News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:App Store to Be 'Split in Two' Ahead of EU iPhone Sideloa... by bb123 on Monday January 15, 2024 @02:11PM (#39004799)
I do not relish the idea of having to download Facebook/Instagram/WhatsApp directly from a 3rd party store. For me Apple standing between sketchy devs like Zuck-co and my phone is a feature not a bug.
Re:App Store to Be 'Split in Two' Ahead of EU iPhone Sideloa... by dylan604 on Monday January 15, 2024 @02:25PM (#39004971)
If you see apps only appearing in 3rd party stores and not on the Apple store, then that would be a huge red flag. Hopefully, there will be someone looking to make a name for themselves that would download the binaries from each store it is available and test for any differences. Those looking to avoid the cut paid to Apple seem to get all of the attention, but it's these more nefarious things that scare the bejeebus out of me. I don't even use apps from Apple's store because of the shit devs pull. No way in hell would I use something unregulated
Re:App Store to Be 'Split in Two' Ahead of EU iPhone Sideloa... by smoldesu on Monday January 15, 2024 @03:21PM (#39005575)
From United States v. American Tel. (1983):

> The threat to competition that is claimed to be posed by AT&T in this industry is that, through the use of cross-subsidization and customer discrimination, it will use its power in the interexchange market to disadvantage competing electronic publishers. While the possibility of cross-subsidization is as remote here as it is with respect to other subjects considered herein, there is a real danger that AT&T will use its control of the interexchange network to undermine competing publishing ventures.

Sounds familiar, I wonder how things ended for Ma Bell?

Re:App Store to Be 'Split in Two' Ahead of EU iPhone Sideloa... by dylan604 on Monday January 15, 2024 @03:34PM (#39005723)
> I wonder how things ended for Ma Bell?

For a while, they were broken up into the baby bells. Then, one baby bell started buying up all of the other baby bells and renamed itself ATT. Clearly, that's a totally different company than AT&T. So, ultimately, nothing.

Re:App Store to Be 'Split in Two' Ahead of EU iPhone Sideloa... by smoldesu on Monday January 15, 2024 @03:39PM (#39005791)
From a less misanthropic perspective, we avoided the immediate outcome of a direct monopoly and have an undeniably more robust telecommunications infrastructure because of it. If we get an AT&T-style placation out of Apple, I'd consider ourselves lucky.
Re:App Store to Be 'Split in Two' Ahead of EU iPhone Sideloa... by abhibeckert on Monday January 15, 2024 @08:48PM (#39008404)
Ma Bell, at it's peak, was arguably biggest company in the entire world.

The new comglomerate of "baby bells" isn't even the biggest Telco provider in the USA, let alone the biggest company in the USA... let alone the biggest in the world.

Re:App Store to Be 'Split in Two' Ahead of EU iPhone Sideloa... by ThatPlayer on Monday January 15, 2024 @04:58PM (#39006601)
You can choose to let Apple stand between you by staying on Apple's App Store. If you don't get an app because Apple is blocking it from the App Store, isn't that working as intended? If you choose to ignore Apple's block and get the app elsewhere, then it sounds like Apple's barrier is a bug
Re:App Store to Be 'Split in Two' Ahead of EU iPhone Sideloa... by huytersd on Monday January 15, 2024 @11:32PM (#39009523)
Not if Facebook, WhatsApp etc pull their apps from the App Store and only make it available from 3rd party sources.
Re:App Store to Be 'Split in Two' Ahead of EU iPhone Sideloa... by smoldesu on Tuesday January 16, 2024 @12:14AM (#39009762)
That's a possibility right now, with or without iOS sideloading. Nothing stops Facebook or WhatsApp from bypassing Apple's native guidelines and force their evil, expensive anticonsumer practices down user's throat on the web or competing platforms.
Re:App Store to Be 'Split in Two' Ahead of EU iPhone Sideloa... by robin_reala on Tuesday January 16, 2024 @01:19AM (#39010055)
Android already has third-party app stores. Have Meta done that there?
Re:App Store to Be 'Split in Two' Ahead of EU iPhone Sideloa... by huytersd on Tuesday January 16, 2024 @01:58AM (#39010261)
Android is fragmented and open source. There’s no large entitý to squeeze money out of.
Re:App Store to Be 'Split in Two' Ahead of EU iPhone Sideloa... by ThatPlayer on Tuesday January 16, 2024 @03:04AM (#39010701)
That's my point. If consumers are willing to go directly to Facebook, and Facebook are willing to serve them directly, why does Apple need to get involved?

On the other hand, if consumers want Apple involved, they wouldn't leave the app store, they wouldn't download the app, and the app will fail when there's no users.

Re:App Store to Be 'Split in Two' Ahead of EU iPhone Sideloa... by abhibeckert on Monday January 15, 2024 @08:50PM (#39008420)
If you hate Zuck so much, why are you using his products?
Re:App Store to Be 'Split in Two' Ahead of EU iPhone Sideloa... by Nevermark on Tuesday January 16, 2024 @12:03AM (#39009712)
Maybe the causal direction goes the other way.

