That's a big "if". Look at how the government has protected physical keys...
Ever since the TSA accidentally leaked them, you can buy a set of keys on Amazon for $5 that opens 99% of "TSA approved" locks
Your devices would be secure as long as a private key that happened to be the most valuable intelligence asset in the United States, accessed thousands of times per day, by police spread across the entire nation, was never copied or stolen.
Well, keep in mind they would have to keep it secure in perpetuity. Any leak over the lifetime of any of that hardware would be devastating to the owners. Blue Team/Defensive security is often described as needing to be lucky every time, where as Red Team/attackers just have to get lucky once.
This attack vector is in addition to just exploiting the implementation in some way, which I don't think can be handwaved away.
Not disingenuous. Keys are stolen or leaked all the time. And the blast radius of such a master key would be extremely large.
As Pauli said, "That's not even wrong". It cannot even meet the basic criteria for truth or falsehood.
It's simply naked hubris.
It's an unnecessary moving part that can break, except that this particular part breaking defeats the whole purpose of the system.
If the power doesn't exist, nobody can exploit it.
Such a key would be highly sensitive and it would also require very little traffic to use. You would just need to send the secure system a KEM (<100 bytes) and it will respond with the symmetric key used for the protected package.
I don't doubt they could secure it. Can even split the key into shares and require multiple parties to be present in the secure location.
For many years, the code was 00000000.
https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2013/12/launch-code-for-...
Nobody has to know the rate of leaks, it's irrelevant. Gross negligence is not necessary, how would you even know? Leaks by definition are rarely exposed, we only see some of them.
A "highly sensitive" key doesn't mean anything. Assigning more words to it doesn't somehow change the nature of it. Humans are bad at securing things, that's why the best security is to not have a system that requires it.
Whatever hypothetical solution you have would be crushed under the weight of government committees and office politics until your security measures are bogus.
Looks like criminals were using it for four years undetected.
In practice though most people are screwed b/c it's all already in icloud.
During the last days of 2023 there was a big discussion, also on HN, after it was revealed that all recent Apple devices had a hardware backdoor that allowed bypassing all memory access protections claimed to exist by Apple.
It is likely that the backdoor consisted in some cache memory test registers used during production, but it is absolutely incomprehensible how it has been possible for many years that those test registers were not disabled at the end of the manufacturing process but they remained accessible for the attackers who knew Apple's secrets. For instance any iPhone could be completely controlled remotely after sending to it an invisible iMessage message.
if (user_id == "adrian_b")
pwn ();
?Mercedes recently forgot a token in a public repository which grants access to everything.
Microsoft forgot its “Golden Key” in the open, allowing all kinds of activation and secure boot shenanigans.
Microsoft’s JWT private key is also stolen, making the login page a decoration.
Somebody stole Realtek’s driver signing keys for Stuxnet attack.
HDMI master key is broken.
BluRay master key is broken.
DVD CSS master key is broken.
TSA master keys are in all 3D printing repositories now.
Staying on the physical realm, somebody made an automated tool to profile, interpret and print key blanks for locks with "restricted keyways" which has no blanks available.
These are the ones I remember just top of my head.
So yes, any digital or physical secret key is secure until it isn’t.
It’s not a question of if, but when. So, no escrows or back doors. Thanks.
On the other hand, there are 4K, 10bit HDR + multichannel versions everywhere, so there must be some secret sauce somewhere.
This is not a rabbit hole I want to enter, though.
Which government? Software crosses borders.
You can bet that if the US mandated a back door to be inserted into software that was being exported to another country, that country would want to either have the master key for that back door, or a different version of the software with a different back door or without the back door. A software user could choose the version of the software that they wanted to use according to which country (if any) could snoop on them. It's unworkable.
There are plenty of reasons not to tolerate such a backdoor, but using false claims only provides potential ammunition to the opposition.
[1] <https://libsodium.gitbook.io/doc/public-key_cryptography/sea...>