News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Germany's Days as an Industrial Superpower Are Coming to ... by JKCalhoun on Saturday February 10, 2024 @07:48AM (#39325809)
I agree that we need to keep what you call here mid-skill jobs.

Too often I see people say to the disappearance of manual labor jobs: good, retrain people to use computers. I have slowly come to the belief that there are some people for whom working with their hands is the only kind of sane work they can do.

You can call them blue-collar, or working class (these are the people incidentally that raised me, the people in my neighborhood growing up).

Why would anyone not want to work in a clean office with only a compiler as your boss and a big paycheck waiting for you every two weeks? When I was younger I assumed that anyone not in the tech field were people not smart enough to pass Algebra in high school. It had not occurred to me then that it might go beyond aptitude and instead be due to something more fundamental about a person's nature or character.

I know I'm getting hand-wavy with nature, character but I'm not sure what other words to use. I came to believe that though many people who are like me find some satisfaction from having solved a difficult problem, or having created a functional framework that can now do work to solve problems there are many others where satisfaction primarily comes from having changed something with their hands.

I don't know if all of that makes sense or resonates with anyone. I'll add this though, the older I get, the more I recognize even in myself the satisfaction that comes from doing something physical (even mowing the lawn as an example). I seem to take some pleasure from taking something unordered or in a raw state, and ending up with a thing in an ordered or "finished" state. It's no doubt why I have pursued woodworking as a hobby, print making, creating PCBs. (And that fresh mown lawn looks so much nicer than the ragged lawn that was there before.)

In any event, following that line of reasoning has made me realize we should keep a large number of manufacturing, construction, repair and other manual labor jobs so that we can serve the whole of society. Just expecting everyone to learn to code is misguided and will fail so many people.

It is sad to me that Germany appears to have tried this model, tried to keep manufacturing in their country, and yet it is purportedly failing. I'm not too optimistic about our future when we apparently measure progress by "cost of living standards".

Re:Germany's Days as an Industrial Superpower Are Coming to ... by snapplebobapple on Saturday February 10, 2024 @09:12AM (#39326241)
I think you and the op are both missing that the vast majority of those mid skilled jobs still exist, they just exist in countries whose labor costs are drastically lower. When you realize that, you then realize that betting that your workers will be able to maintain a quality gap large enough to justify keeping them around is extremely questionable over the medium to long term because you are assuming some combination of there being a difference in your populations at a macro level (almost certainly wrong), that you will be able to innovate quality/other differentiating characteristics fast enough to maintain a large gap (almost certainly wrong, it's way harder to come up with something new vs copying the practices that exist already, especially when it is in the interest of the company in control of those practice to offshore for more profit), or your government will always be better in the specific subset of ways that maintains an advantage (better infrastructure, better regulation, etc. Also wrong when environmental regulation is at odds with profits and infrastructure only needs to be good between the factory and the port).

The better strategy is what everyone else has been doing, letting the third world catch up in labor costs for a few generations while ensuring you maintain the design capability. This does more than any ngo ever to decrease poverty and suffering, it will mean at some point in the future your labor won't be so starkly uncompetitive so eventually you can bring some manufacturing back, and it makes it less likely that the best and brightest arent' wasted on subsistence farming/made less due to childhood malnutrition in the third world, which should help us innovate faster in the future.

Re:Germany's Days as an Industrial Superpower Are Coming to ... by JKCalhoun on Saturday February 10, 2024 @02:19PM (#39329329)
I'm not sure waiting for the rest of the world to catch up is a good strategy as there always seems to be somewhere else that is still willing to work for less.

I suspect if manufacturing ever did come back it would be automated manufacturing.

Re:Germany's Days as an Industrial Superpower Are Coming to ... by snapplebobapple on Saturday February 10, 2024 @04:06PM (#39330216)
depends on your definition of a good strategy.

None of the options are good for overpriced manufacturing labor in the first world that doesn't want to retrain/can't retrain.

Most of the options are good for the whole world, because manufacturing with less expensive labor usually translate to higher output for lower cost and the labor inflation that causes in the third world is in the really nasty subsistence level of the human suffering index rather than the can't afford a second car and/or the new video game console area of the human suffering index. The benefit to the world of labor price inflation in that level of the curve is so high it's not really comparable.

From the perspective of specific first world countries whether it is good or not depends on a mix of priorities from maintaining output capabilities in the face of potential war, maximizing the stuff your populace can get (bread and circuses limit political risk to rulers) and ensuring the spread between the upper and lower ends of society doesn't get so wide that the lower end looks up from its bread and circuses to revolt. Overall it will be a good strategy to move a significant portion elsewhere from this perspective as well.

Re:Germany's Days as an Industrial Superpower Are Coming to ... by nradov on Saturday February 10, 2024 @04:57PM (#39330600)
Geopolitics and military affairs can override labor cost issues to a limited extent. The global supply chain that was enabled by Pax Americana after WW2 is gradually breaking down. The US Navy is no longer willing or able to ensure worldwide freedom of navigation and so shipping on some major routes has become slower and less reliable. Sanctions and protectionist measures are fracturing the world into regional rather than global trading blocs. And governments are increasingly willing to subsidize strategic manufacturing industries (especially weapons) in order to avoid being dependent on unreliable trading partners.