Someone who loves Zuck products and finds them indispensable, but still underhanded and despicable in terms of user abuse (surveillance, manipulative feeds, no socially healthy ad-free no-tracking neutral-feed for-pay option …), has reason to dislike Mr. Meta.

Unfortunately, reality is rarely as a la carte as we all might wish.

Re:App Store to Be 'Split in Two' Ahead of EU iPhone Sideloa... by perryizgr8 on Tuesday January 16, 2024 @12:26AM (#39009818)
> I do not relish the idea of having to download Facebook/Instagram/WhatsApp directly from a 3rd party store.

So don't. It's your choice. The benefit is that those who don't mind, will also be able to exercise their choice.

Re:App Store to Be 'Split in Two' Ahead of EU iPhone Sideloa... by jjulius on Tuesday January 16, 2024 @12:36AM (#39009864)
A whole lot of people taking this hypothetical seriously but nobody bothering to ask the real question...

Why do you think you will be unable to download FB, IG & WA from the App Store?

Re:App Store to Be 'Split in Two' Ahead of EU iPhone Sideloa... by mckn1ght on Tuesday January 16, 2024 @01:36AM (#39010137)
Imagine being able to make in app purchases for boosting your posts, or ad campaigns, facebook marketplace items (think meta brand items just like amazon brand items) or tiktok shop items.

Now imagine those companies paying a percentage off the top for app store in-app purchases when there is an alternative that doesn’t involve that percentage.

Facebook and Amazon have both tried (and failed) to make their own phones. That’s how much they want to control the entire UX. Of course they would funnel people to their own app stores.

Hell, app stores themselves are places to sell ads and other apps, Apple has proven that.

So why wouldn’t a company with the developer resources and monetization potential of Meta or Amazon create their own app store?

Re:App Store to Be 'Split in Two' Ahead of EU iPhone Sideloa... by infotainment on Tuesday January 16, 2024 @02:31AM (#39010472)
Simple: if they were going to do that, they already would have on Android, where it's possible right now.

Sure, Meta could demand that people install their super-extra-spyware version of Instagram from the META STORE instead of Google Play. But, what they'd likely find out is the same thing Epic found out when it tried to found its own store: most users just don't care enough to install stuff from third-party stores, and generally won't bother.

Re:App Store to Be 'Split in Two' Ahead of EU iPhone Sideloa... by disgruntledphd2 on Tuesday January 16, 2024 @05:36AM (#39011731)
> Simple: if they were going to do that, they already would have on Android, where it's possible right now.

Maybe, maybe not. Android didn't attempt to destroy their business though, whereas Apple did (and then turned around and introduced their own, non ATT compliant ad system).

Re:App Store to Be 'Split in Two' Ahead of EU iPhone Sideloa... by jjulius on Tuesday January 16, 2024 @08:56AM (#39013290)
I'd grant you that point if this was someone like Musk that we're talking about, but Zuck just doesn't seem like he's at that level of vindictive/petty to go to all of this trouble[1] just out of spite.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39013192

Re:App Store to Be 'Split in Two' Ahead of EU iPhone Sideloa... by disgruntledphd2 on Tuesday January 16, 2024 @09:43AM (#39013760)
Yeah, fair. iOS was super, super important to their business though, so it might net out as financially worthwhile, especially if they created it more as a gaming store with a pitch to all the mobile gaming companies that they'd be able to do analytics again.

(Actually, they're one of the few people that could make a store like that work, dunno if they'd want the distraction but it might be worthwhile for the ads business).

Re:App Store to Be 'Split in Two' Ahead of EU iPhone Sideloa... by CrimsonRain on Tuesday January 16, 2024 @02:35AM (#39010498)
You have a valid concern but directed in the wrong way. If apple charged similar to a normal payment gateway, none of these would have happened
Re:App Store to Be 'Split in Two' Ahead of EU iPhone Sideloa... by jjulius on Tuesday January 16, 2024 @08:45AM (#39013192)
>So why wouldn’t a company with the developer resources and monetization potential of Meta or Amazon create their own app store?

Because that is an incredibly excessive alternative. Instead of just duplicating their app to a third-party app store run by someone else, you're assuming that Meta will go to the effort to create an entire ecosystem that they then have to manage. They would have to ensure that each app on the store is on the up-and-up and hire an immense amount of staffing for that sort of thing - moderation, development, backend support, customer support, yadda yadda. Not only do they already struggle to control the narrative around content moderation on their platforms, but now they've gotta work on preventing malware from being installed on folks phones, too?

It's way too extra, when the much more affordable option is to drop a Meta-preferred alternative onto a third-party app store that already exists. Yet they haven't even bothered doing that with something like f-droid, so I'm expected to believe that they're just going to jump to the more cumbersome option of opening their own store? When the average end user will just use the default store that comes installed on their phone?

I don't buy it. And I say this as someone who is very much in the "Fuck Zuck"/"Meta is trash" camp.

Re:App Store to Be 'Split in Two' Ahead of EU iPhone Sideloa... by Kbelicius on Tuesday January 16, 2024 @06:52AM (#39012264)
> For me Apple standing between sketchy devs like Zuck-co and my phone is a feature not a bug.

They still do since, you know, they make the OS on which those apps would run.