1. Those who love their Macs a little too much
2. Those who routinely build a PC.
i.e. Are you familiar with the hardware market.
I'm the kind of person who would rather take the 3y server and recomission it as a lower priority service than just do a 1:1 replacement. "Old" computers aren't as useless as they used to be. Computing power has advanced to the point where computation is arbitrary. For all intents, in most sectors, you can scale your compute capacity as high as your budget allows and you won't hit any performance barriers ever. There will always be more compute. It is a commodity now.
My stance is this; sure the new server is faster than the old one, but you know what's even faster? Dividing the existing workload between both of them.
What about the core count and memory capacity
How do you factor reliability into your analysis? I mean, the reason companies ditch their 3yo server is that their service life is nearing it's end, and odds are they will fail in the upcoming year or so.
Meanwhile, increased compute capacity means companies can use a single brand new server to replace multiple old ones, not to mention cheaper operational costs.
Move the exact same workload to the industry's default but much more expensive choice, and the problems vanish entirely.
This is, unfortunately, one of those things that's really hard to judge about a hosting provider unless you have direct experience using them "at scale", as they say. Nobody puts that stuff on a sales page spec sheet or comparison grid.
Could I save money by hosting on real hardware at some popular, cheapish server-leasing place? Or colocating at one? Or hosting out of my own basement!? Maybe. Would it cause some users to consistently see dial-up speeds and dropped connections on gigabit Internet service because of either some quirk of routing, or bad peering agreements? Who knows!
Unbelievable (new) specs, hosted and at prices points tough to beat doing it yourself.
E.g.
Hetzner
AMD RYZEN™ 9 7950X3D (current gen Zen 4)
16 physical cores (4.2 GHz)
128GB DDR5 ECC ram
4TB NVMe
completely hosted
For only ~$100/moIsn't on-die ECC necessary just because DDR5 is less reliable than previous generations, especially at higher frequencies and density? Makes me wonder whether they use an actual ECC DDR5 memory.
They normally are trying to keep their IPs and Network clean of scammers abusing their resources, which inevitably hurt all customers.
Is there still more needed to complete their KYC process?
AWS is expensive and not without trouble but in my experience they’ve been best of the pack.
Otherwise, on-premises + collocation is never a mistake if the maintenance and upright expenditure is in your budget.
Yet many other folks praise them…
What’s your experience?
The duct-tape-maintenance vs your-time criticisms are 100% dead-on though.
I also pay for 1Gbps symmetric fiber with dedicated IP going into my house ($140/month at the moment) so I also host some stuff right from my own place.
I run a couple ryzen mini PCs on Verizon fios 1Gbps at home now for my hosting needs but I would jump at $60 colo in a heartbeat if I got even 100mb connection unmetered.
Plus flexibility of scale up / scale down as needed for load, transient testing, etc.
Cloud is definitely not for everyone but it makes sense for some.
For larger projects I guess, but I have a few VPSes that have been running sites for a decade or more that require almost no maintenance (occasional apt-get upgrade). In fact it’s the frameworks / languages these projects were built in that cause most of the work (for which deployment target makes no difference).
If the thought of your service going down for a few hours because some random unplugged the power cable or your ADSL router crashed doesn’t make the CFO lose sleep then some raspberry pi is surely good enough. Just make sure you run it inside a safe if you store personal information.
I notice a trend that the people who scoff at hardware specs are usually the same ones standing in line for 2 cores and 4gb of RAM for $50+/month. They'll laugh when you suggest utilizing an obsolete $50 computer with a decade old CPU (that's just sitting in a closet), but more than willing to spend $50/month on similar performing hardware from a Cloud vendor.