February 18, 2024 @12:05PM (#39420739)
I think we’re actually in agreement. All I meant by that was that the fossil fuel companies have been happy to support things like an envisioned transition to hydrogen, biofuels, or nuclear power when that means it’s business as usual for decades until [hypothetically] some major change happens and our emissions will drop precipitously. Toyota is similarly happy to talk about how green they’ll be in 2040 while heavily advertising that you need a $60k ICE Tundra to drive to the office in the meantime since those have a much higher profit margin than the few hydrogen vehicles they can sell.

I strongly agree that nuclear is relevant for some last n% stuff but am hoping that the renewable boom will buy enough time to deploy it. As you noted, the capacity there has been on a reassuringly massive growth curve with no barriers to stop it other than politics.

Re:'Zombie Fires' burning at an alarming rate in Canada by bostonwalker on Sunday February 18, 2024 @03:04PM (#39422571)
Q: Who decides whether the policy focus is on the supply side or consumption side?

A: The government and its voters.

That’s it. That’s who I am going to hold accountable.

Now, the point I am making that you seem to miss is that in Canada, the supply side is the larger issue. This is because we are a net energy exporter. So hence why to most Canadians outside of Alberta, blaming the consumer while giving the oil sands a pass feels like cheap political theatre.

OTOH Albertans feel very threatened any time the government starts to talk about doing something supply side, and I think many are actually very happy to go along with the political theatre of the demand side focus because they know it doesn’t directly threaten their jobs.

What should we do in an ideal world? Target both. But if I were designing an effective climate policy and had to pick only one, I would do supply side first.

On a side note, studies have estimated that the current carbon tax levels are 5-10x too low to effectively price in the externalities due to releasing the carbon. So yes, it’s virtue signaling.

Re:'Zombie Fires' burning at an alarming rate in Canada by acdha on Sunday February 18, 2024 @04:48PM (#39423759)
> The government and its voters.

Do they operate in an ideal state of perfect knowledge or have they possibly been influenced by the billions spent by fossil fuel companies trying to deny or minimize the problem, and massively overstate the economic cost of reducing carbon emissions? By all means, hold people accountable for bad decisions but also recognize that they’re not making those decisions in a vacuum. If you think the carbon tax is low, start your blame with the people who strenuously opposed it more than the people who got you the current tax.

Re:'Zombie Fires' burning at an alarming rate in Canada by Hammershaft on Sunday February 18, 2024 @03:44PM (#39423091)
A carbon tax is not 'weak virtue signalling', a sufficiently priced carbon tax changes the composition of supply and demand for all goods to account for carbon emitted.
Re:'Zombie Fires' burning at an alarming rate in Canada by bostonwalker on Monday February 19, 2024 @08:21AM (#39429444)
I agree and am in favour of carbon taxes. However this particular carbon tax is weak virtue signaling exactly because it is not sufficiently priced.
Re:'Zombie Fires' burning at an alarming rate in Canada by newsclues on Monday February 19, 2024 @12:07PM (#39432101)
And it’s poorly targeted.
Re:'Zombie Fires' burning at an alarming rate in Canada by Hammershaft on Sunday February 25, 2024 @08:37PM (#39506777)
The Canadian carbon tax can barely politically survive at the price its at, and moreover its slated to reach $170 / ton
Re:'Zombie Fires' burning at an alarming rate in Canada by mecsred on Sunday February 18, 2024 @09:27AM (#39419334)
Unfortunately, having an ideological agenda against climate change and trying to effectively manage and mitigate climate change are completely orthogonal.
Re:'Zombie Fires' burning at an alarming rate in Canada by AdrianB1 on Sunday February 18, 2024 @08:39AM (#39418975)
You can say the same about Norway, that went full speed for electric cars but still extract and sell a lot of oil.
Re:'Zombie Fires' burning at an alarming rate in Canada by hatenberg on Sunday February 18, 2024 @08:43AM (#39418999)
You do understand that it's dry as fuck after snowpack is at a record low the last 3 years.
Re:'Zombie Fires' burning at an alarming rate in Canada by mildchalupa on Sunday February 18, 2024 @09:16AM (#39419246)
Sustainable forrest management requires frequent controlled burns to manage underbrush. Around Michigan this can be a yearly occurrence.
Re:'Zombie Fires' burning at an alarming rate in Canada by throwup238 on Sunday February 18, 2024 @09:17AM (#39419262)
You’re thinking of the forest in British Columbia that don’t sit on meters of peatland.

This is peat burning deep underground. There is nothing forest management can do to stop that because it’s not a forest problem, it’s a dried out peat problem.

Re:'Zombie Fires' burning at an alarming rate in Canada by littlestymaar on Sunday February 18, 2024 @09:47AM (#39419468)
> because it feeds their ideological agenda of climate change.

If Alberta, and Canada in general, has any ideological agenda about climate change, it's about making it worse faster, given that they are one of the biggest producer of oil, and the worse kind possible…

Re:'Zombie Fires' burning at an alarming rate in Canada by sandworm101 on Sunday February 18, 2024 @10:54AM (#39420059)
Canada's forests are just too vast for active management. At best, forests that threaten structures might be managed at the edges. But for climate change location doesn't matter. All the big fires in the north, started by lightning in areas far from roads, cannot be prevented through raking out the underbrush. There aren't enough rakes in the world.
Re:'Zombie Fires' burning at an alarming rate in Canada by someonehere on Sunday February 18, 2024 @11:42AM (#39420495)
California is doing the same thing too. Take the poor forest management and add trees being killed by a foreign beetle to the mix, and you have powder keg every summer waiting to go off.
Re:'Zombie Fires' burning at an alarming rate in Canada by Hammershaft on Sunday February 18, 2024 @03:46PM (#39423113)
The reason pine beetle infestations have exploded is because Canadian winters are no longer reliably cold enough to kill them off.
Re:'Zombie Fires' burning at an alarming rate in Canada by idiotsecant on Sunday February 18, 2024 @12:41PM (#39421141)
Exactly what 'management' do you mean? I ask because this is a frequent astroturf point timber companies use to claim that they need to have larger, cheaper timber leases.

The forests were fine for a very, very, very long time before timber companies were around to help 'manage' them. Many species require forest fire as part of a larger biological cycle. Forest fires are OK. Let them burn. The problem is that we're trying to insert our human stuff into the forests, at which point all of a sudden they are something that requires 'managing'.

Re:'Zombie Fires' burning at an alarming rate in Canada by davidbanham on Sunday February 18, 2024 @05:35PM (#39424197)
I mean, depends on how you define OK. On a geological timescale, sure they’ll be just fine. On a timescale measured in decades to centuries, not necessarily.

Fire is definitely part of many ecosystems. Fire every ten years in a sclerophyll forest? Great! Fire in a rainforest during a bad drought? It’s gone now. Might come back after the next ice age.

Also, “forest” environments that have been clear felled and replaced with a monocrop at some point basically have to be managed thereafter. Any properly bad fire through there will leave the ground essentially sterile. Seed bank destroyed. Still black years later. Their natural resilience is gone and it’s our responsibility to manage the fire ecology while they rehabilitate in the same way we need to manage the flora back to something healthier.

And then of course, anywhere we’ve built human stuff on the interface. We either defend it or we resign ourselves to the people who live there being homeless after the next fire. Leaving aside whether that’s right or wrong, it’s a very different social pact than the one we’ve operated under so far. Any change to that is going to be generational rather than short term.