Too often I see people say to the disappearance of manual labor jobs: good, retrain people to use computers. I have slowly come to the belief that there are some people for whom working with their hands is the only kind of sane work they can do.
You can call them blue-collar, or working class (these are the people incidentally that raised me, the people in my neighborhood growing up).
Why would anyone not want to work in a clean office with only a compiler as your boss and a big paycheck waiting for you every two weeks? When I was younger I assumed that anyone not in the tech field were people not smart enough to pass Algebra in high school. It had not occurred to me then that it might go beyond aptitude and instead be due to something more fundamental about a person's nature or character.
I know I'm getting hand-wavy with nature, character but I'm not sure what other words to use. I came to believe that though many people who are like me find some satisfaction from having solved a difficult problem, or having created a functional framework that can now do work to solve problems there are many others where satisfaction primarily comes from having changed something with their hands.
I don't know if all of that makes sense or resonates with anyone. I'll add this though, the older I get, the more I recognize even in myself the satisfaction that comes from doing something physical (even mowing the lawn as an example). I seem to take some pleasure from taking something unordered or in a raw state, and ending up with a thing in an ordered or "finished" state. It's no doubt why I have pursued woodworking as a hobby, print making, creating PCBs. (And that fresh mown lawn looks so much nicer than the ragged lawn that was there before.)
In any event, following that line of reasoning has made me realize we should keep a large number of manufacturing, construction, repair and other manual labor jobs so that we can serve the whole of society. Just expecting everyone to learn to code is misguided and will fail so many people.
It is sad to me that Germany appears to have tried this model, tried to keep manufacturing in their country, and yet it is purportedly failing. I'm not too optimistic about our future when we apparently measure progress by "cost of living standards".
The better strategy is what everyone else has been doing, letting the third world catch up in labor costs for a few generations while ensuring you maintain the design capability. This does more than any ngo ever to decrease poverty and suffering, it will mean at some point in the future your labor won't be so starkly uncompetitive so eventually you can bring some manufacturing back, and it makes it less likely that the best and brightest arent' wasted on subsistence farming/made less due to childhood malnutrition in the third world, which should help us innovate faster in the future.
I suspect if manufacturing ever did come back it would be automated manufacturing.
None of the options are good for overpriced manufacturing labor in the first world that doesn't want to retrain/can't retrain.
Most of the options are good for the whole world, because manufacturing with less expensive labor usually translate to higher output for lower cost and the labor inflation that causes in the third world is in the really nasty subsistence level of the human suffering index rather than the can't afford a second car and/or the new video game console area of the human suffering index. The benefit to the world of labor price inflation in that level of the curve is so high it's not really comparable.
From the perspective of specific first world countries whether it is good or not depends on a mix of priorities from maintaining output capabilities in the face of potential war, maximizing the stuff your populace can get (bread and circuses limit political risk to rulers) and ensuring the spread between the upper and lower ends of society doesn't get so wide that the lower end looks up from its bread and circuses to revolt. Overall it will be a good strategy to move a significant portion elsewhere from this perspective as well.
Of course automation levels will continue to increase as they always have since the Industrial Revolution.
They exist in lower income countries, but the work quality is often shoddy and poor at best. The talented ones have already migrated to the West. Case in point, a factory we built for a project in the Middle East with a fully European team took just 9 months to finish from the start of laying the foundation stone. Similar projects in the same country by a Chinese or local company would have taken 3-4 years. Another American team executed a project in Singapore in 2.5 years, but that same project was estimated to take 6 years in India.
It's a sad waste of human potential due to toxic politics and unfavorable geography.
The people who say these kinds of things are usually pathetic specialists with a sole focus on their singular task, without looking at the big picture. They have limited interaction with the rest of the team/company/world, and think too highly of their talents and their jobs.
Tell a 50-yr old Java engineer to retrain in Python and Machine Learning, while juggling family, kids and a mortgage, and see how that goes. Newsflash, it doesn't go well. Heck, I've grown up on Android my entire student life, that now I can barely relearn mobile usage with an iPhone. One of the managing partners at my old firm, ex-Harvard and Wharton grad, stuck to using a Blackberry till 2020ish, because he couldn't figure out both.
Now expect a miner to learn how to code, like Joe Biden tells them to....
What is more insane is, that whole progress I see in IT is just joke. All the new tooling that supposed to be better, easier to use and more productive is actually more bloated, slower and works against you. Yeah, indeed, sometimes its easier to start with a tool (aka, clickty clickty) but thats all.
Im heavy CLI user and I follow UNIX philosophy. I love it, write many simple tools and use them together. It works so well. Why abandom it?