Of course automation levels will continue to increase as they always have since the Industrial Revolution.

Re:Germany's Days as an Industrial Superpower Are Coming to ... by fakedang on Saturday February 10, 2024 @02:33PM (#39329458)
> I think you and the op are both missing that the vast majority of those mid skilled jobs still exist, they just exist in countries whose labor costs are drastically lower.

They exist in lower income countries, but the work quality is often shoddy and poor at best. The talented ones have already migrated to the West. Case in point, a factory we built for a project in the Middle East with a fully European team took just 9 months to finish from the start of laying the foundation stone. Similar projects in the same country by a Chinese or local company would have taken 3-4 years. Another American team executed a project in Singapore in 2.5 years, but that same project was estimated to take 6 years in India.

Re:Germany's Days as an Industrial Superpower Are Coming to ... by snapplebobapple on Saturday February 10, 2024 @03:52PM (#39330092)
That's literally point two and three of the argument I made in the second half of the first paragraph as something that is incorrect to bet on continuing forever. What would your project spread have looked like 20 years ago? I am guessing quite a lot worse. What will the spread look like in 20 years? I would bet on it being closer than it is now.
Re:Germany's Days as an Industrial Superpower Are Coming to ... by nradov on Saturday February 10, 2024 @05:01PM (#39330636)
Most Middle Eastern countries have made approximately zero progress on worker training and productivity in the past 20 years. Some have even gone backwards. There's no reason to expect they will do better in the next 20.

It's a sad waste of human potential due to toxic politics and unfavorable geography.

Re:Germany's Days as an Industrial Superpower Are Coming to ... by snapplebobapple on Saturday February 10, 2024 @07:06PM (#39331483)
If progress was equal everywhere we wouldn't have all these laggards willing to work for peanuts to improve their life (because the peanuts they were working for locally are even smaller than foreign peanuts). ~5% of the population currently not getting the job done doesn't invalidate any part of my argument. It just means that 5% might be the last guys left in the dark ages if progress continues and the policy of offshoring doesn't reverse (either for political reasons or because we cracked the full automation code and labor costs no longer matter because we aren't using much labor to produce things. If that happens the dirty stuff will still be offshored but the calculus will be different for the foreign country).
Re:Germany's Days as an Industrial Superpower Are Coming to ... by nradov on Saturday February 10, 2024 @07:48PM (#39331704)
Political instability means that manufacturing will never be significantly offshored to the Middle East. It doesn't matter how cheap the labor is if you're worried your factory is going to get blown up. For all the faults of the Chinese government, they have at least created a safe environment for manufacturers to operate.
Re:Germany's Days as an Industrial Superpower Are Coming to ... by scrubs on Sunday February 11, 2024 @04:39PM (#39339030)
Well argued snapplebobapple. Japan isn't cheap anymore; and neither will China be either in the long run
Re:Germany's Days as an Industrial Superpower Are Coming to ... by fakedang on Saturday February 10, 2024 @02:29PM (#39329428)
> Too often I see people say to the disappearance of manual labor jobs: good, retrain people to use computers. I have slowly come to the belief that there are some people for whom working with their hands is the only kind of sane work they can do.

The people who say these kinds of things are usually pathetic specialists with a sole focus on their singular task, without looking at the big picture. They have limited interaction with the rest of the team/company/world, and think too highly of their talents and their jobs.

Tell a 50-yr old Java engineer to retrain in Python and Machine Learning, while juggling family, kids and a mortgage, and see how that goes. Newsflash, it doesn't go well. Heck, I've grown up on Android my entire student life, that now I can barely relearn mobile usage with an iPhone. One of the managing partners at my old firm, ex-Harvard and Wharton grad, stuck to using a Blackberry till 2020ish, because he couldn't figure out both.

Now expect a miner to learn how to code, like Joe Biden tells them to....

Re:Germany's Days as an Industrial Superpower Are Coming to ... by Borg3 on Saturday February 10, 2024 @03:49PM (#39330069)
Yeah, our world started to move way too fast. In the past, new tech usually came slower so new generation could get hands on it, learn and then use it for life time. Now, you start learning on thing and sometimes even in the middle, you are going to switch because it become obsolete. Its insane.

What is more insane is, that whole progress I see in IT is just joke. All the new tooling that supposed to be better, easier to use and more productive is actually more bloated, slower and works against you. Yeah, indeed, sometimes its easier to start with a tool (aka, clickty clickty) but thats all.

Im heavy CLI user and I follow UNIX philosophy. I love it, write many simple tools and use them together. It works so well. Why abandom it?

Re:Germany's Days as an Industrial Superpower Are Coming to ... by ulfw on Sunday February 11, 2024 @04:13AM (#39333669)
Oh please. I am 47 and can't find a job, no matter how hard I try. And I'm in Product (coding is even worse). Ageism in tech is a real thing that's not often talked about.
Re:Germany's Days as an Industrial Superpower Are Coming to ... by FirmwareBurner on Sunday February 11, 2024 @09:03AM (#39335052)
Don't think it's age , but more that companies want people versed in the latest tech wizz-bangs but without the crust and habits from the old outdated tech.

If you don't have 3+ years experience in AWS, Kubernetes, specific frameworks with knowledge about system design, your employment prospects are in the toilet right now. Nobody values generalists anymore.