If you don't have 3+ years experience in AWS, Kubernetes, specific frameworks with knowledge about system design, your employment prospects are in the toilet right now. Nobody values generalists anymore.
> The Anglophone strategy led to greater internal inequality but seems to be better from an aggregate standpoint.
Let's see. I feel like whatever is brewing economically and socially may hurt the "service industry backed societies" harder, when the time has come.
> Germany still has an enviable roster of small, agile manufacturers, and the Bundesbank and others reject the notion that full-blown deindustrialization is anywhere close.
It's not all cars. It's a lot of things you haven't heard about, because they are highly specialized, niche industrial parts. I think, the German economy rests on the shoulders of Maschinenbau and, presumably, there is a whole lot less naked growth enabled "bullshit" products in that space.
Don't lie, don't you feel something is freaky with the economy? I don't just mean numbers and stock value... something more fundamental. Don't you feel overwhelmed by commerce, at times? Like, there is a lot of non-products produced. Almost violently pushed onto people, sickening amounts of "stuff" saturating all channels. How many mouths does marketing feed? There is so, so much marketing. Can this really be sustainable???
I don't know. I feel something is getting horribly out of balance and the service industry is a symptom. Rabid inequality is a symptom. Like core rot, it looks fine, until a little gust lays the tree onto your house.
In my country, they dropped interest rates to near 0 in the wake of 9/11 in order to prevent the economy from crashing, and held them there until the Covid pandemic. It seems like that free money was used to buy _anything_ that could be invested in, driving up prices for assets like stocks, houses, and cryptocurrencies. I remember reading articles around 2018 that said that economists didn't know how the economy worked anymore.
The crazy low, long term interest rates are what _I_ feel has been freaky about the economy since at least 2005 when I looked at a dark, unremarkable 4 bedroom condominium priced at $400k, which was at least 6x my annual income.
It's felt like a huge house of cards has been built for over 20 years now, the whole economy outside of the service sector has been hollowed out, and I'm still waiting for it to all come crashing down.
I suspect, people, even with comparatively high income, stopped being able to buy hard securities like houses. Why save up then? So, folk had a lot more "disposable income" to consume soothing, but overall transient consumable products and services like clothing, tech gadgets, food, subscriptions... – lifestyle stuff. You know: 1000$ sneakers and a 12$/month meditation app. A bit of luxury and the illusion of wealth. This in turn enabled an industry of bullshit pushers, who started manufacturing the demand for all these consumables, trying to reap a new massive YOLO market. All, of course, paying their 20% to the 1%.
Rents and living costs kept rising, so now we got to the point where "luxury" has become cheap, cheap lookalike instead, and most everybody is hustling to keep their "standard of living". Multiple jobs and a side gig, to pay for the fix and all your subscriptions... no pension, no pause. Ever.
> "You'll own nothing and be happy"
Look at the housing crisis and get all academic about the economy... What terrifies me, is this new, omnipresent private sell-out and monetization of social interactions. Everybody always has something to sell, is self-branding. Everybody wants to get in my head constantly, stomp their shit between my dopamine receptors. Too often, I feel exhausted and physically sick from this dynamic, I feel the sick. Decency and respect had their IPO.
And I am carrying a new generalized anger with me everywhere, which I see in fellow strangers, too. People are increasingly short-fused. The pandemic accelerated this. Traffic is mad.
I fear the fabric of the collective is on sale at this moment. Maybe the mandated growth dogma has hit the capacity of healthy attention or something. This is not just an economic bubble, but the exhaustion of a part human along with it. Someone is getting high on their own supply...
https://ipropertymanagement.com/research/homeownership-rate-...
https://edition.cnn.com/interactive/2023/06/homes/housing-ma...
1. https://www.ribbonfarm.com/2017/08/17/the-premium-mediocre-l...
I see immediately why you thought of it. It's exactly the same theme, identifying the same developments, the same critique, same everything. But - It is not the same. Ha! I've been there!
Whatever the author is talking about can't be the same. Retrospectively, 2017 was infinitely more hopeful. He must be getting all raged up over merely a bow wave in the fog, a neighbor's new baby hippopotamus pet, the rape of Kathleen Maddox, that persistent cough, a first hottest summer.
All the developments were present already, but nobody could have foreseen the sick then. A quick fix: You take every observation in the article and add bath salts.
So, let's make a collage!
> Premium mediocre is food that Instagrams better than it tastes. <
> So you fake it till you make it. Unless you don’t. <
> The essence of premium mediocrity is being optimistically prepared for success by at least being in the right place at the right time <
> But the demographic at the very heart of the phenomenon is the young, gentrifier class of Blue Bicoastal Millennials. The rent-over-own, everything-as-a-service class of precarious young professionals auditioning for a shot at the neourban American dream, sans condo ownership somewhere at a reasonable distance from both the nearest meth lab and minority ghetto. <
Venkatesh, gentrification is over. The minority ghetto became unaffordable all by itself. Oh, and the meth lab got acquired by Big Fentanyl. Must be popular, draws more people to the sidewalk than a Supreme store.
Oh dear! We're not faking enjoyment for our friends on Instagram anymore. We either made it early in the business of exploiting teenage insecurities, or we aspire for the Girl-Boss Dream on OnlyFans. On C-SPAN, Mark Zuckerberg is telling the judge, a child's suicide wasn't his fault. You can pretend you care, read about it behind the New York Times paywall, or retweet the trending blue check antisemitism spin on X, for free. X is what you called Twitter in 2017. But, you know, on bath salts. Anyway. Or... you come watch me unbox this gift from my sponsor Bad Dragon! You do this for me and I get under the knife for you. Backyard fillers minimum. Instagrams better than it feels, to be honest.
(BTW, I think you can buy optimism on BetterHelp, now. Link in the description.)
Everthing-as-a-service used to mean Office365 and outsourcing corporate infrastructure to The Cloud.. in 2024 we mean a paid subscription for a calculator app.
If you're ugly then there is only the option of a full stack bootcamp, the one in eight billion chance of creating your own means of extraction.
> It is a class for which I have profound affection, and one whose eventual success I am sincerely rooting for. <
Yeah. Because you haven't mentioned climate change even once, Venkatesh...
> Premium mediocrity is in part a theater put on by Maya Millennial in part to spare the feelings of parents. Inter-generational love, not inter-generational war. <
> First, the consumers of premium mediocre things are generally strongly and acutely self-aware about what they are doing.
... well, best we can do now, is this peace deal: We get the house and all the pre-war money left - and until you're dead, you will carry the sorrow, Daddy! Or, you know, next pandemic we won't stay home for you.
> That leaves the cryptocurrency lottery as the only documented way up open to all, regardless of skills. <
Crypto is over, so that's it, huh?
> Unlike a covered call, which is about promising to sell what you actually own, a naked call is about promising to sell what you don’t actually own. <
Rhetrotorical question. Funniest thing, you don't have to explain naked options in 2024! Lol.
If your parents death isn't that promising, you better haven't held the $TSLA bag, but got lucky with $NVDA instead. Why Nvidia?
> You either tell robots what to do, or are told by robots what to do. <
Oh, boy!
Lastly, our collage gets a center piece: A 2017 truth remaining faithful and a 2017 wish becoming true ...
> The public markets are no longer reliable wealth builders, while the private markets exclude almost everybody who isn’t already wealthy. <
> Because you see, while it is somewhat important that everybody drink some kool-aid, it is absolutely crucial that the leaders drink a lot of their own kool-aid. <
Underneath we put picture of Peter Thiel's survival bunker in New Zealand.
Nauseating nostalgia. I would really, really, really love a remake by the author!
Beating apple on software (linux?) is one thing. Ditto hw. Both at the same time is tougher.
Apple is operationally strong.
That won't leave to China either. Sure they've messed up etc etc but nothing life threatening
Then the US sanctions, supposedly unrelated to the mobile phone market, hit Huawei hard making it pretty much undesirable to buy their phones in the Western market, and its market share in Europe plunged to near zero. How convenient.
Spanish forums and social networks are still full of "Huawei orphans" who can't find any Android phone in the current market that can match the quality of the pre-sanctions Huawei P20/P30/P20 Pro/P30 Pro flagships. It's a recurrent post topic. I'm one of them, and I'm even considering switching to Apple. My current phone (Pixel 6 Pro) doesn't even come close to my previous Huawei P30 Pro in battery life, signal reliability, heating issues, etc. and it's the same for every other Android model I've seen from family/friends. While it does have great camera and software, in many respects it feels like more of a downgrade than an upgrade. At least I can keep using my Huawei smartwatch which gives me two weeks of battery life, rather than a few days like most of the competition.
With this I mean... China is very capable of developing high-quality products like California, but California can leverage its political and military power to tilt things in their favor. At least at the moment.
That said, I don't believe the sanctions are at all an anti-competitive move; the threat of hardware (Huawei, DJI) and software (TikTok) backdooring is very real. The sanctions hit more than just phones anyway-- Huawei routers are also affected.
The Anglophone economies, whose shift to services away from manufacturing has been ballyhooed and decried in many quarters, embraced competing on novelty. By being the first mover in many industries.
The Anglophone strategy led to greater internal inequality but seems to be better from an aggregate standpoint. I'd like to see Germany's manufacturing strategy work since it preserves mid-skill jobs, but this is casting doubt.